Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

It’s a DIL one this time!

931 replies

Muminturmoil0 · 14/11/2026 22:53

Long time lurker, first time poster.
I know MILs get a rough ride on MN but I don’t know where else to go.
I really don’t believe IABU so probably the wrong board to post on and I’m sure some of you will say IABU but also hoping for some advice and also to vent.

DS has been with his wife for I don’t know maybe 20 years and married about 15. They have twin 10 yo DDs
Last year DS came to stay with us, saying his wife had kicked him out for cheating. We were upset but didn’t question him on it as he didn’t seem to want to talk about it. He stayed with us around 6 weeks and eventually went home to his wife and children, 100 miles away from us. I didn’t ask any info and he didn’t tell us any. Personally I think she’s a mug for having him back but apparently they’re having therapy and working on things, so I’ve not said anything.
Was having monthly calls with DS and DGDs after he left here but the wife wouldn’t show her face on the calls. We’ve had no visits from any of them.

Anyway DS has now called us with a barrage of abuse telling us what awful people we are and I’m shocked! We had him staying here when his wife kicked him out and never interfered. He says we’ve not been supportive, his wife has never liked us (first I’ve heard!) and DGDs find us difficult too (again, first I’ve heard!)
I can’t help but think DIL has poisoned DS and DGDs against us and I don’t know why she would, maybe embarrassment, but we’ve done nothing wrong. I’m now told we can’t speak to our DGDs until we take responsibility for our actions. What actions? We’ve done nothing. AIBU for thinking they can all fuck off! DS has pissed me off as well tbh for falling for this shit from his wife. My DD agrees with us and thinks they (mainly DIL) are the problem, so I don’t think it is us and it’s good to hear that it’s not just me and DH who think it.

Would be good to know what MNers think should happen next. I think it’s on DS and his wife to get in touch with us, but I just don’t know what to expect next. He put the phone down on me because he didn’t like that I was standing up for myself and not just apologising for made up accusations.
I know MILs are often hated on here, but remember some of us are good and sometimes DILs are not. So help on what to expect from them next and what might happen next for anyone who has been in a similar situation would be gratefully received.

Can give more info or background if needed, happy to answer questions if helps with context. We’ve always been a nice happy family, but looking back I have felt the distance from DS since he moved away to where his wife and her family are from. But interactions up until now have been fine, so I don’t know where this has all come from. Hence why I’m thinking DIL may have had a heavy hand in this.

Expecting some criticism, but hopefully more help that hate. TIA.

OP posts:
Woodfiresareamazing2 · Yesterday 05:00

Ive read all of your posts @Muminturmoil0 , and most of TFT.

Ive also been in your position, so I'm not "virtue signalling", I actually did keep in touch with my then DiL.

I have to say that you come across as very cold - "tbh I thought they had permanently split" so you were quite happy to just never talk to your DiL again?!
This woman who had been in your life for 20 years, called you, spoke to you when you rang because your son was "too busy", and thereby facilitated your relationship with your GC...

I'm surprised that you thought "blood is thicker than water" so it was fine to blank her completely when she was going through such a terrible time because of your son!

It would not have been 'disloyal' to your son to reach out to her, and of course your GC - but you didn't bother even once to ring her.
That's awful OP.
Truly awful.
If I were her I would not be able to forgive that.

And you think "she's a mug" for having him back!!

No, she's probably just one more betrayed wife trying to do what she thinks is best for her children, ie keep her family together. Surely you can see that?!

You say you're not blaming her for the marriage issues, but also say "a happily married man doesn't cheat" ...
Come on OP, be real!
You ARE blaming her, and happily married men cheat EVERY DAY.

You obviously have been unhappy in the past when she hasn't gratefully received and acted upon your 'helpful' advice, and I think you've held that against her.

You insist that it's "easier" for the whole family to visit you rather than for you and your DH to visit them - really?!
And they're not even that far away...

Your relationship with your son doesn't sound great either. He was "too busy" to talk to you on the phone, you didn't make the effort to travel to see him and his family, and they didn't visit you very often. You never even talked to him about what was happening when his wife kicked him out and he stayed with you for 6 weeks!

Honestly, I would not be at all surprised if your DiL wants nothing more to do with you. You have come across through your posts as cold, bossy, self-centred, and self-righteous. And maybe your son now sees you in a different light too.

I think you have a lot of fence-mending and relationship rebuilding to do, but you first have to acknowledge and accept that you have some accountability for how you have all reached the current state of affairs. But unfortunately you appear to be stuck in the mode of "I've done nothing wrong!" and blaming your DiL for everything bad that has happened.

To sum up: it's NOT a DiL one this time.
It's another MiL one with a side order of a son who's been a shitty DH.

EdgyNewt · Yesterday 05:01

@Muminturmoil0 you posted at 1am so aren't going to get the most intelligent responses...

Even if your DS is under the thumb due to your DILs demands, he has still chosen to behave this way.

Personally I'd just not contact him then just send cards in the post for your DGDs for birthday, Christmas etc...

One day he will realise he is behaving like a dick.

Bingbong9009 · Yesterday 05:15

‘the woman carrying my grandkids‘

throughout the thread you haven’t sounded like you like your DIL at all, and this line really struck me. Surely if you wanted to give advice it’s because you care for the person, because it’s your son’s wife etc. not simply because she’s an incubator providing you with more grandchildren. You sound like the problem IMO.

heads up, don’t give advice if it’s not asked for.

Mapletree1985 · Yesterday 05:27

I'm going to put on my armchair psychologist hat and guess that in order to reconcile, they had to displace all the anger, resentment and blame onto some third party, and they picked you, for different reasons: DIL because you're nothing to her, and if she can com out of this having excluded you from the lives of her family, she will take that as a win; your son because you're his parents and ultimately will always forgive him.

Zanatdy · Yesterday 05:27

I find it very odd that you didn’t even text his wife to ask how she and the DC were when he cheated. When my brother cheated on his wife, I was straight on the phone to her. Yes he is my brother, but I wanted to make it clear I did not condone it and still cared about her. Your silence there to her and the kids speaks volumes.

You say it’s not your responsibility to visit them and they should visit you, even though they have children, and twins at that. I’m sure you could have made more effort over the years. Some grandparents would be there every couple of months, yet you sit and wait for them to come to you, and even if it’s been 2yrs, you still make no effort to go. So of course they think you favour the other grandchildren, but I expect you wouldn’t visit them either if they moved away. Sounds like your GC barely have a relationship with you due to this lack of effort.

You say you haven’t explained yourself properly and that’s why people aren’t agreeing with you. Are you someone who can never see they are wrong? It sounds like it. You will lose your son and GC, but sounds like you’re prepared to do that as you don’t see how you’re in the wrong. This is your biggest problem and no doubt why your son got annoyed with you.

SnowflakesandSlippers · Yesterday 05:37

Unfortunately, your ds is a proven liar, why would you start believing anything he says now?

Mapletree1985 · Yesterday 05:44

HangrySloth · Yesterday 01:16

Except he cheated on his wife the mother of his child tearing their family apart and his mother effectively condoned his behavior by rewarding it by giving him a place to stay not even reaching out to her DIL for 20 years who is the mother of her GC after her whole world fell a part sounds like there may be abusive people in this scenario but DIL ain’t it.

Clearly you don't know the story of the Prodigal Son. A mother will always shelter and protect her child, no matter what he or she has done. And so it should be. As a mother herself, DIL should understand that. A mother's first loyalty must always be to her own child.

Imisschampagne · Yesterday 05:51

Woooow, this thread took a turn.

OP, not contacting your DIL and GC at all after what happened is so wrong. You took in your son, fair enough but also enabled him just distancing himself from his wife and children. You’ve showed your DIL and your GC that you do not care about them. Additionally you’ve placed the blame for cheating on your DIL.

And now that they’re back together you unfortunately reap what you sow.

I can read zero of reflective thoughts on your side.

Passingthroughtwice · Yesterday 05:52

Anyone else getting major narcissistic vibes?! OP thinks she had the right to tell DIL what to do when it came to having babies (even though she hasn’t had twins herself) and expects everyone to visit her and she’s not wrong and she won’t be apologising. I say well done to her son for finally standing up to her and protecting his wife and DC from her.

Differentforgirls · Yesterday 05:53

JulietteRoche · 14/11/2026 23:53

It's not unfair at all. OP is being a pick me and she's reaping what she sowed.

Hate that phrase.

LaurieFairyCake · Yesterday 05:57

“A happy husband doesn’t cheat”

I can assure you as a relationship therapist that they do. Over and over again.

thepariscrimefiles · Yesterday 06:01

Muminturmoil0 · 14/11/2026 23:26

I’m not placing blame but a happy husband doesn’t cheat. I don’t know if they had marriage problems before but he’s not going to cheat if he’s happy at home is he! He shouldn’t have done it but it does make me wonder if she knew she’d in some way pushed him to this, because why else would she have him back? I would no way have my DH back if he had cheated. I just can’t understand any it.
I am annoyed with DS after his call, make no mistake, but it was just so out of character. Contact from him has dwindled since he moved back to her, but he’s never said any or things before that he’s said on the phone. Does make me wonder if she given him an ultimatum.
Might call him when I know she’s not with him in case he wants to condone a different issue. Or get my DD (his sister to call), maybe he will say or act differently and tell the truth as to what’s going on. Keep flipping between that and just thinking they can fuck off now. Don’t know if I’m more angry or upset.

Your original post sounded quite reasonable. However, with each additional post you have shown your true colours and this last posts has shown what a horrible and judgemental MIL you really are.

You sound like someone from the 1950s blaming the woman for her husband's infidelities. Your son is a twat (the apple doesn't fall very far from the tree) but your DIL hasn't done anything wrong, apart from taking back your cheating son.

You didn't give a shit about your DIL and your grandchildren while your DH was living with you. No support, care or concern even though your own son was to blame. You didn't check in to see whether they were OK.

It also sounds as though you have prioritised and favoured the grandchildren by your daughter. I think it's probably best for your grandchildren by your son that you stay away.

Batsuke1 · Yesterday 06:04

To be honest I would just let them get on with it. Send birthday and Christmas cards and presents for the kids, but apart from that I wouldn’t bother. No doubt they’ll come crawling back at some point (probably when they want money or there’s a will to pick apart).

Granville82 · Yesterday 06:05

What exactly did your son say on the phone?

Eviebeans · Yesterday 06:06

Maybe your DIL is not happy that you allowed him to stay with you after he’d cheated, did she know where he was at that time and was he still taking care of his responsibilities regarding the children while he was playing at being single at your place.
Are you sure that he went back home and resumed that relationship or is he living somewhere else/with someone else
I’m a MIL and I would be reaching out to her - she may bite your head off but it gives her the chance to tell you her point of view if she wants to

Thatsalineallright · Yesterday 06:09

Muminturmoil0 · 14/11/2026 23:39

Oh I’m getting in both barrels here aren’t I! I feel I mustn’t have explained myself properly. But then this has all been very upsetting so my head is all over the place.
I know my DS did wrong cheating but I thought I was doing the right thing letting him stay here. He clearly didn’t want to talk about what had happened so I didn’t bring it up.
Since they’ve been back together I’ve not really known what to think as it seems very unusual to me that she’d have him back. Then with this phone call out of the blue I don’t know what to think or what’s going on!

DIL has two children who she loves. She might be taking him back purely for their benefit. Either way, YABVVU!

Actions are what count.

  1. your son cheated.
  2. your son moved miles away from his children for 6 weeks.
  3. your son phoned you to shout at you and then cut contact with the grandchildren (though possibly deserved, it's impossible for readers to say for certain,).

Your son is a bad husband, a bad father, and now a bad son. This is 100 percent on him. DIL isn't holding a gun to his head, he is making his own decisions and they show he is a nasty piece of work.

OhDuckWhatNow · Yesterday 06:19

Lunde · Yesterday 01:08

I think it's more likely that therapy has opened his eyes to problems in his childhood

  • the misogyny of the "women are to blame for men cheating" that you have put forward here
  • that you seem to feel a god given right to push unsolicited advice onto your DIL
  • that your son left for 6 weeks and you didn't check on your grandchildren - you appear not to care about the wife and kids who were the victims of his cheating
  • perhaps there are other parts of DS's childhood where you have been insenstitive is the attitudes here are anything to go by

I have lovely memories of my wonderful MIL who was so supportive when my ex-H left me for the other woman. I find your attitudes quite odd

Agreed.

With every additional post OP just sounds like a demon to deal with.

Your son cheated then abandoned his children & wife while he hid in your home and you never once thought to check in on how she was doing after her world was blown up?

"Happy men don't cheat". Total bollocks OP & I don't think I'd speak to you again after that and the unsolicited advice you've given her.

Also what your son has told you has more to do with realising his behaviour is your fault & how you raised him. But you don't want to admit that so you blame DIL who has had to deal with the mess of a person you created, raised & still make excuses for.

And of course your DD agrees with you; she's either a nightmare carbon copy of you or she wants a quiet life.

Either way it sounds like you're getting the consequences of your actions.

thepariscrimefiles · Yesterday 06:19

Muminturmoil0 · 14/11/2026 23:55

I did use to speak with her directly actually thank you! DS would rarely pick up because he was always busy at work so I’d call her instead and speak to DGC and she would have a conversation with me too. So things were fine before. Sometimes she would even make the phone calls herself for us to speak to DGC and she never hinted at having a problem with us then! So when DS tells me all these things we’ve apparently done wrong over the years but nobody has ever mentioned it before, I’m just not buying it.
He claims she’s been hurt by comments we’ve made, yet she’s still answered our calls, called us herself, visited us and never said a word of there being a problem. So she’s either making it up now about having a problem with us all this time or she’s a very good two faced actress!

So your DIL was always nice to you and made the effort to keep in touch and to facilitate your relationship with your grandchildren? In fact, she made much more effort than your own son. She did this when it's now clear that she didn't really like you and I can see why from your posts on here.

However, instead of being grateful for her efforts to build and maintain a relationship between you and your grandchildren, you have the sheer gall to call her two-faced? Wow! You threw everything back in her face and supported your cheating son and you couldn't be arsed to check whether she and your grandchildren were OK.

Broken12 · Yesterday 06:20

’ a happy husband doesn’t cheat’

a decent man doesn’t cheat. Your son isn’t a decent man. You let him live with you for 6 weeks why your DIL probably thought her world was falling apart and you didn’t check in with her once!? He came running to mommy 100 miles away and left his daughters? No wonder she doesn’t want to talk to you.

if you want a relationship with your granddaughters you need to apologise even if you still didn’t feel like you’ve done anything wrong or else you’ll lose them from pure stubbornness! Is the relationship worth so little to you!?

PlayingDevilsAdvocateisinteresting · Yesterday 06:23

WoW @Muminturmoil0, After reading your original, opening, post, I felt very sympathetic towards you. Unfortunately, with all of your subsequent posts you have dug yourself an ever deepening hole. In fact, it has got so deep now that I think you might have fallen into it a while ago, whilst still clutching your phone tightly in your hand. Whether that is the case or not, may I suggest that you stop digging that hole right now, before it actually does collapse and bury you? You are sounding less and less likeable with every one of your posts.

I have actually experienced at least some of what you are going through, which is probably why I felt some sympathy for you at the beginning. When I was a young mother my ex husband, and father of my children, left me for another woman. His parents came to see me afterwards and offered me moral support if I ever needed it. Moving on about 30 years, my son left his wife and son for similar reasons, and we put him up on a temporary basis as he had no-where to go, and couldn't rent his own place because all his salary was taken up continuing to pay the rent on the property his wife and child were living in, and paying all the other bills as well, as his wife was a stay at home mum.

That same day, I was on the phone to my DiL telling her how shocked I was at my son's terrible treatment of her - being unfaithful to her, in case you're not sure what he did wrong - and how sorry I was, and that she and my Grandchild would always have my support. We talked together on the phone every day, sometimes several times a day, as she was so devastated, and needed to keep on discussing how such an awful thing could happen, especially after my son had suffered similarly to what his DD was going through right then. I never once made excuses for my son, because as far as I was concerned, how can you defend the indefensible?

Of course I still loved my DS, in most other ways he had always been a kind and caring person, and as I said before, I was absolutely shocked at his unfairhfulness. All my children were brought up knowing that I believed that if one partner wants to have an affair, they should go to couple's counselling, with their partner first - if their partner agreed - and then if the couple's relationship could not be saved, the partner wishing to have an affair should leave the partnership first - after the counselling, or similar - and not start a relationship with anyone else until they were officially separated from their original partner. So, I was very disappointed in my son's behaviour. I was also open with both my son and DiL that I wouldn't be sharing with the other one what I talked about with either of them.

So you are wrong OP about every mother in your sort of situation always behaving as you have done, I didn't, and in truth I feel pretty disgusted by your behaviour. Unfortunately, I don't think you are capable of taking aboard what anyone who disagrees with you says, so really, you are wasting both your own, and our time...

BobbieFleckman · Yesterday 06:31

NewLifeNewName26 · Yesterday 00:37

This sounds quite similar to a situation I’ve been in.

someone previously mentioned that your DS is a cheater so also a liar. I completely agree with that.

I suspect your DS has behaved much worse than he has lead you to believe and is now creating a situation where you no longer talk to DIL and therefore never hear her version of events around the cheating. And/or your DS has told you more about the cheating than he told your DIL and your DS is scared that your DIL will find out things DS hasn’t disclosed to DIL.

Also, cutting contact with your DGC and DIL during an incredibly tough time for them is IMHO unforgivable. When this happened to me I felt that it was showing me how little MIL actually cared about DGC and that MIL was condoning her sons behaviour.

That’s exactly what I was thinking. He’s fed his parents and his wife a whole string of lies and now, if they were to meet, the whole thing would crumble.

Add to that a critical MIL who sees no purpose in a DIL who is unable to facilitate a relationship with the cheating son, which was the case when they were separated. Sounds like the DIL now no longer wants any part of it.

thepariscrimefiles · Yesterday 06:32

Muminturmoil0 · Yesterday 00:33

No I’ve had kids of my own and have been around babies all my adult life. DD has kids so I definitely am allowed to give advice to the woman carrying my grandkids! Whether she takes it or not is up to her, but don’t throw it back in my face years later after apparently holding it in until the time suits!

Lol! This is like a spoof of what an unbearably overbearing MIL with absolutely no self-awareness would say and do!

Having kids of your own really does not give you the right to give unwanted and probably very outdated advice to your DIL.

PrincessFairyWren · Yesterday 06:38

My DH and I separated last year
after 20 years. He didn’t cheat but he has a history of treating me shabby and not being a true partner. I love my mother in law but :-

  • she constantly makes excuses for his behaviour. For example one time mil and I were together in a cafe. DH was supposed to be picking us up, from this shopping strip. I called him to see how far away he was. He swore and declared that he was waiting for us in this cafe. When I called him out (he was still driving and ten minutes away( my mil got annoyed at me. She said that her son would never lie and clearly I had tye name of the cafe wrong and that we should go straight to him.
  • I Would ask him to ask mil if she could provide school holiday cover. DH would like tell me he had checked and she could do it. However despite this exchange several school holiday periods I would call her to confirm drop offs etc that find out she was looking after her other grand children and was leaving me in the lurch. I have found out since separation that he wasn’t actually asking her. Just lying to say that he had. I could have asked her directly but I believed him. I do have a history of being silently resentful of thinking she is fucking me around on purpose when I in hindsight it was just him.
  • DH has seriously misled his family about how much he earns and downplayed my significant financial contribution. They think I’m some kind of lady of leisure that spends his money. I have put up with years of passive aggressive comments.
  • his family are completely ok with his brother not making any financial contributions to his son since separated from his wife. Seriously disgusting and if it was my brother or son there would be words.
  • DH doesn’t get me Christmas or birthday presents consistently. It hurts my feelings that he can’t be bothered. My mil has lectured me that wanting presents on special occasions is greedy.

This crap builds up. There is literally thousands of examples of shitty things they have excuses and defended. I hold my in laws at arms length because it doesn’t matter how unreasonable DH is acting apparently I caused it.

I can’t believe that he moved in with you post break up and you didn’t speak to him at all about it. He has literally exploded the world of your grandchildren and you just want it smoothed over. That’s why she’s pissed off. You enable him.

WeDid2 · Yesterday 06:38

I think you said it yourself. You didn’t contact her as blood is thicker than water. I think given your grandkids are your blood, and she influences their lives, that maybe you should have. You have by default told her how you feel about her and probably the best outcome you can hope for is being civil to each other.

We have a similar issue in our family once again a daughter’n’law although no cheating either side. And really you are on the back foot and need to decide what outcome you want. If you are prepared to accept not being part of your grandkids lives than leave things as they are. They won’t contact you - they considered they are the aggrieved party.

The thing is - when a partner cheats it’s the non cheating partner that goes through the most. She’s having to suck it up and overcome her feelings to keep her family together. If you want to keep your family together, you are going to have to suck it up and overcome your feelings too.

it doesn’t matter if it’s fair - it’s not fair but it’s even more not fair for her.

She is going through more than you and while it’s not a race to the bottom, if you don’t step up here it’s very likely you won’t be seeing your grandkids for a long time.

you need to reach out to her directly not through your son and say you really sorry if you’ve hurt her feelings you were giving her space but maybe you approached things wrongly. But you are willing to learn what she needs to rebuild your relationship and you hope she will consider you meeting her 1-1.

thepariscrimefiles · Yesterday 06:39

Muminturmoil0 · Yesterday 00:58

It’s not like I completely ignored DGDs, I asked my DS how they were getting on when he spoke to them or he got updates from his wife. They didn’t know their dad had cheated thank god, just that he was visiting us or away with work I think. So they won’t have felt abandoned.
DS was only able to visit them a couple of times during that period so I didn’t want to call DGDs when they were with their dad and take away their time with him as it wasn’t much at that time due to the circumstances.
And like I’ve already said I don’t think it was my place to contact DIL during this time, although I see some of you disagree with that. Wonder if you would if you were in my shoes though? I doubt you’d be doing all the things you are virtue signalling and checking in with her.
It’s not easy for us to visit them when they live far away. It’s not on us to go all the way over there and it’s actually easier and makes more sense for them to come to us, but they very rarely would, maybe only once or twice a year. It’s been 2 years since they last brought the DGC over but yes of course I’m the problem!

Why is it easier for your son, DIL and two grandchildren to make the journey to see you, rather than the other way round, particularly when the children were very young?

With every post you show yourself in a worse light. I'm thinking that either this is a reverse or just a wind-up post. It doesn't seem possible that anyone could be as lacking in self-awareness and empathy as you.

Swipe left for the next trending thread