Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

M&S refusing to sell me alcohol because I was with my teen

110 replies

gingerninja · 14/11/2026 18:54

I’m baffled, I had one bottle of red wine and three canned cocktails and I was refused the sale because my 17 year old (who doesn’t even drink) was with me and didn’t have any ID! I questioned the cashier who told me that it was because of the amount of booze I was getting! Not that it matters but it was for sharing with other adults and how does that tally with her being under 18? Absolutely barmy so I walked out and took my business to Tesco. UABU it’s a sensible policy UANU the policy is batshit.

OP posts:
Frankie2018 · 16/11/2026 18:21

Im 43 and got asked for ID in Aldi to buy non alcohol mulled wine. I thought I'd picked up the wrong one and said oh sorry I wanted the non alcoholic one. The guy said they ID for that now to deter teenagers. So what if teenagers want to buy alcohol free mulled wine? Nothing makes sense anymore.

Nighttimenoise · 16/11/2026 18:29

It's ridiculous, if they think that you're going to give alcohol to a child just because they are with you in the shop, then they should ask you to prove that you don't have any children at home if you're shopping alone.

ProfessorofCunning · 16/11/2026 18:51

Please believe me when I say that most checkout workers hate the gamble of whether or not to ask for ID. It’s fine to use common sense, but they are the ones that get fined and in most cases lose their job, which is why it looks as though they don’t. I would always support a colleague who has asked for ID. Test sales happen all the time, and they aren’t a 14 year looking like they are trying their luck.
Proxy sales are also a real thing, is your bottle of wine and cocktails worth more than the cashiers job to you? They don’t know you aren’t a test sale. They quite often push quite hard to get a cashier to put the sale through just to see how they react. It has to be a blanket check and down to the lowest common denominator else shops could be seen as discriminating. Bring it up with the law makers, and do not take it out on the £12.75ph shop worker.

ZanyTealQuail · 16/11/2026 18:58

Ridiculous! I had someone challenge me in coop when I was pregnant and buying beers for my partner 😱

NamelessNancy · 16/11/2026 19:40

WonderingWanda · 14/11/2026 21:32

It's annoying when they do that but I can sort of see the thinking when it's a 17 yo. What I don't get is when I had my primary school kids with me years ago and they refused to sell me a bottle of wine...why the fuck would I be buying white wine for a 10 year old. Or even more mental when I brought some paracetamol for my 16yo this summer and they refused to serve me because he didn't look 25. 16 yo are allowed to buy paracetamol. I was buying it for him because I am his parent, if I can't buy it for my teenager then who can?

This annoys me so much. There is no legal age limit for paracetamol, yet stores enfore their own. Teens should absolutely be able to buy painkillers.

Cattyisbatty · 16/11/2026 19:57

I was w (then) 18 year old DS in Tesco buying a bottle of whisky for someone’s present and I had to tell him to wait outside for me or they wouldn’t sell it as he had no ID on him.

Svalberg · 16/11/2026 19:57

A relative of mine who'd had leg surgery was asked for ID, she was just out of hospital & needed paracetamol - she was 50ish but looked at least 60 being just out of hospital. She didn't have a passport or driving license so she had to walk to the next nearest seller of paracetamol and unfortunately it set the recovery back and she ended up back in hospital.

yellowbobble · 16/11/2026 19:57

Frankie2018 · 16/11/2026 18:21

Im 43 and got asked for ID in Aldi to buy non alcohol mulled wine. I thought I'd picked up the wrong one and said oh sorry I wanted the non alcoholic one. The guy said they ID for that now to deter teenagers. So what if teenagers want to buy alcohol free mulled wine? Nothing makes sense anymore.

This is the reason I’ve been given as well when Ive been ID’d for non-alcoholic drinks. So the rule is there to deter teenagers from … not drinking alcohol? Make it make sense

As a PP said it’s not the cashiers I’m annoyed at, it’s the stupid policies. I actually feel sorry for shop workers having to enforce such nonsense or be bollocked / sacked.

Iloveeverycat · 16/11/2026 20:05

They are very wrong to do this in sainsburys you only ask ID for the person that is paying doesn't matter who they are with even if they are with friends.

user1484264563 · 16/11/2026 20:11

NimbleTaupeTiger · 14/11/2026 19:00

The policy is batshit. You daughter cannot buy drink at her age but legally she can drink from the age of 5 at home so wtf are M&S up to?

It's mystifying.

Trading standards send mystery shoppers into stores, it's trying to catch store staff out, people will rightly err on the side of caution.

user1484264563 · 16/11/2026 20:13

Iloveeverycat · 16/11/2026 20:05

They are very wrong to do this in sainsburys you only ask ID for the person that is paying doesn't matter who they are with even if they are with friends.

That is absolutely not correct and that action would result in a disciplinary action.

Laura1978 · 17/11/2026 06:22

The cashier is totally in the right. Having held an alcohol licence and been on many courses on the subject I say well done cashier! You have clearly never worked in retail.

Sartre · 17/11/2026 06:45

FartyFriday · 14/11/2026 18:56

There’s been loads of threads about this.

It’s to discourage adults buying for underage drinkers.

If you were stupid enough to buy alcohol for someone underage, you wouldn’t take them up to the till.

It happened to me in Morrisons about 10 years ago so it’s nothing new. I was with my younger brother and she wouldn’t serve me as a result because he was 17.

Prioryfodder · 17/11/2026 07:09

I’ve had this at Waitrose (on a thread a couple of years ago). It’s patently ridiculous. I asked if the decision would be the same if my daughter was 6, or 10, 12? It’s judging you, your parenting and your child and should not be tolerated. I think if you are young enough to need to show ID then fair enough - to stop teens buying for younger friends. But stopping parents doing a normal shop in the company of their child is just plain stupid

Iloveeverycat · 17/11/2026 09:02

user1484264563 · 16/11/2026 20:13

That is absolutely not correct and that action would result in a disciplinary action.

They only refuse if they think it is a proxy sale and they are intentionally buying for someone else. If mum has a bottle of wine and has a child with her it is obvious that it is for the mum.

Maverickess · 17/11/2026 09:48

NimbleTaupeTiger · 14/11/2026 19:00

The policy is batshit. You daughter cannot buy drink at her age but legally she can drink from the age of 5 at home so wtf are M&S up to?

It's mystifying.

Even though it's not illegal for the child to drink alcohol at home from 5, it's still illegal for the cashier to sell it when they could 'reasonably' suspect that it's for that child* and they can be personally fined for it, as well as the person holding the premises licence and the business, and here's the thing, the law doesn't have to have been broken for that to happen, you can be fined or have a licence revoked, suspended or have conditions added if a condition of a licence condition is broken, or could have been broken.
Protection of children from the effect of alcohol is a mandatory licencing condition and you must demonstrate how you do this with robust policies, and how you adhere to them.

*And it's up to a licencing officer or police officer to determine if I should 'reasonably' know if it was intended for someone under 18, or if I've broken a condition of the licence.

Is it ridiculous? Yes I do think it is, but that doesn't change anything unfortunately. And let's face it, if someone's 14 year old comes home pissed and it's discovered that the alcohol was bought by someone over 18 with that 14 year old present, most people would be demanding that the cashier is held to account, I've seen it on threads here.

Hoppinggreen · 17/11/2026 10:00

KnittedPenguinHat · 14/11/2026 20:09

It’s a silly policy because if you actually were buying alcohol for a teenager you wouldn’t be stupid enough to have them standing there next to you at the till!

Quite
If I am buying booze for DS (17) I tell him to go and wait in the car or something

WilliamTopazMcGonagallPoorPoetFromDundeeBeItTold · 17/11/2026 10:25

KnittedPenguinHat · 14/11/2026 20:09

It’s a silly policy because if you actually were buying alcohol for a teenager you wouldn’t be stupid enough to have them standing there next to you at the till!

Yes, it seems deliberately designed to only inconvenience the people who aren't remotely planning on breaking any rules. It's a bit like the cameras on the self-service tills at Morrison's, where they call the assistant over if they can see something in your trolley that you haven't scanned - whether it's items for a second transaction, a free local paper that you picked up at the entrance, a handbag or even - so I was told by one exasperated assistant - somebody's 'unpaid-for' toddler sitting in the trolley!

Meanwhile, the actual thieves are the ones filling a holdall with booze or other expensive stuff and walking straight out, going nowhere near a till. You could even have slipped any small, expensive item in your coat pocket beforehand. The very, very last thing any determined thief would ever do is to leave an item on full view in their trolley, when they had no intention of paying for it.

LewisChessmenMeetSingingHeads · 17/11/2026 10:33

It's the law that is inconsistent here - the cashier has done nothing wrong.

It is not illegal to drink alcohol in private premises at any age above the age of five. Yet it is illegal to sell alcohol to someone if there is a suspicion it might be for consumption by someone under the age of 18. That is inconsistent.

If the government doesn't want people under the age of 18 drinking, make it illegal, full stop. It will still happen, just as stopping a mum buying wine with her DD present won't stop the 18 year old in the group who has ID buying a fucktonne of vodka for his 17 year old mates who are waiting outside the offie - but at least the rules would be consistent.

WilliamTopazMcGonagallPoorPoetFromDundeeBeItTold · 17/11/2026 10:35

yellowbobble · 15/11/2026 10:01

I think it’s a ridiculous policy

Same for the policy of asking for ID for non-alcoholic drinks. DH and I occasionally buy non alcoholic beers and cocktail tinnies (literally 0% alcohol) as sometimes we fancy a drink but don’t want to get pissed or have a hangover the next day, and we get ID’d for those as well.

I don't drink alcohol either, but I do sometimes buy the 0% wine and beer - and as you say, you have to prove (or just be waved by at my age!) that you're 18 and thus old enough to buy soft drinks.

I wonder what would happen if I went in the shop with my 14yo DS, and sought to buy some 0% beer. Would they refuse the sale to me, because even though I am obviously over 18 and thus they are happy to sell me soft drinks, I might be wanting to buy those soft drinks for my DS - who is clearly also legally old enough to buy and consume soft drinks, as he is old enough to go into a shop, carry them and hand over money - whether it's mineral water, milkshake, squash, Fanta, 0% beer or any other drink that doesn't contain any alcohol?!

Maverickess · 17/11/2026 11:21

WilliamTopazMcGonagallPoorPoetFromDundeeBeItTold · 17/11/2026 10:35

I don't drink alcohol either, but I do sometimes buy the 0% wine and beer - and as you say, you have to prove (or just be waved by at my age!) that you're 18 and thus old enough to buy soft drinks.

I wonder what would happen if I went in the shop with my 14yo DS, and sought to buy some 0% beer. Would they refuse the sale to me, because even though I am obviously over 18 and thus they are happy to sell me soft drinks, I might be wanting to buy those soft drinks for my DS - who is clearly also legally old enough to buy and consume soft drinks, as he is old enough to go into a shop, carry them and hand over money - whether it's mineral water, milkshake, squash, Fanta, 0% beer or any other drink that doesn't contain any alcohol?!

It can be seen as irresponsible and 'encouraging' people under 18 into alcohol to give them access to products that are branded as usually alcoholic, like 0% beers etc.
Everywhere I've worked it comes under ID rules the same as alcohol does, I don't have to agree with it, but I do have to abide by it.

You have to be a 'proper' person (or words to that effect, I forget the specific wording now) to have a licence to sell alcohol and be the 'responsible' person, locally someone lost their alcohol licence because of untasteful things they were posting on Facebook and people complained about it, and the posts weren't related to alcohol at all.

All these licence conditions, policies etc are is the government saying "Look at what we're doing to tackle under aged drinking" while doing absolutely nothing other than pissing people off.

TheBrunswick · 17/11/2026 11:36

My sil, bil were denied access to a vineyard in the US because they had baby dgd with them.

I pointed out that they should have taken her to a gun club, it would have been easier to get in.

LeedsLoiner · 17/11/2026 11:39

I got refused at a Tesco checkout with my then 19 year old son. They asked for his ID and the only thing he had on him was his university ID card, the cashier said that because it didn't have his date or birth on it, it wasn't acceptable even through they agreed that you have to be 18 to go to university.
I left the wine and all my shopping on the conveyor belt and walked out.

LewisChessmenMeetSingingHeads · 17/11/2026 11:43

LeedsLoiner · 17/11/2026 11:39

I got refused at a Tesco checkout with my then 19 year old son. They asked for his ID and the only thing he had on him was his university ID card, the cashier said that because it didn't have his date or birth on it, it wasn't acceptable even through they agreed that you have to be 18 to go to university.
I left the wine and all my shopping on the conveyor belt and walked out.

You don't have to be 18 to go to university. There are cases of 'child prodigies' going at a younger age, there was one in my year at university, a 13 year old maths whizz.

I agree it's rare, though.

Scarlettpixie · 17/11/2026 11:58

It is ridiculous but comes up a lot so it isn't just M&S.

My son went to the Tesco Express to get some bits for tea and asked him to get me a bottle of prosecco. They wouldn't sell it to him even though he had ID because his gf was with him and she didn't.

We also had the Pro Cook knife experience. My son was not allowed to hold one and I wasn't allowed to buy one because he didn't have ID.