Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think a man who leaves his alcoholic wife is bad news potentially?

270 replies

qualotybleat · 14/11/2026 18:22

I’m dating him. He left his wife after twelve years of progressive alcoholism and several trips to rehab which were unsuccessful.
Do you think he should have tried harder to help her?
His now young adult kids left with him

OP posts:
Thegirlwhowent · 14/11/2026 22:03

Nobody can help someone who doesn't want to help themselves.

Pessismistic · 14/11/2026 22:04

Hi op if you’re dating him and he’s not the alcoholic his ex is not your concern he’s tried but she didn’t want to be helped so you might have actually found yourself a decent man. You don’t need to have any experience of people who are alcoholics he’s not one so your good to keep dating him.

CrapADoodleCupcake · 14/11/2026 22:07

You sound very odd OP! Genuinely quite odd! 🤯

MissingMeadow · 14/11/2026 22:11

Go easy on you?

You don't seem to be going easy on the poor man. Calling him bad news etc.

MardyMillylala · 14/11/2026 22:21

No i think he's done the right thing for his own sanity & the emotional wellbeing of his children. Although alcoholism is an illness there is a limit to what loved ones can take & it can't have been healthy for his children to witness his wife's decline.

LondonLass2026 · 14/11/2026 22:22

Nope.

My neighbour is an alcoholic. When we all moved into our new houses about 5 years ago, she was really nice, had given up drinking when we met her, and her husband and 2 teenage daughters lived there too.

And then she went back on the drink and she's been a nightmare ever since. Her husband and one of the girls moved out, and over the next months she stopped working and alienated us and all her other neighbours all around us. She's a nightmare, plays deafening music all the time, and tries her best to annoy everyone around her when she's been drinking. Which is every day.

Nobody in this development will talk to her because of her behaviour, and my partner and I constantly get asked what her problem is.

My partner had an alcoholic grandparent and has tried his best to help our neighbour, and just gets told to fuck off. I stopped talking to her earlier this year because she's so abusive, and I'm not a mug, and he's finally starting to see my point.

We've all borne the brunt of her sharp tongue when she's been drinking, and we're actually going to sell because of her.

If your boyfriend's wife is anything like this, no I can't blame him for leaving. These people make everyone's lives a misery.

RaspberryCoffeePot · 14/11/2026 22:24

qualotybleat · 14/11/2026 18:22

I’m dating him. He left his wife after twelve years of progressive alcoholism and several trips to rehab which were unsuccessful.
Do you think he should have tried harder to help her?
His now young adult kids left with him

My ex MIL was an alcoholic. Sadly they can be very selfish, manipulative people. During the years I knew her, all she ever did was manipulate snd push the other members of the family into situations where she could drink. And she was unpleasant. She was constantly on everybody's case. Nobody could ever relax and when she got really drunk she'd be really cruel and vicious, blaming everybody for everything. It's very hard to be around an alcoholic. And in the later stages, they become very physically ill and it's a horrible mess.. it's such a horrible , complicated illness that only really professional help works. Famoiy just run themselves ragged trying to support alcoholics. They just bang their heads against a wall, so he was probably right to leave and take the kids.

BMW6 · 14/11/2026 22:25

OP alcoholics aren't just the people you love but pissed.
Their character usually completely changes to become really nasty, hateful, even violent.

They often piss and shit themselves. They're incapable of cleaning it up so you have to.

Their personal hygiene goes out the window.

My DH died 18 months or so ago vomiting blood everywhere in our bedroom with about 6 paramedics trying to save him. Thousands spent on rehabs, 3 stays in hospital within 2 years.
He was starting to deteriorate mentally.

I think we were lucky he died when he did. Both our lives were hell.

Waitingfordoggo · 14/11/2026 22:27

qualotybleat · 14/11/2026 21:18

I have never spent any time with an alcoholic and am trying to educate myself about addiction. He is a good and kind and loving man and father . I know every family situation is different but I guess I was trying to get some understanding to support him and wondered how it impacted him and his kids but feel very sad for his ex wife who is my age and she hasn’t one friend left in the world and lives alonedrinking all day every day apparently . It’s new to me. Please go easy on me.

It is very sad. Alcoholism is a very sad illness. It’s normal to feel sad for someone who is in that situation, but you have to remember that it’s not an illness that can be cured by Drs without any effort or will from the alcoholic themselves. It certainly can’t be cured by partners and children, or by friends. The only person who can attempt to manage the illness is the person who has got it. It can’t be cured- alcoholics who stop drinking are still alcoholics. They have to make the choice every day to not drink alcohol. And that is incredibly challenging for them, but it is in their hands and theirs alone. She has no friends left because one by one, the people who loved her had to accept that they couldn’t fix her, and that ultimately they needed to keep themselves safe from the harm that she was capable of inflicting on those around her.

Waitingfordoggo · 14/11/2026 22:28

That sounds so incredibly traumatic @BMW6 , I’m so sorry. 💐

Brucebogtrotter257 · 14/11/2026 22:29

My sister is an alcoholic I've lost all sympathy for her and all other alcoholics. Devious, self centered people. I'd be gone after a few months TBH so 12 years is well beyond the pale.

BobLemon · 14/11/2026 22:32

A colleague of mine (PW in case this thread is about him!) fits the description. He is a wonderful man who has worked hard to protect his children and given his wife an incredible amount of support. If he told me that he has decided to move on and had a new partner I would be so delighted for him.

BMW6 · 14/11/2026 22:32

Thanks Waitingfordoggo

Justtobeclear · 14/11/2026 22:32

As a child of an alcoholic - so have lived through this - I am gently saying this is not the relationship for you. There will be many, many scars, wounds and stories that you will face that are far worse than him leaving especially if she’s tried to get clean a few times and failed. You clearly already judge him with little to no understanding of what it takes to get to the point to leave. To be honest, he should be applauded because I and many others wished hard for their parent to do that and many don’t due to the weight of responsibility caring with someone in active addiction holds. Your innocence on this is not a criticism because most of us that have had to live with or alongside addiction would happily give those memories up. But what that family needs right now is a level of compassion, patience and understanding which I’m not sure you are ready to provide.

nidvideouioui · 14/11/2026 22:33

Good for him. People tend to overstay because you feel responsible for them and for saving them.

Addicts are the only ones who can save themselves. His ex needs to have a moment where she decides enough is enough, but very often that moment never comes.

Junglejune · 14/11/2026 22:38

Lilylady · 14/11/2026 21:39

There is plenty of support available

I completely agree with the rest of your comment but interested to know what support is available? Daughter of an alcoholic mother here - my mum asked for help many times but received nothing. Got told to ‘just stop drinking’ by the GP many times. Is support for alcoholics different maybe county to county?

I don’t know what is available where you live but there is tons of support near me. From the NHS, charities and peer organisations like AA. You have to be willing to access it though and admit that you have a problem and go through the pain of recovery. The trouble is that addicts often use their addiction to avoid their pain in the first place.

Also I’ve come across many people who say they’d do anything to get better. But when it comes down to it they won’t do a thing. They want a magic bullet or someone to fix it for them but none exists.

Strawberrydelight78 · 14/11/2026 22:40

Well even their children left with him so no he’s not unreasonable. Some people have all sorts of help chucked at them but they go back. They have to want to do it for themselves. I have cut off a family member due to alcoholism. Non of our family speak to him. We just leave him to get on with it. Anyone tries to stop him drinking we just get accused of being controlling. He’s the one that’s controlling not us or they’re long suffering spouse.

HowardTJMoon · 14/11/2026 22:41

I'm a man who left his alcoholic partner. If people judge me for "not trying hard enough" then all that tells me is that they're lucky to not to have had to experience what I, and many other people with alcoholic partners, have been through.

A relationship with an alcoholic rises and falls on the tide of their drinking. You come home and you don't know if you're going to find someone who's moderately sober, or drunk but happy, or drunk and arsey. You drive yourself insane trying to count how many bottles they're putting in the recycling and finding the full ones they're hiding around the house, trying out different strategies for stopping yet another night turning in to a drunken disaster, coming up with plans to try to minimise the effects of their drinking on your children.

Addictions are built on lies. Lies erode trust. And without trust the relationship crumbles. Short of locking them up in a cage for the rest of their lives there's nothing you can do to stop someone from choosing to live their life as an alcoholic. All you can do is decide whether you want a front-row seat to their choice and to be embroiled in all the chaos and drama that causes, or to walk away.

JustAnotherWhinger · 14/11/2026 22:49

12 years is a long time.

i was taken from my alcoholic parents by my grandparents when i was just 7.

It was entirely normal for me to step over an unconscious parent on the bathroom floor before school in the morning. I already knew that you rolled them onto their side and made sure their tongue was out.

I knew how to tell creative, but believable lies about what I’d had for dinner the night before (often nothing) and what we’d done at the weekend (nothing being the best weekends as that meant at least no drunken rages).

I knew that different smells meant different things - one (which I now know is lager) meant drunken rages and fights, another (which I now know is vodka) meant peace as they’d fall asleep, something sweet meant different spirits and they would mean happiness and then sleep. I can remember my 5th birthday and feeling excited because I didn’t smell beer or lager.

This man likely should have removed his children sooner than 12 years, but absolutely deserves credit for removing them and not subjecting them to it forever.

Gengha · 14/11/2026 22:51

You can’t help alcohol addicts. They have to help themselves.

YABU

Clonakilla · 14/11/2026 22:52

You have a serious problem with empathy if you hear that story and your immediate thoughts are he didn't try enough.

I don't think you have to have any direct experience of alcoholism to develop more empathy than you've shown towards this situation.

TheBlueKoala · 14/11/2026 22:55

qualotybleat · 14/11/2026 21:18

I have never spent any time with an alcoholic and am trying to educate myself about addiction. He is a good and kind and loving man and father . I know every family situation is different but I guess I was trying to get some understanding to support him and wondered how it impacted him and his kids but feel very sad for his ex wife who is my age and she hasn’t one friend left in the world and lives alonedrinking all day every day apparently . It’s new to me. Please go easy on me.

He sounds like a catch tbh. Tried everything for wife then did the right thing and left with his kids. Her addictiction is not his fault.

O00ps · 14/11/2026 23:04

qualotybleat · 14/11/2026 21:18

I have never spent any time with an alcoholic and am trying to educate myself about addiction. He is a good and kind and loving man and father . I know every family situation is different but I guess I was trying to get some understanding to support him and wondered how it impacted him and his kids but feel very sad for his ex wife who is my age and she hasn’t one friend left in the world and lives alonedrinking all day every day apparently . It’s new to me. Please go easy on me.

You obviously do need to educate yourself more and it's good that you are trying to.
But why do you feel sorry for a mother who couldn't put her children and partner before alcohol?
Your sympathy is misguided.
She wanted this more than she wanted her family.
It is a disease, I have an alcoholic parent that I have some affection for, but it ruins lives! You cannot help someone that will not help themselves, you might try to take the helm and steer the ship but will eventually have to take the lifeboat and save the kids.

PollyBell · 14/11/2026 23:06

TheBlueKoala · 14/11/2026 22:55

He sounds like a catch tbh. Tried everything for wife then did the right thing and left with his kids. Her addictiction is not his fault.

Yes and if he was an alcoholic she would have been told to leave years ago

ClairDeLaLune · 14/11/2026 23:09

You can’t help someone who doesn’t help themselves. He would’ve been flogging a dead horse. The only thing unreasonable about him is that he didn’t get his children out of that shit situation much much sooner.

Swipe left for the next trending thread