Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Lodger wants to move evening meal time

525 replies

Proseccoisking · 13/11/2026 20:12

I have had a lodger staying Monday to Friday for about 5 months.

It was generally working out quite well.

He has his own large room, which has a sofa and TV, and his own bathroom.

We share the kitchen and dining room. I have a separate living room.

The arrangement started that I provided basic breakfast food items for him to prepare: cereal and bread, butter, jam, honey etc

An evening meal was not included in our agreement. I did tell him, however, that he was welcome to have what I’d cooked, or if I was out or he wanted something different he could have one of several ready meals, or use any food in the fridge or freezer unless it was earmarked for another meal.

I made it clear that I eat fairly early, normally around 6.00pm, and if he wanted the meal I’d cooked and he wasn’t home in time, I would plate it up and he could re heat it when he liked.

He was happy with this as he hadn’t expected any meals ( the rent is very low for the facilities provided in this area), and had only asked for space to store his own food.

He now has his own cupboard/ fridge space in case he wants something different.

I like to cook and the meals I provide are cooked from scratch and accompanied by fresh vegetables. If we are both there when the meal is ready we often eat together in the dining room.

He has recently mentioned a few times that he would prefer to eat his meal when it was hot, rather than having to re heat it. This is quite a change from when he first moved in, and told me that he often ate Pot Noodles as he couldn’t be bothered to cook.

I advertised for a lodger to help with the bills and am happy to let him share my food, but I am not running a hotel. I don’t want to eat later, nor cook a separate meal for him and be clearing up at up to 8.30pm. He arrives back somewhere between 5.30 - 8.15pm.

Our contract only states that I will provide basic breakfast items. I am under no obligation to provide any other meals, although I am concerned that it might appear so through custom/ practice.

I’ve already told him that I am not prepared to change the timing of my meal, but it hasn’t stopped him mentioning it.

I am considering withdrawing the offer of evening meals altogether.

I am posting here to try to get a balanced view.

In other ways he is a good fit as a lodger, although there have obviously been some niggles.

OP posts:
Gwenhwyfar · 14/11/2026 13:34

""I think my idea of a lodger, however, must have been formed from seeing the arrangements in old films or similar."
I must admit when I read about you providing meals I was put in mind of lodgers and their landladies as described in several Agatha Christie books. Single working men and the occasional single working women, renting a draughty room which came with dubious kippers for breakfast, lunch at Lyons Tea Rooms or British Restaurants (if the book is set in/near WWII)"

My great-grandmother had lodgers after she was widowed and I think she provided breakfast and dinner. I suppose that was in the days when men were considered unable to cook or it was seen as such a chore that it would be difficult to combine with working. I don't think my ggm had a job when she took in lodgers so that became her job.

PensionedCruiser · 14/11/2026 13:35

Proseccoisking · 14/11/2026 08:46

I researched all of the legal aspects, Council Tax, Income Tax, electrical safety certificates ( I don’t have gas), etc. The contract I downloaded was quite specific for the financial aspects and notice periods, etc but I had to put in my own answers for services provided. It gave little information.

I think my idea of a lodger, however, must have been formed from seeing the arrangements in old films or similar.

I have lodgers from time to time and once had a Monday to Friday lodger. Nothing you have written seems unusual. The offer of food is a nice "extra" but not a requirement. In some ways, I think you are treating your lodger like a long term bed and breakfast guest, but because you have a contract, it doesn't really matter.

He is being unreasonable because:

  1. He is not taking steps to make the room available when he's not paying for it and
  2. He is taking the evening meal for granted and wants it arranged for his convenience - even though you are not contracted to supply it.

For those who don't know, lodging is very different to subletting and the tenant rights are different. He is paying to lodge 4 nights per week and @Proseccoisking has chosen to supply food. He could stay in a guesthouse/B&B - as many of us do when working away from home - or take on an AirB&B property (I have done all those). All possibilities have their own advantages and drawbacks. The lodger, for whatever reason has chosen to lodge. That is perfectly fine, but he is being a CF for wanting more than @Proseccoisking is making freely available to him and needs to either be told to shape up and be grateful for the extras or given notice.

TLDR: a lodger has very few rights and holds his lodgings for as long as the owner consents. If the lodger does not abide by the contract then can be evicted without a reason.

pollcat · 14/11/2026 13:38

Tricksortreats · 14/11/2026 12:55

I think that if a lodger lives as part of the family you don't then have to pay capital gains tax. Worth thinking about in your situation.

Capital gains tax isn't relevant to this situation at all. It would apply when, for example, selling a second home / rental property that you don't live in.

Rainandhail · 14/11/2026 13:39

West coast Scotland and dinner is 5pm, always has been since childhood and always will be. This is the case for most folk here.

Id be gnawing my hand off by 7pm tbh

PensionedCruiser · 14/11/2026 13:39

caffeineanddryshampoo · 14/11/2026 13:08

What Rights Do Lodgers Have? Don't change a mealtime but also
Your landlord’s right to enter your room
Your landlord shouldn’t go into your room without your permission.
Your landlord can enter your room without your permission if for example:

  • you agreed they’ll do things for you - like cleaning your room
  • they need to do repairs
  • there’s an emergency - like a leak in the room

That's when the lodger has rented the room for a full week. This one only has it for 4 nights per week.

Also, with the rent a room scheme, the landlord can enter the room to clean or change beds. That should be spelled out in the contract.

Skippythemagnificent · 14/11/2026 13:40

There isn’t such a thing as a sub tenant in the UK, is there?

You’re a tenant, with all the rights that comes with, if you rent a whole property or a room in a shared property in which the owner does not live (like students who share a house but each have separate tenancy contracts).

You’re a lodger if you rent a room or property in which the owner also lives, you cannot be a tenant and you do not have tenants rights.

This guy is a lodger no matter how much food you provide or washing you do. You seem to be treating it like you’re running a boarding house in Little Women rather than renting a room to a lodger. You don’t cook for them and you don’t do their washing.

Gwenhwyfar · 14/11/2026 13:40

Rainandhail · 14/11/2026 13:39

West coast Scotland and dinner is 5pm, always has been since childhood and always will be. This is the case for most folk here.

Id be gnawing my hand off by 7pm tbh

Most people? Doesn't anybody work 9 to 5?

QuietChristmas2026 · 14/11/2026 13:42

Jaichangecentfoisdenom · 14/11/2026 13:34

If the arrangement for the lodger is that they only pay from Monday to Friday, then they should not have access to that room on Saturday and Sunday, obviously, as they have not paid for that occupancy. If they pay from Monday to Sunday inclusive, then they do have access to that room the whole of that time. As many others have mentioned, it is more like booking a hotel during the working week and returning home for the week-end, you would not expect to leave your stuff in the hotel room whilst you were not paying for it.

Exactly. This lodger pays for Monday to Friday.

I genuinely think some people are pretending to not understand. I have a relative who admits she likes arguing for the sake of it.

QuietChristmas2026 · 14/11/2026 13:43

Gwenhwyfar · 14/11/2026 13:40

Most people? Doesn't anybody work 9 to 5?

It’s apparently a minority of people do that. A previous poster mentioned it up thread.

OffTheMap · 14/11/2026 13:46

Check he isn't telling you that he doesn't need you to leave plated up food because he will cook something hot.

Why not just leave leftovers in the pan or whatever in the fridge rather than 'plating up' - which is sort of....prescriptive?

And then if he doesn't eat it you can freeze it.

Thegirlwhowent · 14/11/2026 13:50

You've been very generous (over generous?) and are obviously a very kind person. I'd never have offered free food in with the agreement, for a start! However, you must guard against being taken advantage of. Make your boundaries clear and stick to them.

Gwenhwyfar · 14/11/2026 13:51

QuietChristmas2026 · 14/11/2026 13:43

It’s apparently a minority of people do that. A previous poster mentioned it up thread.

Hard to believe as offices and some retail and hospitality have that pattern.

everynowandthenifallapart · 14/11/2026 13:56

Lodging is a weird situation.

Ive only done it once after a long stint in shared housing in my 20s I moved in with a woman from work who had had lodgers.

I found it weird a fuck, she used to come in my room and take my washing and wash it without asking me (which I hated) and she’d also do the weird plating up thing and leave food out for me, which I also hated. I was a party animal and used to come home at 11 on a work night and clear up the food she’d left out for me.

I think if he keeps mentioning it it’s the perfect opportunity for you to reset some boundaries op.

Ive no idea why you’ve been offering him dibs on your ready meals either.

Just tell him you’ll be cooking around 6 each evening and he can have the kitchen to himself after that to sort out his own cooking.

Insertcreativenamehere · 14/11/2026 14:00

You are being unreasonable because you’ve blurred the lines. Stick to the original agreement - breakfast items only. Cheeky f’er can sort the rest out himself.

Frenzi · 14/11/2026 14:02

Your lodger is doing very well for himself. Low rent, food provided, room cleaned by a cleaner every Monday, bedding washed and remade every week and getting to keep use of the room for the 3 days he is not paying for.

I think you need to stop being quite so nice.

CandidHedgehog · 14/11/2026 14:03

Realorsurreal · 14/11/2026 12:53

I do understand. I’ve had M-F lodgers for years. So no need for the sarky comments.

And I and my colleagues were/are M-F lodgers for years. Nobody has landlords that give full control of the room on the weekends for M-F prices. You are apparently very, very generous to an unusual degree. That’s your choice but it’s not the normal way M-F contracts work.

CandidHedgehog · 14/11/2026 14:06

caffeineanddryshampoo · 14/11/2026 13:08

What Rights Do Lodgers Have? Don't change a mealtime but also
Your landlord’s right to enter your room
Your landlord shouldn’t go into your room without your permission.
Your landlord can enter your room without your permission if for example:

  • you agreed they’ll do things for you - like cleaning your room
  • they need to do repairs
  • there’s an emergency - like a leak in the room

That’s a full time lodger and in any event says the landlord can enter the room with permission. The contract explicitly returning control of the room to the landlady at the weekends is the permission.

C8H10N4O2 · 14/11/2026 14:07

Proseccoisking · 14/11/2026 08:46

I researched all of the legal aspects, Council Tax, Income Tax, electrical safety certificates ( I don’t have gas), etc. The contract I downloaded was quite specific for the financial aspects and notice periods, etc but I had to put in my own answers for services provided. It gave little information.

I think my idea of a lodger, however, must have been formed from seeing the arrangements in old films or similar.

Put it down to experience and have the discussion, feel free to say its slipped a long way from the original agreement, you need to revert to the original contract (he clears out properly Friday to Monday, you don't provide evening meals) but you understand he may want to look for somewhere providing half board.

End of discussion.

He is taking the piss - its the classic case of being given an inch and grabbing a yard and it won't stop here if he is already expecting you to move your meal times (to suit his free dinner) and not clearing out properly without paying for the extra nights. If you sat down and costed up what you are providing (including the cleaner) you will likely be earning a lot less than you expected.

You might be better if he goes and you can reset with a new lodger and apply what you have learned. FWIW, neither breakfast nor dinner are usual for M-F lodging. Its solely use of the room and facilities and the lodger should be clearing out fully every Friday.

Greag · 14/11/2026 14:07

Stop cooking for him. He's an adult paying for a room with a kitchen, not a bed and breakfast. The fact that he's complaining about having to reheat food you cooked for him for free is incredibly entitled. Just tell him the arrangement isn't working for you anymore and stick to the contract.

Deneke · 14/11/2026 14:10

You definitely wouldn't be unreasonable to retract the offer of evening meals. His contract doesn't include them so he can't expect them and can't dictate the time you eat yours.
He also shouldn't be allowed to help himself to the food in your fridge and cupboard (apart from breakfast, coffee and tea which are included in his contract). Certainly no helping himself to ready meals without reimbursing you for them!
You said you originally offered to cook because your kitchen is too small for you to cook at the same time, but that doesn't sound problematic, since you want to eat early and he wants to eat later. Simply tell him you will be using the kitchen to cook between 5 and 6pm and he can use it to make his dinner from 6.30 onwards.
If you want to offer to feed him, say you'll do it only on the days he'll be home early enough and he'll need to pay for it.

Cailleach1 · 14/11/2026 14:16

dottiedodah · 14/11/2026 09:08

Im guessing maybe you felt a bit lonely ? Like someone to eat with and cook for.Is he quite young .I think hes being cheeky ,but surely most lodgers would not be too happy with their room being used when they are not there either.I would say 6pm is the time ,Non negotiable .I think many people would like a reduced room rate with some meals as well

Thing is, though, that he is not paying for nearly half the week - Friday from 11am and night, Saturday night, and Sunday night. If he doesn’t like not being a lodger for those nights, he can pay for it. Easily fixed to save his sensitivities.

I remember trying to book a room in a hotel for two weeks. I couldn’t get the weekend in the middle as it was already booked. So we had to move out and stay elsewhere for that weekend.

It wouldn’t have dawned on me to have been unhappy that someone else got to stay in ‘my’ hotel room between the first week and the second. When I had no booking, and hadn’t paid for it.

Proseccoisking · 14/11/2026 14:18

I have been a bit distracted and only just catching up with all of these posts.

I had intended to wait until Monday to have a chat in person, but when I went into the room this morning to collect the bedding ( which was still on the bed) I found that he had breached a fundamental, and to my mind non negotiable rule.

I have spoken to him by telephone and told him that he is not welcome back. I have of course made arrangements for his belongings to be made available for collection. This might sound harsh but my home is not his home, just somewhere he stayed part of the time as it was cheaper than a hotel or Airbnb.

I am now looking at other alternatives. I have seen an advertisement from an agency which places visiting employees of a huge local employer in temporary lodgings for various periods from odd days to regular Monday to Fridays. I think this may work better as being able to use my room at weekends without any issue is important to me.

OP posts:
MeridaBrave · 14/11/2026 14:19

Tell him he can cook his own food as you’ll be finished in the kitchen by then.

Cailleach1 · 14/11/2026 14:27

Gwenhwyfar · 14/11/2026 10:28

OMG I couldn't live out of a box like that. Pretty normal to want to have his belongings around him.

I suspect those who couldn’t live like that would happily pony up twice the cost to book or hold the room for them for the days they are elsewhere.

For some reason thought, the op’s lodger is only paying for the days that he stays there from 3pm Monday until 11am Friday. Someone should tell him he can pay double and not have to free up the room on the days he has not paid for.