Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Benefits boundary at age 25

228 replies

TrappedByThisDesk · 13/11/2026 09:21

AIBU to think that any benefit which has an age threshold or boundary of age 25 is just wrong?
You are an adult at 18, but might be in college until 19 if you repeat a year. Or you might go to uni, so still not launched into 'adult life' until age 21, lets be generous and add in a gap year, so your adult life should start at age 22 at the very latest.
So where is the logic in assuming you don't need full adult benefits until age 25? Behind it is the assumption that you have family to prop you up and subsidise you until then.

I seem to recall the age 25 thing was brought in under Thatcher, with regard to paying B&B accommodation for homeless jobless young adults. It was restricted to only two weeks in any one location. Happy to be corrected if it was introduced before that.

Since then, there seems to be a default assumption that is it fine to treat adults age 22, 23, and 24 as if they were not "proper adults" with regards to benefits.

OP posts:
ChronicallyDisbelieved · 14/11/2026 14:39

Pandersmum · 14/11/2026 14:34

The problem is the country cannot afford to sustain the current welfare bill.
it is not ok that young people who could work are funded by the state to a better level than if they are working.
Who is going to pay the taxes to pay the benefit bill in 10/20 years time?

The welfare state should support those that genuinely need it, and arguably they should be supported to a higher level than current.

So changes need to be made and so young people who had planned a life with benefit support will need to have a re-think.

That said, I have no idea where the jobs are that they will all do.

You are assuming that all the 18-24 year olds on disability benefits can work - that is not the case. Some , with support may be able to but the vast majority I bet can’t. For those that can get a job with support, what if they struggle to get reasonable adjustments, or will employers even give them a chance in the first place?

Pandersmum · 14/11/2026 14:46

ChronicallyDisbelieved · 14/11/2026 14:39

You are assuming that all the 18-24 year olds on disability benefits can work - that is not the case. Some , with support may be able to but the vast majority I bet can’t. For those that can get a job with support, what if they struggle to get reasonable adjustments, or will employers even give them a chance in the first place?

Edited

No I am not. But some currently in receipt of benefits could work if they had no choice. The current safety net is too easy to access.

i have already stated that some current recipients should get more than current.

DisabilityCosts · 14/11/2026 14:52

There is no nuance to the current system. PIP is given for all sorts of random things, which has skewed it towards mental health issues rather than actual physical issues. You can have all sorts of daily struggles, physical disabilities, increased daily costs, but if you can wash and cook and hold a conversation you are deemed able. DD has an issues list as long as your arm, but because she is bloody minded doesn't qualify for any help. In fact what she gets is daily abuse for needing seats on trains and for using disabled toilets. She can't claim other benefits because she is straight out of uni. I am amazed how young adults can claim anything really.

Badbadbunny · 14/11/2026 14:54

Greenismyfavouritecolournow · 14/11/2026 13:25

Why don’t we vote on it? But you only get a vote if you don’t claim benefits ( perhaps exclude child benefit as most full time employed will still get that )
We do not pay it because we as a country can not afford to pay it. I mean it’s not a difficult concept. You cannot keep taking from the workers or they will stop working.

Nail on the head, but it's already happening - ever growing numbers of people "economically inactive". It's just not sustainable. We can't keep raising taxes on working people to pay benefits to those who don't.

Badbadbunny · 14/11/2026 14:57

ChronicallyDisbelieved · 14/11/2026 14:39

You are assuming that all the 18-24 year olds on disability benefits can work - that is not the case. Some , with support may be able to but the vast majority I bet can’t. For those that can get a job with support, what if they struggle to get reasonable adjustments, or will employers even give them a chance in the first place?

Edited

That's why the government need to "encourage" employers to take youngsters on. Whether that's grants, enhanced tax relief, non financial support, reducing red tape, or a mixture of those options. What they shouldn't have done was increase NMW for the youngest of workers, increase employers NIC, make it harder to dismiss staff, etc etc. - it's utter stupidity that it costs the employer exactly the same to employ a very young worker perhaps disabled, than it costs them to pay someone older, more experienced, without a disability.

TrappedByThisDesk · 14/11/2026 15:00

This thread is not about the benefits bill overall. It is about the age discrimination against under 25's, which is just morally wrong.

We should pay 18-24 year olds exactly the same as those over 25 who are in the same circumstances.
Or, at the very least go back to the previous age of majority of 21, and pay all 21, 22, 23, and 24 year olds the same as a 25 year old.

To fund this we need to cut or tax elsewhere.

OP posts:
Badbadbunny · 14/11/2026 15:01

Pandersmum · 14/11/2026 14:34

The problem is the country cannot afford to sustain the current welfare bill.
it is not ok that young people who could work are funded by the state to a better level than if they are working.
Who is going to pay the taxes to pay the benefit bill in 10/20 years time?

The welfare state should support those that genuinely need it, and arguably they should be supported to a higher level than current.

So changes need to be made and so young people who had planned a life with benefit support will need to have a re-think.

That said, I have no idea where the jobs are that they will all do.

Nail on the head. The current system is simply unaffordable. We can't increase taxes on working people any higher.

BooksAndHooks · 14/11/2026 15:03

oviraptor21 · 13/11/2026 11:41

Young people will still get UC, they just won't get the disability add ons unless severely disabled.

I'm not sure what is wrong with expecting an under 35 year old to live in a room in a shared house.

Housing allowance is not paid to claimants living in the parental home. If they want to pay "rent" to their parents then it comes out of their standard allowance.

Problem being PIP is not an out of work benefit, it is there to cover the extra costs of disability, those on PIP who currently work will lose that support and not be entitled to claim UC. Costs of disability are no less for those under 25 than those over.

pauseforthoughts · 14/11/2026 15:05

Pandersmum · 14/11/2026 14:46

No I am not. But some currently in receipt of benefits could work if they had no choice. The current safety net is too easy to access.

i have already stated that some current recipients should get more than current.

Sone could work yes but would you want to work with them?
When I was young I got a job in a pub and there was a girl I worked with that always messed up the orders, never managed to get the hang of the till and got drinks and mixers wrong and we spent so much time apologising to customers for her mistakes yet she was shown over and over and over and nothing sunk in.
She would even get muddled up with shifts and never knew what shift she was doing, forgot to do things and never had things she needed, nobody wanted to work with her and she was eventually fired.
I bumped into her some 10 years later and she had been diagnosed with adhd which made sense, she hadn’t been successful for pip and was looking for work but had had several jobs in the meantime but none of them have lasted past the probation period because she just wasn’t able to learn the job and what she was supposed to be doing, while I don’t agree benefits for all with adhd there are some people you just wouldn’t be able to work with yet they are deemed fit for work so are applying for jobs while not having to disclose their disabilities and then it’s a process of realising they can come to an interview and mask but they can’t do the job, they need to try their best to get the job though or be sanctioned.

TrappedByThisDesk · 14/11/2026 15:07

Badbadbunny · 14/11/2026 15:01

Nail on the head. The current system is simply unaffordable. We can't increase taxes on working people any higher.

There are plenty of alternatives to taxing working people (by which I assume you mean income tax).
Dividend tax, Capital Gains Tax, Corporation tax, and property taxes are the logical targets.

OP posts:
Badbadbunny · 14/11/2026 15:09

TrappedByThisDesk · 14/11/2026 15:07

There are plenty of alternatives to taxing working people (by which I assume you mean income tax).
Dividend tax, Capital Gains Tax, Corporation tax, and property taxes are the logical targets.

All of which have already been increased by several percentage points in recent years.

Fiscal drag is having a very detrimental impact on workers and lots of other people too. I saw some stats the other week saying that we now have the highest tax burden since just after WW2!

We can't keep taxing people more (working or otherwise) to increase the benefits bill.

LakieLady · 14/11/2026 15:11

DisabilityCosts · 14/11/2026 14:52

There is no nuance to the current system. PIP is given for all sorts of random things, which has skewed it towards mental health issues rather than actual physical issues. You can have all sorts of daily struggles, physical disabilities, increased daily costs, but if you can wash and cook and hold a conversation you are deemed able. DD has an issues list as long as your arm, but because she is bloody minded doesn't qualify for any help. In fact what she gets is daily abuse for needing seats on trains and for using disabled toilets. She can't claim other benefits because she is straight out of uni. I am amazed how young adults can claim anything really.

That really surprises me. Needing a seat on public transport and disabled toilets suggests to me that there's a good chance she would get lower rate mobility, at least.

It would be worth taking a look at the PIP descriptors and points PIP descriptors and points.

If there are any activities that she cannot complete "safely, to an acceptable standard, repeatedly and within a reasonable timescale"*, she would get points for that activity. The threshold for a standard rate award of either component of PIP is 8 points.

It would be worth her discussing this with a benefits adviser at CAB or similar. If there's a charity that supports people with her specific health condition, they're likely to have someone who really gets how her condition affects her.

*PIP regulation 4 (2)A

https://assets.ctfassets.net/vms0u05139aw/pip_descriptors.pdf/93820be60dcc6420191292ed56e2c95f/pip_descriptors.pdf

JustAnotherWhinger · 14/11/2026 15:15

Badbadbunny · 14/11/2026 14:57

That's why the government need to "encourage" employers to take youngsters on. Whether that's grants, enhanced tax relief, non financial support, reducing red tape, or a mixture of those options. What they shouldn't have done was increase NMW for the youngest of workers, increase employers NIC, make it harder to dismiss staff, etc etc. - it's utter stupidity that it costs the employer exactly the same to employ a very young worker perhaps disabled, than it costs them to pay someone older, more experienced, without a disability.

They should also practice what they preach about employers.

my DD is disabled and had a PT WFH job in the civil service. She started some new medication just before lockdowns and during lockdowns increased to FT. Two days a month in the office (that at the time was an 8 minute walk from our house).

Post covid the office had moved into the city and her two days a month was £250ish in taxis, but the difference between FT and PT meant it was well worth it (she used her PIP mobility for it).

They then decided that everyone had to be in 60% of the time. Despite her boss, her bosses boss and their boss agreeing that her work was perfectly fine they weren’t doing any adjustments for people so she could either accept it, drop back to PT (but the taxi cost wasn’t feasible) or quit. As well as the finances the travel time made it exhausting for her and they couldn’t guarantee she’d have somewhere to have a lunchtime nap (she naps for 20 mins every day at lunch).

The office she was meant to go into 3 days a week was a hit desking setup so not like being wfh meant she was missing out on team time. That only happened on the two days a month.

Thankfully her absolutely glowing references meant she has managed to find a new job and is FT (which means she claims no help with rent or anything, as she had to when PT). Her bosses boss actually lined her up an interview with a friend of hers. They said themselves that it made no sense but they weren’t allowed to allow her to WFH FT any longer. So short sighted.

If they won’t allow WFH then why would other companies make the efforts to allow it? She would have been caught up in this had changes happened sooner as she’s just turned 26.

TrappedByThisDesk · 14/11/2026 15:20

Badbadbunny · 14/11/2026 15:09

All of which have already been increased by several percentage points in recent years.

Fiscal drag is having a very detrimental impact on workers and lots of other people too. I saw some stats the other week saying that we now have the highest tax burden since just after WW2!

We can't keep taxing people more (working or otherwise) to increase the benefits bill.

So cut the benefits bill across the board, including pensioners. Just don't have this horrendous age discrimination built in to the system.

OP posts:
NightHeron · 14/11/2026 15:27

DisabilityCosts · 14/11/2026 14:52

There is no nuance to the current system. PIP is given for all sorts of random things, which has skewed it towards mental health issues rather than actual physical issues. You can have all sorts of daily struggles, physical disabilities, increased daily costs, but if you can wash and cook and hold a conversation you are deemed able. DD has an issues list as long as your arm, but because she is bloody minded doesn't qualify for any help. In fact what she gets is daily abuse for needing seats on trains and for using disabled toilets. She can't claim other benefits because she is straight out of uni. I am amazed how young adults can claim anything really.

What - you have no conception how people with learning disabilities, say non verbal and functioning at the level of a six month old baby, can’t get a job and need benefits to live on?

Noras · 14/11/2026 15:39

Shamwee · 14/11/2026 07:52

People with jobs still can get pip. Although it would be harder for someone with a wheelchair to get a job they wouldn’t be able to work really physical jobs so would be picking from a limited pool of jobs.

Its a shame PIP came under so much scrutiny because of people taking the piss with their adhd and anxiety

Ok here’s the wheel chair thing again!

You do realise that is your brain does not work properly it can hugely impede your ability to work.

Someone with severe receptive language and pragmatic language on below 1 percentile will struggle to get work in a cafe or charity shop and frankly neither will be at all keen on employing them even for free ( as a volunteer). There are always excuses.

HollyBerri · 14/11/2026 16:08

monkeysox · 13/11/2026 10:22

I think it's ridiculous that some young people are going and renting when they could be at home.
I think you are right though as young people without safety net of a supportive family are those who will suffer

Not all young people are choosing to rent. Not all young people have a loving supportive family. I support young people who have no choice. One young lad, horrific mental health but was turned down for pip gets £280 per month after his uc deductions.
His bills aren’t any less because he isn’t 25. This week he has no gas as he can’t afford to top to top it up so no heating in this weather. I got him a food bank parcel and asked what he usually did. He said he is used to going days without food due to the appalling childhood neglect.
The fact that his anxiety is so bad he barely leaves the house is why he can’t work either but he is trying.

monkeysox · 14/11/2026 16:09

HollyBerri · 14/11/2026 16:08

Not all young people are choosing to rent. Not all young people have a loving supportive family. I support young people who have no choice. One young lad, horrific mental health but was turned down for pip gets £280 per month after his uc deductions.
His bills aren’t any less because he isn’t 25. This week he has no gas as he can’t afford to top to top it up so no heating in this weather. I got him a food bank parcel and asked what he usually did. He said he is used to going days without food due to the appalling childhood neglect.
The fact that his anxiety is so bad he barely leaves the house is why he can’t work either but he is trying.

Yes circumstances vary a lot.

ChronicallyDisbelieved · 14/11/2026 16:10

Badbadbunny · 14/11/2026 14:57

That's why the government need to "encourage" employers to take youngsters on. Whether that's grants, enhanced tax relief, non financial support, reducing red tape, or a mixture of those options. What they shouldn't have done was increase NMW for the youngest of workers, increase employers NIC, make it harder to dismiss staff, etc etc. - it's utter stupidity that it costs the employer exactly the same to employ a very young worker perhaps disabled, than it costs them to pay someone older, more experienced, without a disability.

They need to get the support in place first and check it is fit for purpose before even thinking about PIP etc

Legolasses · 14/11/2026 16:23

The benefits system should be there for the people who need it the most regardless of their age.

Boomer55 · 14/11/2026 16:25

Shamwee · 13/11/2026 10:30

Because why should they get hundreds of pounds a month for those conditions? I lived in a hostel (shared kitchen, bathroom and living room) with a girl getting pip for “adhd” she had absolutely nothing wrong with her. Not at all hyperactive, had no difficulties paying attention, fully functioning ordinary human being. Then I also know multiple people getting pip for autism (the mild type where you’re just slightly quirky) if you multiply this across the entire country it’s a colossal money pit

That is the criteria the government says it wants to cut back on. They want to concentrate on physical disabilities.

Who knows how it will work?

Greenismyfavouritecolournow · 14/11/2026 16:35

TrappedByThisDesk · 14/11/2026 15:00

This thread is not about the benefits bill overall. It is about the age discrimination against under 25's, which is just morally wrong.

We should pay 18-24 year olds exactly the same as those over 25 who are in the same circumstances.
Or, at the very least go back to the previous age of majority of 21, and pay all 21, 22, 23, and 24 year olds the same as a 25 year old.

To fund this we need to cut or tax elsewhere.

No one would vote to pay more tax to fund young people to not work. You do realise how disillusioned you sound. Employers are already struggling to pay staff because of the increase in minimum wage etc.
What would you cut to raise the funds needed?

Greenismyfavouritecolournow · 14/11/2026 16:38

Benefits should be available for those who are mentally and physically disabled. Anxiety and depression are best treated with exercise, fresh air and being busy. I think more people with these conditions would continue to work if they didn’t have a choice. Is it any wonder high earners are reducing their hours? Why would they work more to hand more and more of it over to those who can’t get up the mornings?

TrappedByThisDesk · 14/11/2026 16:43

Greenismyfavouritecolournow · 14/11/2026 16:35

No one would vote to pay more tax to fund young people to not work. You do realise how disillusioned you sound. Employers are already struggling to pay staff because of the increase in minimum wage etc.
What would you cut to raise the funds needed?

Anything.

OP posts:
NeverDropYourMooncup · 14/11/2026 16:47

TrappedByThisDesk · 13/11/2026 11:14

But the reality is that they won't take 'any job possible to survive', they will just be supported by their parents. My objection is that the state is not recognising them as 'proper' adults, independent of their parents even though they lodge in the family home.
There are already rules about how much housing allowance you get for where you live: if you are living with your parents you get a much lower rate than if you managed to move out and have rent to pay to a landlord (e.g. you moved out before you lost your job). This is perfectly sensible.

The policy is not about preventing a journey of reliance on the state, because the rule about a 24 year old getting a lower rate would still apply even if they had already moved out age 18 and been working for 5 or 6 years before losing their job.
It is using age discrimination to save money, and the government dressing it up as 'helping young people be independent' is bullshit.

And how can anyone justify the age boundary at age 35 for shared housing?

I reckon whoever came up with that was watching Friends of a Saturday evening and had this image of everybody living together happily ever after in a massive apartment until they got married to somebody in the next flat along.