Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Should I speak to the other mum or just leave it?

127 replies

Darkdiamond · 14/11/2026 10:44

My 9 year old daughter has become very good friends with a little girl who started in her class in September. Lets call her Jenny. I also work with Jenny's mum. I asked if Jenny wanted to come to our house today and the mum said yes. My daughter and Jenny were delighted about this and planned the whole day out and yesterday were hoth jumping up and down with excitement about it at the end of the day. The mum seemed very happy too.

I live in the suburbs on one side of the city, and they live on the other. The plan was that Jenny's mum, dad, Jenny and elder siblings would get the train into town. One parent and the two older siblings would go to the cinema, while another parent would take further transport to where I live, drop Jenny off and and go back to join the rest of the family so they didn't have to do another big journey later. They were going to make a day of it since they were going that way and so they didn't have to go home and come back again.

Last night I texted the mum to say I would leave Jenny back to the main train station after the playdate, to further reduce their travel time. The mum said that they had told Jenny about the cinema plans with the older siblings but when she heard, she got upset and wanted to go too. The mum asked could we rearrange the playdate so Jenny could go to the cinema too and that she was very sorry.

My daughter had been tidying her room in anticipation and I went in and told her that the playdate was cancelled. She asked why and I didn't know what to say so just told her what the mum told me. I didn't want to start getting into a lie but she was very hurt and extremely disappointed.

There was no follow up from the mum and I just said said something like 'ok i will explain to my daughter'. For context I have been really trying to get my daughter having more play opportunities out of school so it hurt me to see her let down like that. The mum may have had her own reasons so I dont know if my own protectiveness towards my child is taking this more seriously than it needs to be. I do feel like saying that as a consequence of being dumped for better plans, I had to console my daughter but I get on fine with this mum and don't know whether to just say nothing, move on and not actively seek out any further play days with her.

Maybe I am being totally OTT as I can be a bit neurotic about my children! I've my hard hat on AIBU!

OP posts:
Chiefunderling · 14/11/2026 13:32

My sibling has done this to me a few times with my Nephew. I’ve made arrangements to do something with my Nephew (at his request), had plans in place for a few weeks. Then, something ‘better’ comes along so my sibling texts me to cancel my plans. Personally, I feel this presents a good opportunity to teach children that we stick to the plans we made first (exceptional circumstances aside). It’s polite & respectful. Obviously my sibling sees it differently! Family might accept this type of behaviour but other people likely won’t. If the child grows up to think it’s ok to do this with friends, they may find their friends become reluctant to make plans with them.
I wouldn’t say anything in this instance op, but I would make a mental note & avoid making plans with this family again. It says a lot about their values & they don’t appear to be aligned with yours. Hope you have a fun Mother-Daughter day with your dc.

theresnolimits · 14/11/2026 13:40

For some families, family time always takes priority. I have a friend like this - friends are a nice to have, but she’d always rather have her family doing something together. She certainly wouldn’t have encouraged Jenny to chose a friend over a family outing.

It’s not Jenny’s fault and people are flaky sometimes. Explain that to DD, encourage her never to do that and move on.

Chilly80 · 14/11/2026 13:42

The mum was probably thinking great I don't have to do that long journey now. She was willing to do it to make her child happy but she wasn't willing to do it to make your child happy. While it was wrong I can sort of understand her pov.

RikthePoet · 14/11/2026 13:47

Aneversolongwalk · 14/11/2026 11:01

This girl is 9. 9!!!! You have No idea what’s gone on this morning. Maybe the mother is saying this to conceal a massive argument with her DH and now she’s taking both alone to the cinema. Who knows!! But to write her off like this? When she’s 9. No

Yes, I agree

Massive amount of judgement about what's gone on. Who knows what's happened in that other house to lead to this outcome?

Perfectly reasonable to catch up with the other mum this week and ask about it, but no reason to judge the nine year old for it!!

Moonnstarz · 14/11/2026 13:50

RikthePoet · 14/11/2026 13:47

Yes, I agree

Massive amount of judgement about what's gone on. Who knows what's happened in that other house to lead to this outcome?

Perfectly reasonable to catch up with the other mum this week and ask about it, but no reason to judge the nine year old for it!!

Agree.

To me the journey seems like a factor that would make me reconsider. Having to get a train and then another form of transport to get to the house seems pretty full on for a standard playdate. A birthday party or special occasion maybe, but I can see why they have made an excuse not to do this.

Darkdiamond · 14/11/2026 13:51

RikthePoet · 14/11/2026 13:47

Yes, I agree

Massive amount of judgement about what's gone on. Who knows what's happened in that other house to lead to this outcome?

Perfectly reasonable to catch up with the other mum this week and ask about it, but no reason to judge the nine year old for it!!

I already explained that its the parents I am annoyed with, not the child. I literally said that Jenny is a very sweet girl. Its not her fault. However I don't want to arrange things again if her mother pulls the plug again.

OP posts:
Illalwayssayhi · 14/11/2026 13:54

One strike and you’re out it would seem.

Not a chance I’d be ruling out inviting over the girl on the basis of this. Nor would I be boxing up the mum as a rude and inconsiderate person.

Happens again? Yes.

You seem quite determined to consign this mother to room 101 though so 🤷‍♀️

ChairmanMeowsMinion · 14/11/2026 13:55

At what point does a child who thinks her own minor disappointment at not being included ( in plans made to accommodate her in the first place ) is more important than the disappointment caused to her friend become old enough to essentially ditch her for it?

If she has so little awareness and empathy at 9 and her parents are doing bugger all about it other than encouraging it, then it's only going to get worse. Do your DD a favour and focus on reliable, well parented children.

If DD really likes her, a good approach is to make it a 3 child play date - so even if the flaky family drop out, you can go ahead, and th FOMO means they are less likely to ditch. I'd make that clear to he mum when rescheduling, that you are incorporating a plan B because of her behaviour.

WiltedLettuce · 14/11/2026 13:57

It's annoying, but obviously not Jenny's fault as she's only a child and you may not have been given the real picture about what is going on.

We know a few families whose children are friends with our children through school or nursery and the parents are what might be called 'flaky' for some reason... some are lovely but genuinely disorganised, one I suspect will drop us if a better offer comes along and another the parents are separated and constantly back and forth in court over the children so they don't really know what is happening with care arrangements day to day.

When I arrange meet ups with them, I assume there's a good chance they'll cancel and don't tell my kids in advance. I also schedule the playdate in a way that doesn't inconvenience us... so at our house or the playground where we'd be going anyway, or I invite other friends along as well.

RikthePoet · 14/11/2026 14:02

Darkdiamond · 14/11/2026 13:51

I already explained that its the parents I am annoyed with, not the child. I literally said that Jenny is a very sweet girl. Its not her fault. However I don't want to arrange things again if her mother pulls the plug again.

Yes, and you also said "she has other more loyal friends who haven't dropped her in such a way" so you are quoting qualities that make her seem a little less sweet without knowing the real circumstances of what has gone on.

Everlygreen · 14/11/2026 14:06

Is your dd an only op?

Darkdiamond · 14/11/2026 14:08

Everlygreen · 14/11/2026 14:06

Is your dd an only op?

No, my middle child.

OP posts:
Bigtrapeze · 14/11/2026 14:10

OP, I am really sorry you are disappointed but I can see this from two sides. It sounds like a fairly involved journey and I can see Jenny feeling that she is missing out on a family cinema trip. The last thing you want is a child at your house who would rather be elsewhere.

Might you be able to invite Jenny to a play date where it is more convenient for her family? For example, take her home with you after the girls have both been somewhere together?

This sounds like a convoluted plan and a long play date. I always think a few hours is better than a whole day if not already established friends.

Are there not some other more local children you can invite around? This sounds like quite hard work all round.

I appreciate your daughter might be a bit disappointed but could you have been quite light about it and said Jenny couldn't make it but perhaps you could invite her another day, and then make a plan to do something else with DD on the day. I think they look to parents to see how to manage minor disappointments and it's a skill that will serve her well in the future. Complaining to the other mother might not make more play dates likely so I wouldn't personally.

SkinnyOatFlatWhiteForMePleaseBarista · 14/11/2026 14:13

It’s rude and shows little regard for anyone’s feelings except for themselves. I wouldn’t be in a hurry to facilitate anything else.

Darkdiamond · 14/11/2026 14:19

RikthePoet · 14/11/2026 14:02

Yes, and you also said "she has other more loyal friends who haven't dropped her in such a way" so you are quoting qualities that make her seem a little less sweet without knowing the real circumstances of what has gone on.

You're right I said that and I am going to ask to get it deleted because I didn't mean it. My annoyance was at the mum and not the child who I hold no grudge against at all, in the slightest. I was going out and rushing as I typed.

OP posts:
gratefulmezze · 14/11/2026 14:19

It is a hard lesson to learn in friendships that some people are flaky and let you down. At least your DD has you in her corner to support her. I would also not overly encourage this friendship in the future as further let downs will be inevitable (the mother's message showed she didn't really take into account your DD's disappointment and wouldn't think twice about cancelling again)

Bigtrapeze · 14/11/2026 14:20

Janetwin · 14/11/2026 10:59

That’s very thoughtless of jenny (seemingly willing to dump your kid when a better plan comes along) and thoughtless of the other mum (maybe jenny is used to getting her own way or that mum just couldn’t be bothered having a chat with jenny to say that she’s committed to other plans and should not flake). Either way, it doesn’t reflect well on them and I’d be encouraging your DD to make other friendships. (Not cut Jenny out exactly but invite a different friend around instead)

Jenny is 9. She's only joined the class recently. She can say no thanks to a play date if she changes her mind for any reason. I don't think this makes her uncaring. She hasn't been mean or dropped anyone. She just wants to be included with her family cinema trip. As adults you should generally stick with the first plans you make but Jenny is 9 and I think it would be unfair on both girls to send het on a play date if she has got cold feet.

Illalwayssayhi · 14/11/2026 14:24

jenny is new to the school

She got anxious and worried and didn’t feel like she could go as too nervous I reckon. But didn’t want her mum to tell the other mum so her mum told a fib. Or something along the lines I would think in your shoes @Darkdiamond

not @Darkdiamond though- straight to the mum is incredibly rude and this girl is falling on her daughter and she won’t ever facilitate another get together ever again.

Darkdiamond · 14/11/2026 14:25

Bigtrapeze · 14/11/2026 14:20

Jenny is 9. She's only joined the class recently. She can say no thanks to a play date if she changes her mind for any reason. I don't think this makes her uncaring. She hasn't been mean or dropped anyone. She just wants to be included with her family cinema trip. As adults you should generally stick with the first plans you make but Jenny is 9 and I think it would be unfair on both girls to send het on a play date if she has got cold feet.

I agree. Maybe she did get cold feet and I wouldn't want that either. There is a big long back story as to why the playdate was arranged despite the long distance but it didn't seem relevant and would have been too outing anyway. I've chilled out about it now. I just needed a bit of time to process it and I am over it.

OP posts:
Illalwayssayhi · 14/11/2026 14:29

I really hope your level of pissed off-ness hasn’t filtered down to your DD and she then passes it on to Jenny on Monday who only recently started at the school and probably feels quite unsettled

Darkdiamond · 14/11/2026 14:31

Illalwayssayhi · 14/11/2026 14:29

I really hope your level of pissed off-ness hasn’t filtered down to your DD and she then passes it on to Jenny on Monday who only recently started at the school and probably feels quite unsettled

No i didn't reveal my annoyance. As I said, I was very matter of fact about it and just said I was sorry to my daughter for her disappointment. That was it.

OP posts:
Illalwayssayhi · 14/11/2026 15:00

Darkdiamond · 14/11/2026 14:31

No i didn't reveal my annoyance. As I said, I was very matter of fact about it and just said I was sorry to my daughter for her disappointment. That was it.

Your three children are going to be disappointed many times in their lives and if your response is to need time to “process” to “get over it” it and spend the next day posting about it - your parenting journey is going to be a difficult one

OutOfTheOtherSide · 14/11/2026 15:02

tripleginandtonic · 14/11/2026 11:02

I dont see it as being flaky, it seemed like quite an onerous task to get to and from the play date. I think most young dc would choose cinema with family.

That's irrelevant. They had made plans which impacted others. The child should have been told that she couldn't let people down. At 9, you don't get a choice once you've made plans.

Velumental · 14/11/2026 15:04

Aneversolongwalk · 14/11/2026 11:00

It was a one off
who knows what’s gone on behind the scenes
I wouldn’t write this off or not facilitate anything going further on the basis of a one off
but… I’m generally in the minority on Mumsnet

I agree, everyone gets awfully het up, if just make new plans for us for that day instead or even ask if they minded tagalongs at the cinema. Although if I was the mum I'd have suggested they come along

OutOfTheOtherSide · 14/11/2026 15:07

Bigtrapeze · 14/11/2026 14:20

Jenny is 9. She's only joined the class recently. She can say no thanks to a play date if she changes her mind for any reason. I don't think this makes her uncaring. She hasn't been mean or dropped anyone. She just wants to be included with her family cinema trip. As adults you should generally stick with the first plans you make but Jenny is 9 and I think it would be unfair on both girls to send het on a play date if she has got cold feet.

Wow. What kind of parenting is just letting your child let people down? She's 9, not 3.

We don't know that she got cold feet, we just know that she preferred the cinema. She should not be rewarded for letting people down, she either sticks to the plan or stays at home. Going to the cinema should never have been an option.