Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Lodger wants to move evening meal time

525 replies

Proseccoisking · 13/11/2026 20:12

I have had a lodger staying Monday to Friday for about 5 months.

It was generally working out quite well.

He has his own large room, which has a sofa and TV, and his own bathroom.

We share the kitchen and dining room. I have a separate living room.

The arrangement started that I provided basic breakfast food items for him to prepare: cereal and bread, butter, jam, honey etc

An evening meal was not included in our agreement. I did tell him, however, that he was welcome to have what I’d cooked, or if I was out or he wanted something different he could have one of several ready meals, or use any food in the fridge or freezer unless it was earmarked for another meal.

I made it clear that I eat fairly early, normally around 6.00pm, and if he wanted the meal I’d cooked and he wasn’t home in time, I would plate it up and he could re heat it when he liked.

He was happy with this as he hadn’t expected any meals ( the rent is very low for the facilities provided in this area), and had only asked for space to store his own food.

He now has his own cupboard/ fridge space in case he wants something different.

I like to cook and the meals I provide are cooked from scratch and accompanied by fresh vegetables. If we are both there when the meal is ready we often eat together in the dining room.

He has recently mentioned a few times that he would prefer to eat his meal when it was hot, rather than having to re heat it. This is quite a change from when he first moved in, and told me that he often ate Pot Noodles as he couldn’t be bothered to cook.

I advertised for a lodger to help with the bills and am happy to let him share my food, but I am not running a hotel. I don’t want to eat later, nor cook a separate meal for him and be clearing up at up to 8.30pm. He arrives back somewhere between 5.30 - 8.15pm.

Our contract only states that I will provide basic breakfast items. I am under no obligation to provide any other meals, although I am concerned that it might appear so through custom/ practice.

I’ve already told him that I am not prepared to change the timing of my meal, but it hasn’t stopped him mentioning it.

I am considering withdrawing the offer of evening meals altogether.

I am posting here to try to get a balanced view.

In other ways he is a good fit as a lodger, although there have obviously been some niggles.

OP posts:
Royaly82 · 14/11/2026 12:52

I seem to have a different opinion to a lot of other posters.
The way im seeing it its a bit like a long term air b&b type set up which works for you both and would be cheaper than him constantly finding new ones each week and easier for you than finding new people every week?

PigletJohn · 14/11/2026 12:53

"No, that isn't a service I offer."

Realorsurreal · 14/11/2026 12:53

MyCatChloe · 14/11/2026 12:43

Another one who doesn’t understand Mon - Fri rentals. 🙄

I do understand. I’ve had M-F lodgers for years. So no need for the sarky comments.

Tricksortreats · 14/11/2026 12:55

I think that if a lodger lives as part of the family you don't then have to pay capital gains tax. Worth thinking about in your situation.

user1471538283 · 14/11/2026 12:57

I think you need a reset conversation with him. You cannot afford to feed him and you certainly would not change your mealtimes to suit him. He knows he's taking the piss.

If he doesn't like it he can leave and you can get someone else.

My friend had a great M-F lodger years ago. He bought all his own food, worked long hours outside the home, put his bed linen in the wash and took all his belongings with him. It was so much cheaper than a hotel or Airbnb.

puppyinapumpkinpatch · 14/11/2026 12:58

I agree you've made things too comfortable for him. He's been very fortunate that you've generously shared food with him for free, and he shouldn't be requesting or hinting that he'd like you to shift the mealtime.

In my opinion, 6 isn't even all that early. It's when I aim to eat and have done all my adult life. However, if you were eating at 3 pm it still wouldn't change things. You should eat when it suits you. Out of the goodness of your heart you have offered to leave him a plate to heat up whenever he likes. If that doesn't suit him, he can start preparing his own food when he wants to eat.

Personally, I'd be inclined to stop sharing food altogether. It must be costing you a fait bit, and he doesn't seem to appreciate it!

Hiredgun · 14/11/2026 13:02

Proseccoisking · 13/11/2026 20:12

I have had a lodger staying Monday to Friday for about 5 months.

It was generally working out quite well.

He has his own large room, which has a sofa and TV, and his own bathroom.

We share the kitchen and dining room. I have a separate living room.

The arrangement started that I provided basic breakfast food items for him to prepare: cereal and bread, butter, jam, honey etc

An evening meal was not included in our agreement. I did tell him, however, that he was welcome to have what I’d cooked, or if I was out or he wanted something different he could have one of several ready meals, or use any food in the fridge or freezer unless it was earmarked for another meal.

I made it clear that I eat fairly early, normally around 6.00pm, and if he wanted the meal I’d cooked and he wasn’t home in time, I would plate it up and he could re heat it when he liked.

He was happy with this as he hadn’t expected any meals ( the rent is very low for the facilities provided in this area), and had only asked for space to store his own food.

He now has his own cupboard/ fridge space in case he wants something different.

I like to cook and the meals I provide are cooked from scratch and accompanied by fresh vegetables. If we are both there when the meal is ready we often eat together in the dining room.

He has recently mentioned a few times that he would prefer to eat his meal when it was hot, rather than having to re heat it. This is quite a change from when he first moved in, and told me that he often ate Pot Noodles as he couldn’t be bothered to cook.

I advertised for a lodger to help with the bills and am happy to let him share my food, but I am not running a hotel. I don’t want to eat later, nor cook a separate meal for him and be clearing up at up to 8.30pm. He arrives back somewhere between 5.30 - 8.15pm.

Our contract only states that I will provide basic breakfast items. I am under no obligation to provide any other meals, although I am concerned that it might appear so through custom/ practice.

I’ve already told him that I am not prepared to change the timing of my meal, but it hasn’t stopped him mentioning it.

I am considering withdrawing the offer of evening meals altogether.

I am posting here to try to get a balanced view.

In other ways he is a good fit as a lodger, although there have obviously been some niggles.

Case of give an inch…. He’s taking advantage of your hospitality.

LightUpLavender · 14/11/2026 13:02

Is he not allowed to cook for himself? Maybe he’s hoping you’d allow that rather than change what you’re doing. But you are certainly not being unreasonable.

HumbleStumble · 14/11/2026 13:04

MyBigPony · 14/11/2026 12:49

I can't imagine eating so late, I would be going to bed on a full stomach. I'd also need an extra meal between lunch and dinner. I eat at 7.30, 12 and 6. Nothing in between.

Edited

To be fair, no one asked when you scheduled all your meals. Do you ever feel like your life has no meaning when you shovel down your set meals at set times? What if friends invite you out for late night tapas ?

PigletJohn · 14/11/2026 13:05

Tricksortreats · 14/11/2026 12:55

I think that if a lodger lives as part of the family you don't then have to pay capital gains tax. Worth thinking about in your situation.

You are perhaps thinking of the tax concessions of the Rent-a-Room scheme.

https://www.gov.uk/rent-room-in-your-home/the-rent-a-room-scheme

Rent a room in your home

Renting a room in your home out - Rent a Room Scheme, types of tenancy or licence, rent, bills, tax and ending a letting

https://www.gov.uk/rent-room-in-your-home/the-rent-a-room-scheme

PrincessHedgehog · 14/11/2026 13:08

My own mother wouldn’t change dinner time for me when I couldn’t get home until 6 from my first graduate job. I ended up moving to another continent anyway but that’s neither here nor there. He’s not your kid.

Plumnora · 14/11/2026 13:08

He's taking the piss! That's it!
People suggesing you blurred the lines are essentialy putting the blame on you and that's unfair.
Tou kindly offered him a meal he could reheat.
Most people- decent people who understand boundaries and professional agreements- would be enormously grateful for this and would run with it. Or politely decline if it didn't suit them.
This man is pushing boundaries to see how far you'll accommodate him. He's behaving like an entitled partner and has overstepped your hospitality by a long way.
I'd end the contact and find someone who can agree to an appropriate formal agreement with you as the landlord and them as your tenant.
You owe this man zero.

caffeineanddryshampoo · 14/11/2026 13:08

What Rights Do Lodgers Have? Don't change a mealtime but also
Your landlord’s right to enter your room
Your landlord shouldn’t go into your room without your permission.
Your landlord can enter your room without your permission if for example:

  • you agreed they’ll do things for you - like cleaning your room
  • they need to do repairs
  • there’s an emergency - like a leak in the room
Lunde · 14/11/2026 13:09

Gwenhwyfar · 14/11/2026 10:28

OMG I couldn't live out of a box like that. Pretty normal to want to have his belongings around him.

He doesn't pay for the weekends though - he has a cheaper M-F deal.

Eddielizzard · 14/11/2026 13:10

Your lodger is being a bit of a CF.

You are kind, welcoming and generous and he is beginning to take advantage. It is now time to decide what your boundaries are and tell him. You haven't done anything wrong. But now you have to hold the line.

Or you could get rid of him and find someone else with similar values who would just be grateful to be in your space.

BestZebbie · 14/11/2026 13:14

TheSnappyBluePoster · 13/11/2026 20:30

I was just about to say that as well.

He's paying below market rates, but he's paying nonetheless. He's not even allowed to leave his belongings on display.In the room he's renting monday to friday because somebody else is sleeping in it over the weekend.

I mean fuck that. I sincerely hope the sheets are being changed.

Edited

This is normal - for example, if you live in halls as a student you rent them in term time only and in the holidays (including the mid-year ones) you have to put your stuff into storage or take it home and conference guests sleep in your room.
If you rent a hotel room mon-fri, obviously other people have it over the weekend.

To have continuous use of the room to keep his stuff out, he would need to pay rent for it continuously, e.g.: 7 days a week rather than 5. In most situations, any stuff left out after departure would just get binned, so he is lucky this host is being accommodating so far.

Lunde · 14/11/2026 13:14

HumbleStumble · 14/11/2026 12:39

6pm is a ridiculous time to eat dinner. That's irrelevant to this though. OP can do as she pleases.

It's a really normal time for parents that eat with their children

KWaldron · 14/11/2026 13:15

annoyedatlandlord · 13/11/2026 20:40

This isn’t what the thread is about, message each other privately if you feel the need to continue debating when to have dinner

Thank you. My thoughts too. Dinner time is whenever you want it to be. The whole issue comes down to a woman being 'kind', and a man taking advantage of that. As a PP said - he thinks she's a pushover.

No point having a lodger to help pay the bills when he's literally eating into any profit you're making. I suggest putting the points to him in writing - email him restating what his contract covers, and confrming that henceforth, you're abiding strictly by the terms of that legal agreement. No more free food and he packs his stuff away when he leaves on Fridays.

If this makes you feel uncomfortable, just consider that he has no respect for you. Get angry - you should be.

SisterMidnight77 · 14/11/2026 13:16

Today’s favour is tomorrow’s obligation.

QuietChristmas2026 · 14/11/2026 13:17

caffeineanddryshampoo · 14/11/2026 13:08

What Rights Do Lodgers Have? Don't change a mealtime but also
Your landlord’s right to enter your room
Your landlord shouldn’t go into your room without your permission.
Your landlord can enter your room without your permission if for example:

  • you agreed they’ll do things for you - like cleaning your room
  • they need to do repairs
  • there’s an emergency - like a leak in the room

He is a lodger between 3pm Monday and 11am Friday. Between those hours, OP abides by those rules.

Between 11am Friday and 3pm Monday OP has no lodger. She can do what she wants with her own spare room then.

If the lodger wants use of the room all week then he should find someone offering that.

QuietChristmas2026 · 14/11/2026 13:20

Realorsurreal · 14/11/2026 12:53

I do understand. I’ve had M-F lodgers for years. So no need for the sarky comments.

M-F lodgers neither rent nor live in the room unless it is M-F.

If you’ve done this for years, you already know this.

WhereYouLeftIt · 14/11/2026 13:28

Proseccoisking · 14/11/2026 08:46

I researched all of the legal aspects, Council Tax, Income Tax, electrical safety certificates ( I don’t have gas), etc. The contract I downloaded was quite specific for the financial aspects and notice periods, etc but I had to put in my own answers for services provided. It gave little information.

I think my idea of a lodger, however, must have been formed from seeing the arrangements in old films or similar.

"I think my idea of a lodger, however, must have been formed from seeing the arrangements in old films or similar."

I must admit when I read about you providing meals I was put in mind of lodgers and their landladies as described in several Agatha Christie books. Single working men and the occasional single working women, renting a draughty room which came with dubious kippers for breakfast, lunch at Lyons Tea Rooms or British Restaurants (if the book is set in/near WWII), and the landlady setting the time for an uninspiring 'supper' which always seemed to involve bread and butter. The difference from your set-up being, the landlady was always indisputably the one in charge!

You strike me as a kind person, but unfortunately your current lodger's earlier gratitude for your kindness has now become entitlement, so I'm afraid you will have to set aside your natural kindness and become more business-like. Read @SalmonOnFinnCrisp's post (08:04 this morning) and take her advice. I think she's right, it might be best to draw a line under this lodger and start again. Because he' s likely to be either miffed at the withdrawal of what he now feels entitled to (he isn't) or even at best shamefaced and apologetic, which can be just as awkward to deal with. So, draw a line, re-advertise, and this time - business-like.

(Edited for spellng)

Casualuser · 14/11/2026 13:30

Can i move in with you? Tbf doesnt sound too bad there are some lodgers from hell. Are you near any language schools, the cleaning, providing breakfast and dinner would be perfect for language students.

Jaichangecentfoisdenom · 14/11/2026 13:34

QuietChristmas2026 · 14/11/2026 13:20

M-F lodgers neither rent nor live in the room unless it is M-F.

If you’ve done this for years, you already know this.

If the arrangement for the lodger is that they only pay from Monday to Friday, then they should not have access to that room on Saturday and Sunday, obviously, as they have not paid for that occupancy. If they pay from Monday to Sunday inclusive, then they do have access to that room the whole of that time. As many others have mentioned, it is more like booking a hotel during the working week and returning home for the week-end, you would not expect to leave your stuff in the hotel room whilst you were not paying for it.

Neurodiversitydoctor · 14/11/2026 13:34

TheSnappyBluePoster · 13/11/2026 20:39

Really?

I was still sitting at my desk in the office at 6pm

I've just eaten now and it has gone 8:30pm.

This is a massive derail it really doesn't matter whether or not it is early it ks when OP wants to eat ! It's up to her in her own house.