Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Whole Life Order

32 replies

Coulditbesam · Today 13:26

My prison AMA got a lot of discussions going, so thought I would see what people think about whole life orders.

To get a whole life order you will almost 100% have been found guilty of murder often with a sexual element or a murder of a child.

Current WLO’s are Belfield, Roy Whitting, Wayne Couzens etc.

How should day to day life look for them in prison?

OP posts:
shellyleppard · Today 13:30

No luxury privileges....so no TV/game system. They should not have any luxuries

Coulditbesam · Today 13:34

shellyleppard · Today 13:30

No luxury privileges....so no TV/game system. They should not have any luxuries

Agreed, for what it’s worth

OP posts:
TheShitChefShow · Today 13:35

The man who raped me has been given a whole life order (due to sadism and the levels of violence)

What is relevant is not how he spends his time in prison but the complete lack of resources and help available to me to heal from the trauma.

The focus needs to shift to the victims and away from the offenders in these crimes because it's the victims that are the ones who have a chance at rehabilitation and healing but only if the resources are there to help them

Coulditbesam · Today 13:36

TheShitChefShow · Today 13:35

The man who raped me has been given a whole life order (due to sadism and the levels of violence)

What is relevant is not how he spends his time in prison but the complete lack of resources and help available to me to heal from the trauma.

The focus needs to shift to the victims and away from the offenders in these crimes because it's the victims that are the ones who have a chance at rehabilitation and healing but only if the resources are there to help them

I’m so sorry to hear that.

OP posts:
SaggySagittarian · Today 13:37

Although rationally I agree it sends the wrong message to kill people for killing people I think most of these guys should just be put down. Then the resources can go to helping the victims, as pp said above. We don’t need people like Wayne Couzens in the world.

Portmore · Today 14:03

The punishment is the whole life order behind bars, If there were further reductions of privileges due to the WLO eg not being allowed work, tv, books, canteen etc then surely that would just make them more difficult & dangerous to manage.

My understanding is those things are earned for 'good behaviour' & can be removed. That helps maintain some kind of order in the prisons. Without that you've got a bunch of highly dangerous & manipulative men with nothing to lose. That would make it then a very dangerous place for prison staff.

I didn't follow your AMA OP so I don't know if you covered that. If victims requests for certain treatments behind bars were honoured would that work?

I have been a victim of CSA & don't think that seeking revenge in terms of dictating what conditions inside he gets would make any difference to me. I fact I think revenge would prolong my distress. I would want him to spend as much of his sentence behind bars but hearing about whether he was allowed TV or not would be unhelpful

Tryagain26 · Today 14:10

Portmore · Today 14:03

The punishment is the whole life order behind bars, If there were further reductions of privileges due to the WLO eg not being allowed work, tv, books, canteen etc then surely that would just make them more difficult & dangerous to manage.

My understanding is those things are earned for 'good behaviour' & can be removed. That helps maintain some kind of order in the prisons. Without that you've got a bunch of highly dangerous & manipulative men with nothing to lose. That would make it then a very dangerous place for prison staff.

I didn't follow your AMA OP so I don't know if you covered that. If victims requests for certain treatments behind bars were honoured would that work?

I have been a victim of CSA & don't think that seeking revenge in terms of dictating what conditions inside he gets would make any difference to me. I fact I think revenge would prolong my distress. I would want him to spend as much of his sentence behind bars but hearing about whether he was allowed TV or not would be unhelpful

I completely agree with this. The punishment is the loss of liberty for life. And whatever people may discuss or think that does not mean that they live a life of luxury.
And I don't think victims should have a say in what happens once the person is in prison.

Acertwirl · Today 14:10

I think they should have a pretty miserable existence within the realms of decency. So, some outside time, basic but nutritionally balanced meals, no access to shop bought “luxury” items, no screens (some books perhaps).

XelaM · Today 14:10

Coulditbesam · Today 13:26

My prison AMA got a lot of discussions going, so thought I would see what people think about whole life orders.

To get a whole life order you will almost 100% have been found guilty of murder often with a sexual element or a murder of a child.

Current WLO’s are Belfield, Roy Whitting, Wayne Couzens etc.

How should day to day life look for them in prison?

Jeremy Bamber? I still think he was stiched up and scapegoated

Coulditbesam · Today 14:12

XelaM · Today 14:10

Jeremy Bamber? I still think he was stiched up and scapegoated

Honestly I know very little about the case.

But I’ve sat through enough huge trials to know the insane levels of detail that is covered.

OP posts:
FriggadyDiggady · Today 14:18

SaggySagittarian · Today 13:37

Although rationally I agree it sends the wrong message to kill people for killing people I think most of these guys should just be put down. Then the resources can go to helping the victims, as pp said above. We don’t need people like Wayne Couzens in the world.

I think I agree with you morally, and I much prefer the idea of the state doing it as society's common consensus that vigilante justice (e.g. "I hope Russell Brand gets raped in the showers"). I just can't support it because of the irreversibility in case of a miscarriage of justice.

Mymanyellow · Today 14:22

How many men and women have been given whole life orders? I don’t believe it’s a huge amount is it?

HelpMebeok · Today 14:23

A whole life order can only be given if there is murder. It's difference to life imprisonment with minimum serving term applied. Reserved for the most serious crimes. I think there should live a very basic life in prison with no luxuries.

Coulditbesam · Today 14:26

Mymanyellow · Today 14:22

How many men and women have been given whole life orders? I don’t believe it’s a huge amount is it?

It’s very few.

OP posts:
Laiste · Today 14:30

How should it look?

Dark. Down a big fucking hole with the trapdoor shut forever.

wishingonastar101 · Today 14:35

Assisted dying should be made an option for whole life servers... if they want to die let them.

Netcurtainnelly · Today 14:49

Coulditbesam · Today 13:26

My prison AMA got a lot of discussions going, so thought I would see what people think about whole life orders.

To get a whole life order you will almost 100% have been found guilty of murder often with a sexual element or a murder of a child.

Current WLO’s are Belfield, Roy Whitting, Wayne Couzens etc.

How should day to day life look for them in prison?

Can't you talk about something nice. Prisons and whole life orders? Tell us a joke or a nice funny story fgs.

mumumental · Today 14:53

I don’t have an opinion. I’m just glad they are locked away in prison.

Coulditbesam · Today 14:55

Netcurtainnelly · Today 14:49

Can't you talk about something nice. Prisons and whole life orders? Tell us a joke or a nice funny story fgs.

Knock knock.

Who’s there?

Move along.

Move along who?

Move along if you don’t like the thread.

OP posts:
chickenpotnoodle · Today 15:00

Think these should be given the death penalty IMO - unless the prison sentence is hell on earth. (for those cases and serial killers - Peter Sutcliffe should have been the first)

takealettermsjones · Today 15:01

FriggadyDiggady · Today 14:18

I think I agree with you morally, and I much prefer the idea of the state doing it as society's common consensus that vigilante justice (e.g. "I hope Russell Brand gets raped in the showers"). I just can't support it because of the irreversibility in case of a miscarriage of justice.

I mostly agree with you, but in the case of people who've been literally caught doing it, such as the Southport attacks, I'd bring back capital punishment 100%. I do understand (and somewhat share) the "thin end of the wedge" reservations though.

takealettermsjones · Today 15:02

wishingonastar101 · Today 14:35

Assisted dying should be made an option for whole life servers... if they want to die let them.

A very good point.

FriggadyDiggady · Today 15:21

takealettermsjones · Today 15:01

I mostly agree with you, but in the case of people who've been literally caught doing it, such as the Southport attacks, I'd bring back capital punishment 100%. I do understand (and somewhat share) the "thin end of the wedge" reservations though.

I guess you could have a category of "overwhelming evidence" or something (i.e. if 100 people caught them bang to rights) but then if feels like we've got a case where some people are guilty, but some are more guilty than others. Our system is based on the jury determining guilt and the judge deciding the sentencing and having a different category of guilt would seem to break this principle.

Dollymylove · Today 15:41

Its my understanding that when the death penalty was abolished that those convicted of murder served a whole life order in its place . I firmly believe that this should be the case. There is a long (and ever growing) list of people who have been murdered by an already previously convicted murderer . This needs to be addressed

gonoodleoodle · Today 16:26

I think of the cost of keeping them locked up for all that time. That’s one reason why I support of the death penalty.