Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

£5k per year but can't afford a holiday

234 replies

Fingerless · 15/11/2026 20:19

My OH smokes. For years we've struggled for money. Holidays not possible is probably the biggest thing. No family holiday for almost 10 years. It's also my OH's biggest complaint about our lives. We've had such big arguments about it. I get a lot of stick because we haven't been able to give our children a holiday.

I've never questioned or appreciated the cost of smoking. I now know the cost of a 20 a day habit. I'm a little in shock to be honest. At an approx current cost of £15 ish for a pack of 20, thats over £5000 per year.
I feel like ive been gaslit. I dont even know where to begin.
Am I over reacting?

OP posts:
ChocolateCinderToffee · 15/11/2026 22:19

YANBU. My mother smoked and I always resented the fact that she had money for cigarettes while we got beans on toast for tea at least once a week. She gave up after I moved out because she was worried about her health, but wasn’t bothered about the effect of her habit on her family.

FlyingCatGirl · 15/11/2026 22:20

paraseetamollie · 15/11/2026 21:58

It's not a recommendation, but I did become quite good at it. However, just because it's virtually free doesn't mean it's any good. It's still terrible for your health. If I had the choice again, I'd probably have switched to vaping and then tried to quit altogether. But vaping seems incredibly addictive in its own right. My brother certainly can't seem to give it up. He switched from smoking to vaping, which was obviously a step in the right direction, but he now has a hacking cough.

My own baccie though, after growing, curing and shredding it, was actually pretty good when rolled into cigarettes - I gave a lot away and made about 2kg very year !

Yeh I think the trouble with vapes is that they should be only a temporary tool to give you the cigs and are a bit of a health unknown for long term use! My partner used to smoke 10 a day, gave up smoking when he turned 40 which is 12 years ago and vaped for 4 years and gave that up thank god as he didn't get a cough but he's a healthy bloke who I really thought was starting to get sleep apnea at night from it! It changed his nasal passages!

Idontknownowwhat · 15/11/2026 22:21

My parents were both smokers, and us kids had nothing. No holidays, no nice things- and as an adult i look back and think, all that money they spent on fags whilst we had holes in our school shoes!

I think he needs to look seriously at giving up that £5000 a year could be redirected and if that went towards extras thats what £90 a week?
That would make such a difference to your lives even if it just went straight on shared extras for the family.

SuperBlondie28 · 15/11/2026 22:21

I've never smoked. My husband hasn't either. My work colleague smokes, as does her husband. I thinks its awful that they smoke in their rented flat around their cats. One recently put to sleep due to tumours in nose, eye, mouth.
I suspect it's from the fag smoke.

Smokers just don't realise what damage they do sadly to themselves or their loved ones.

My own father, a smoker, died at 58 following a big heart attack. He spent quite a bit of our low household income on ciggies.

MrsE1 · 15/11/2026 22:21

I couldn’t live with a smoker - even if they were free. Even if they were paid to smoke.

Mumtobabyhavoc · 15/11/2026 22:23

Fingerless · 15/11/2026 22:15

Been together 10 years. So potentially £50k. Mind blowing isn't it.
Haven't had a proper holiday together in all that time.

A few weekends away, but literally a few, over 10 years.

I feel very resentful

I would, too.
Obviously, you need to sit down when things are calm and lay it out after you've thought about everything.
What if he refuses to give it up?
what if he tries, fails and doesn't try again?
What if there is a repeating cycle of try, fail, try fail....
You need to decide what you children will be subjected to health-wise, and deprived of due to lack of money. You alone have their future in your hands. Your dh has absolved himself of that. He has made his choice.

Shatteredallthetimelately · 15/11/2026 22:23

Giving up smoking can be difficult, it's an addiction after all. A smoker has to want to give up, not a half hearted cut down/only smoke while socialising attempt.

Some see it as being a thing that's for them, they've worked for it so can have something from what they've earned, irrelevant of cost in the same way as having a few glasses of alcohol, getting your nails, brows, botox or a facial done.

My DH isn't a smoker and although I never smoked in the house he didn't particularly like the smell, I tried a few times to give up, even with the help of the practice nurse, done well for the time that I had to see her, once that time was over I went straight back to smoking.

Eventually though with the cost rising near £5 a pack and 2 young DC I woke up one morning and decided that was it, no way could I afford to spend £5 every other day on cigarettes.

This Tuesday coming will be 20 years since I had my last cigarette, and I'm so glad I finally achieved it as the thought of them costing £20 a pack really does give me a WTF moment.

Pipsquiggle · 15/11/2026 22:31

@Fingerless I am assuming you aren't married?

I would encourage a more transparent approach to finances eg. How much you both earn, your big expenses / bills.
After all the essentials ,are you both able to put a set amount into a savings account e.g £100 a month.

Re addiction, he really needs to want to give up. There's lots of help out there. Most people I know who smoked have given up due to cost

DrMorbius · 15/11/2026 22:34

Same but different. My BIL goes to the pub every night. 3-4 drinks Sunday to Wednesday, 6-8 Thursday to Saturday. He's always moaning about being skint, and not going on decent holidays. That's about £200 per week, for 25 years.

PyongyangKipperbang · 15/11/2026 22:34

Idontknownowwhat · 15/11/2026 22:21

My parents were both smokers, and us kids had nothing. No holidays, no nice things- and as an adult i look back and think, all that money they spent on fags whilst we had holes in our school shoes!

I think he needs to look seriously at giving up that £5000 a year could be redirected and if that went towards extras thats what £90 a week?
That would make such a difference to your lives even if it just went straight on shared extras for the family.

My mum used to say this (Dad gave up in his 50's). "Oh we couldnt afford this or that but there was always money for his bloody fags".

MaidOfSteel · 15/11/2026 22:34

emuloc · 15/11/2026 20:44

He is an addict, just like someone addicted to food, or drinking alcohol. There is help available from the GP. They should have a programme to help smokers who want to quit. It is worth him seeking help to do so, as he is more likely to quit the habit, with professional help. He is addicted to nicotine, it is not so easy to just say stop, that does not work for people who overeat, or drink, does it?

That’s all well and good, but it doesn’t give him the right to try shifting the blame for not having any holidays onto the OP.

RaggedRocks · 15/11/2026 22:39

I smoked heavy from 14 to 40. I quit around the millennium. Pensioner now. 20 a day, Dot Cotton-style smoking—that's half the state pension gone on fags. If I got one thing right in my life, it was quitting smoking. I used to think if I could, anyone could, because I was hopelessly addicted.

mamaof4losingmymind · 15/11/2026 22:41

I think everyone is allowed one thing whether thats cigarettes or a coffee on the the way to work or a takeaway. Life is hard we work full time crappy jobs with very little left over. I would never begrudge someone that 1 thing

PrincessofWills · 15/11/2026 22:42

Yuk - LTB . . .

LancashireButterPie · 15/11/2026 22:46

I went to school with holes in my shoes but there was always money for Mum and Dad's "smokes".
Mum was on 40 a day and Dad on 100+ a day. He chain-smoked.
He died at 58 of a huge stroke.
We never had a holiday because their smoking came first. We stank of smoke at school. Our mental health was suffering from about the age of 9 when we learned what smoking does to people. Your DH needs to put his family first.

BrokenWingsCantFly · 15/11/2026 22:48

Fingerless · 15/11/2026 22:15

Been together 10 years. So potentially £50k. Mind blowing isn't it.
Haven't had a proper holiday together in all that time.

A few weekends away, but literally a few, over 10 years.

I feel very resentful

If it makes you feel any better it won't be anywhere near that amount. Smoking has shot up drastically the last few years.

I smoke 5 packs a week. Back 1.5 years ago when I split with my ex, I distracted myself by pushing my focus into getting my house ready to sell in the near future, I worked out my outgoings to see what type of house i can afford. Smoking was costing me just over £2,900 per year. Today after seeing this thread, and a pack rising from £14.85 to £15.89 just over the last couple of weeks, that total is now just over £4,100. It makes me sick, even though I still can afford a few holidays a year, meals out at nice places, a decent car and the occasional treat. I could have decent savings if I quit or more equity in my house to put towards the next. Kind of justify it by saying others spend on contract phones, regular salon trips, big regular nights out but im not interested in all that. Someone doing those few things can easily surpass my spending on cigarettes each month.

When I do the big move with a much bigger mortgage, I will have to quit smoking to maintain the life I have now. The choice will be holidays and meals out, or a life of budgeting for smoking. I love holidays more than smoking. Having a push & support from a partner would definitely help, I dont have that but your DH does. Would you go on holiday with the kids alone? If so I would tell him, you was fine to be in this together when you thought there was a good reason he couldn't afford it, but you won't be suffering for his habbit. Save your half and go away without him. He knows what he needs to do if he wants to join you. Even if you can only go away every other year without you doing this together, it is still something

FunGoldStork · 15/11/2026 22:49

Holidays are optional, I last took one in 1996, but burning £5000 a year at the same time as stinking the place out and damaging everyones health seems rather daft, if not outright stupidity.

AInightingale · 15/11/2026 22:50

A rechargeable, refillable vape will cost a fraction of what he spends on cigarettes. In saying that, if he decides to give up vaping in future, it is much harder than quitting smoking (I've done both). But it might work as a solution in the short term. The device costs about £18-£20 and the liquids cost about £5 a week, plus coils. Altogether it would cost him roughly about £300 a year as opposed to five fecking thousand.

Youhadrambledonfor18pages · 15/11/2026 22:51

Fingerless · 15/11/2026 21:43

He doesn't smoke inside. Always goes outside. It's kind of out of sight out of mind, that may be why I don't think about it too much.

What's made me think about it all is rhis weekend he mentioned hes going to give up because he has an older son who doesn't live with us, and he's going to need the money to contribute to his university living costs next year, and not smoking would save him a fortune.

I didn't know whether to be happy for him or feel very very angry!!!

“doesn't smoke inside. Always goes outside. It's kind of out of sight out of mind,”

I don’t understand how you’re not immediately thinking about it when he comes back inside stinking of cigarettes!

“When we go out I tend to drive so I'm always aware I spend more on fuel.”
Well sort this out - ask for petrol money or equal driving, don’t let him keep getting away with an unequal contribution.

Next time he moans about no holidays “if you didn’t spend £5k a year on smoking we could have some lovely holidays”.

Autumnalhibernationisthedream · 15/11/2026 22:54

I have two family members who died from smoking but I think you’re (and a lot on this thread) being ridiculous (sorry!). You knew how much it cost, you had to have known he was a smoker and so most likely hooked. We can all say if we didn’t spend on x we’d have a holiday but it’s one of your life’s costs unfortunately. My brother has tried to quit for years and years. At times he’s gone a few years and then fallen back. My mum and dad quit when they first got pregnant and never smoked again and I feel for him when it comes up in conversation. FWIW he’s a marathon runner and quits for months at a time but can’t stop even though he knows it’s killed people in our family

RaggedRocks · 15/11/2026 22:54

A packet of fags costs 4 quid to make, and the remaining 13 quid is tax. What mugs smokers are giving the govt 13 quid a day.

ScrollingLeaves · 15/11/2026 22:57

Fingerless · 15/11/2026 20:24

Yes, tried to give up a few times but it didn't last.

Did he go through the gp and get help with replacement therapy at a high enough dose? ( gum, lozenges, spray?)

RaggedRocks · 15/11/2026 22:57

So an extra 3k a year in tax.

MsAmerica · 15/11/2026 22:57

Fingerless · 15/11/2026 20:19

My OH smokes. For years we've struggled for money. Holidays not possible is probably the biggest thing. No family holiday for almost 10 years. It's also my OH's biggest complaint about our lives. We've had such big arguments about it. I get a lot of stick because we haven't been able to give our children a holiday.

I've never questioned or appreciated the cost of smoking. I now know the cost of a 20 a day habit. I'm a little in shock to be honest. At an approx current cost of £15 ish for a pack of 20, thats over £5000 per year.
I feel like ive been gaslit. I dont even know where to begin.
Am I over reacting?

I know what DH is, but not OH.

However, what interests me is that you're reacting (not over-reacting) to the financial issue, but not the health issue. And with children! I know someone with lifelong health problems because her mother smoked, so she was exposed to it until she left the home when she was about 20.

I have no idea how you were "gaslit." There does not seem to be any deception or misdirection involved, and I wish people would stop over-using it. But in the same way that people can't save money because they are addicted to one or two expensive daily Starbucks coffee, yes, it's money uselessly down the drain if you're on a budget.

I wish you would have told us what he says during your arguments - if he has solutions or proposals, or if he just shrugs it off. Do you think if you both went to some kind of counselor you might make some headway?

Overthebow · 15/11/2026 22:58

YANBU. I couldn’t be with someone who chooses to smoke over providing experiences for their kids.

Swipe left for the next trending thread