Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Estranged DIL - Advice Please

32 replies

DaringQuoter · Yesterday 16:02

I have been married to DH for 20 years. He was divorced from his first wife when their only daughter was 5. I came along when she was 25. Our relationship seemed fine, although in some respects she behaved in ways I thought were not always appropriate. As the newcomer, however, I kept quiet - I didn’t feel at all responsible for her; her mother was still around and her father was very indulgent - nothing to do with me!
She married eventually and has three children. We saw a lot of them and the children called us Grandma and Grandpa. The biological grandmother is called Granny.
The eldest child is 11. Five years ago DSD had a disagreement with her father and since then she has not allowed me to see the children. I wasn’t present when they had the disagreement but I believe it was about money.
She was completely estranged for about a year but eventually allowed DH to see the children, but not me. I have written several times asking what has happened but never received a reply. She will not answer the phone to me or DH.
My DH now has a terminal illness and he is desperately sad that his daughter is being so cold and distant. Should I try and contact her again? Any advice would be greatly appreciated.
YANBU = yes
YABU = No

OP posts:
DewDropsAndCobWebs · Yesterday 23:58

I'm very sorry to hear about your DH.
In general, if someone has chosen to go no contact, it either means there has been a lot of things building up over a while, or a one off horrible thing happened.
If there was no big event you can think of, then it was likely a slow growing issue that just got to big to deal with anymore.
If your DH has already reached out to her, id leave it, and just try and support your DH best as possible

DaringQuoter · Today 00:00

SP2024 · Yesterday 20:55

I’m going to hazard a guess the disagreement was about OP’s husband leaving his money to OP and not his daughter otherwise I can’t work out why she doesn’t want to speak to OP but has spoken to her Dad and let him see the kids. Or it was about something OP did and Dad stood up for her. I’d send a letter explaining how ill be is and if she wants to be involved/informed and leave it to her. Do you have any contact with the ex wife?

You’re right. Everything is left in trust to her, but not until I die. I understand she wants everything upon DH’s death. Of course I might die first anyway but apparently that’s not the point. Her mum is entirely supportive of her daughter. I had nothing to do with DH’s will but he would not have left me unsupported. I will only receive an income from the estate - everything is in trust to her and the grandchildren.

OP posts:
Quitelikeit · Today 00:02

Well I don’t think she deserves a dime if she’s treating him like this!

Whoops75 · Today 00:04

I wouldn’t make further contact.
Even as an adult a broken home is difficult and her relationship with her father isn’t yours to fix.

He has decided to leave his daughter nothing on his death, do you think that is fair?

DaringQuoter · Today 00:06

Quitelikeit · Yesterday 23:53

I think you should send a polite brief message to let her know that her father is seriously unwell then it is up to her.

Was it that you gave your own children money and that she didn’t get the same type of assistance? Or did she think you were taking his money and spending it on your kids?

Thst aside definitely get the message to her

Quite the reverse. She has had far more financial assistance over the years than I have ever been able to do for my own children.

OP posts:
DaringQuoter · Today 00:08

Whoops75 · Today 00:04

I wouldn’t make further contact.
Even as an adult a broken home is difficult and her relationship with her father isn’t yours to fix.

He has decided to leave his daughter nothing on his death, do you think that is fair?

She will receive a lump sum, as will the children but the bulk of the estate will not be hers until I die. I think this is normal for married couples?

OP posts:
DaringQuoter · Today 00:11

DewDropsAndCobWebs · Yesterday 23:58

I'm very sorry to hear about your DH.
In general, if someone has chosen to go no contact, it either means there has been a lot of things building up over a while, or a one off horrible thing happened.
If there was no big event you can think of, then it was likely a slow growing issue that just got to big to deal with anymore.
If your DH has already reached out to her, id leave it, and just try and support your DH best as possible

Thank you for responding. I just wish I knew what the problems were so they could be addressed. The silence is deafening.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page