Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Not supplying my brother and SIL with breastmilk

363 replies

Seloos · 12/11/2026 09:47

My DB and SIL are great sharers of information, and so if you don’t share they just assume everything is easy or alright for you. So the whole family heard about their fertility struggles - absolutely fine to share, but when I announced my pregnancy I was told I was lucky I had it so easy- even though they had no idea.

Now some might disagree but I say breastfeeding is tough. It needs a bit of determination, in the early days I was sore and tired but as it is baby is 6 months and still EBF. I am proud of this but never told anyone how hard I found it.

My SIL has just given birth to her second and after not BF her first really wants this one to be EBF, I had a call from my DB last night saying she is very tired and can I pump a couple of bottles for them… as if I can just produce a couple of bottles on cue!!!

I don’t even have a pump- he said they could Amazon me one.

Am I being unreasonable to say no? My parents and brother are saying I would find it easy and she is struggling and don’t I want what is best for the baby.

Im only just starting to feel I am on the downward slope with feeding after months or gritting my teeth and getting on with it.

OP posts:
Dancingintherain09 · 12/11/2026 20:58

Just explain you dont have a over supply. You are just producing enough for your child. If you pump your baby goes hungry or if you try to pump after there's nothing.

The women who donate are the ones that have over supply. (I was one of those) with my ds2.

With my first Was a different story, I tried to pump spare but had nothing after DS was fed or in between. I wanted spare so husband could do a night feed if needed.

Maybe tell your brother youve tried expressing before but you dont have a spare supply after DC has been fed. He can't expect your child to starve to feed his.

Scottishskifun · 12/11/2026 20:59

Seloos · 12/11/2026 13:37

Thanks everyone.

I think part of the problem was they were given some donated milk early on in the hospital, so that has normalised the idea of donating to them so they think if they can find their own donor they can carry on. My brother says it’s unfair my baby is EBF and theirs won’t be.

Your brother is showing complete contempt and lack of understanding with how bf and pumping works!

Your SIL is way better getting a hakaa and feeding on one side using the hakaa on the other especially in the mornings to build up a stash. If she is having supply issues and baby is dropping weight then she needs to speak to the infant feeding team. She may need to go onto a feeding plan which is gruelling (been there) but it's what she needs to establish supply. She will get stuck in a low supply loop otherwise for weeks.

It's not about being unfair on the baby it's about establishing supply and you not being a surrogate feeding option!

Genevieva · 12/11/2026 20:59

This is so far beyond the boundaries of acceptable behaviour that it initially left me speechless. You will obviously say no. No, you don’t pump and have no intention of pumping. No, you don’t have the time or supply. No, you are not their own private dairy cow. No no no… People like this are so tone deaf you will no doubt offend them when they don’t get their way, but unfortunately you can’t control that.

Thereshewasjustwalkingdownthestreet · 12/11/2026 21:01

Wtf! There’s nothing wrong with formula so if they’re happy to give baby something else that isn’t her own milk, they can buy it! Cheeky fucks!

YourWildAmberSloth · 12/11/2026 21:07

If she can't breastfeed then they'll have to switch to formula. You're not a wet nurse. It is not your problem to fix, she should discuss her difficulties with her health visitor.

Genevieva · 12/11/2026 21:08

Seloos · 12/11/2026 14:27

No, they offered the pump. I said I didn’t even have one as part of my reasons why I couldn’t do it, and he said he could get me one by tomorrow. I think that’s the issue, he doesn’t see it as “costing” me anything, or doing anything I’m not already. But there’s a big difference between feeding one baby and 2!!
As others have said also if my SIL doesn’t establish a supply I can see this going on for weeks

She won’t establish a supply if they are supplementing already. They need to give it a shot and, if it doesn’t work out, use formula. They’ve used it before. They know babies can thrive on it. Bottle feeding breast milk won’t give the mother and baby an equivalent experience of breastfeeding, so they need to accept reality and be grateful for all the advances of the modern world that keep mothers and babies alive and well.

birdglasspen2 · 12/11/2026 21:13

What nonsense. Breast feeding can be easy and it can be hard and it has little to do with the mother and lots to do with the baby!
If she wants to BF she has to get the right support in place, there are people out there who can help.
it can be sore and miserable
for weeks and then improve. It can be easy from day one and it can be very difficult even on a 3rd plus baby as they are all different!
There are specialists that check for tongue tie.
Ive BF and I’ve pumped milk and I think once your milk supply settles down for your own Baby you are unlikely to easily pump etc. If you pump a lot and supply isn’t settled then yes you possibly could and some woman produce a lot. But the chance of you being able to is very slim and pumping as well as BF is incredibly difficult.

OP you’re correct it’s hard (although once established (one took me 3 months!) it’s easier in my mind than a bottle. But it can take a lot of determination and perservence and I know I’m fortunate that the hardest one came last as if he was first I probably
would have gave up on the advice of those around me. But number one took 6 weeks of dressing every feed and struggling.

Just say no and maybe share your issues more don’t make it all look easy when it’s not!

UnintentionalArcher · 12/11/2026 21:17

Seloos · 12/11/2026 14:27

No, they offered the pump. I said I didn’t even have one as part of my reasons why I couldn’t do it, and he said he could get me one by tomorrow. I think that’s the issue, he doesn’t see it as “costing” me anything, or doing anything I’m not already. But there’s a big difference between feeding one baby and 2!!
As others have said also if my SIL doesn’t establish a supply I can see this going on for weeks

Purely from a practical perspective, I think you would be of no use to them on an ongoing basis. Maybe you could express a bottle’s worth here and there, but you couldn’t possibly do this frequently enough to be of meaningful benefit to them without messing with your supply and potentially causing feeding issues for your baby. And that’s assuming that your supply would even be good enough to let you make extra.

The expectation isn’t fair or reasonable. If you had a massive oversupply and offered then that would be different. But even then, I’m not sure your milk is the ideal option for another baby. There are so many reasons this is a bad idea.

Strawberrydelight78 · 12/11/2026 21:35

Your not a cow ffs tell them pissoff.

ReadingSoManyThreads · 12/11/2026 21:37

I'd be replying with factual information, things such as:

Whilst your milk would help babies in dire need, it doesn't have the composition of nutrients and antibodies that your newborn baby needs.

If you start supplementing with donor milk or formula now, it's going to be even harder to establish a breastmilk supply/breastfeeding. I'd state how hard it is (for many of us) to begin with and that the first 6 weeks of establishing breastfeeding and sleep deprivation is just horrendous, but it's something they need to push through, as all new mothers go through it.

Then say you found it really difficult yourself in the early days, and with the right support SIL can get through it.

Then I'd suggest she sees a breastfeeding support volunteer ASAP to help.

Ethelspagetti · 12/11/2026 21:38

Terrible idea. I’d message back saying, I find breast feeding very hard work too. I cannot pump as it would make me produce too much and would feel painful and engorged. Sil can top up with formula milk for in between feeds, lots of mums do this.

Missohnoyoubetterdont · 12/11/2026 21:42

I think your brother is a huge problem. I hope he’s not making his wife feel like a complete failure. Entitled! Never heard the like.

Thatsalineallright · 12/11/2026 21:50

Seloos · 12/11/2026 14:27

No, they offered the pump. I said I didn’t even have one as part of my reasons why I couldn’t do it, and he said he could get me one by tomorrow. I think that’s the issue, he doesn’t see it as “costing” me anything, or doing anything I’m not already. But there’s a big difference between feeding one baby and 2!!
As others have said also if my SIL doesn’t establish a supply I can see this going on for weeks

Wow, what an idiot your db is.

His wife is finding bf so hard that she doesn't want to feed any baby. But you should find it easy to feed 2???

I happily bf my DC (after a very rocky start) but always hated pumping with a passion. It's so lifeless and utterly boring. Even with those hands free pumps that fit in your bra, it's uncomfortable and you can't bend down or move freely.

He's asking you to give up your time, comfort, energy, and food for your own baby just so that they don't have to use formula. What utter cheek to even think of asking!

Thatsalineallright · 12/11/2026 21:50

You know what, I think you should send him and your parents a link to this thread. It might bring them back to reality.

KookyPlumPanda · 12/11/2026 21:55

it takes time to establish supply… i only had enough to supply for my baby, can you say you don’t have enough supply for your baby and theirs too? it is an odd request…

CatSquirrelDuck · 12/11/2026 21:59

I would probably be giving your brother and mum short shrift on tis one. Imagine asking a mother of a 6 month old that has been EBF through much effort and lack of sleep herself ... to 'just pump a few bottles of milk' for a mum who has just had her second baby yet who can't be arsed to BF herself because she's 'tired' and wants another new mother to sort her.

Fuck her. Fuck your brother. Say no and hang up and don't engage with them any further until they apologise for their fucking audacity.

CatSquirrelDuck · 12/11/2026 22:00

Seloos · 12/11/2026 13:37

Thanks everyone.

I think part of the problem was they were given some donated milk early on in the hospital, so that has normalised the idea of donating to them so they think if they can find their own donor they can carry on. My brother says it’s unfair my baby is EBF and theirs won’t be.

Tell hi to fuck off. He wasn't so worried about his first baby now was he?

JustSawJohnny · 12/11/2026 22:06

DB - It seems that somehow people have got the impression that I find breast feeding easy. I don't. It's painful and relentless and I just do not have the capacity to produce enough milk for another child. I would very much appreciate you calling off the family dogs on this one because I am not being unreasonable in any way and I will not be bullied over it or guilted into doing it. I have sympathy for DSIL as I know how tiring and difficult it is, especially in the beginning. If she wants any advice I can give it but I will not be pushing myself to produce enough milk for a 6 month old and a newborn. Please don't ask again.

I'd go with something like this BUT I'd actually want to say what @gamerchick said!

KTheGrey · 12/11/2026 22:08

Seloos · 12/11/2026 13:37

Thanks everyone.

I think part of the problem was they were given some donated milk early on in the hospital, so that has normalised the idea of donating to them so they think if they can find their own donor they can carry on. My brother says it’s unfair my baby is EBF and theirs won’t be.

Is it not unfair their first baby wasn’t EBF?

Ohnobackagain · 12/11/2026 22:12

Tulipsriver · 12/11/2026 09:51

I would reply honestly:

"Hi DB, I'm sorry SIL is struggling. I know I don't share very much but I have found breastfeeding very taxing, both emotionally and physically myself. I'm happy to give her some tips but I can't give you any milk. Unfortunately I only have the supply and energy to feed my own baby".

This @Seloos

Besidemyselfwithworry · 12/11/2026 22:14

Seloos · 12/11/2026 09:47

My DB and SIL are great sharers of information, and so if you don’t share they just assume everything is easy or alright for you. So the whole family heard about their fertility struggles - absolutely fine to share, but when I announced my pregnancy I was told I was lucky I had it so easy- even though they had no idea.

Now some might disagree but I say breastfeeding is tough. It needs a bit of determination, in the early days I was sore and tired but as it is baby is 6 months and still EBF. I am proud of this but never told anyone how hard I found it.

My SIL has just given birth to her second and after not BF her first really wants this one to be EBF, I had a call from my DB last night saying she is very tired and can I pump a couple of bottles for them… as if I can just produce a couple of bottles on cue!!!

I don’t even have a pump- he said they could Amazon me one.

Am I being unreasonable to say no? My parents and brother are saying I would find it easy and she is struggling and don’t I want what is best for the baby.

Im only just starting to feel I am on the downward slope with feeding after months or gritting my teeth and getting on with it.

Jesus Christ this is beyond weird!
if she can manage to breastfeed then her baby needs to go on formula
end of

OVienna · 12/11/2026 22:17

"No, Dbro, and have you COMPLETELY LOST IT."

Cherryicecreamx · 12/11/2026 22:27

I'm currently breastfeeding and if someone asked me this, I would also say no because I am so aware that it's training your body to produce more milk as your body thinks the baby needs more! It would make me feel like I'm tricking my own body and it can lead to over supply.

Bamboozledbylife · 12/11/2026 22:28

WTF. People really are batshit crazy aren't they. I could not pump to save my life. I'd sit for an hour and get 1oz if I was lucky. Tell them to sod off. If baby is hungry combi feed, not demand you start producing milk for them. You're not Daisy the bloody cow!

TempestTost · 12/11/2026 22:34

AngelinaFibres · 12/11/2026 10:03

I thought too. Mine are in their 30s but I seem to remember that breast milk changes according to YOUR babies needs. Not the needs of other people's babies

It does, but it's still not as different as formula.