Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

What to do if no one will admit breaking something?

30 replies

Backandforthandnow · Yesterday 22:10

I have three daughters, 12, 14 and 17, middle one under assessment for AUDHD.

something my partner made got broken, it was on the counter and a fragile peice got broken off.

I’ve asked all three girls to be honest and admit it without anger or threat of being in trouble I just want to know. All of them deny it, We have cats, to me it’s possible one got on the counter and knocked it. He isn’t buying this.

hes decided none of us care about him, none of us care it mattered to him. As I’ve told him to leave parenting MY children to me (we’ve had issues with him overstepping in the past), he is to tell me if something upsets him and I will deal with it. I’ve said I’ve told every girl if they are lying to me I’ll be very disappointed and he is really upset.

He’s now saying “you said you’d deal with it how are you dealing with it?”

So AIBU saying I HAVE dealt with it, I’ve glued it back together, let the girls know I’m disappointed and it’s caused upset, if they did do it then that’s their guilt to carry.

what else can I do? What next steps would you take? Advice please as I’m at a loss and feeling like a crap parent 😭

OP posts:
BePeachNewt · Yesterday 23:30

bunnypenny · Yesterday 23:25

Ffs

I don’t think teenage girls benefit from living with an unrelated male with a history of ‘overstepping’ who wants them collectively punished for something that, at most, one of them did.

JemimaTiggywinkles · Yesterday 23:41

Cats don’t break pieces off things - they knock things over. So the item would have been found broken on the floor. A piece knocked off is far more likely to have been damaged and the person responsible is unwilling to own up. You can’t force anyone to tell the truth but I’d stop the “maybe it was a cat” bullshit. Other than that, all you can do it tell all three you are disappointed none of them will tell you the truth (likely they all know and are covering).

Dollymylove · Yesterday 23:45

HeddaGarbled · Yesterday 22:20

As a child who was regularly punished for accidents, I’ve never made a big deal of accidents when my own children had them. Things get damaged sometimes. Adults break things too. There is no need for this to-do.

Same here. I would get belted for accidentally spilling a drink. The DH in the post is being a knobhead and should be more careful with his stuff, especially with cats around

LivelyGreyShark · Yesterday 23:59

Why leave something fragile around three kids and cats?

Backandforthandnow · Today 00:08

Shouldgivethisup · Yesterday 23:29

He sounds like bloody hard work, lovely. Is he the Spanish Inquisition or something in his day job? Just forget about it and ignore the moping. Was it particularly nice?

It does hold emotional value and I do feel really upset for him. It’s awful it’s broken but it just feels any more with the kids other than saying I’m disappointed none of them have admitted it there is no more steps to take I guess.

I get why he’s upset, I do. I just won’t parent differently. I can hold both to be true.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page