Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

What to do if no one will admit breaking something?

30 replies

Backandforthandnow · Yesterday 22:10

I have three daughters, 12, 14 and 17, middle one under assessment for AUDHD.

something my partner made got broken, it was on the counter and a fragile peice got broken off.

I’ve asked all three girls to be honest and admit it without anger or threat of being in trouble I just want to know. All of them deny it, We have cats, to me it’s possible one got on the counter and knocked it. He isn’t buying this.

hes decided none of us care about him, none of us care it mattered to him. As I’ve told him to leave parenting MY children to me (we’ve had issues with him overstepping in the past), he is to tell me if something upsets him and I will deal with it. I’ve said I’ve told every girl if they are lying to me I’ll be very disappointed and he is really upset.

He’s now saying “you said you’d deal with it how are you dealing with it?”

So AIBU saying I HAVE dealt with it, I’ve glued it back together, let the girls know I’m disappointed and it’s caused upset, if they did do it then that’s their guilt to carry.

what else can I do? What next steps would you take? Advice please as I’m at a loss and feeling like a crap parent 😭

OP posts:
blythet · Yesterday 22:11

What else does he expect you to do? Have you asked him that?

DeftGoldHedgehog · Yesterday 22:12

Is he their dad?

Coeliacsmum · Yesterday 22:13

It was probably the cats lol. Things get broken. That's normal family life. Would he really rather they apologised for something they didn't actually do?

something2say · Yesterday 22:14

I can see where you are coming from, but reading your OP, it did seem to me personally that the issue is not closed yet. Someone did do this (unless you think it could possibly the cat?)

I would reassure my partner that something WILL come out at some stage, the truth. Meanwhile I would comfort him for his disappointment and at least let him be heard.

It must be difficult tho, you say he can overstep and does that cause friction? But at the same time he is upset about something that mattered to him and at this stage it may be that someone is lying about it.

Parenting your girls must be hard with him there to be honest.

Estepony · Yesterday 22:17

Your partner sounds quite nasty.

It seems as if he wants you to punish all the girls even though it might not have been any of them, and (presumably) it was at most one of them.

Even if one of them did do it - you say you wouldn’t be angry, but would he be? If so, I can see why they’re trying to protect themselves.

HeddaGarbled · Yesterday 22:20

As a child who was regularly punished for accidents, I’ve never made a big deal of accidents when my own children had them. Things get damaged sometimes. Adults break things too. There is no need for this to-do.

BibbityBoppityTwo · Yesterday 22:22

Your partner is being very childish. What does he want you to do? Probably punish them all until the guilty party owns up. Except there may not be a human guilty party. Sometimes in family life things don’t get resolved, sometimes our choices about how we parent mean that we don’t give arbitrary punishments even if that sometimes means a guilty party gets away with something. Your partner is acting like the victim of some heinous crime demanding compensation. He needs to grow up.

Anyahyacinth · Yesterday 22:23

Tell him store fragile things safely? Honestly he is being ridiculous...accidents happen and his reaction shows that if one of DC did it they are right to be afraid to confess.
What an person to subject children to 😔

BibbityBoppityTwo · Yesterday 22:24

HeddaGarbled · Yesterday 22:20

As a child who was regularly punished for accidents, I’ve never made a big deal of accidents when my own children had them. Things get damaged sometimes. Adults break things too. There is no need for this to-do.

This is true. I also don’t believe people should be punished for accidents. Your partner’s reaction to this is a good indication of why no one would want to own up to it. Who can blame them, he’s obviously going to have some completely disproportional response.

seahorsessky · Yesterday 22:25

If they're normally good, I just don't see why he would think this? Like my parents knew which of my friends were good, and wouldn't let some of them come round unsupervised because they would be careless, but they knew which ones were good, and that was only my friends-you'd expect him to know the kids? Unless they had new friends invited when it got broken, but your post suggests it was only them there. So surely he knows if they're good kids that they wouldn't break it and lie.
Unless there's something you've not said, like they've done bad stuff before, I don't see why he wouldn't believe it.

Catza · Yesterday 22:28

HeddaGarbled · Yesterday 22:20

As a child who was regularly punished for accidents, I’ve never made a big deal of accidents when my own children had them. Things get damaged sometimes. Adults break things too. There is no need for this to-do.

I completely agree.
I think the only way I would have dealt with it myself is to tell my partner that things break and this is just life and he should move on. I would not have interrogated my children as I can't see why it matters who did it. The outcome is still the same. The thing is broken regardless.
Kids shouldn't be afraid of breaking things. In fact, nobody should be.
This is a weird power play and I don't like the sound of it. Maybe it's because my own parents made a big deal out of it and never actually believed me when I said I didn't do what they accused me of. So the rule in our house is - if you broke something, clean it up and forget about it.

WonderingWanda · Yesterday 22:29

Tell him he has learnt an important lesson, don't leave fragile items lying around. Presumably you know your dd's are they normally trustworthy? I know one of my dc would be able to admit this, the other woild struggle and it may take time.

Backandforthandnow · Yesterday 22:44

Two of mine would admit it, middle one is known to lie if caught out, or for random reasons, but she’s never really bad none of them are. They can be clumsy they are kids! I suppose I have a relaxed approach to parenting, I would ask them all if they broke something then move the fuck on. In the grand scheme of things it doesn’t matter.

He wouldn’t be angry but he would do the whole disappointed/moody thing.

I asked him what he would do, originally he said he would refuse to help any of them with anything until one of them admitted it and if we continued to presume it was the cats then they weren’t to be trusted and should be outside of shut in the catio at all times. He backed off that quite fast and is saying he won’t advise me as “I said parenting was my job so do it”.

I honestly cannot be arsed with the level of petulance of drama anymore. I know he’s hurt and I’m sorry for that but there is nothing else for me to do, I will not sit here and expect them to be mired in guilt and misery.

OP posts:
wildnwilde · Yesterday 22:46

He enjoys manipulating you to discipline your kids to cause tension . It’s not that big a deal he’s making one .

Waitingfordoggo · Yesterday 22:50

Seems like you’ve done what you can. Does he want you to do lie detector tests or waterboard them or something?

MarieKlepto · Yesterday 22:56

Suggest since you don't know if it was children or cats (none of whom can seemingly be "trusted") they all live in the catio all the time. Seems fair by his logic. I despair of his attitude.

socialdilemmawhattodo · Yesterday 22:59

Catza · Yesterday 22:28

I completely agree.
I think the only way I would have dealt with it myself is to tell my partner that things break and this is just life and he should move on. I would not have interrogated my children as I can't see why it matters who did it. The outcome is still the same. The thing is broken regardless.
Kids shouldn't be afraid of breaking things. In fact, nobody should be.
This is a weird power play and I don't like the sound of it. Maybe it's because my own parents made a big deal out of it and never actually believed me when I said I didn't do what they accused me of. So the rule in our house is - if you broke something, clean it up and forget about it.

I disagree. Things "don't break", they are broken. By someone or something. Now it can be an accident. What is an accident? Children playing football or similar in the house? That isn't an accident, that is an outcome. A cat leaping up and knocking something to the floor. Yes, an accident, but was it inevitable? The last time ceramic went on the floor of my house was when a cat tail swished; she was annoyed about something. Trust me, no accident there. So I feel in a supposed no-blame house there should be no issue with a child coming forward to state they broke, and apologise. And they need to do so, if genuinely an accident. I think @opyou are lax in your parenting.

ilovemykindle · Yesterday 23:10

Maybe your children are too scared to admit if they were to blame with your partners attitude.
If something is so fragil/precious why is it in a position that even a cat could accidentally damage it.

Backandforthandnow · Yesterday 23:15

socialdilemmawhattodo · Yesterday 22:59

I disagree. Things "don't break", they are broken. By someone or something. Now it can be an accident. What is an accident? Children playing football or similar in the house? That isn't an accident, that is an outcome. A cat leaping up and knocking something to the floor. Yes, an accident, but was it inevitable? The last time ceramic went on the floor of my house was when a cat tail swished; she was annoyed about something. Trust me, no accident there. So I feel in a supposed no-blame house there should be no issue with a child coming forward to state they broke, and apologise. And they need to do so, if genuinely an accident. I think @opyou are lax in your parenting.

Ok. So in your non lax parenting what would you do in this situation?

I may have “lax” parenting but my eldest is working, studying and a genuinely good human. My middle is kind, fun but has the additional issues linked to her probable diagnosis so she has been known to be untruthful but I will not assume it’s her because neurodivergence comes with enough negative input, my youngest is full of empathy, works her absolute hardest at school and at sports.

All are well liked. None has broken a single school rule.

I don’t believe I can be doing that much wrong.

OP posts:
RedDogWizz · Yesterday 23:19

Backandforthandnow · Yesterday 22:44

Two of mine would admit it, middle one is known to lie if caught out, or for random reasons, but she’s never really bad none of them are. They can be clumsy they are kids! I suppose I have a relaxed approach to parenting, I would ask them all if they broke something then move the fuck on. In the grand scheme of things it doesn’t matter.

He wouldn’t be angry but he would do the whole disappointed/moody thing.

I asked him what he would do, originally he said he would refuse to help any of them with anything until one of them admitted it and if we continued to presume it was the cats then they weren’t to be trusted and should be outside of shut in the catio at all times. He backed off that quite fast and is saying he won’t advise me as “I said parenting was my job so do it”.

I honestly cannot be arsed with the level of petulance of drama anymore. I know he’s hurt and I’m sorry for that but there is nothing else for me to do, I will not sit here and expect them to be mired in guilt and misery.

Is the item ok now it’s glued or is it still obviously damaged/won’t ever be the same again?

What would have happened if one of the girls did break it and told your partner straight away, would he have had a massive strop regardless and still expected them to be punished?

If they’re not fessing up for fear of his reaction, I can kind of understand why the culprit (unless it was a cat) hasn’t owned up.

BePeachNewt · Yesterday 23:22

It doesn’t sound like he’s a positive addition to your daughters’ lives, or to your relationship with them. If it’s your house and he’s moved in with you I’d be looking to get rid.

Keroppi · Yesterday 23:24

Obviously you tell him to fuck off and stop pushing it. And really think about what is he benefitting or bringing to your lives as you're very defensive of your parenting and girls on here, as you should be, but yet you're letting him manipulate them and you with his sulks and moods ?
If he had something fragile why was it just left on counter and not put away?

It could have been smashed by accident. Teenagers are clumsy and ifbit was on the counter, something could have knocked against it when cooking etc or even walking past. Was itdiscovered on the floor?
You've said sorry and fixed it, that's enough. Wtf he wants the cats locked away and kids whipped and ignored?
Obviously he just wants you on your own

OlderGlaswegianLivingInDevon · Yesterday 23:24

Is he the children's father - I guess not as you refer to him as ' partner ' and not Dad.

' and if we continued to presume it was the cats then they weren’t to be trusted and should be outside of shut in the catio at all times. '

He's not very nice, is he.

bunnypenny · Yesterday 23:25

BePeachNewt · Yesterday 23:22

It doesn’t sound like he’s a positive addition to your daughters’ lives, or to your relationship with them. If it’s your house and he’s moved in with you I’d be looking to get rid.

Ffs

Shouldgivethisup · Yesterday 23:29

He sounds like bloody hard work, lovely. Is he the Spanish Inquisition or something in his day job? Just forget about it and ignore the moping. Was it particularly nice?