Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

It’s a DIL one this time!

930 replies

Muminturmoil0 · 14/11/2026 22:53

Long time lurker, first time poster.
I know MILs get a rough ride on MN but I don’t know where else to go.
I really don’t believe IABU so probably the wrong board to post on and I’m sure some of you will say IABU but also hoping for some advice and also to vent.

DS has been with his wife for I don’t know maybe 20 years and married about 15. They have twin 10 yo DDs
Last year DS came to stay with us, saying his wife had kicked him out for cheating. We were upset but didn’t question him on it as he didn’t seem to want to talk about it. He stayed with us around 6 weeks and eventually went home to his wife and children, 100 miles away from us. I didn’t ask any info and he didn’t tell us any. Personally I think she’s a mug for having him back but apparently they’re having therapy and working on things, so I’ve not said anything.
Was having monthly calls with DS and DGDs after he left here but the wife wouldn’t show her face on the calls. We’ve had no visits from any of them.

Anyway DS has now called us with a barrage of abuse telling us what awful people we are and I’m shocked! We had him staying here when his wife kicked him out and never interfered. He says we’ve not been supportive, his wife has never liked us (first I’ve heard!) and DGDs find us difficult too (again, first I’ve heard!)
I can’t help but think DIL has poisoned DS and DGDs against us and I don’t know why she would, maybe embarrassment, but we’ve done nothing wrong. I’m now told we can’t speak to our DGDs until we take responsibility for our actions. What actions? We’ve done nothing. AIBU for thinking they can all fuck off! DS has pissed me off as well tbh for falling for this shit from his wife. My DD agrees with us and thinks they (mainly DIL) are the problem, so I don’t think it is us and it’s good to hear that it’s not just me and DH who think it.

Would be good to know what MNers think should happen next. I think it’s on DS and his wife to get in touch with us, but I just don’t know what to expect next. He put the phone down on me because he didn’t like that I was standing up for myself and not just apologising for made up accusations.
I know MILs are often hated on here, but remember some of us are good and sometimes DILs are not. So help on what to expect from them next and what might happen next for anyone who has been in a similar situation would be gratefully received.

Can give more info or background if needed, happy to answer questions if helps with context. We’ve always been a nice happy family, but looking back I have felt the distance from DS since he moved away to where his wife and her family are from. But interactions up until now have been fine, so I don’t know where this has all come from. Hence why I’m thinking DIL may have had a heavy hand in this.

Expecting some criticism, but hopefully more help that hate. TIA.

OP posts:
Italiangreyhound · Yesterday 02:21

You were right to take your son in, of course.

Scandalicious · Yesterday 02:21

Muminturmoil0 · 14/11/2026 23:55

I did use to speak with her directly actually thank you! DS would rarely pick up because he was always busy at work so I’d call her instead and speak to DGC and she would have a conversation with me too. So things were fine before. Sometimes she would even make the phone calls herself for us to speak to DGC and she never hinted at having a problem with us then! So when DS tells me all these things we’ve apparently done wrong over the years but nobody has ever mentioned it before, I’m just not buying it.
He claims she’s been hurt by comments we’ve made, yet she’s still answered our calls, called us herself, visited us and never said a word of there being a problem. So she’s either making it up now about having a problem with us all this time or she’s a very good two faced actress!

You say she is either making it up and had no problem, or she was a two faced actress. Are those really the only two options you can think of? Isn’t it much more likely that she was did feel unhappy or uncomfortable about something but was trying her best to make things work and didn’t want to risk making them worse? I can think of several other possible explanations too, no point listing here but the point is that there are so many possibilities beyond your distorted binary thinking.

It is also possible she hasn’t actually complained about you much or even at all, and your son is just trying to cast blame around onto both her and you. Either way, if your son is ringing you up having a go at you, that is absolutely his choice and his action. He is not made to do it by someone else, he’s a grown man and can decide for himself how he speaks to his own mother. Remember also, just as you don’t know if what he is saying about her is true, you also don’t know what he says to her about you is true. He could be blaming and bad mouthing you to her.

I do think that it was natural and understandable to take him in, of course you would. Affair or not he’s your son. I don’t understand why he couldn’t fine a solution closer to his kids. What about his work, is that totally flexi on location? But that aside, I think you should have reached out to your DIL and grandkids. You could have said that obviously he is your son, you are going to be there for him if he needs somewhere to live, but you hope she knows that are concerned for her p, you support her and you are very unhappy with how he treated her. You could have reached out more to see how the children were. You could have made it clear you will be pushing your son to get back to her area as soon as possible, support her in childcare and see his kids. Just because she was the main carer doesn’t mean it was easy to suddenly become a sole carer, especially one who’s juts been betrayed by her husband.

Instead you were and are trying to blame her for your own son’s behaviour. You make a lot of assumptions , and don’t have much reliable evidence about what she has actually said or done. I think if you can’t become a bit more thoughtful and open minded you’re going to have a struggle rebuilding things,

HangrySloth · Yesterday 02:27

Scandalicious · Yesterday 02:21

You say she is either making it up and had no problem, or she was a two faced actress. Are those really the only two options you can think of? Isn’t it much more likely that she was did feel unhappy or uncomfortable about something but was trying her best to make things work and didn’t want to risk making them worse? I can think of several other possible explanations too, no point listing here but the point is that there are so many possibilities beyond your distorted binary thinking.

It is also possible she hasn’t actually complained about you much or even at all, and your son is just trying to cast blame around onto both her and you. Either way, if your son is ringing you up having a go at you, that is absolutely his choice and his action. He is not made to do it by someone else, he’s a grown man and can decide for himself how he speaks to his own mother. Remember also, just as you don’t know if what he is saying about her is true, you also don’t know what he says to her about you is true. He could be blaming and bad mouthing you to her.

I do think that it was natural and understandable to take him in, of course you would. Affair or not he’s your son. I don’t understand why he couldn’t fine a solution closer to his kids. What about his work, is that totally flexi on location? But that aside, I think you should have reached out to your DIL and grandkids. You could have said that obviously he is your son, you are going to be there for him if he needs somewhere to live, but you hope she knows that are concerned for her p, you support her and you are very unhappy with how he treated her. You could have reached out more to see how the children were. You could have made it clear you will be pushing your son to get back to her area as soon as possible, support her in childcare and see his kids. Just because she was the main carer doesn’t mean it was easy to suddenly become a sole carer, especially one who’s juts been betrayed by her husband.

Instead you were and are trying to blame her for your own son’s behaviour. You make a lot of assumptions , and don’t have much reliable evidence about what she has actually said or done. I think if you can’t become a bit more thoughtful and open minded you’re going to have a struggle rebuilding things,

No sorry I would never speak to ny mil again if my husband destroyed our family by cheating and she rewarded such behavior esp bc I’ve been with my husband a long time and I’m close to my mil I would feel she is effectively taking sides

Uniqueusername3 · Yesterday 02:27

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

HangrySloth · Yesterday 02:29

Italiangreyhound · Yesterday 02:21

You were right to take your son in, of course.

For real!? He cheated on her destroying his family unit how was the tthe right move to make things easy for him and reward bad behavior. He isn’t a teenager he’s a grown man surely he had other options than staying with mommy

Twinklecomic · Yesterday 02:37

Muminturmoil0 · 14/11/2026 23:17

No didn’t contact her or the kids during that time, didn’t feel it was my place. Blood is thicker than water and all that and tbh I thought they would permanently split do didn’t think I’d see her again, and didn’t want DS to think I wasn’t supporting him (although I accept he was wrong to cheat)
Some might disagree with that, but I didn’t even think to get in touch with her. I’m sure in the same situation you’d do the same.
Once DS went back to her though I started up contact with the kids again, but as I say she never wanted to show her face.

That’s cold OP.
You didn’t contact your DIL or your two ten year old granddaughters because, “blood is thicker than water”? But your twin granddaughters are your blood too, and yet it didn’t occur to you to reach out to them?
At ten years old, they’d have registered that. It must have been hugely upsetting and left them feeling entirely unloved both by you and your son. Now they are retaliating in the only way available to them. Not that you seem to be bothered by much more than getting abuse from your son.
You chose to be very clannish and you backed the wrong clan member.
If I was your daughter in law and your grandchildren I’d have read loads into your complete radio silence and I’d have seen you as complicit.
Now your cheating son has turned his disloyalty onto you. If this state of play lasts you have no allies left on that branch of the family. I am sorry for your situation but you really don’t seem to get it. You say with regards to your blind support of your son, “I’m sure in the same situation you’d have done the same” I categorically would not have, and if you look at the Mumsnet mum-in- law notice board you’ll see that plenty of others didn’t either.

Italiangreyhound · Yesterday 02:53

@HangrySloth
Yes for real. If my adult child cheated on a partner, I would be very sad and upset. But i would not turn them away.

mysittingduck · Yesterday 03:05

You sound very very angry with DIL and I imagine you are difficult to see or speak to about this. She may be trying to see if her marriage can be saved, and feeling that your input won't help. She must be upset that you weren't in touch during the separation to see if she and the children were OK.

PollyBell · Yesterday 03:09

HangrySloth · Yesterday 02:29

For real!? He cheated on her destroying his family unit how was the tthe right move to make things easy for him and reward bad behavior. He isn’t a teenager he’s a grown man surely he had other options than staying with mommy

You leave no idea what ahe ia like nor what she has done wrong in the relationship, you only know one side and this all women are saints and never do anything wrong and men are always to blame, maybe she cheated first and the son didn't want to tell anyone

There are 2 sides to a relationship and I will always stay neutral on any of my child's relationships, I can support them as a parent while not taking sides regardless of who did what, their relationship is between the parties involved only

Lacksie · Yesterday 03:10

Having read all your posts, your attitude and behaviour to your DIL is beyond appalling.

You clearly have zero self awareness either.

Your son is responsible for calling you up and saying the things he did, but also it sounds like you deserved it.

There's no evidence your DIL has done anything wrong whatsoever , but if I were in her shoes I'd be having zero relationship with you going forward,

WhatHappenedToYourFurnitureCuz · Yesterday 03:12

Obvious rage bait is obvious.

Tamtim · Yesterday 03:18

If you care for your DIL and your DGC, surely the first thing you’d do upon DS’s arrival is call her to see if she’s ok and if she and the DGC need anything. To ignore them for six weeks is bizarre. Sure, you don’t want to get involved with the drama, but you are family. You should have wanted to check on her, see if she needed anything, check to see how the DGC are coping.

You are placing all the blame at your DIL’s door and none of it on your DS. He messed up, he called you with all these accusations, not her. Maybe she’s always felt like an outsider, maybe she’s upset and disappointed that you didn’t contact her or your grandchildren for six weeks.

Maybe give it a bit of time and then call her for a chat.

Atari5000 · Yesterday 03:19

When I’ve had friends cheat on their partners I’ve always rang to check how the partner is, I can’t understand how you think so many of us wouldn’t do that with family? It’s common decency, she might only be your DIL but she is still family! To not ring your granddaughters for 6 weeks?!!
No wonder they feel distant from you, my daughters are only 2 & 3 and are already aware when they don’t receive calls from their grandparents.
I also can’t understand how it must be your DIL just because it sounds ‘unlike your son’. I’m sure it was unlike your so. To cheat but he still did, and funnily enough just because he cheated doesn’t automatically mean that ‘she must have pushed him to it’ you might not want to believe it but your son might just be a scumbag cheater

ThatHangryRubyReader · Yesterday 03:20

Just wanted to say Id take my son in But man he would know I was disappointed and angry. and My DIL would know I was a mere call away if she needed anything. I would NEVER ever leave my DIL thinking I blamed her in anyway

Namenamchange · Yesterday 03:22

Your ds put you in a difficult situation, and now your kindness to him has been turned against you.
I reckon dil is just pissed off in general, the spot light fell on you and ds ran with it because it’s deflects from his behaviour.

I think it’s can be quite hard to see a grandparent have a better relationship with one set of children over another, but if inevitable if they are kept at arms length.

ThisMauveTurtle · Yesterday 03:24

Your dil didn't say anything that you know of.
I wouldn't be blaming her at all.
I'd blame your son

ThisMauveTurtle · Yesterday 03:34

He wouldn't cheat if it was a happy marriage WOW
Why is he gone back to her so if he was unhappy with her

LoudWriter · Yesterday 03:44

Muminturmoil0 · Yesterday 00:59

I don’t know if a lot of you are misunderstanding what I’m saying here or if you just can’t appreciate my position because you’ve not been in the situation I am in here. Or whether you’re just being purposefully argumentative as often seems to be the case on here!

You think the most plausible scenario here is that "Maybe she’s embarrassed because we know what he’s done and she doesn’t want to face us because she feels like a mug.".

No-one is misunderstanding what you're saying, and that attitude is exactly why so many PP are disagreeing with you- you are failing to see that your DIL is more of a victim here than you. Your son is a cheat- you can love him and take him in of course, but you also didn't give a shit that he'd hurt your DIL or your DGDs and chose to turn a blind eye to his actions. You reap what you sow OP- raise a man to treat women like shit and he'll treat ALL women like shit. You think you're exempt from his lack of respect towards women because you're his mother?!!

Has it not occured to you that maybe it's your son who's embarrassed because you know what he's done and doesn't want to face you because HE feels like a twat? No, of course not

Justtobenosey · Yesterday 03:50

The thing that stands out to me, you call the children once a month and your others live incredibly close. There is without a doubt favouritism.

I live 300 miles away from my parents, my sister lives next door! And guess what they call my children EVERY SINGLE DAY.

why is it easier for them to visit you? Have you seen them at all in the 2 years since they last came?

bottom line is she doesn’t like you because you are absolutely shocking grandparents and nothing you say can excuse that

Sleepyjeans · Yesterday 04:23

Muminturmoil0 · Yesterday 01:07

Errrrr let me think… he’s my son! Right or wrong he will always be welcome to stay in our home.
Their mum is their main caregiver so it’s not like she’s not used to looking after them alone!
She kicked him out (not saying that was the wrong thing to do, even though she did later have him back) so she must’ve been confident she could cope without him, and where did she expect him to go? Of course we as his parents would take him in. She’d do the same as would the rest of you.

Well of course you were right to house your son. Anyone pretending otherwise is batshit or just lying for fun.

And you're right, she was a mug to have him back, cheaters don't change.

It would have been good if you'd checked in on her and the kids. Sent money, offered to visit, anything really. But what's done is done and it's actually incredibly standard - despite the faux shock on this thread - that when a couple split up the family continues links mainly only with their own blood.

If you were in touch with the grandchilren prior to this, you should have kept in touch with them afterwards, however.

Anyway, that aside, without knowing the specifics of what she is saying you've done, chapter and verse, there's no way to really say if they're being unfair or not.

To be fair, you'd have had to be pretty gruesome to deserve getting it both barrels like that.

If she's mainly upset that you didn't reach out when they had split up, and overall had a few quibbles with your interactions over the years, a sane and fair reaction would be for the dil to go cold with you and just let her husband deal with you and facilitate visits for the grandchildren. But maybe there's more.

It's also almost definitely some displacement. She's understandably absolutely fucking furious that your son has utterly humiliated her and destroyed their marriage, and she's casting around for someone to take out her anger on - it's often the betrayal partner that gets both barrels as well rather than the man who cheats.

There's nothing much you can do I'm afraid. Try not to rise to it or keep arguing about it. You could offer family counselling if it's something you think they'd engage in.

Meanwhile, don't keep arguing, just tell your son the door's always open, that he, your grandchildren and his wife are, as they have always been, welcome in your home. State that if they want to talk about it respectfully you're fine with that or happy to just leave it and move on - least said soonest mended is actually a fantastic way of dealing with a lot of issues and it's a shame society now thinks endlessly rehashing issues is helpful, it's not, endless venting just consolidates bad memories and bitterness.

And then just leave it. I'd then go with sending your son a message once a month saying hi, we miss you all, hope you're all well, and sending birthday and Christmas messages etc.

Also, don't keep talking about it to other family members, you're only fuelling the fire.

Sounds like they're going down the no contact route. Sometimes that's for good reasons, and sometimes not. If they've decided to make you the scapegoat for their terrible marriage there's not much you can do. If you've actually done something to deserve such treatment, there's not much to be done either.

Just keep the door open. And do put money aside or gifts or whatever is appropriate for the grandchildren for each birthday and Christmas, as that way they get to see you always did care about them, if matters improve and you do get to see them again.

AnnoyedAsAllHeck · Yesterday 04:27

Muminturmoil0 · 14/11/2026 23:14

Well I don’t know if maybe DIL has said the only way she’ll have him back is if he cuts us off. I don’t know, I’m just trying to think of reasons why he would do this as we’ve done nothing wrong. Maybe she’s embarrassed because we know what he’s done and she doesn’t want to face us because she feels like a mug.
I admit I’m clutching at straws but I can’t believe when DS says DIL has never liked us because she’s never said so before. DS wasn’t being verbally abusive, he said he needed to get some things off his chest including how we’ve apparently made her feel over the years and how DGDs apparently don’t like visiting us because we seem to favour our DDs kids who live on the same street as us. He ended up shouting at me because I dared to stand up for myself and disagree with some things he was saying.
It’s just not like him and it seemed to come from nowhere. He wasn’t like this with us when he stayed here but I can just imagine DIL standing there telling him what to say, because the way he was carrying on just wasn’t like him at all.

Of course he was nice when you were housing him after hs cheating.
I also wonder if you were supportive of the DGDs and wife while he was staying with you?

Just going on the basis of what you have written, here is my opinion:
I think your son has dumped the blame of his mistreatment of his marriage vows on you. Instead of shouldering his sins, he has decided that he can blame you. He can tell his wife that you didnt like her, that the DGDs were not equal to his sisters kids, and anything else he wants to dump on you to lessen his consequences If he keeps saying you were saying this, that and the other when you would talk with him, he can even try to blame the affair on you because you were always dissing his wife and made him "doubt her love". JMHO

It doesn't matter if ANY of it is true. It's what he has gotten her to believe and perhaps the therapist to believe.

I don't think you should be blaming the DIL when it's your son going off the deep end. He would be that nasty if he was trying to convince her that everything wrong he did is because of you and the rest of your family.

fairiesinthegarden1 · Yesterday 04:28

labamba007 · Yesterday 00:16

The part that stood out to me oddly was calling your DIL a mug for taking your cheating son back. Not nice at all and I suspect she’s picked up on this unpleasantness. I would be thinking she was a saint and telling my DS he was an idiot.

thid is all on your DS. And he might’ve uncovered things in therapy that have annoyed him about you.

This. And the comments about ‘she didn’t show her face’ when contact was made with the grandkids when DS was staying with OP. As if she had something to feel ashamed of. Rather than the cheating son. Very strange.

OP scoffs at her DIL taking her son back but clearly fails to understand or acknowledge that, perhaps, DIL has been downtrodden or treated very badly by her precious son, and now doesn’t have the self esteem to kick him to the curb? So she’s doubling down on the idea that ‘DIL is taking him back because she knows she’s at fault for him cheating!’

with the nastiness OP shows to her DIL, it isn’t hard to see that son is likely to have behaved similarly to his wife, and this could have been going on for a long time! And I suspect this is precisely what has been picked up by their therapist.

Thepossibility · Yesterday 04:40

I'd like to think if my DH cheated on me and went off to stay with MIL, my MIL would care about me enough to get in touch and check on me and her grandchildren. I'd like to think knowing each other for years and being so called family has earned me that.
She was going through an awful time, of course it is your place to show her you still give a shit about her!!! And you seemingly dropped her (and your grandchildren!) like a stone because your son did something awful to them.
And you obviously merrily continued a relationship with your other grandchildren all the while, didn't you? The ones that didn't particularly need your support because their lives hadn't just blown up?
I don't know if I could forgive that coldness.
YOU fucked up here.

Phoenix1Arisen · Yesterday 04:43

In short, the bottom line of "blood is thicker than water" wasn't true in the final analysis was it?

Those grandchildren are your stake in the future, your flesh and blood but, when the proverbial stuff hit the fan, they heard not a peep out of you.

I cannot think of any words you could utter, then or now, that speak more loudly or clearly of where they rank in your thinking. Your silence would have been deafening.

I'm sorry for your sadness and for the sake of those children, I hope the relationship can be repaired.

AnnoyedAsAllHeck · Yesterday 04:47

Muminturmoil0 · Yesterday 00:10

I don’t want DS or DGDs to hate us, heck I don’t even want DIL to hate us. But I’m not accepting blame when I’ve done nothing wrong and I’m not apologising when I’m not sorry because I haven’t done anything.
I think it’s wrong for DS to even suggest we should do that. His wife might think she can manipulate him into having a go at us but she can think again (they both can!) if they think she can manipulate me into apologising for things I’ve not done!
Maybe she’s just trying to get power back after the cheating or she is indeed pissed off with us for having DS with us, but she threw him out! She’d do the same for her kids in the same situation.

@Muminturmoil0 Serves me right for not reading everything.

You left the DIL and DGDs to fend for themselves while your NVDS was living at your place. You actually use the excuse "blood is thicker than water and all that". You actually say other MNers would do the same.
Well, guess what? You are 150% wrong. I think few MNers would abandon the DGDs and DIL when their son was the screw-up. By ignoring the rest of the family, you basically supported what your NVDS did, and you actually went and made excuses as to why he might have cheated! By blaming your DIL, of course.

I am embarrassed of what I wrote earlier. Your son has shown that the apple doesn't fall far from the tree.

Your DIL and especially your DGDs must have been so hurt. You made your bed, now sleep well in it.

Swipe left for the next trending thread