Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

M&S refusing to sell me alcohol because I was with my teen

110 replies

gingerninja · 14/11/2026 18:54

I’m baffled, I had one bottle of red wine and three canned cocktails and I was refused the sale because my 17 year old (who doesn’t even drink) was with me and didn’t have any ID! I questioned the cashier who told me that it was because of the amount of booze I was getting! Not that it matters but it was for sharing with other adults and how does that tally with her being under 18? Absolutely barmy so I walked out and took my business to Tesco. UABU it’s a sensible policy UANU the policy is batshit.

OP posts:
SpanThatWorld · 15/11/2026 08:18

Portmore · 15/11/2026 08:12

They probably shouldn't have refused you in that case. Unless you were doing something silly like DD selecting & carrying the booze. A quiet & polite word with a manager would have probably sorted it for you.

The cashiers will have to sit through 'challenge 25' training every few months & it really stresses the consequences for the cashier of getting it wrong - arrest, fine of up to £5000 & criminal record for the cashier, fine for the PLH & fine for the business. Even if that doesn't happen it's gross misconduct & dismissal. It's something as a manager I will always back my staff on - it's never wrong to refuse an alcohol sale but there are situations like yours where I would say - the cashier is correct but I would still authorize the sale

There's likely prompts all over the till & staff areas reminding her of that

All major supermarkets have the same policy so going elsewhere won't solve the problem & actually raising it & for the manager to explain that to the member of staff means it's not likely to happen there again.

Also look at in on the other hand. If you got a call saying your 17 year old DD had been taken to hospital unconscious in an ambulance due to being intoxicated on alcohol, she then had to stay in hospital to be assessed by psych & you by social services (or worse if she had died) - would you not be absolutely livid with the supermarket that had sold the alcohol that had been given to her.

I actually have received the call saying that my 16 year old is in hospital with acute alcohol poisoning. There was no psych evaluation and no social services. They rehydrated him and sent him home.

This did not impact my irritation at pushing a £150 shop through a checkout and being challenged as to whether the cider in my trolley was for the teen who was there helping with the big shop.

gingerninja · 15/11/2026 09:14

Portmore · 15/11/2026 08:12

They probably shouldn't have refused you in that case. Unless you were doing something silly like DD selecting & carrying the booze. A quiet & polite word with a manager would have probably sorted it for you.

The cashiers will have to sit through 'challenge 25' training every few months & it really stresses the consequences for the cashier of getting it wrong - arrest, fine of up to £5000 & criminal record for the cashier, fine for the PLH & fine for the business. Even if that doesn't happen it's gross misconduct & dismissal. It's something as a manager I will always back my staff on - it's never wrong to refuse an alcohol sale but there are situations like yours where I would say - the cashier is correct but I would still authorize the sale

There's likely prompts all over the till & staff areas reminding her of that

All major supermarkets have the same policy so going elsewhere won't solve the problem & actually raising it & for the manager to explain that to the member of staff means it's not likely to happen there again.

Also look at in on the other hand. If you got a call saying your 17 year old DD had been taken to hospital unconscious in an ambulance due to being intoxicated on alcohol, she then had to stay in hospital to be assessed by psych & you by social services (or worse if she had died) - would you not be absolutely livid with the supermarket that had sold the alcohol that had been given to her.

I don’t need to look on the other hand because there was no question of them selling it to her, they were selling it to me! I have no issue with the cashier I was baffled by the policy as I’d never heard of it before and never encountered the situation before despite having shopped with her and my other child hundreds of times before.

OP posts:
SockPlant · 15/11/2026 09:49

i totally get challenge 25, but like so many policies aimed to combat X it disproportionately affects peope who aren't doing X.

Parents who are buying alcohol for their children will do it anyway. People who have children who help them with the shop? may indeed also be doing it anyway, but stopping those ones buying alcohol at that time isn't addressing the problem. It is performative nonsense that does absolutely zip to address the problem of teenage drinking.

And yes, the cashiers aren't to blame, but they get the brunt so they are also collateral damage in this: especially when peope like OP just leave the shopping there for them to deal with.

So I'd ask lawmakers 2 things:

  1. what are you doing that ACTUALLY combats underage drinking and b) if you don't have rules/laws about carrying ID to prove your age why are we constantly having to prove our age somehow iii) (there must always be 3 points) is it time to go to a model of "alcohol can only be sold from licenced premises to people over 18"?
yellowbobble · 15/11/2026 10:01

I think it’s a ridiculous policy

Same for the policy of asking for ID for non-alcoholic drinks. DH and I occasionally buy non alcoholic beers and cocktail tinnies (literally 0% alcohol) as sometimes we fancy a drink but don’t want to get pissed or have a hangover the next day, and we get ID’d for those as well.

Motomum23 · 15/11/2026 10:04

It makes literally zero sense to me. I am 40 - i look at least 30 and that's being kind. I was IDed this summer buying a 12 pack of beer with my 19 year old son wity me. My son wasnt IDed. I had ID on me so the sale went ahead... but if i wanted to give an underage teen the booze being IDed wouldn't have stopped me. So it makes zero sense.

NorthernJim · 15/11/2026 10:06

It's a stupid 'nanny state' style policy, and many supermarket checkout operators are completely thick and unable to apply any common sense.

Years ago me any my then partner wee shopping in Asda, we had a trolley load of groceries, a week's shopping and it which included a 4 pack of cider (so nothing odd in the scheme of things, and it was for my dp, I don't even drink cider). We were both in our 30's and had our toddler daughter with us. My dp happened to be in front of me at the checkout - she was packing the scanned shopping while I carried on unloading onto the conveyor. But the cashier refused to sell us the cider because she believed my partner was buying it for me and that I was underage. I didn't have any ID on me (still only had a paper driving licence at that time), even though I was paying fur the shopping with my credit card. But I certainly didn't look under 18, anyone with a brain could determine that.

SBarnarbasPimlicoIsReallyInBelgravia · 15/11/2026 10:17

Yes I was refused tobacco once because my teenager was with me. It's a thing.

FancyLilacHare · 15/11/2026 10:23

It's the infantilization of the population, it's a completely unnecessary policy.

noworklifebalance · 15/11/2026 10:52

Agree it doesn’t make sense - we have booze delivered with online food shop, spirits, wines and cans of cocktails if it is for a picnic. Not sure how they factor in us having underage teens in the house at the time of delivery.

XadenRiorsonforPresident · 15/11/2026 11:12

Minasama · 14/11/2026 22:31

I may be in a minority but I support them here because some of my 14 yo daughter’s parents seem to buy them alcohol.

It was the canned cocktails - do adults actually drink these?!

I’m guessing if you’d been buying a decent bottle of French red they’d have let you have it!

I buy tins of G&T because I dont want a whole bottle in the house and dont have £30-40 quid to spare. Once every couple of weeks, £5 in a couple of tins is nice.

FartyFriday · 15/11/2026 11:13

gingerninja · 14/11/2026 22:22

Yeah I mean she would have needed a corkscrew so would have been a shit choice if I was giving it to a teen to neck on the street LOL

Mine's on my keyring 🤭

maudelovesharold · 15/11/2026 11:22

gingerninja · 14/11/2026 20:57

Who is buying a bottle of claret for their 17 year old? 🤪 they only needed to ask who it was for and that’s their due diligence.

Yes, it’s the same as the Post Office asking what’s in any package you’re sending. You could say literally anything, They never check, but they’ve asked you, so that’s their bit done. Should be the same for someone who is obviously doing a shop accompanied by their teen.

Hadalifeonce · 15/11/2026 11:40

I don't buy from Amazon, but DH does. Last week an Amazon delivery arrived, driver asked for my YOB, I asked why he needed it, he replied saying it must be alcohol; DH doesn't normally get alcohol from Amazon. I said I am obviously over 18, he then, I felt quite sharply, said, I need a year of birth. So I gave him DS's year of birth, he stared at me and said 'you're not 25!' It all gets a bit petty then, as I pointed out that he obviously believed I was over 25, so what was the problem. He then showed me his telephone which I then realised, he needed to input a year, so I said DH's YOB. Then said if he orders anymore alcohol through Amazon, he will have to be here to accept it, because I don't want to give personal info to some stranger at my front door.
This chap just looked at me, and said 'That's rude'
I can get a crate of wine delivered without this hassle.
Do Amazon not trust their drivers to recognise a person as being over 25, or ask for ID if they don't?

PurpleThistle7 · 15/11/2026 11:52

Hadalifeonce · 15/11/2026 11:40

I don't buy from Amazon, but DH does. Last week an Amazon delivery arrived, driver asked for my YOB, I asked why he needed it, he replied saying it must be alcohol; DH doesn't normally get alcohol from Amazon. I said I am obviously over 18, he then, I felt quite sharply, said, I need a year of birth. So I gave him DS's year of birth, he stared at me and said 'you're not 25!' It all gets a bit petty then, as I pointed out that he obviously believed I was over 25, so what was the problem. He then showed me his telephone which I then realised, he needed to input a year, so I said DH's YOB. Then said if he orders anymore alcohol through Amazon, he will have to be here to accept it, because I don't want to give personal info to some stranger at my front door.
This chap just looked at me, and said 'That's rude'
I can get a crate of wine delivered without this hassle.
Do Amazon not trust their drivers to recognise a person as being over 25, or ask for ID if they don't?

I ordered my (gasp) tins of g&t on Amazon and they ID’d me at the door. I’m 46 and definitely look it so was scrambling around the house trying to find my license. Very odd.

gannett · 15/11/2026 12:13

I can imagine this. I was IDed in M&S when I was 32 - I didn't have any and they refused to sell me booze. I was going to a friend's birthday party (her 35th!) and it was a bottle of Veuve Clicquot ffs.

And then they refused to sell booze to my friend (also 32) even though she had ID because she was with me!!!!!

I'm still fuming a decade on, as you can see.

gannett · 15/11/2026 12:15

If the OP had sent her daughter home would she then have been able to say "I'm not with her any more"?

It's so batshit.

MadisonAvenue · 15/11/2026 12:20

It goes further than alcohol. A friend was buying an 18 rated X Box game for her husband from Tesco and she was refused the sale at the till as she had her 12 year old with her.

ExpensiveDecorations · 15/11/2026 12:33

DS got refused for an age 3-rated xbox game (F1) when he was about 14 because he didn't have ID.

Portmore · 15/11/2026 16:00

gingerninja · 15/11/2026 09:14

I don’t need to look on the other hand because there was no question of them selling it to her, they were selling it to me! I have no issue with the cashier I was baffled by the policy as I’d never heard of it before and never encountered the situation before despite having shopped with her and my other child hundreds of times before.

How was the cashier meant to know your intentions. She was just doing her job & it's better to make the mistake of not selling it than making the mistake of a proxy sale.

A polite word with the manager would have sorted it at the time

gingerninja · 15/11/2026 18:47

Portmore · 15/11/2026 16:00

How was the cashier meant to know your intentions. She was just doing her job & it's better to make the mistake of not selling it than making the mistake of a proxy sale.

A polite word with the manager would have sorted it at the time

They can ask me if I intend to give it to a child and I would have said no, they don’t need to assume. It’s as simple as that. If my intention was to supply an underage teenager I can do that without taking them shopping with me! It is a stupid rule because people are clearly too stupid to use their common sense.

OP posts:
ChaToilLeam · 15/11/2026 19:00

It's ridiculous, nanny state levels of idiocy and making cashiers personally liable leaves them taking the flack from rightfully pissed off customers.

Katemax82 · 15/11/2026 21:25

[hink 25 policy clearly states that to refuse a proxy sale you must have clear evidence the adult is buying alcohol for an underage person (for example overhearing a conversation where the child asks the adult to buy it)
Having worked in Sainsbury's 9 years we got that drummed into our heads every 6 months. I still was refused alcohol in co op when my then 13 year old was with me, despite me quoting the think 25 policy (idiots)

Aviarythebird · 15/11/2026 21:36

Very weirdly my 17 year old was not allowed to buy dolmades in Tesco. The till flagged up over 18 and an assistant came and rather than say it was a mistake asked him for ID which he didn’t have on him. Couldn’t explain why he needed to be over 18 - just said he couldn’t have them.
I emailed Tesco ( was just curious about this new madness) and got a reply back apologising and saying it was a mistake but when he tried to buy them again same thing happened ( he’s weirdly keen on them).

Nospringchix · 15/11/2026 21:46

gingerninja · 14/11/2026 22:41

I’m not sure your pearls are going to survive your tight grip when I tell you that the cans were for me and a couple of friends to drink in the park when we were watching some fireworks. So common.

I must be common too! I buy them to drink on the train when going on holiday.
How uncouth of me 😆

CaraMP01 · 16/11/2026 18:18

Clearly. But that's not their business if an adult is purchasing it. No evidence whatsoever i was I'D as a 56 yr old woman. I look good but not that good!! It's borderline big brother..nanny state.