Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Whole Life Order

32 replies

Coulditbesam · Today 13:26

My prison AMA got a lot of discussions going, so thought I would see what people think about whole life orders.

To get a whole life order you will almost 100% have been found guilty of murder often with a sexual element or a murder of a child.

Current WLO’s are Belfield, Roy Whitting, Wayne Couzens etc.

How should day to day life look for them in prison?

OP posts:
ColdAsAWitches · Today 16:59

shellyleppard · Today 13:30

No luxury privileges....so no TV/game system. They should not have any luxuries

I'm bored, I've nothing to do, I can't even watch TV. There's nothing more they can do to punish me as there's no luxuries they could remove, so I might as well try to murder the next prison officer I see, just for some excitement....

shellyleppard · Today 17:01

@ColdAsAWitches they still plan attempts on staff life regardless.....

takealettermsjones · Today 17:49

FriggadyDiggady · Today 15:21

I guess you could have a category of "overwhelming evidence" or something (i.e. if 100 people caught them bang to rights) but then if feels like we've got a case where some people are guilty, but some are more guilty than others. Our system is based on the jury determining guilt and the judge deciding the sentencing and having a different category of guilt would seem to break this principle.

I wouldn't say it's about being more guilty as such, I think it's a question of standard of proof - the standard in criminal cases is beyond reasonable doubt, but in cases where the reasonable doubt is zero (and the offence is serious enough), there could just be an additional sentencing option. There would have to be a strict test for the level of doubt being zero obviously.

Or we could just make like the US and shoot them on sight... not entirely joking!

MalateOxaloacetate · Today 17:58

I believe that deprivation of liberty is the punishment but that deprivation should include all access to the outside world including internet access, phone use and use of games consoles or television. I do think they should have basic food that meets their nutritional needs, exercise, books and learning materials and access to religious or mental health services and basic medical services.

They should be given a job to do and the money earned from it paid to their victims.

I do not believe they should have any access to staff of the opposite sex. I also believe their confidentiality in terms of psychological work, mental health information etc should be struck and this should be made available to the medical community.

scalt · Today 18:06

The type of prisoner that annoys me most are not the murderers, but the wealthy career criminals for whom prison is a “temporary inconvenience”. The prolific burglars, who go straight back to it when released. The drug dealers who earn more inside prison than they do outside. The banned drivers who are straight back in their BMWs, licence or no licence. Those who enter prison as petty criminals, and then leave much more criminally minded, having been tutored by the crime professionals.

If only there was a way of confiscating the assets of wealthy career criminals easily, so that they contribute to funding prisons. I’m sure they are the minority, as many prisoners are there because their life was bad early on.

And don’t get me started on criminal politicians, such as Boris Johnson and Tony Blair, both of whom told massive lies in public office, while ordinary people can be jailed for lying about who was driving a speeding car.

HappyLizard23 · Today 18:08

No luxuries, tv, games etc
No visitors
Limited written and phone communication eg once a month
Mostly solitary except for eating and group sessions
No access to ‘fun’ activities eg sports, arts, speakers

HappyLizard23 · Today 18:09

ColdAsAWitches · Today 16:59

I'm bored, I've nothing to do, I can't even watch TV. There's nothing more they can do to punish me as there's no luxuries they could remove, so I might as well try to murder the next prison officer I see, just for some excitement....

Easy, food through a hatch then and removal from cell under sedation if they’re violent.

New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Swipe left for the next trending thread