Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to think switching off landlines is crazy?

301 replies

humanassy · 13/11/2026 18:48

Old school telephone landlines are being switched off in January 2027 as we’ve all been told to go digital. In the light of the last 2 days with the Microsoft ‘outage’, AIBU to think this is lunacy?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
6
Lkt32 · 15/11/2026 07:59

There's mobile reception dead spots all around here. I can't get a mobile signal in my house, or at either of my two kids schools. (I do calls over wifi on my mobile at home but its still hit and miss) Landlines are definitely necessary here but since being forced to switch to digital, if the WiFi goes down we have no way to phone/message/email anyone.

(I'm in SE London btw, not put in the sticks)

Askingforafriendtoday · 15/11/2026 10:13

DoubleHellos · 15/11/2026 01:03

My issue isn't that i am some dinosaur who can't move with the times.

It is that our mobiles do not work at home or in many local areas near us - we have neen in a variety of networks and they are all hopeless. Our wifi isn't great, there's no fibre here, and we have paid for new hardwire, wiring, router and tp link gadgets and we still get lagging and the voip pulses and drops out.

I love new tech but only when it works and doesn't leave me with no way of speaking to school/GP/hospital etc

Exactly this. It's so annoying when people think it's some sort of tech phobia.

Puzzledandpissedoff · 15/11/2026 10:49

I think we need to build in "redundancy" or backup - first for emergency purposes. But also for the Digitally Excluded

You're right of course, @SockPlant, but the very nature of exclusion - and it is exclusion - means that many simply don't care

The blank stare comes first, then the shrug, and if really pushed you get attempts to shut down other people's lived experience because "It'll work if you just try a bit harder"

As we've seen on here, too often it doesn't and can't work, but acknowledging that would mean accepting the issues in what's being created and some simply don't want to do it

MrsJeanLuc · 15/11/2026 11:28

CarlaH · 14/11/2026 10:28

Are the people who just keep parroting that they haven't had a landline for years and are doing just fine able to offer a solution to those who don't have a decent mobile signal or what people are supposed to do in the event of a power failure?

Just saying 'I haven't had any problems' really doesn't cut it.

Come on people offer up a proper solution for a lengthy power outage.

Well if it was a long outage I'm not sure phone would be my number 1 priority - I'm more worried about water tbh.

But you could consider getting a battery backup (or UPS) for your router - which would give you internet and phone usage for a few hours

ItsOkItsDarkChocolate · 15/11/2026 11:34

Autumnallaround · 13/11/2026 19:20

Landlines are not being switched off. The way they work is changing.

You will still be able to use a land-line. It will just be digital not copper and so jot work in a power cut.

@humanassy

Indeed. And it seems a bit ironic given the recent, prepare for doomsday, push.

The copper landline would have still worked then at least 🤷‍♀️

ItsOkItsDarkChocolate · 15/11/2026 11:37

MrsJeanLuc · 15/11/2026 11:28

Well if it was a long outage I'm not sure phone would be my number 1 priority - I'm more worried about water tbh.

But you could consider getting a battery backup (or UPS) for your router - which would give you internet and phone usage for a few hours

No, but being able to contact other family may be helpful.

Ref. Broadband - Unlikely as the provider service will also be down as well, no?

rwalker · 15/11/2026 11:46

Who do people think should pay for the copper network
what we have now is dying on its knees
it literally needs rebuilding and new exchanges for it to continue the investment required would be billions

Barranca · 15/11/2026 12:05

rwalker · 15/11/2026 11:46

Who do people think should pay for the copper network
what we have now is dying on its knees
it literally needs rebuilding and new exchanges for it to continue the investment required would be billions

Perhaps a properly resilient backup then so that those of us who are losing out are ok?

Barranca · 15/11/2026 12:11

MrsJeanLuc · 15/11/2026 11:28

Well if it was a long outage I'm not sure phone would be my number 1 priority - I'm more worried about water tbh.

But you could consider getting a battery backup (or UPS) for your router - which would give you internet and phone usage for a few hours

Sorry but a few hours 🤣
A few days more like needs to be considered, as many on here have described.

When there were severe storms many were also without water. As pumps etc are electric I believe (I’m not so familiar with the set up as I’m on private water supply). To be without water and power at the same time, for days on end, in cold weather, would be horrendous.

rwalker · 15/11/2026 13:07

Barranca · 15/11/2026 12:05

Perhaps a properly resilient backup then so that those of us who are losing out are ok?

Again who pays for that broadband and communication companies are folding and being taken over as there’s not enough money in it so certainly not enough to develop anything
but also the problem arises from power cuts why isn’t there the same outrage about power cuts as there is about phones going off solve the power cut issue and the phone problem will solve itself

Barranca · 15/11/2026 13:19

rwalker · 15/11/2026 13:07

Again who pays for that broadband and communication companies are folding and being taken over as there’s not enough money in it so certainly not enough to develop anything
but also the problem arises from power cuts why isn’t there the same outrage about power cuts as there is about phones going off solve the power cut issue and the phone problem will solve itself

Actually I agree with you about power cuts. I wrote earlier that I am sure they happen much more frequently, sometimes barely a high wind. The cause of this yes needs to be identified and addressed and there needs to be much more joined up resilience planning across all forms of infrastructure.

As for who pays. No idea. But I’m talking about proper, thorough, forward planning to have been part of the transition from copper. The contingency that’s there - battery packs for a few hours for example - is not a solution for those on this thread who are concerned about losing all comms in a multi day outage. But yes, again I agree, stop or massively reduce the outages in the first place should be part of that effort.

Right now, for many of us what we have in an emergency is less than before. That was foreseen but as has been demonstrated by the total insufficient measures apparently in place for “vulnerable” people, let alone “ordinary” people, the foresight has not been recognised let alone addressed. It feels like a case of tough shit.

ColinISabirthdaycake · 15/11/2026 13:29

JJMama · 14/11/2026 18:33

I’ve not used a landline for about 20 years. Don’t see why one would ever be needed?

Because people want them. Because the reception is better. Because more than one person can answer it. Because it's probably plugged in and the battery hasn't run down. Because people want to be phoned at home, and not when they are driving or working.

And that's before you get to the small matter of power cuts rendering other forms of communication useless.

And no, I don't have a landline anymore. But I can totally see why you'd want to keep one (that works in a power cut).

Also - until recently the landline was bundled with your broadband, so you had one even if you didn't plug a phone into it.

rwalker · 15/11/2026 13:42

Barranca · 15/11/2026 13:19

Actually I agree with you about power cuts. I wrote earlier that I am sure they happen much more frequently, sometimes barely a high wind. The cause of this yes needs to be identified and addressed and there needs to be much more joined up resilience planning across all forms of infrastructure.

As for who pays. No idea. But I’m talking about proper, thorough, forward planning to have been part of the transition from copper. The contingency that’s there - battery packs for a few hours for example - is not a solution for those on this thread who are concerned about losing all comms in a multi day outage. But yes, again I agree, stop or massively reduce the outages in the first place should be part of that effort.

Right now, for many of us what we have in an emergency is less than before. That was foreseen but as has been demonstrated by the total insufficient measures apparently in place for “vulnerable” people, let alone “ordinary” people, the foresight has not been recognised let alone addressed. It feels like a case of tough shit.

Unfortunately this is the result of of privatisation
a national company and they could of done that
As it is none of the many companies are in a position to make that investment

the issue is it’s not essential a mind for a lot of people and inconvenience not the end of the world
and in storm we had no power telephones or broadband for 3 days a complete blackout no streetlights nothing the whole town was out
we survived I wouldn’t pay any extra for the backup

extramile · 15/11/2026 14:14

I have been saying this for years. In an increasingly unstable world where we are being told to be more resilient, it seems crazy to have communication that is purely reliant on access to electricity and the internet. We don't have a landline any more because I don't see the point of it if it can't be used when the internet is down. How can the government be advising households to have a wind up radio and yet not think about maintaining an independent telephone network?

DoraSpenlow · 15/11/2026 16:36

rwalker · 15/11/2026 13:42

Unfortunately this is the result of of privatisation
a national company and they could of done that
As it is none of the many companies are in a position to make that investment

the issue is it’s not essential a mind for a lot of people and inconvenience not the end of the world
and in storm we had no power telephones or broadband for 3 days a complete blackout no streetlights nothing the whole town was out
we survived I wouldn’t pay any extra for the backup

You survived but what would you have done if your house had caught fire or there had been a medical emergency. How would you have contacted the emergency services?

Rainbowpumpkin · 15/11/2026 16:59

For those that don't know analogue phone service will be switched off in the uk at the end of Jan 2027!

So lunacy or not ...we have no choice all.phones will be digital.

DoraSpenlow · 15/11/2026 17:22

And still no-one has come up with solutions to contacting the Fire Brigade, Ambulance Service or Police in the case of an emergency if you have no phone or internet. Perhaps they will supply each household with a homing pigeon or perhaps some flares!

ThisTicklishFatball · 15/11/2026 18:21

DoraSpenlow · 15/11/2026 17:22

And still no-one has come up with solutions to contacting the Fire Brigade, Ambulance Service or Police in the case of an emergency if you have no phone or internet. Perhaps they will supply each household with a homing pigeon or perhaps some flares!

You ain't wrong!

The country’s government bodies are literally telling people to keep a wind-up radio for emergencies, so they can receive information when everything else fails—including anything connected to the internet. Yet they’re cutting off traditional landlines, which can work without mains electricity or an internet connection. Make it make sense. Why cut off traditional landlines while telling people to keep wind-up radios?

The country is becoming less and less resilient, with one government decision after another seemingly making the most vulnerable people even more vulnerable.

If you know any elderly or ill people who need help but don’t live with you, look out for them, because nobody else will.

There are many reasons I’m so supportive of preppers: they’re right to prepare for a wide range of scenarios, and they understand that no one may come to help—certainly no one from government agencies.

rwalker · 15/11/2026 18:22

DoraSpenlow · 15/11/2026 16:36

You survived but what would you have done if your house had caught fire or there had been a medical emergency. How would you have contacted the emergency services?

I’m not saying this isn’t a problem but
who’s problem is it to solve
the copper network isn’t viable it’s limping along now in a few more years it would totally give up repairing it isn’t an option due to cost and return
none of the service providers are in a position to to offer alternatives
what can the actually do
they couldn’t even leave it switched on if they wanted to

DoraSpenlow · 15/11/2026 19:45

rwalker · 15/11/2026 18:22

I’m not saying this isn’t a problem but
who’s problem is it to solve
the copper network isn’t viable it’s limping along now in a few more years it would totally give up repairing it isn’t an option due to cost and return
none of the service providers are in a position to to offer alternatives
what can the actually do
they couldn’t even leave it switched on if they wanted to

Edited

I don't know the answers but it surely can't be acceptable that under certain circumstances hundreds, if not thousands of people are left without access to the emergency services.

Barranca · 15/11/2026 19:52

DoraSpenlow · 15/11/2026 19:45

I don't know the answers but it surely can't be acceptable that under certain circumstances hundreds, if not thousands of people are left without access to the emergency services.

I agree with you. thousands of people have been totally overlooked and they have been left worse off, being placed at unacceptable risk. Knowingly!!! This should have been part of the planning for the phase out of copper. Not just basically telling us to make do with fuck all backup.

BritherPhil · 15/11/2026 20:20

FeralWoman · 13/11/2026 18:55

YANBU. Australia turned off old fashioned reliable copper landlines a few years ago. It’s all digital now. It’s stupid. No reliable way to phone for help or contact family in a bad storm or disaster that knocks out electricity supply and mobile phone communication towers. Landlines didn’t need electricity or towers.

Have a radio and keep a couple of batteries charged. Plus a ham license, of course.

Also, landlines do need electricity - it's just that they have lots of batteries at the exchange. I suspect that if you put a UPS on your router & fibre modem, you'd be fine.

Longtimelurkerfinallyposts · 15/11/2026 20:22

All these people saying "I haven't had a landline in years" are missing the point.
If there's a power cut then there's no guarantee that anyone's phones will work. Digital landlines need electricity to function; copper ones didn't.
Mobile phone masts need electricity to function.
Even if you have a power-bank or similar to charge your personal mobile handset, it won't be much good if the mast doesn't have power...
This switchover just makes the entire country more vulnerable in the case of extreme weather/ any power outages that affect the national grid. Not everything has a huge battery or generator back-up.

Elbowpatch · 15/11/2026 20:25

Digital landlines need electricity to function; copper ones didn't.

They did, but the supply was independent of the national grid.

Moros · 15/11/2026 23:39

Elbowpatch · 15/11/2026 20:25

Digital landlines need electricity to function; copper ones didn't.

They did, but the supply was independent of the national grid.

Yup. Local exchanges have battery backup that die after a few hours. Once those batteries run down then you'll lose both analogue and digital phone services.

Central exchanges have battery and generator backup that will last as long as they can get tankers in to keep the diesel supplies topped up. In a localised power outage then that's pretty much indefinitely. In a widespread power outage then that will get much harder.

Swipe left for the next trending thread