Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think a man who leaves his alcoholic wife is bad news potentially?

270 replies

qualotybleat · 14/11/2026 18:22

I’m dating him. He left his wife after twelve years of progressive alcoholism and several trips to rehab which were unsuccessful.
Do you think he should have tried harder to help her?
His now young adult kids left with him

OP posts:
watchingthishtread · 14/11/2026 23:11

You can't be serious.

JustAnotherWhinger · 14/11/2026 23:15

And whatever you do, given your “feel sorry for her” comment do NOT start suggesting he or his children see her/see more of her/or the ‘you only have one mum’ shit.

If you know nothing about it don’t judge it and don’t comment on it to them.

id be mega rich if I had £1 for every time I heard “you only get one dad”.

JasmineMac · 14/11/2026 23:18

CrapADoodleCupcake · 14/11/2026 22:07

You sound very odd OP! Genuinely quite odd! 🤯

Well, she IS asking MN users (aka complete strangers) to deign their approval of a relatively significant life decision. Odd for anyone to do that. Particularly given there isn't a man on earth who'd get blanket approval on MN 😂

Ah the cult of MN, eh.

OneLoudPombear · 14/11/2026 23:19

She let alcohol take over her life why should he have to put up with it, it takes a lot to walk away. Good on him

InessaMou · 14/11/2026 23:23

qualotybleat · 14/11/2026 18:22

I’m dating him. He left his wife after twelve years of progressive alcoholism and several trips to rehab which were unsuccessful.
Do you think he should have tried harder to help her?
His now young adult kids left with him

I wouldn't want to waste my life with an alcoholic that either can't or won't be helped. He stuck around for 12 years trying to help, how many more years do you think he should have stuck around for to no avail? It sounds like his ex is seriously ill and needs professional help and proper rehab facilities for a prolonged time to have a chance in hell to beat her alcoholism. But I don't see why anyone should put their life on hold for someone else's addiction.

beyondyuck · 14/11/2026 23:24

The toll on the rest of the family of an alcoholic can not be underestimated. My sister stayed for too long, supporting multiple rehabs, working to keep them going, paying all the bills. It nearly broke her and her children.

The relief when she left from all of us and started getting counselling for herself was massive. We had not realised we were all holding our breath for her and my nieces and nephews.

The guilt associated it with this move was huge. The kids were unaware as they should be of how many times she had been through the rehab game and initially wanted her to give it another go - one more time. In the end it was me who took them aside ( teens ) and explained because my sister would still not disrespect the man who had pissed his life up against a wall.

I would respect him for protecting his children and his sanity having watched the car crash that became my sisters lfie. She is in a better place, as are the kids and surprisingly her eX - who now has a job and whilst still drinking - not as much.

Chiefunderling · 14/11/2026 23:26

Op, I’m a recovering drug addict. Have you ever heard of rock bottom? Many addicts cannot even contemplate recovery until they hit rock bottom. I hit rock bottom when I lost everything & I mean everything (relationships, job, home, myself etc.). You can only attempt recovery when it’s something you want. A partner wanting you to recover is not enough. Your children wanting you to recover is not enough either. This is why so many rehab attempts fail. The addict has to want to recover & even then it’s incredibly difficult. Addiction is a devastating illness that doesn’t respond to reason or logic.

You do need a lot of support to achieve recovery in the short to medium term, but professionals are best placed to provide that. At least for the first few years. After 12 years I’d say your new partner’s physical & mental health was probably in tatters. He chose to save himself & his children, & that was the right decision. We cannot save other people, no matter how hard we try. Further, recovery sometimes isn’t possible. I’ve lost many friends, family & acquaintances over the years. Recovery isn’t a given, not even for me.

Scout2016 · 14/11/2026 23:28

No. He should have left earlier. Exposing children to that for over a decade is the problem. But better late than never.

Notaverageinanyway · 14/11/2026 23:41

Off course not ! If he stayed with her during several stints of rehab then he obviously supported her for a long time . How long can anyone wait until they destroy their own life ? Unless you have some other info like he abandoned his kids with this women then I don’t think he did anything wrong

Bloatstoat · 14/11/2026 23:55

Another child of an alcoholic here - he did the right thing in leaving. My mum will never leave my dad now, but I would 100% support her if she would do it, he's ruined her life along with his. You can pity your partner's ex wife without feeling he was responsible for giving up any more of his life than he did.

NorthernJim · 15/11/2026 00:00

The more you try and help an addict, the more they take advantage of your good nature. And it's very true that the only person that can help an addict is themselves. It's mentally, emotionally and financially draining, if not physically, being in a relationship with an alcoholic and trying to help and support them. They will drag you down with them.

When I got together with my now ex, I was aware she had issues with alcohol, mental health and self harm. I naively thought that with my support and stability she would get better. And she did, a bit. But would always relapse. I began to realise that the other issues were a result of her alcoholism, but she always maintained that it was the other way round. When she'd get drunk her mood would swing from one extreme to the other, at first you'd get dr Jekyll, but you knew it was only a matter of time until Mr Hyde arrived. So from the first drink I was on eggshells, knew what was coming, but couldn't prevent it. When drink she'd end up completely self destructive, whether that was self harming, smashing our house up, starting fights or having one night stands with literally anyone.

She was well for a while, and we decided to have kids together. And at first that helped, having dependents to focus on. It was less frequent, but she still kept slipping back into her old ways. And then I was trapped - I knew that if I left her I wouldn't be there to protect the kids from her. There was no way I'd get full custody of them, even in the unlikely scenario that I managed to convince the courts to make me primary carer, they'd still give her unsupervised access to the children. She even told me one day (while sober) that if I ever left her she'd make sure I never saw the kids again. I didn't know exactly what she meant, but I genuinely believed she was capable of trying to take them with her on one of her suicide attempts.

But even while we stayed together it became apparent that it was impossible to protect the kids from her, the number of times she'd go out in the day time with the kids and then not come home. Or pick them up from school and go straight to the pub with them.

Numerous times she'd turn up the next day miles away (with the children), half way across the country, with no rational explanation of how it why she'd got there. This was when our children were really young. One time I had a pub landlord phone me up at 10pm saying he was holding our baby DC and had wrapped her in a blanket because the was getting cold, while her mum was oblivious, too busy getting drunk. Stuff like that was a regular occurrence, but I knew it would be far worse and happen more frequently if we separated, so I stayed.

I did write another few chapters here, but was a depressing read, if not outing as well. The abridged version is that eventually, after much intervention from social services, our DC now reside with me and see court ordered minimum of their mother (who still drinks).

winnieanddaisy · 15/11/2026 00:02

I have a relation who both him and his wife were alcoholics , they also had two children at that time . He wanted to stop drinking but couldnt while married to her so he divorced her snd took the children with him . This was over 40 years ago . He died last year and she is still an alcoholic at nearly 80. The now adult children are not close to her but make the effort to stay in touch . I think your friend has done the right thing to leave her and be a good dad .

AuntiePettitoes · 15/11/2026 00:07

He did the right thing. How can you possibly think otherwise.

SmolBlackKitten · 15/11/2026 00:07

Like you said - you clearly know nothing about alcoholism.

One of the features of alcoholics is that they pull everyone else down with them.

But the main feature is - all that matters is the drink.
They can't quit - even for one day.

All they do is circle the drain because of the booze and eventually they die of it.

Alcoholism is also hereditary so perhaps he decided to get his kids out of the sphere of influence of her addiction.

He stayed about 10 years too long, if you ask me.

Takeapause · 15/11/2026 00:10

If she was a man, everyone would beg her to leave him asap.

Alcoholism is horrific and it turns someone you love into an unrecognisable person sometimes. If the wife was not willing to change he cannot do anything about it.

I know a few people that have taken their children away from an alcoholic parent. Both men and women.

GetPyjamasOnThatDog · 15/11/2026 00:11

I’d have left with my kids too.

Laurmolonlabe · 15/11/2026 00:28

no one can stop someone being alcoholic- the person needs to want to stop, you can be supportive of their efforts, but it has to be their efforts.
Without knowing exactly what went on it is impossible to tell whether he was reasonable to leave her.
It's a complex subject and there isn't even complete agreement about what constitutes being alcoholic- my mother was a heavy drinker some of her GP's supported her in rehab efforts , some didn't and told her she was a heavy drinker not alcoholic.

PollyBell · 15/11/2026 00:38

Op if you genuinely know nothing about it why automatically think bad of him?

worreidaboutdpnow · 15/11/2026 00:44

CrapADoodleCupcake · 14/11/2026 22:07

You sound very odd OP! Genuinely quite odd! 🤯

Yes makes me wonder if OP is the wife...

FizzyPopLove · 15/11/2026 00:45

Is he telling the truth?

whitecrowbird · 15/11/2026 00:49

You don't happen to have a camper van do you?

Ikeatears · 15/11/2026 00:56

@qualotybleatmy oldest friend was an alcoholic. Sadly, it killed her in her early 40s. She had ruined her relationships, her career and many, many friendships. Dh and I remained her friends until the end (part of a very, very small remaining circle) but I stopped her seeing my dc (one of whom was her godchild) for the last two years because her behaviour was destructive, erratic, sometimes aggressive (verbally), abusive and unpredictable. I didn’t want to expose my dc to this, despite the fact that she loved them and they loved her.
We supported her through all the highs and lows, we advocated for her, we tried so hard to help her but still, every time my phone rang after 11pm, the anxiety would rise. She sometimes took over my life and I wasn’t married to her or even living with her. We loved her until the end but there were times when we had to step back for our own sanity.
If this man has had a similar experience to us over many years, I don’t blame him for prioritising his own happiness and the safety and security of his children. Please don’t judge him on this alone.

AcrossthePond55 · 15/11/2026 00:58

@qualotybleat

I'm going to accept that you are acting out of total ignorance of what it is to live with an alcoholic. That's not your fault and you have been very lucky.

I am the estranged wife of an alcoholic. We were married 38 years before his drinking spun out of control. He was a good husband for many of those years and our marriage ended with me being escorted out of our home by the police. Neither of our adult sons will have anything to do with him. He lost his wife, his sons, and even his beloved dog all because alcohol was more important to him than we were.

Living with an alcoholic/addict is hell on earth. It is seeing your life, and your children's lives, be destroyed by one person's selfishness. Yes, addiction is a disease, not a 'moral failing'. It is something that is both physically and mentally addicting and breaking free and staying free of it will be the hardest thing the addict ever does. Some never manage it, some never try. But some succeed and live wonderful lives because of their courage and determination.

If you cannot accept that this man had a very good reason to leave his marriage because of his wife's drinking, then it's best you call time on things and let him find someone who does understand the effort it took him to make that decision. Because it's a very hard decision to make. None of us wanted to leave our loved one, we were driven away by the decision they made to keep using. Because their addiction was more important than us. And because they love their 'substance of choice' more than they loved us.

thisismeithinkorisit · 15/11/2026 01:00

so because he's a man he's not entitled to a life free from an alcoholic, it's his job to fix her whilst keeping the kids within that setting to experience it?

I'm inclined to think he could do better at girlfriends that he is currently

thisismeithinkorisit · 15/11/2026 01:02

qualotybleat · 14/11/2026 21:18

I have never spent any time with an alcoholic and am trying to educate myself about addiction. He is a good and kind and loving man and father . I know every family situation is different but I guess I was trying to get some understanding to support him and wondered how it impacted him and his kids but feel very sad for his ex wife who is my age and she hasn’t one friend left in the world and lives alonedrinking all day every day apparently . It’s new to me. Please go easy on me.

but you didn't ask for advice on supporting him, you were asking people to criticise him and tear his down for walking away.