Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

£5k per year but can't afford a holiday

234 replies

Fingerless · 15/11/2026 20:19

My OH smokes. For years we've struggled for money. Holidays not possible is probably the biggest thing. No family holiday for almost 10 years. It's also my OH's biggest complaint about our lives. We've had such big arguments about it. I get a lot of stick because we haven't been able to give our children a holiday.

I've never questioned or appreciated the cost of smoking. I now know the cost of a 20 a day habit. I'm a little in shock to be honest. At an approx current cost of £15 ish for a pack of 20, thats over £5000 per year.
I feel like ive been gaslit. I dont even know where to begin.
Am I over reacting?

OP posts:
suki1964 · 16/11/2026 00:43

@Fingerless , Im not making excuses for him, addiction to nicotine is one of the hardest addictions to break

I remember when cigerettes went to 50p a pack under Thatchers first term, and me saying that's it - Im quitting - and all these years later I still smoke - albeit Im down to 2 or 3 a day

I have had periods of being smoke free , most has been 7 years , and that was with Champix , Im not even sure if its prescribed anymore > But I still go for a cig when things get tough - learned behaviour and so tough to break

Mostly now I vape. My favoured kit is £40, lasts around 8 to 12 months and costs about 3 quid a week on juice

Smoking is a luxury , even though its a killer, one I cant afford, but the addiction is totally real I make a packet last 10 days , I can just about afford that without it impacting on our lives..

Encourage him to switch to vaping. It's not ideal but it's the cheapest option of dealing with a nicotine addiction . It's not ideal, still feeding the addiction , but so much cheaper once the kit is paid for. Ive spent today cost of a packet of high end cigs, to keep me going 6 to 8 weeks

PrincessFiorimonde · 16/11/2026 01:48

OneFunBrickNewt · 15/11/2026 22:14

An unhelpful comment, but I only know a couple of smokers, but they buy their cigs under the counter at half the price. They're middle-class professionals.
But even that's expensive.

Please tell them that's a really risky thing to do. There was a lot of that going on in my town a few years ago, and it turned out the cheap 'under the counter' cigarettes contained various additives that were even more harmful than those you find in legitimate cigarettes. Smoking is bad enough for your health without adding extra, unregulated stuff into the mix.

Goatsarebest · 16/11/2026 01:59

paraseetamollie · 15/11/2026 21:40

It's a horrible habit that I gave up when I turned 50 and haven't looked back (I'm 67 now ) but as a keen gardener I grew my own towards the end and it was cheap as chips and perfectly legal.

https://www.tobaccoseed.co.uk/help/

Nice one. Did you grow any 'varieties' to smoke. I'm also keen gardener recently retired and ex smoker, but have never grown any tobacco. New greenhouse arriving soon, so I have options😁

Goatsarebest · 16/11/2026 02:06

paraseetamollie · 15/11/2026 21:58

It's not a recommendation, but I did become quite good at it. However, just because it's virtually free doesn't mean it's any good. It's still terrible for your health. If I had the choice again, I'd probably have switched to vaping and then tried to quit altogether. But vaping seems incredibly addictive in its own right. My brother certainly can't seem to give it up. He switched from smoking to vaping, which was obviously a step in the right direction, but he now has a hacking cough.

My own baccie though, after growing, curing and shredding it, was actually pretty good when rolled into cigarettes - I gave a lot away and made about 2kg very year !

Been reading up on this since your informative post. Giving away OK, but side hustle selling could get you into trouble. Nobody on Mumsnet would do that, so all good.

Goatsarebest · 16/11/2026 02:22

Fingerless · 15/11/2026 22:15

Been together 10 years. So potentially £50k. Mind blowing isn't it.
Haven't had a proper holiday together in all that time.

A few weekends away, but literally a few, over 10 years.

I feel very resentful

I know what you are saying and wouldn't defend the expense if you have missed out on things, but you have to be a bit careful when looking at 10 years non essential expenses of a partner and be resentful. Are you going to add up all the coffees, magazines, etc over last 10 years too. Your posts are indicating an increasing resentment of things you have not done or sacrifices you have made and focus it all on tobacco expenditure.
It's an easy one to focus on, but maybe some of the posters saying how bad it is spend money on cocktails or Spa days or a piece of art.
Time for a plan.
But all those saying end your relationship over this are not you. 5k discrepancy in your finance will be an insignificant amount if you separate and run two separate households. That's a fact.

PeloMom · 16/11/2026 04:19

When I was growing up , around 13 yrs old I think, smoking was fashionable and some of my peers started to smoke too. I sort of tried and didn’t liked it however was feeling the pressure. Not sure what made me, but one night is added up how much would smoking cost me a month, a year and few decades. I realized every 20 - 25 yrs if I smoke a pack a day I’d be smoking the equivalent of a one bed apartment where I lived. I never touched a cigarette since.

iamnotalemon · 16/11/2026 04:32

We never had any money growing up as kids but my parent still found the money to smoke 20 a day!

Nopersbro · 16/11/2026 04:35

You've said a few times that he blames you or makes you feel guilty about not being able to afford certain things including a holiday. This is ridiculous - even more so, because of the smoking, but even without it, if you make roughly the same amount and have combined finances! Don't entertain those comments any more, not even once.

It sounds like your household doesn't do any formal budgeting at all (or perhaps he has done it and doesn't share the details?) In any case, I'd really suggest making a monthly budget together starting now (and also a note of periodic but less frequent expenditures such as annual.) If there's an expense like a holiday that you both really want but think you can't afford, do some research together and determine the ballpark cost and then look to see where it could come out of existing expenditures. But you can also see where you can reduce unnecessary expenditures just to save, even if it's not yet for something specific.

Biscuitjockey · 16/11/2026 04:36

Are you saying all smokers are inconsiderate and selfish? Very judgmental of you. Do you know them all personally do you?

NapsForTheWin · 16/11/2026 05:30

Your kids will probably be like me then. When I look back I remember that even when my parents were struggling for food, struggling to afford medicine for us, or activities, or anything - there was always money for smokes.

I don't care how hard it to to break. When it comes before the well being of your children and their health and safety (like having enough food or medicine), smokes first is selfish. The smokes were more important than we were.

NapsForTheWin · 16/11/2026 05:31

Biscuitjockey · 16/11/2026 04:36

Are you saying all smokers are inconsiderate and selfish? Very judgmental of you. Do you know them all personally do you?

I don't know any now that the smoking induced illness finally made my father quit to save his own life. Too bad it wasn't such a priority when they couldn't afford things like food for us but could always afford the smokes. I don't want to know any.

rwalker · 16/11/2026 05:32

I think your being unfair it’s an addiction that he’s been addicted to for years
i think when you date a smoker you have to accept it’s for life and that’s a decision you make and have to live with and stick with
you’ve moved the goal post which isn’t fair

It’s not as easy as just saying stop I think unless you’ve been a smoker yourself you want understand

NapsForTheWin · 16/11/2026 05:35

rwalker · 16/11/2026 05:32

I think your being unfair it’s an addiction that he’s been addicted to for years
i think when you date a smoker you have to accept it’s for life and that’s a decision you make and have to live with and stick with
you’ve moved the goal post which isn’t fair

It’s not as easy as just saying stop I think unless you’ve been a smoker yourself you want understand

That was always my father's line when we couldn't afford food or medicine or anything we needed, not just wanted when we asked him why there was money for smokes. "It's an addiction." Too bad. We can see where your priorities lie and never forget it.

HoraceCope · 16/11/2026 05:42

i would buy him a vape

DeathNote11 · 16/11/2026 05:52

Not many people pay full price these days. They're around £6 a pack around here. That's still a fair chunk of money though.

Re holidays, get a tent & just go. No need for holidays to cost a fortune. Took mine all over the world but our best holiday memories are from the tent adventures. We never went far, but that sense of roughing together does something positive to a family.

berrytart · 16/11/2026 05:56

rwalker · 16/11/2026 05:32

I think your being unfair it’s an addiction that he’s been addicted to for years
i think when you date a smoker you have to accept it’s for life and that’s a decision you make and have to live with and stick with
you’ve moved the goal post which isn’t fair

It’s not as easy as just saying stop I think unless you’ve been a smoker yourself you want understand

Yes it’s an addiction but it’s also a choice not to seek help to stop. There’s a lot of support to stop. It’s selfish, without doubt.

imagine if the op was spending the same equivalent on online gambling, I’m sure he would have something to say.

Im not a smoker but both my parents were, I’m still resentful of the lack of money and zero concern to the health implications.

berrytart · 16/11/2026 05:57

DeathNote11 · 16/11/2026 05:52

Not many people pay full price these days. They're around £6 a pack around here. That's still a fair chunk of money though.

Re holidays, get a tent & just go. No need for holidays to cost a fortune. Took mine all over the world but our best holiday memories are from the tent adventures. We never went far, but that sense of roughing together does something positive to a family.

Why should op ‘rough it’, she could go 5 star if he wasn’t selfish

DeathNote11 · 16/11/2026 05:59

berrytart · 16/11/2026 05:57

Why should op ‘rough it’, she could go 5 star if he wasn’t selfish

Because it's fun.

NapsForTheWin · 16/11/2026 06:01

One of the most ironic memories is my father having financial stress and coping with it by lighting up a smoke.

Or telling me I might have to choose a different career because he couldn't afford for me to take the one I wanted - then dealing with the stress of me being upset by lighting up a smoke.

Or the time I coughed because of being around his smoke and I saw him look guiltily at his smoke like he was considering putting it out, shrugging, and continuing because he had the right to smoke.

I have a very low opinion of smokers.

My husband has also said we aren't helping them financially as they are getting older because they have smoked huge amounts of money they could have saved for their old age. Can't really argue with that one.

NapsForTheWin · 16/11/2026 06:02

DeathNote11 · 16/11/2026 05:59

Because it's fun.

Not for everyone.

berrytart · 16/11/2026 06:03

DeathNote11 · 16/11/2026 05:59

Because it's fun.

It may be, but that’s not the point of her post.

she wasn’t asking for cheap holiday alternatives to enable her husband to waste money on his selfish habit.

HoraceCope · 16/11/2026 06:08

she must have been with him for some time though
bit late to start moaning about his habit
buy him the alan parker book

berrytart · 16/11/2026 06:09

NapsForTheWin · 16/11/2026 06:01

One of the most ironic memories is my father having financial stress and coping with it by lighting up a smoke.

Or telling me I might have to choose a different career because he couldn't afford for me to take the one I wanted - then dealing with the stress of me being upset by lighting up a smoke.

Or the time I coughed because of being around his smoke and I saw him look guiltily at his smoke like he was considering putting it out, shrugging, and continuing because he had the right to smoke.

I have a very low opinion of smokers.

My husband has also said we aren't helping them financially as they are getting older because they have smoked huge amounts of money they could have saved for their old age. Can't really argue with that one.

Absolutely, there’s understandably resentment there.
It’s even worse these days as there’s so much information about the health consequences, not so much back then. So it’s probably a mix of denial and stupidity.

My DM stopped smoking at 80, she couldn’t get to shops herself so that stopped that. She said she couldn’t understand how her money wasn’t going down anymore.

rwalker · 16/11/2026 06:10

berrytart · 16/11/2026 05:56

Yes it’s an addiction but it’s also a choice not to seek help to stop. There’s a lot of support to stop. It’s selfish, without doubt.

imagine if the op was spending the same equivalent on online gambling, I’m sure he would have something to say.

Im not a smoker but both my parents were, I’m still resentful of the lack of money and zero concern to the health implications.

I agree with everything you say but when you sign up for a relationship with an addict that’s what you get
Thinking you can change people never ends well

MrsMurphyIWish · 16/11/2026 06:19

NapsForTheWin · 16/11/2026 05:30

Your kids will probably be like me then. When I look back I remember that even when my parents were struggling for food, struggling to afford medicine for us, or activities, or anything - there was always money for smokes.

I don't care how hard it to to break. When it comes before the well being of your children and their health and safety (like having enough food or medicine), smokes first is selfish. The smokes were more important than we were.

Edited

And me but it was alcohol for my dad and cigarettes for my mum. Sometimes the only food I would have a day would be my FSM but there was always cider in the fridge and a fag in my mum’s hand.

Mt dad died 16 years ago but I rarely spoke to them from the moment I left for uni. Awful, selfish parents.