Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Am I being ridiculous or would ‘DH’ annoy you too?

139 replies

Whoknows94 · 14/11/2026 19:37

So a few years ago my DH really wanted a new gaming console- they were extremely hard to get and quite expensive but I drove 4 hours each way to get it and surprise him with it for Xmas that year. My 2 teenage boys (16&14 now) decided they wanted one few months later so saved money and did extra jobs and bought themselves one each. DSS (also 14) preferred a different console so wasn’t interested until a few months ago when he decided he wanted the same one. Me and DH discussed it and he was told he needed to save birthday and XMas money they same as my DS’s- he didn’t have any money at the time as he has recently broken 2 phones by getting annoyed and smashing them which we will not pay to replace.
i have today come home and DH has just given his DS his console. I am angry that my 2 children in the house were made to earn and save for it and he just gets given one which is not a fair message to my sons. DH has decided to sulk off to bed as I told him as much and I actually don’t care he is ignoring me because I feel we discussed this, the expectation was given to his son as mine and then he just gives him it- am also annoyed that I spent a lot of time and money getting him that gift and he just gave it away.
AiBu or would you be annoyed too?

OP posts:
Cherrysoup · 15/11/2026 09:15

And again, it’s very naive if you honestly think after almost 10 years together that you won’t lose part of the house should you split up. Dunno why you’re allowing him to use you as his domestic skivvy. I’d be doing bugger all for him.

askmenow · 15/11/2026 09:19

Whoknows94 · 14/11/2026 20:01

we live in my house- only my name is on the deeds and a pre nup was signed prior to marriage. My DS see there dad every other weekend but getting to the age where they don’t always go due to friends and commitments.
we have been together 9 1/2 years

You sound as tho you have your head screwed on and he is making trouble for the future in his handling of his son.

Given your general dissatisfaction this won’t get better and I’d be cutting my losses now.

Think about what’s your plan for your future.

Sleepyjeans · 15/11/2026 09:22

askmenow · 15/11/2026 09:08

I wouldn’t accept him doing this. That would be it for me. I’d be looking for an out and be preparing as of now.
A sulking man is never attractive. And you are either a family or not.
He owes your sons comparable gifts.

He owes your sons comparable gifts

Lol. So much lol. No, he definitively, absolutely, does not.

DraigCymraeg · 15/11/2026 09:32

Whoknows94 · 14/11/2026 19:37

So a few years ago my DH really wanted a new gaming console- they were extremely hard to get and quite expensive but I drove 4 hours each way to get it and surprise him with it for Xmas that year. My 2 teenage boys (16&14 now) decided they wanted one few months later so saved money and did extra jobs and bought themselves one each. DSS (also 14) preferred a different console so wasn’t interested until a few months ago when he decided he wanted the same one. Me and DH discussed it and he was told he needed to save birthday and XMas money they same as my DS’s- he didn’t have any money at the time as he has recently broken 2 phones by getting annoyed and smashing them which we will not pay to replace.
i have today come home and DH has just given his DS his console. I am angry that my 2 children in the house were made to earn and save for it and he just gets given one which is not a fair message to my sons. DH has decided to sulk off to bed as I told him as much and I actually don’t care he is ignoring me because I feel we discussed this, the expectation was given to his son as mine and then he just gives him it- am also annoyed that I spent a lot of time and money getting him that gift and he just gave it away.
AiBu or would you be annoyed too?

I'd be more concerned about the boy's anger issues.

OneHazelBird · 15/11/2026 09:33

Going against the grain here but I think YABU

Surely you patent your kids how you want - by making them pay for their condoles.

And he parents his kid how he wants - by not making him pay.

I’d be annoyed if my DP tried dictating how I raised my DC.

You’re also BU to be annoyed that his DS didn’t pay - but then fully admit that DH didn’t pay either and you travelled 4 hours to get it for him.

Moonnstarz · 15/11/2026 09:38

OneHazelBird · 15/11/2026 09:33

Going against the grain here but I think YABU

Surely you patent your kids how you want - by making them pay for their condoles.

And he parents his kid how he wants - by not making him pay.

I’d be annoyed if my DP tried dictating how I raised my DC.

You’re also BU to be annoyed that his DS didn’t pay - but then fully admit that DH didn’t pay either and you travelled 4 hours to get it for him.

Finally someone else seeing that DH got his gifted while her own son's were made to pay for their own!
That's the bit that stands out to me.
The points about the DSS are irrelevant, and just added as an attempt to direct the thread in her favour (horrible SS not deserving of presents, DH doesn't parent him well).
She was happy to drive around for hours to get her DH the present, making it sound like he is prioritised in the family over everyone, why is this?

NineteenSeventyThree · 15/11/2026 09:44

Your DH got the console when it was newly released 'a few years ago'.

Your sons wanted them 'a few months later' - so the same year it was released - and saved up to get them.

Your stepson only decided he wanted one 'a few months ago'.

The point I'm making is that at the time your sons wanted it, it was the brand new, expensive console that everyone wanted and was difficult to find. 'A few years' is a long time in tech - while it will still be a decent console, it won't be the viral 'thing' that everyone wants and it talking about, and your stepson is getting a used one that will be worth much less than a brand new console in its year of release.

It isn't comparable, in other words. If your sons had been happy to wait a few years, they could have got used ones more cheaply. Nothing wrong in wanting the latest one if that's what you're into, but it comes with a price tag and you've taught your sons a good lesson by asking them to save up rather than buying them brand new consoles.

It's up to your stepson's dad in any case what he does, but as I've said, passing on a console he's had for a few years is not comparable to rushing to a shop and buying his son a brand new one.

Edit for typo

BustyLaRoux · 15/11/2026 09:50

I actually don’t think children should always be treated the same. They are different people. What I do for my son is different to what I do for my daughter. They’re very different so I treat them according to their needs and talents and limitations.

I agree with a PP who asked whose idea it was that your boys earn their console. I presume yours? Perhaps he parents differently to you. Is he favouring his child so much as just parenting differently?

What would piss me off is that you spent a lot of money and effort getting that gift for your DH and he just gave it away!!! Gave it to a child who seems entitled. This says your gift meant very little to him if he could just give it away like that, and this is the part that would really upset me.

I did live in a blended family for 6 years. My parenting style and my ex’s were very different. I felt his children were spoilt and given far too much leeway. But at the same time he was authoritarian in his approach and they were scared of upsetting him. I parent very differently. My children aren’t spoilt. They understand the value of things. My son has a little job and pays for his own things. They are grateful for the smallest of gifts and expect very little. They are cheeky and rude sometimes, but always kind and apologetic if they upset me. We could not have been more different in the way we parented.

You can’t change the way he parents and you can’t expect him to adopt your approach no more than you’re willing to adopt his. This is blended families for you! The trick is to blend with someone who shares your values in the first place. (Wish younger me had realised this!).

It doesn’t sound as though his son is growing up to be a stellar young man (smashing phones in anger) and you don’t have to look far to see why.

Your issues are about much more than just this incident though. Your DH doesn’t seem to share your values and you sound like you are carrying far too much with little support. I think you know what you need to do. Thank goodness it’s your house!

OneHazelBird · 15/11/2026 09:55

Moonnstarz · 15/11/2026 09:38

Finally someone else seeing that DH got his gifted while her own son's were made to pay for their own!
That's the bit that stands out to me.
The points about the DSS are irrelevant, and just added as an attempt to direct the thread in her favour (horrible SS not deserving of presents, DH doesn't parent him well).
She was happy to drive around for hours to get her DH the present, making it sound like he is prioritised in the family over everyone, why is this?

I completely agree!!

OP not only paid for DH’s but drove a ridiculous distance to get it.

Then she makes her own DS’s pay for their own.

But then gets annoyed when DH does the same thing for his son as OP did for him (without the long drive and it being second hand).

OP is the inconsistent one here and no way would I make my DCs pay for something when I’ve given it to my boyfriend for free.

I wonder what other things the DP does/doesn’t have to do compared to her DCs.

CleverKitten · 15/11/2026 09:59

You parent your DC how you want to and leave him to do the same with his DC.

viques · 15/11/2026 10:16

So he gave the only child in the house who didn’t have one an out of date, second hand games console. 😁

The good news is the DSS will be able to pay for his new phone now.

1coconut2coconut3coconut4 · 15/11/2026 10:23

What was his rationale for doing it, did he explain? Had he agreed with you about earning it or did you say that and he didn't really engage? Not good if he just ducked the question but worse i if he definitely agreed and then went back on it. Either way, you wouldn't feel so strongly about something comparatively minor if there weren't other issues. If you can't trust him to be your partner by mucking in (sounds like you are always doing the work) then you at least want him to be a partner when parenting. And sounds like he's not.

If you do stay with him never buy him an expensive present again, and tell him it is because he obviously didn't value it enough if he was willing to give it away like that, nd you cant afford to just throw money away.

NineteenSeventyThree · 15/11/2026 10:26

1coconut2coconut3coconut4 · 15/11/2026 10:23

What was his rationale for doing it, did he explain? Had he agreed with you about earning it or did you say that and he didn't really engage? Not good if he just ducked the question but worse i if he definitely agreed and then went back on it. Either way, you wouldn't feel so strongly about something comparatively minor if there weren't other issues. If you can't trust him to be your partner by mucking in (sounds like you are always doing the work) then you at least want him to be a partner when parenting. And sounds like he's not.

If you do stay with him never buy him an expensive present again, and tell him it is because he obviously didn't value it enough if he was willing to give it away like that, nd you cant afford to just throw money away.

Last Christmas, I gave you an Xbox
But the very next year, you gave it away
This year, to save me from tears
I'm not getting you anything special ...

NorthernJim · 15/11/2026 10:27

I think you're over reacting a bit on this. Has she actually outright gifted the games console to dss, or just letting him use it (i.e. sharing)?

It does seem a bit weird to me for a household to own 4 identical games consoles, can none of them share anything? I'd especially expect a parent to share things like this with the DC. Imagine telling your kids they can't watch the TV in the living room, that they'll have to save up and buy their own TV to watch in their bedroom.

Bountyhunter888 · 15/11/2026 10:33

Whoknows94 · 14/11/2026 20:01

we live in my house- only my name is on the deeds and a pre nup was signed prior to marriage. My DS see there dad every other weekend but getting to the age where they don’t always go due to friends and commitments.
we have been together 9 1/2 years

If he doesnt have your back then kick him out

Sleepyjeans · 15/11/2026 10:43

1coconut2coconut3coconut4 · 15/11/2026 10:23

What was his rationale for doing it, did he explain? Had he agreed with you about earning it or did you say that and he didn't really engage? Not good if he just ducked the question but worse i if he definitely agreed and then went back on it. Either way, you wouldn't feel so strongly about something comparatively minor if there weren't other issues. If you can't trust him to be your partner by mucking in (sounds like you are always doing the work) then you at least want him to be a partner when parenting. And sounds like he's not.

If you do stay with him never buy him an expensive present again, and tell him it is because he obviously didn't value it enough if he was willing to give it away like that, nd you cant afford to just throw money away.

He doesn't have to explain why he gave his kid an old second hand out of date gaming console, and he needs no rationale. His kid, his choice.

Perhaps OP should have spent all that money on her sons, years ago, instead of on her boyfriend. She definitely needs to stop trying to tell him what he can and can't give his own son.

Franpie · 15/11/2026 10:45

My guess is that this is a PS5 and DSS wants one now as GTA6 is being released this week exclusively on the PS5.

If it is the PS5 and you bought it for your DH when it was released, that was 6 years ago! So your DH has given his son a 6 year old console. I don’t think there’s anything wrong with that. In fact it’s more sensible than your DSS having to buy one himself now just for 1 game.

I’ve just had to buy my DS a PS5 just so he can play that one game (he’s usually a PC gamer having built his own PC from scratch). It’s bonkers! Had DH had an old one knocking about (alas DH isn’t a gamer) I would have given it to DS myself whether DH liked it or not!

ApplePumpkin · 15/11/2026 10:53

So if it was 6 years ago the op’s sons were then 10 and 8. How long did it take them to save up to buy their own @Whoknows94 ?
And who in their right mind would allow 2 young children to spend hundreds on 2 consoles ??

Maisymouse2 · 15/11/2026 10:58

Oh god so what
2 kids saving compared to a single child.
Let ot go and stop the games and comparing or youre expectations

JayJayj · 15/11/2026 11:19

You can do what you want with your children. Your husband can do what he wants with his child.

CleverKitten · 15/11/2026 11:19

NorthernJim · 15/11/2026 10:27

I think you're over reacting a bit on this. Has she actually outright gifted the games console to dss, or just letting him use it (i.e. sharing)?

It does seem a bit weird to me for a household to own 4 identical games consoles, can none of them share anything? I'd especially expect a parent to share things like this with the DC. Imagine telling your kids they can't watch the TV in the living room, that they'll have to save up and buy their own TV to watch in their bedroom.

I don’t think it’s very unusual for families who are into gaming. We have a few of the same PlayStations and Xboxes in the house plus a Wii.
I can’t remember how many I’ve bought over the years, I’m sure I’ve paid for the actual one twice on more than one occasion where I’ve bought it for one DC, then they want the new one out and I’ve bought it off them to give to another DC.
I think the OP is overreacting.

Laurmolonlabe · 15/11/2026 11:48

Use the Christmas present allowance for DH to even this up and if he complains tell him to stop being such a toddler.

EmeraldShamrock000 · 15/11/2026 11:49

Would you have been unhappy if your partner gave his DS £500 or would that also be a problem? You expect his DS to save his pocket money, like your children. How much did your child’s father pay into their very quickly earned money? Did you offer to pay DSS for jobs around the house? You are being unreasonable. You just don’t like his child yet you expect him to treat your children as equals why you dislike his.

Whoknows94 · 15/11/2026 12:02

All 3 get pocket money and mine used Xmas and birthday money they had saved as all 3 have birthdays around Xmas so often get money to save and use. DSS just used a lot of his on broken phones and lost devices so hadn’t saved much. I never mentioned not liking him at all and have not once made any comments about him my annoyance was purely aimed at my DH NOT his son

OP posts:
MyDpsanarse · 15/11/2026 12:11

The game systems aren't the important part here, the Ops run ragged trying to run the household, work and care for a family member and her DH doesn't seem to be pulling his weight. Your DH feels guilty so he gives your DSS money or gifts, what the boy would probably prefer is his Dad's time. He needs to stop sulking and start being a better DH and DF or he'll end up divorced and with an overindulged son