Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Benefits boundary at age 25

228 replies

TrappedByThisDesk · 13/11/2026 09:21

AIBU to think that any benefit which has an age threshold or boundary of age 25 is just wrong?
You are an adult at 18, but might be in college until 19 if you repeat a year. Or you might go to uni, so still not launched into 'adult life' until age 21, lets be generous and add in a gap year, so your adult life should start at age 22 at the very latest.
So where is the logic in assuming you don't need full adult benefits until age 25? Behind it is the assumption that you have family to prop you up and subsidise you until then.

I seem to recall the age 25 thing was brought in under Thatcher, with regard to paying B&B accommodation for homeless jobless young adults. It was restricted to only two weeks in any one location. Happy to be corrected if it was introduced before that.

Since then, there seems to be a default assumption that is it fine to treat adults age 22, 23, and 24 as if they were not "proper adults" with regards to benefits.

OP posts:
Shamwee · 14/11/2026 11:33

LookToYou · 14/11/2026 11:10

Someone with ADHD can need it and they can’t do anything to not have ADHD. They have no choice.

People don’t have to have babies that they don’t have the money to look after. They have a choice to not have sex, use contraception, have an abortion or wait until they can afford a child. They have a choice.

I wouldn’t see a 16 year old parent left without enough money, but for you to argue for money for 16 year old girls to have babies and yet people with conditions like ADHD not to get it is sickening.

You sound completely ignorant about the impact ADHD can have on someone’s life, but that doesn’t surprise me.

Edited

They don’t need hundreds of pounds a month because of adhd, yes there are conditions where people should get pip but adhd is not one of them.

I was 15 when I got pregnant probably not a responsible life choice but did you make perfect choices at 15?
You can’t compare young parents and their babies to someone with adhd this is not a serious argument. Most of the symptoms of adhd are just a continuum of things everyone does to some extent anyway

LookToYou · 14/11/2026 11:38

Shamwee · 14/11/2026 11:33

They don’t need hundreds of pounds a month because of adhd, yes there are conditions where people should get pip but adhd is not one of them.

I was 15 when I got pregnant probably not a responsible life choice but did you make perfect choices at 15?
You can’t compare young parents and their babies to someone with adhd this is not a serious argument. Most of the symptoms of adhd are just a continuum of things everyone does to some extent anyway

You sound very ignorant and uneducated, but that isn’t surprising.

Mumsnet said they had a ND troll. Are they back? 🧐

x2boys · 14/11/2026 11:39

Shamwee · 14/11/2026 09:05

your own detailed written form and assessment interview are valid evidence. You can literally put into ChatGPT why would someone with adhd need pip and get all the reasons.

You need evidence from professionals too.

x2boys · 14/11/2026 11:41

Shamwee · 14/11/2026 09:05

your own detailed written form and assessment interview are valid evidence. You can literally put into ChatGPT why would someone with adhd need pip and get all the reasons.

A diagnosis of ADHD does not gurantee a PIP award it goes off need
ADHD can also have other co morbid conditions along side them.

Shamwee · 14/11/2026 11:46

LookToYou · 14/11/2026 11:38

You sound very ignorant and uneducated, but that isn’t surprising.

Mumsnet said they had a ND troll. Are they back? 🧐

Not me, you can’t just “everyone who disagrees with me is a troll”

Badbadbunny · 14/11/2026 11:52

bababamama · 14/11/2026 09:11

@TrappedByThisDesk the logic for shared housing is based on the fact that many if not most young people live in shared housing, young people working in jobs paying £50k a year plus who have studied (taking on debt) work 40 hours + a week and contributing taxes still can only afford a room in a shared house at 30. Why should people not working get a whole flat?

Nail on the head. That's my DS. He is working full time in a professional job and can only afford a crappy small basement bedroom in a shared house with shared kitchen and bathroom. Completely unfair that some non working people (for whatever reason) have their own flat and facilities.

LookToYou · 14/11/2026 12:02

Shamwee · 14/11/2026 11:46

Not me, you can’t just “everyone who disagrees with me is a troll”

When someone is talking nonsense, they are either uneducated/ignorant regarding the subject, a troll, or potentially both.

Some people with ADHD won’t need much extra support, some will, and that support may need to be financial. They don’t get a choice in having ADHD or how badly it impacts them. You had a choice to have a baby at 16.

I’m happy for tax to pay for both someone needing it for ADHD or 16 year olds making irresponsible choices of having babies they can’t support and I pay a lot more tax than most people.

I’ve learnt in life that things aren’t black and white. I am presuming you are still quite young so hopefully more life experience will make you more understanding.

BooHissScarySeason · 14/11/2026 12:28

I don’t like the going after a particular diagnosis either it seems a bit tabloid although times does it too, but Milburn is entirely correct to shift the narrative to finding what you can do rather than expectations of benefits especially when young.

we have mismanaged the ND message around disability and work when we started to see big increases in diagnosis rates and the support into work has been insufficient.

Jimmyneutronsforehead · 14/11/2026 12:42

Shamwee · 13/11/2026 10:30

Because why should they get hundreds of pounds a month for those conditions? I lived in a hostel (shared kitchen, bathroom and living room) with a girl getting pip for “adhd” she had absolutely nothing wrong with her. Not at all hyperactive, had no difficulties paying attention, fully functioning ordinary human being. Then I also know multiple people getting pip for autism (the mild type where you’re just slightly quirky) if you multiply this across the entire country it’s a colossal money pit

So report them if you think they're claiming fraudulently

Greenismyfavouritecolournow · 14/11/2026 13:11

Shamwee · 13/11/2026 09:49

I had my dc at 16 and moved out at the same time and I remember finding out people over 25 were getting a lot more UC than me. Which felt like a very high age.
Another thing that seems unfair is university loans am I right in thinking they assume everyone’s parents are helping their adult child and give less money based on parents income?
The whole thing is weighted towards assume everyone’s parents are bankrolling them.

PIP should have been ended for anyone with adhd, anxiety etc. but they didn’t have the balls to do that so now a 24 year old in a wheelchair won’t get it but a 26 year old with “adhd” will

At 16 you hadn’t paid anything in so why would you assume you would her the same out as someone 9 years older ?

Greenismyfavouritecolournow · 14/11/2026 13:12

I agree with it. No vendors until you’ve paid into the system. Unless you are disabled and unable to work.

Greenismyfavouritecolournow · 14/11/2026 13:12

Benefits

Greenismyfavouritecolournow · 14/11/2026 13:15

TrappedByThisDesk · 13/11/2026 10:28

I think young people should be helped to move out of their parents' home. It is not good for young adults to be trapped into an extended period of feeling like overgrown teenagers, dependent on their parents, when they need to be making their own way in the world.

Do 24 year olds get a lower rate of housing benefit than 25 year olds? I don't know the details of how housing benefit or UC housing element work.

I disagree. Young people should stay at home until they can financially afford to pay your own rent and support themselves. They live in a house share like we did 30 years ago.

Greenismyfavouritecolournow · 14/11/2026 13:25

TrappedByThisDesk · 13/11/2026 16:08

I couldn't disagree more.
Society should be treating 18 year olds as adults, and treating them as fully financially independent from their parents (from the end of the term after they finish full time education after their 18th birthday, i.e. after they finish A' levels or whatever course at college or sixth form, which is what I believe the child benefit rules are now - happy to be corrected).

It is absolutely damaging to the growth and mental health of young adults to infantilise them and force them to remain dependent on their parents long after they should have flown the nest.
We should be fixing the housing and employment issues, not just throwing our hands up and saying 'we can't afford it, your parents will have to fund you'.

And if we can't currently afford to treat 18-24 year olds as adults, then something else has to be cut or taxed so that we can afford it.

Why don’t we vote on it? But you only get a vote if you don’t claim benefits ( perhaps exclude child benefit as most full time employed will still get that )
We do not pay it because we as a country can not afford to pay it. I mean it’s not a difficult concept. You cannot keep taking from the workers or they will stop working.

LakieLady · 14/11/2026 13:48

PIP should have been ended for anyone with adhd, anxiety etc. but they didn’t have the balls to do that so now a 24 year old in a wheelchair won’t get it but a 26 year old with “adhd” will

I'd love you to meet my friend's 18 year old son @Shamwee, but you never will because his "anxiety" is so severe that he finds it impossible to stay in the same room as anyone he doesn't know well. He's autistic and has diagnoses of ADHD, PTSD and general anxiety disorder, all diagnosed by a CAMHS consultant psychiatrist, but only after spending 5 years on the waiting list.

He's been out of school entirely since he was 13, and was only going intermittently since he started secondary. He was so badly bullied by another child on the school bus that he would be violently sick every schoolday morning, so friend had to drive him there. Even then, if he saw his bully he would go white and start to shake. He visibly blanches and looks terrified when someone knocks at their door, and runs to his room.

Friend has to make sure that if a workman or anyone has to come to her home, she has plenty of notice to prepare him, and and gets them to ring her 15 minutes before they arrive, so that he has time to hide himself away. When she goes out, she can only leave him for 3-4 hours max before he starts to get distressed, she has to let him know what time she will be back by, and if she's delayed and doesn't ring him, he starts to freak out. He is terrified of her dying and had a real setback when she had a potential cancer scare a couple of years ago.

MH services have been useless. He uses his PIP to pay for psychotherapy, and is starting to show slight improvement. She gets carer's allowance and UC.

If his PIP was stopped, she'd lose her entitlement to carer's allowance and would have to get a job. I can't imagine what would happen to him then, I suspect he would end up in hospital.

I've known this young man since he was 6. It was obvious then that he had significant issues, but it took 3 years to get a CAMHS referral and a further 5 just to get assessed. He was on the waiting list for a specific therapy for PTSD (EMDR, iirc), but reached the age limit where his case had to be transferred to adult MH services. He's had no input from them.

He has been badly failed by the education system and by NHS MH services, and now people want to take the money that pays for his therapy from him. He's already been fucked over by the "bedroom tax" which meant that they could no longer afford the rent on the rural home he had lived in for years and had to move into a sink estate in a town, which triggered a significant deterioration in his MH.

I worked with clients with MH issues for 18 years, and have known many a young person fucked over in this sort of way, albeit not as badly as he is. Society has failed them terribly.

FeelingOldOldOld · 14/11/2026 13:52

SoSoLong · 13/11/2026 15:50

It literally discriminates based on your birthdate. You can get it at 67, but not at 66. Regardless of how many years of NI contributions you've got, as long as it's more than 10. It's literally a made up threshold based on age, with no other basis than the financial cost to the state.

State pension age was not designed to be arbitrary. I was once talking to a pensions specialist, who told me that when the state pension was first set up, it was designed around the assumption that people would only live for x number of years after they starting taking it (so it was very much originally designed in terms of how much it would cost overall, in terms of the average life expectancy at the time, as life expectancy was much shorter in those days). He said that if the same calculations were made now, state pension age would be when someone was in their early 90s… (as it was originally anticipated that someone would only be on state pension for maybe a few years before they died, and many would have died before reaching state pension age).

As people are now living so long, they can be on state pension for 20+ years, something that was not planned for when it was first introduced.

LakieLady · 14/11/2026 14:03

oscarthethird · 13/11/2026 12:00

Why do you need extra money for ADHD? What about the condition costs more?

In the case of a former client of mine, repairing the damage to their home after they got distracted while they had something on the stove, went out, and had a kitchen fire!

ChronicallyDisbelieved · 14/11/2026 14:03

LakieLady · 14/11/2026 13:48

PIP should have been ended for anyone with adhd, anxiety etc. but they didn’t have the balls to do that so now a 24 year old in a wheelchair won’t get it but a 26 year old with “adhd” will

I'd love you to meet my friend's 18 year old son @Shamwee, but you never will because his "anxiety" is so severe that he finds it impossible to stay in the same room as anyone he doesn't know well. He's autistic and has diagnoses of ADHD, PTSD and general anxiety disorder, all diagnosed by a CAMHS consultant psychiatrist, but only after spending 5 years on the waiting list.

He's been out of school entirely since he was 13, and was only going intermittently since he started secondary. He was so badly bullied by another child on the school bus that he would be violently sick every schoolday morning, so friend had to drive him there. Even then, if he saw his bully he would go white and start to shake. He visibly blanches and looks terrified when someone knocks at their door, and runs to his room.

Friend has to make sure that if a workman or anyone has to come to her home, she has plenty of notice to prepare him, and and gets them to ring her 15 minutes before they arrive, so that he has time to hide himself away. When she goes out, she can only leave him for 3-4 hours max before he starts to get distressed, she has to let him know what time she will be back by, and if she's delayed and doesn't ring him, he starts to freak out. He is terrified of her dying and had a real setback when she had a potential cancer scare a couple of years ago.

MH services have been useless. He uses his PIP to pay for psychotherapy, and is starting to show slight improvement. She gets carer's allowance and UC.

If his PIP was stopped, she'd lose her entitlement to carer's allowance and would have to get a job. I can't imagine what would happen to him then, I suspect he would end up in hospital.

I've known this young man since he was 6. It was obvious then that he had significant issues, but it took 3 years to get a CAMHS referral and a further 5 just to get assessed. He was on the waiting list for a specific therapy for PTSD (EMDR, iirc), but reached the age limit where his case had to be transferred to adult MH services. He's had no input from them.

He has been badly failed by the education system and by NHS MH services, and now people want to take the money that pays for his therapy from him. He's already been fucked over by the "bedroom tax" which meant that they could no longer afford the rent on the rural home he had lived in for years and had to move into a sink estate in a town, which triggered a significant deterioration in his MH.

I worked with clients with MH issues for 18 years, and have known many a young person fucked over in this sort of way, albeit not as badly as he is. Society has failed them terribly.

So accurate and so sad.

The government should forget this absolute nonsense and instead focus on an overhaul of MH support . Sort out CAMHS, sort out earlier diagnosis and intervention in schools. Not just taking away PIP for a whole group of society. It’s wrong and cruel.

oscarthethird · 14/11/2026 14:13

LakieLady · 14/11/2026 14:03

In the case of a former client of mine, repairing the damage to their home after they got distracted while they had something on the stove, went out, and had a kitchen fire!

Why wouldn’t insurance pay for that?

LakieLady · 14/11/2026 14:26

SickofScapegoats · 13/11/2026 23:11

If a young adult loses their PIP, then their carer (parent) loses their carer's allowance.. which means they can no longer care for their own child because they are expected to work.
If that child in on high rate of mobility and has a car to get them about to appointments etc, they will lose that too

So, disabled person loses money to live, and is expected to look for work. Their carer parent is also expected to care for them AND look for work. If they had a car, it is now gone, and that car could have been the reason they had a job to start with.

How does any of this make sense?

I've seen almost exactly that happen IRL. The parent's work coach was very understanding and didn't lean on them to get a job, and their housing officer was very understanding about the build up of rent arrears.

I did an appeal for the PIP, which succeeded (albeit after a year's wait), then all the other benefits that they would have got if the PIP had been awarded initially were reinstated and the arrears payments were massive. The project I worked on kept a spreadsheet of all the appeal outcomes, and it was still the biggest financial gain on it when I retired 3 years later.

LakieLady · 14/11/2026 14:30

oscarthethird · 14/11/2026 14:13

Why wouldn’t insurance pay for that?

They didn't have insurance. Very few clients of mine did, and their premiums were often higher than an owner-occupier would pay (I suspect this might be the case for social housing generally), so affordability was an issue.

pauseforthoughts · 14/11/2026 14:34

Greenismyfavouritecolournow · 14/11/2026 13:15

I disagree. Young people should stay at home until they can financially afford to pay your own rent and support themselves. They live in a house share like we did 30 years ago.

And what if their parent relied on benefits for them and that stopped when they were 16 or 18 or whenever it stops?
Some parents simply cannot afford to fund another adult once they stop getting the money and they are not contributing or covering their expenses.
Maybe they didn’t envision having to or want to, what if they have younger children and they are having to spread their family money over another adult or adults.

I can’t find it now but there was a thread a while back where the parents couldn’t have their adult son move back home as he wasn’t working and it would affect their housing benefit if another adult lived there pushing them into hardship on top of having another mouth to feed but the alternative was he was facing homelessness as he couldn’t get housing benefit to cover his room.

Not to mention adult children and parents relationships being strained because of the dynamics of an adult living at home with zero independence, I know I would find it very difficult to live with my parents as an adult, and not all people be that the parent or adult child are always easy to live with and a lot of parents will be wanting their lives back once their kids are grown up.
Maybe they don’t have very nice parents and for one reason or another it’s not possible to live at home or any amount of scenarios.

Surely a job should be a way out if it meets the minimum wage and is full time.

Pandersmum · 14/11/2026 14:34

The problem is the country cannot afford to sustain the current welfare bill.
it is not ok that young people who could work are funded by the state to a better level than if they are working.
Who is going to pay the taxes to pay the benefit bill in 10/20 years time?

The welfare state should support those that genuinely need it, and arguably they should be supported to a higher level than current.

So changes need to be made and so young people who had planned a life with benefit support will need to have a re-think.

That said, I have no idea where the jobs are that they will all do.

TrappedByThisDesk · 14/11/2026 14:34

bababamama · 14/11/2026 09:11

@TrappedByThisDesk the logic for shared housing is based on the fact that many if not most young people live in shared housing, young people working in jobs paying £50k a year plus who have studied (taking on debt) work 40 hours + a week and contributing taxes still can only afford a room in a shared house at 30. Why should people not working get a whole flat?

Why should people over 35 and not working get a whole flat?
The cut off at 35 is arbitrary and should be scrapped.

OP posts:
LakieLady · 14/11/2026 14:39

Ott3r · 14/11/2026 07:29

It is hugely hard to get PIP just for ADHD. My daughter has ADHD but like many she also has a list of other conditions with high support needs.

I couldn't imagine how many PIP applications I've done over the years, and I'm pretty sure I've never got PIP where ADHD was the only relevant health condition.