Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

M&S calling security because a child was queuing to buy bread.

337 replies

Tinogirl · Yesterday 09:30

Reading another thread prompted me to post this.

Our M&S just a food one, is small with one entrance and a carpark obviously with pedestrian crossings between carpark and shop.

A few weeks ago around 4ish in the afternoon when it was still light I was queuing to pay behind a late primary school girl who was in school uniform. She had three batons of bread.

The cashier asked me if we were together without serving the child. The cashier asked her if she was alone and the child said her mother was in the car in the car park.

The cashier refused to serve her and called security who with a female member of staff took her back to the carpark .

WTF? I and everyone in the queues could not believe it.

When I pushed my trolley out the mother of the. Hold was arguing with the female member of staff. There were two other children in the car. The female staff member offered to stay with the car while the mother bought the bread but the mother just shouted she would never shop in there again.

I don’t think the mother did anything wrong.

I used to send my daughter into a small CoOp and a Tesco Metro while I waited outside to give her independence.

What do people think?

OP posts:
Emilesgran · Yesterday 12:53

Monty36 · Yesterday 12:51

I suspect Marks and Spencer wanted to make sure there was a mum outside in a car. If she had not been and there was a different reality Marks would be hauled over the coals for serving her and not asking any questions. Who had sent her in ? Was she needing help ?

Given they probably rarely come across this situation at their till they proceeded with some caution I can only imagine.

Buying bread?? Why shouldn’t she be served - it’s not sending a child to get medicine or cigarettes!

cryupmykingdom · Yesterday 12:55

QuietChristmas2026 · Yesterday 12:34

Even though this didn't affect you OP, you can still complain in writing, they will identify the cashier from your receipt, please do.

I agree.

Seems a lot of people have lost touch with common sense. A bit of kickback & a few withering words from folk who observed the dumbness is appropriate - especially if you make it clear that you will cease shopping there unless they smarten up their ideas.

timeoutsarethebestchocolate · Yesterday 12:55

And society wonders why children are not as independent as they once were.

Imdunfer · Yesterday 13:00

Isobel201 · Yesterday 11:12

as long as its used with the permission of the adult there is no problem. But if a card was genuinely lost or stolen it would be immediately flagged as such and frozen for future purchases anyway.

You don't report a card lost until you realise you've lost it

And it isn't legal for a child to use it, permission or not.

Anarchy99 · Yesterday 13:01

Emilesgran · Yesterday 12:53

Buying bread?? Why shouldn’t she be served - it’s not sending a child to get medicine or cigarettes!

How do you know the specific circumstances around this? Did they say she was too young?

If the mother had a go at the staff member (because staff don’t regularly start a row with customers as they wouldn’t be working there for long) then surely it makes sense that there was more to it?

Imdunfer · Yesterday 13:02

Skippythemagnificent · Yesterday 12:05

What difference does that make? My kids had their own cards from when they were 8/9.

Their own card is a different thing altogether, we are talking about them using a card without their name on it.

Monty36 · Yesterday 13:03

Emilesgran · Yesterday 12:53

Buying bread?? Why shouldn’t she be served - it’s not sending a child to get medicine or cigarettes!

Best you ask Marks and Spencer. I was just trying to see things from their viewpoint . Which might not be accurate but a possible explanation.

Royaly82 · Yesterday 13:05

How bizarre!

My 10 year old (11 in jan) Is in year 6 of primary and they are allowed to now walk to and from school alone. In the summer holidays i would allow her and her older sister (13) to the shops and park (both local no main roads to cross) alone, as is the done thing around here.

For context they are the youngest of 6, oldest being 26 now so i may have relaxed a bit with the younger ones on rules now ive had more experience with parenting

I cant imagine any shops around here doing this!

Ponoka7 · Yesterday 13:07

It's actually quite worrying that a shop can refuse to serve a child, based on personal opinion. When I've just googled if it is a policy, it isn't and this thread came up. I'd want an explanation from M&S because age is a protected characteristic and the child had a legitimate reason to be there. My 9 year old GC goes to the corner shop and has gone into a shop for a drink etc, while I'm queuing in another.

ChocolateCinderToffee · Yesterday 13:07

Wasywasydoodah · Yesterday 09:32

Wow - I’d worry about a 5 year old, but late primary school should be fine

A friend of mine told me she was 3 years old the first time she went to get bread from the corner shop on her own. This was in a big city, too. I was certainly doing similar at five.

Royaly82 · Yesterday 13:08

Oh I will also regularly give them my bank card if I havent got the cash or they cant find theirs. Tbf be are on first name terms with local shop keepers so they know us

SENsupportplease · Yesterday 13:08

Imdunfer · Yesterday 13:02

Their own card is a different thing altogether, we are talking about them using a card without their name on it.

Edited

I think the point is that it’s too many assumptions to make in order to justify not serving the girl

Even if she was going to pay with a card, it’s not necessarily her mums / fraud, and the cashier wouldn’t know if it was the child’s card or not unless she saw ID

My children have no way to prove that their bank cards are theirs.

Cashier really had no justification removing the child unless there is a no unaccompanied school children policy in which case that should have been spelled out.

Emilesgran · Yesterday 13:08

Anarchy99 · Yesterday 13:01

How do you know the specific circumstances around this? Did they say she was too young?

If the mother had a go at the staff member (because staff don’t regularly start a row with customers as they wouldn’t be working there for long) then surely it makes sense that there was more to it?

I can only go by what’s written here.

The only possible problem I can see is that she was (possibly) using her mum’s bank card, but even then - a child using a stolen bank card to buy bread would need SS involvement rather than a scolding and being put out of the shop by security. They could have given her the bread and had a security guard accompany her out of the shop to make sure she got back safely to her mum (thus discreetly checking that the story was true without stigmatising her)

SENsupportplease · Yesterday 13:09

My children have had their own card AND my card on their phones since age 10 / year 5

I’d be very unimpressed if a shop refused to serve them purely because they were unaccompanied children.

separately my children have been using my card to buy soft drinks and snacks at various pubs and bars since they were about 5 😂 great for confidence

SENsupportplease · Yesterday 13:11

Emilesgran · Yesterday 13:08

I can only go by what’s written here.

The only possible problem I can see is that she was (possibly) using her mum’s bank card, but even then - a child using a stolen bank card to buy bread would need SS involvement rather than a scolding and being put out of the shop by security. They could have given her the bread and had a security guard accompany her out of the shop to make sure she got back safely to her mum (thus discreetly checking that the story was true without stigmatising her)

No definite way of knowing if a card is stolen or not, you can’t compel a child to show ID, given they prob don’t have any

my children’s cards just say Initial Last name

CuteOrangeElephant · Yesterday 13:11

My DD has been going to the supermarket around the corner for simple items like bread and milk since she was 7.

When she was 8 she got a bank account with a debit card so we wouldn't have to have cash in the house.

It's been great for her independence. You can't forbid children from having simple responsibilities and then wonder why they become clueless adults!

dodgercity · Yesterday 13:14

Anarchy99 · Yesterday 13:01

How do you know the specific circumstances around this? Did they say she was too young?

If the mother had a go at the staff member (because staff don’t regularly start a row with customers as they wouldn’t be working there for long) then surely it makes sense that there was more to it?

I assume the mum was having a go at staff because it was such a ridiculous situation. I expect she also felt judged because the implication here is that it’s not appropriate ie neglectful to send a child into the shop (which of course it’s not, but hey ho). I’d be bloody cross too.

moonshinepoursthroughmywindow · Yesterday 13:26

M&S ABVU. At the very latest they should have served the child after they saw that the parent was real and had given permission. It's perfectly normal for children of that age to go into local corner shops on their own, either on the way home from school or as a little independent outing with friends at the weekend - why should things be different just because it's a bigger shop?

SomeoneIsWrongOnTheInternet · Yesterday 13:32

Moonlightdust · Yesterday 12:47

Idiocy level? It was in reference to another post and saying ‘what if’. The question being is if a child was unaccompanied, do staff routinely refuse to serve them? If this child’s mother was not in the car park, were they not going to allow her to buy the bread? As the OP stated that the member of staff even offered to watch the mother’s other children in the car so the mother could purchase the bread. This to me IS utter idiocy.

Who would trust a retail member of staff offering to ‘watch their children’ in tge car park? And how much judgement would they get if they did? M&S here were very heavy handed, 10 & 11 year olds do routinely go into shops. If they were worried why not serve the child and then escort her to the carpark to check she was picked up by her mum? And even then I’d think the staff were over the top. Have there been recent issues involving kids’ safety in your area op?

Similarly to a pp, I was walking 1.5 miles to school with my younger brother at age 7, but I wouldn’t have liked my kids doing the same. My mum didn’t like it either, it was temporary after the school buses got withdrawn in Thatchers times.

Anarchy99 · Yesterday 13:35

SomeoneIsWrongOnTheInternet · Yesterday 13:32

Who would trust a retail member of staff offering to ‘watch their children’ in tge car park? And how much judgement would they get if they did? M&S here were very heavy handed, 10 & 11 year olds do routinely go into shops. If they were worried why not serve the child and then escort her to the carpark to check she was picked up by her mum? And even then I’d think the staff were over the top. Have there been recent issues involving kids’ safety in your area op?

Similarly to a pp, I was walking 1.5 miles to school with my younger brother at age 7, but I wouldn’t have liked my kids doing the same. My mum didn’t like it either, it was temporary after the school buses got withdrawn in Thatchers times.

Why did the OP apparently follow the child out of the shop to listen in to the fallout?

SomeoneIsWrongOnTheInternet · Yesterday 13:40

Because she was behind her in the queue and followed the usual route out of the store? Which led to the car park?

Grammarnut · Yesterday 13:53

At eight I went into town and bought fish for my mother - large London suburb. also went swimming with age-mate friends alone to local swimming baths (2 buses) and to the cinema on Saturday mornings. M&S are beyond ridiculous.

Krautie · Yesterday 13:59

My brother and I were sent down to the off licence on Sundays to buy a couple of bottles of beer for my mum, dad and Grandma. We were still in primary school

IsStchasing · Yesterday 14:02

Krautie · Yesterday 13:59

My brother and I were sent down to the off licence on Sundays to buy a couple of bottles of beer for my mum, dad and Grandma. We were still in primary school

How old were you? Before licensing laws?

AnAlpacaForChristmasPleaseSanta · Yesterday 14:03

Anarchy99 · Yesterday 13:35

Why did the OP apparently follow the child out of the shop to listen in to the fallout?

The OP said she pushed her trolley into the car park. So presumably she paid for her shopping and was parked near/next to the mum. If she was shouting then the OP could hardly avoid overhearing.

Swipe left for the next trending thread