Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Should I speak to the other mum or just leave it?

127 replies

Darkdiamond · 14/11/2026 10:44

My 9 year old daughter has become very good friends with a little girl who started in her class in September. Lets call her Jenny. I also work with Jenny's mum. I asked if Jenny wanted to come to our house today and the mum said yes. My daughter and Jenny were delighted about this and planned the whole day out and yesterday were hoth jumping up and down with excitement about it at the end of the day. The mum seemed very happy too.

I live in the suburbs on one side of the city, and they live on the other. The plan was that Jenny's mum, dad, Jenny and elder siblings would get the train into town. One parent and the two older siblings would go to the cinema, while another parent would take further transport to where I live, drop Jenny off and and go back to join the rest of the family so they didn't have to do another big journey later. They were going to make a day of it since they were going that way and so they didn't have to go home and come back again.

Last night I texted the mum to say I would leave Jenny back to the main train station after the playdate, to further reduce their travel time. The mum said that they had told Jenny about the cinema plans with the older siblings but when she heard, she got upset and wanted to go too. The mum asked could we rearrange the playdate so Jenny could go to the cinema too and that she was very sorry.

My daughter had been tidying her room in anticipation and I went in and told her that the playdate was cancelled. She asked why and I didn't know what to say so just told her what the mum told me. I didn't want to start getting into a lie but she was very hurt and extremely disappointed.

There was no follow up from the mum and I just said said something like 'ok i will explain to my daughter'. For context I have been really trying to get my daughter having more play opportunities out of school so it hurt me to see her let down like that. The mum may have had her own reasons so I dont know if my own protectiveness towards my child is taking this more seriously than it needs to be. I do feel like saying that as a consequence of being dumped for better plans, I had to console my daughter but I get on fine with this mum and don't know whether to just say nothing, move on and not actively seek out any further play days with her.

Maybe I am being totally OTT as I can be a bit neurotic about my children! I've my hard hat on AIBU!

OP posts:
Darkdiamond · 14/11/2026 15:08

Illalwayssayhi · 14/11/2026 15:00

Your three children are going to be disappointed many times in their lives and if your response is to need time to “process” to “get over it” it and spend the next day posting about it - your parenting journey is going to be a difficult one

Edited

Give over. You have absolutely no idea what disappointments my children have faced in their life or how I have supported them through it. Its pretty shitty to imply that if I use Mumsnet, AIBU (!!!) for its intended purpose of being a community of mothers to sounds things off to, I am going to have a 'difficult journey'. And as it happened, I did reflect and I did consider that maybe the child got cold feet because of discussing things here and seeing things from another side.

OP posts:
Illalwayssayhi · 14/11/2026 15:09

Darkdiamond · 14/11/2026 15:08

Give over. You have absolutely no idea what disappointments my children have faced in their life or how I have supported them through it. Its pretty shitty to imply that if I use Mumsnet, AIBU (!!!) for its intended purpose of being a community of mothers to sounds things off to, I am going to have a 'difficult journey'. And as it happened, I did reflect and I did consider that maybe the child got cold feet because of discussing things here and seeing things from another side.

eek

UnbeatenMum · 14/11/2026 15:16

I agree it's not really fair for your DD. But you have to work together so I would probably not send any more messages, but would prioritise other friends going forwards.

gettingolderbutcooler · 14/11/2026 15:24

It’s not that big a deal? Her kid wants to go to the cinema so they need to rearrange your play date?

RBowmama · 14/11/2026 16:00

I voted yes aibu but only in regards to you contacting the mum. Her behaviour was not cool and not fair on your dc. I'd only cancel if an emergency came up. She should have offered to take your dc to the cinema too at the v least. Unfortunately some parents are flakey and do cancel if better plans come along, I've heard this from others and experienced it myself! It is horrible seeing your child disappointed, yes they have to learn to deal with it in life but no one would choose disappointment for their child so you are absolutely not unreasonable for how you're feeling. I'd back off this friendship unless they initiate and only then give them one more chance.

Fortuity · 14/11/2026 16:00

The journey which the other family had to make does sound a pain in the neck, and likely to lead to this sort of problem if it means they have to find something to entertain the other children which Jenny will feel she's missing out on.

If you ever do rearrange, maybe consider agreeing to pick her up either from home or or the two centre?

Agrumpyknitter · 14/11/2026 16:06

If you do invite the girl again, maybe have another friend of your daughter’s along as well. That way if one cancels they have another to look friend still coming and it’s just as easy to handle an extra one. We started having two friends coming for a play date at that age much easier to see everyone in one go as well.

Thepeopleversuswork · 14/11/2026 16:19

theresnolimits · 14/11/2026 13:40

For some families, family time always takes priority. I have a friend like this - friends are a nice to have, but she’d always rather have her family doing something together. She certainly wouldn’t have encouraged Jenny to chose a friend over a family outing.

It’s not Jenny’s fault and people are flaky sometimes. Explain that to DD, encourage her never to do that and move on.

I think that’s a really poor message to send a child tbh. Of course family “comes first” in the philosophical sense that they are prioritised over non family on the big things and they are the first loyalty.

But signaling to a child that you can drop a preexisting commitment because a family member wants to do something different is poor.

Keeping to commitments (unless there are genuinely mitigating circumstances) should be the priority. Family are always there: you have to work harder with friends.

Also “family comes first” shouldn’t mean you can minimise the needs of anyone who is not family. Setting up a dynamic where no one who isn’t a blood relative deserves consideration creates an insular and inward looking culture.

Like these families who refuse to make plans with anyone outside the family at weekends. I have always found that really weird and stifling.

Fieldday26 · 14/11/2026 16:26

Honestly it sounds like a whole hassle for the family to get the child to yours? The whole family on trains and multiple buses etc. Having to spend money to entertain the others kids. Do you drive? Could you have just picked the child up and dropped them off? If so, I’d suggest that next time if you do want to make another arrangement.

Illalwayssayhi · 14/11/2026 16:32

while another parent would take further transport to where I live, drop Jenny off and and go back to join the rest of the family so they didn't have to do another big journey later.

bus or taxi? What a palaver! I’d have picked her up from the station if I had been you

FrauPaige · 14/11/2026 16:45

You've approached this as an adult social event - almost a date - between you and this woman. When she clumsily asked for a reschedule, you took it personally as a slight and were unable to simply ask "does Jenny want DD to go with her to the cinema?".

Due to that inability, you cemented the outcome being that your DD was let down, and your spite meant that you indicated to your daughter that Jenny didn't want to come anymore and that she was now going to the cinema - something that your DD will not be doing. A double whammy.

If you had been a parent facilitating a playdate, and had asked whether Jenny wanted your daughter at the cinema, she may have been invited along, had a great day with her friend, and had gone to the cinema.

Take out the ego and focus on the child.

Darkdiamond · 14/11/2026 17:12

FrauPaige · 14/11/2026 16:45

You've approached this as an adult social event - almost a date - between you and this woman. When she clumsily asked for a reschedule, you took it personally as a slight and were unable to simply ask "does Jenny want DD to go with her to the cinema?".

Due to that inability, you cemented the outcome being that your DD was let down, and your spite meant that you indicated to your daughter that Jenny didn't want to come anymore and that she was now going to the cinema - something that your DD will not be doing. A double whammy.

If you had been a parent facilitating a playdate, and had asked whether Jenny wanted your daughter at the cinema, she may have been invited along, had a great day with her friend, and had gone to the cinema.

Take out the ego and focus on the child.

My daughter wasn't invited and I wasn't going to force them to take her to a family event. I didn't cement anything except by telling truth, so please don't blame me for my daughter being disappointed. My ego! 😂I don't invite myself or children to events that they haven't been invited to, because I know when its appropriate to step back.

OP posts:
Stompythedinosaur · 14/11/2026 17:17

Pretty shitty of the other mum, but equally, having a playdate with a dc who didn't want to be there would have been rubbish too.

I think you have to be a bit thick skinned with playdates. You win some you lose some. I'd try inviting someone else, and build up a list of dc who'll reliably show up.

Darkdiamond · 14/11/2026 17:17

Thanks for all the responses. I was initially upset because my daughter was so disappointed but it wasn't mentioned again and she actually had a nice day. I think Jenny is a nice girl and I get on fine with the mum. I am going to gloss over it and not make a big deal of it. Its done now and my daughter is fine.

OP posts:
BillieWiper · 14/11/2026 17:21

What a bloody palaver.
Your daughter wanted to invite her mate round to play.

You end up hearing this enormous convoluted tale about the movements and activities of various different branches of the family. And then the consequent detailed saga as to why she can no longer come round?

Things are not meant to be this difficult.
Honestly I'd just get your daughter to see if another friend is free or just do something fun together.

And only do off the cuff playdates at the park immediately after school with the other kid. If they can't commit.

ClaredeBear · 14/11/2026 17:31

Teaching her daughter absolutely nothing. I am so sorry your daughter was disappointed. It’s definitely them, not her.

FrauPaige · 14/11/2026 17:35

Darkdiamond · 14/11/2026 17:12

My daughter wasn't invited and I wasn't going to force them to take her to a family event. I didn't cement anything except by telling truth, so please don't blame me for my daughter being disappointed. My ego! 😂I don't invite myself or children to events that they haven't been invited to, because I know when its appropriate to step back.

All it would have taken was one simple clarification question. Was your ego so fragile or your pride so elevated that you couldn't do that? You preferred letting your 9 year old daughter feel the weight of rejection to simply asking that one question. Bravo

Darkdiamond · 14/11/2026 17:42

FrauPaige · 14/11/2026 17:35

All it would have taken was one simple clarification question. Was your ego so fragile or your pride so elevated that you couldn't do that? You preferred letting your 9 year old daughter feel the weight of rejection to simply asking that one question. Bravo

Righteo!

OP posts:
ClaredeBear · 14/11/2026 17:44

FrauPaige · 14/11/2026 17:35

All it would have taken was one simple clarification question. Was your ego so fragile or your pride so elevated that you couldn't do that? You preferred letting your 9 year old daughter feel the weight of rejection to simply asking that one question. Bravo

Wow, you’re just a meanie.

wildnwilde · 14/11/2026 17:50

Darkdiamond · 14/11/2026 10:58

That's what I thought. If the mum brings it up I will say that my daughter was very disappointed and leave it at that. Going forward its not a friendship that I will go out of my way to facilitate. I felt like there were many ways to handle the situation to find a balance and not just drop my little girl because something better came along. I was very matter of fact about it when telling DD and didnt let my feelings show except to say I was very sorry and that we would do something nice together

They should of invited your little one along tbh

FrauPaige · 14/11/2026 17:51

ClaredeBear · 14/11/2026 17:44

Wow, you’re just a meanie.

It was a bit of bludgeoning but a shock to the system may help in future situations. I'll take the hit in highlighting it

Darkdiamond · 14/11/2026 18:02

FrauPaige · 14/11/2026 17:51

It was a bit of bludgeoning but a shock to the system may help in future situations. I'll take the hit in highlighting it

You feel like you're taking one for the team by encouraging me to impose my child on others by inviting them along to things that they have not been invited to. Having dignity and respecting social norms is not egotistical, and if it was, I would still never invite myself or my child to anything that they were clearly not included in. Take the 'hit' all you like! It wasn't a 'bludgeoning', it just sounded silly.

OP posts:
TheCabbageMerchant · 14/11/2026 18:06

gettingolderbutcooler · 14/11/2026 15:24

It’s not that big a deal? Her kid wants to go to the cinema so they need to rearrange your play date?

That's what I thought. Not sure what I am missing. It doesn't seem like a big deal. Just set another date.

Nocturnian · 14/11/2026 18:10

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

MCF86 · 14/11/2026 18:26

I wouldn't write off playdates for good, but next attempt I would meet in the city centre so each child takes one train with one parent and all do something together (museum, park, lunch, whatever). Then Jenny has the chance to know you better which might help in future if she was just too nervous in the end.