Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Estranged DIL - Advice Please

31 replies

DaringQuoter · Yesterday 16:02

I have been married to DH for 20 years. He was divorced from his first wife when their only daughter was 5. I came along when she was 25. Our relationship seemed fine, although in some respects she behaved in ways I thought were not always appropriate. As the newcomer, however, I kept quiet - I didn’t feel at all responsible for her; her mother was still around and her father was very indulgent - nothing to do with me!
She married eventually and has three children. We saw a lot of them and the children called us Grandma and Grandpa. The biological grandmother is called Granny.
The eldest child is 11. Five years ago DSD had a disagreement with her father and since then she has not allowed me to see the children. I wasn’t present when they had the disagreement but I believe it was about money.
She was completely estranged for about a year but eventually allowed DH to see the children, but not me. I have written several times asking what has happened but never received a reply. She will not answer the phone to me or DH.
My DH now has a terminal illness and he is desperately sad that his daughter is being so cold and distant. Should I try and contact her again? Any advice would be greatly appreciated.
YANBU = yes
YABU = No

OP posts:
BMW6 · Yesterday 16:05

I'd give it one last try - I don't think you'd ever regret trying

InWithPeaceOutWithStress · Yesterday 16:07

I’d say it’s for your husband to contact her. Send her a letter if she won’t pick up the phone?

LakieLady · Yesterday 16:08

So sorry about your husband's illness, OP.

Does she know he's so ill? If so, I'd leave things as they are; if not, I'd be minded to let her know, maybe by letter.

outerspacepotato · Yesterday 16:13

He should contact her if possible, not you. If that fails, that's it.

I'm sorry for what you're going through.

DaringQuoter · Yesterday 20:36

Thank you. I’m not sure if she understands how ill he is - or if she just doesn’t care. I think I was hoping for some insight from adult children who have alienated their parents so I can understand what is going on. I loved her children like they were my own but have come to terms with her decision. DH can’t come to terms and I would do anything to make things better for him. I just don’t know what to do if his daughter refuses to engage.

OP posts:
titchy · Yesterday 20:42

Why do you say ‘you believe’ the disagreement was about money? Hasn’t your dh said? Maybe it was about something else?

Has he told her he is terminal?

If she knows then I’d write but asking how she would like to be informed when her father passes and does she want to be involved in the funeral arrangements.

Sorry about his prognosis Flowers

Octavia64 · Yesterday 20:45

Hmm you don’t know what the disagreement was about.

I mean there’s no harm in trying but her behaviour suggests that the disagreement wasn’t about money.

PaddyMcGintysGoats · Yesterday 20:49

titchy · Yesterday 20:42

Why do you say ‘you believe’ the disagreement was about money? Hasn’t your dh said? Maybe it was about something else?

Has he told her he is terminal?

If she knows then I’d write but asking how she would like to be informed when her father passes and does she want to be involved in the funeral arrangements.

Sorry about his prognosis Flowers

Why do you say ‘you believe’ the disagreement was about money? Hasn’t your dh said? Maybe it was about something else?

Yes this stood out to me too, immediately.

So sorry OP, perhaps write one more time making his prognosis crystal clear.

cuddlebear · Yesterday 20:53

I’m confused. Who is the DIL? Is DSD in a same sex relationship?

caringcarer · Yesterday 20:55

Write to her and tell her your DH has a terminal diagnosis. Ask her to visit him. Offer to be out of shed says when she comes for visit.

Blueseaurchin · Yesterday 20:55

I don't think people make the decision to cut a family member out of their life for no reason.

You don't know what the argument was about.

  • If she is already aware that her father is now terminally ill but has no wish to see him you need to respect her decision
  • If she doesn't know then make sure that you write to her or send her a message/text but once she has been informed then you need to step back and let her decide what she wants to do.

You should not try to force her to make contact.

SP2024 · Yesterday 20:55

I’m going to hazard a guess the disagreement was about OP’s husband leaving his money to OP and not his daughter otherwise I can’t work out why she doesn’t want to speak to OP but has spoken to her Dad and let him see the kids. Or it was about something OP did and Dad stood up for her. I’d send a letter explaining how ill be is and if she wants to be involved/informed and leave it to her. Do you have any contact with the ex wife?

sprigatito · Yesterday 21:02

DaringQuoter · Yesterday 20:36

Thank you. I’m not sure if she understands how ill he is - or if she just doesn’t care. I think I was hoping for some insight from adult children who have alienated their parents so I can understand what is going on. I loved her children like they were my own but have come to terms with her decision. DH can’t come to terms and I would do anything to make things better for him. I just don’t know what to do if his daughter refuses to engage.

I am someone who has permanently estranged a parent, so I can give you my perspective. When I made that decision, I made it after many years of rumination and after trying everything else I could do to make the relationship viable. It was the end point of a decision making process, not the beginning. If I heard that my mother was terminally ill, it would make no difference. The relationship is over.

I don’t know what happened between your stepdaughter and her father, and I don’t know whether her decision was a permanent one, but I think you should be prepared for the possibility that she considered this scenario before estranging, and that it won’t change anything.

mindutopia · Yesterday 21:07

I am estranged from my mum, though in much more complicated circumstances than you describe. In all kindness, this isn’t your relationship and you need to butt out.

Her dad should write her a letter and let her know about his diagnosis and tell her he would love to see her. Not the grandkids. Her. Invite her to meet him out at a cafe for a coffee.

Let him be the parent and work this out for himself.

Honestly, if my mum had a terminal illness, I can’t honestly say if I’d want to know or not. I definitely wouldn’t want to see her. I absolutely would not want to have any communication from my awful stepdad though.

OneNewEagle · Yesterday 21:14

That’s up to them to sort out. Estrangement is very hard and you grieve as you go along. As long as she has been told he’s poorly and not left in the dark.

You should have never been contacting his daughter or his grandchildren btw it will just make matters harder and worse. You don’t know why she’s had to resort to this, it will be a last resort and not over nothing.

(and yes I’m very sadly estranged from my family)

Rachelshair · Yesterday 21:22

Maybe she just wanted his money? And he said he wasn't leaving her as much as she wanted. It's a very sad situation for you, seek out support and don't waste your time on her. It's her choice.

DoubleBusy2026 · Yesterday 21:49

Adult children don’t generally cut off all contact with a parent without very good reason. If she knows he’s terminal or could be soon and is still choosing not to be around her dad then it’s likely she has very good reason and so I’d not contact her.

DaringQuoter · Yesterday 23:32

sprigatito · Yesterday 21:02

I am someone who has permanently estranged a parent, so I can give you my perspective. When I made that decision, I made it after many years of rumination and after trying everything else I could do to make the relationship viable. It was the end point of a decision making process, not the beginning. If I heard that my mother was terminally ill, it would make no difference. The relationship is over.

I don’t know what happened between your stepdaughter and her father, and I don’t know whether her decision was a permanent one, but I think you should be prepared for the possibility that she considered this scenario before estranging, and that it won’t change anything.

I don’t know what led you to make this decision, obviously. You say you ruminated for years and I would really like to know if you tried to speak to your mother about what was troubling or upsetting to you. I don’t want to pry but coming from the other side I find it so hard to understand why someone would do this, unless of course there was physical or emotional abuse.
I truly find it blood chilling that you wouldn’t care if your mother was terminally ill. I’m so grateful to have a good relationship with my own kids and honestly find it impossible to understand what could have gone so badly wrong for you. Surely your mother loves you? How would you feel if your own children alienated you? I find it unbearably tragic for all concerned. But thank you for responding, I am truly trying to learn and understand.

OP posts:
DaringQuoter · Yesterday 23:34

InWithPeaceOutWithStress · Yesterday 16:07

I’d say it’s for your husband to contact her. Send her a letter if she won’t pick up the phone?

He has tried but she doesn’t respond.

OP posts:
DaringQuoter · Yesterday 23:39

Octavia64 · Yesterday 20:45

Hmm you don’t know what the disagreement was about.

I mean there’s no harm in trying but her behaviour suggests that the disagreement wasn’t about money.

I understand it was about money. But, I agree there seems to be more to it. Obviously I wasn’t there when she was growing up but he has always been a very loving and supportive father for the time we’ve been together.

OP posts:
DaringQuoter · Yesterday 23:42

cuddlebear · Yesterday 20:53

I’m confused. Who is the DIL? Is DSD in a same sex relationship?

I’m sorry for the confusion, she is my stepdaughter. My mistake.

OP posts:
DaringQuoter · Yesterday 23:48

mindutopia · Yesterday 21:07

I am estranged from my mum, though in much more complicated circumstances than you describe. In all kindness, this isn’t your relationship and you need to butt out.

Her dad should write her a letter and let her know about his diagnosis and tell her he would love to see her. Not the grandkids. Her. Invite her to meet him out at a cafe for a coffee.

Let him be the parent and work this out for himself.

Honestly, if my mum had a terminal illness, I can’t honestly say if I’d want to know or not. I definitely wouldn’t want to see her. I absolutely would not want to have any communication from my awful stepdad though.

I understand your point, but I was deeply involved for the first few years of the grandchildren’s lives. I understand there must have been issues I was unaware of. I can’t help feeling it’s got something to do with me because my stepdaughter has completely cut me off and I don’t know why.

OP posts:
DaringQuoter · Yesterday 23:51

OneNewEagle · Yesterday 21:14

That’s up to them to sort out. Estrangement is very hard and you grieve as you go along. As long as she has been told he’s poorly and not left in the dark.

You should have never been contacting his daughter or his grandchildren btw it will just make matters harder and worse. You don’t know why she’s had to resort to this, it will be a last resort and not over nothing.

(and yes I’m very sadly estranged from my family)

Yes, I think you are right. I should probably not have tried to contact her. But it’s so hard to see DH suffer and not try to help if I can. Thank you for responding. I’m trying to understand.

OP posts:
Quitelikeit · Yesterday 23:53

I think you should send a polite brief message to let her know that her father is seriously unwell then it is up to her.

Was it that you gave your own children money and that she didn’t get the same type of assistance? Or did she think you were taking his money and spending it on your kids?

Thst aside definitely get the message to her

Katemax82 · Yesterday 23:55

DaringQuoter · Yesterday 23:32

I don’t know what led you to make this decision, obviously. You say you ruminated for years and I would really like to know if you tried to speak to your mother about what was troubling or upsetting to you. I don’t want to pry but coming from the other side I find it so hard to understand why someone would do this, unless of course there was physical or emotional abuse.
I truly find it blood chilling that you wouldn’t care if your mother was terminally ill. I’m so grateful to have a good relationship with my own kids and honestly find it impossible to understand what could have gone so badly wrong for you. Surely your mother loves you? How would you feel if your own children alienated you? I find it unbearably tragic for all concerned. But thank you for responding, I am truly trying to learn and understand.

My sister cut my mum off and didn't care when she died. Me and my kids were heartbroken so it made me lose respect for my sister