Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Milburn review and benefits for 18-24 year olds

1000 replies

ReviewAlternatives · 12/11/2026 07:11

I was just reading about this and have some concerns.

I think a better idea initially would be rather than sinking probably millions into setting a new scheme up the government should be putting that money into CAMHS.

I can see the review mentions support for ‘mild’ ADHD, autism and anxiety but that’s not enough. The whole CAMHS system needs the overhaul and only then with a fit for purpose system should benefit reforms for 18-24 year olds be looked at. To act immediately and include existing claimants is wrong.

AIBU to think this will not work unless they do things the correct way - intensive CAMHS reform initially not during or part of and limited to just ‘mild’ cases of certain issues?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
9
BeLemonMoose · 13/11/2026 22:57

XenoBitch · 13/11/2026 20:52

The "ordinary taxpayer" is one illness/accident away from being the "less able".

I agree with @WhitegreeNcandle many of those working and paying taxes are chronically ill or disabled. It's not a them and us situation. There are young people on benefits claiming they are too ill to work while older people with the same conditions are working full time.

XenoBitch · 13/11/2026 23:02

BeLemonMoose · 13/11/2026 22:57

I agree with @WhitegreeNcandle many of those working and paying taxes are chronically ill or disabled. It's not a them and us situation. There are young people on benefits claiming they are too ill to work while older people with the same conditions are working full time.

Then why make it a competition between those who are disabled who can work, and those who are disabled and cant work?
Who benefits from this fighting? No one.

Ott3r · 13/11/2026 23:05

WhitegreeNcandle · 13/11/2026 21:49

Something I see a lot in our workplace is that people who are now in their 60’s are very frustrated by the 20 year old version of them getting benefits.

Im no medical expert but id eat my hat if the older ones don’t have the same conditions as the younger ones. But they managed to hold down jobs and provide for families and the resentment building up is a a pressure cooker in society

You wish.

My husband is in his 60s and our parents in their 80s. These generations recognise how much harder it is for younger generations as highlighted by Fogarty.

Apotofrealcoffee · 14/11/2026 01:45

XenoBitch · 13/11/2026 23:02

Then why make it a competition between those who are disabled who can work, and those who are disabled and cant work?
Who benefits from this fighting? No one.

Disabled people are allowed opinions. Even ones you don’t really like.

WhitegreeNcandle · 14/11/2026 06:27

Ott3r · 13/11/2026 23:05

You wish.

My husband is in his 60s and our parents in their 80s. These generations recognise how much harder it is for younger generations as highlighted by Fogarty.

I don’t wish. I see. We manage the very very tiny adjustments that the younger staff require because common sense has dictated the same adjustments for the older staff for years. The younger staff literally tell their elders in the staff room how much they get in addition to their wages. They see the car they’ve got that’s nicer than theirs. They hear about how when the youngsters went to Disney they got fast track on all the rides as they had the right disability.

All of these people are perfectly capable of working full time jobs that suit them. Lots of them have worked out how to get extra money from the state. It’s unaffordable, unfair and is dividing society. Let alone creating an atmosphere where these youngsters don’t see the value of work.

Ott3r · 14/11/2026 06:51

WhitegreeNcandle · 14/11/2026 06:27

I don’t wish. I see. We manage the very very tiny adjustments that the younger staff require because common sense has dictated the same adjustments for the older staff for years. The younger staff literally tell their elders in the staff room how much they get in addition to their wages. They see the car they’ve got that’s nicer than theirs. They hear about how when the youngsters went to Disney they got fast track on all the rides as they had the right disability.

All of these people are perfectly capable of working full time jobs that suit them. Lots of them have worked out how to get extra money from the state. It’s unaffordable, unfair and is dividing society. Let alone creating an atmosphere where these youngsters don’t see the value of work.

Sorry I don’t see that at all. Wages are topped up according to salary amount not age. Plenty of over 25s on UC. I don’t think I know anybody young or old who would wish to go to Disney so I doubt very much young people are visiting Disney in their droves. 🙄 Getting on the work ladder with zero experience is incredibly hard for all young people as has been pointed out by many across all sectors….

You're getting your prejudice mixed up and your post makes no sense are we berating NEETS in which case they won’t be at work, the disabled or just anybody who has something triggering your green eyed jealousy.

TigerRag · 14/11/2026 06:53

BeLemonMoose · 13/11/2026 22:57

I agree with @WhitegreeNcandle many of those working and paying taxes are chronically ill or disabled. It's not a them and us situation. There are young people on benefits claiming they are too ill to work while older people with the same conditions are working full time.

Same condition doesn't mean they're affected the same

SuddenDaredJelly · 14/11/2026 06:54

The thing is. You have people who can't work. The seriously learning disabled, people with various genetic disorders, the terminally ill etc.

But the majority of those on pip are slightly different. They can work. They are not learning disabled or physically impaired. Their mental health means they find working (or the idea of working) overwhelming etc.

This is not the same as not & never being able to work at all.

We need a mindset shift that:

  • mental health issues are often temporary & can be improved/cured, and should not be considered something you "have for life". You are depressed or anxious "at the moment", not forever.
  • people must be given adequate support from both government & employers to build up their ability to tolerate & thrive in work.
  • part time work (but of at least 15h) might be all some people can manage
  • its not a reasonable expectation that work is within/around school hours only unless you have a severely disabled child with care needs.
  • we arent going to be happy/feel good every single day. I work full time. Ive got disc problems in my back and a chronic sinus issue that mean i have days where I am in pain & juggling work & DC sucks, i do a lot to make it more tolerable including requesting a standing desk and using breaks to stretch & do exercises. Life goes on, i need money to pay bills so I work.
Itchthescratch · 14/11/2026 06:57

XenoBitch · 13/11/2026 23:02

Then why make it a competition between those who are disabled who can work, and those who are disabled and cant work?
Who benefits from this fighting? No one.

It isn't a competition but ultimately disability benefits and other elements of state support require a threshold to access otherwise the system becomes unsustainable and overwhelmed. There are too many of us with poor health, meaningful neurodivergent traits and other additional struggles to make it any other way. Some of us will be expected to work and have a very hard time doing this and this will have to be relatively normal, especially if we continue to improve health care so that we all keep living longer and therefore need to work longer to fund our retirement.

When are you expected to struggle on in difficult circumstances versus when can you expect state assistance and support? When are the struggles so great that you aren't expected to work anymore and instead other people who are often in imperfect health or even disabled themselves have to fund you? We have to make sure we are being fair and this involves a huge element of challenge to the disabled and those with poor health. It's a numbers game and I think it's only realistic that those that are moving heaven and earth to contribute despite their very real challenges are angry with others in a similar situation who believe they can simply opt out because it's hard.

45% of people over the age of 65 are disabled. This will likely increase for future generations due to health trends and increases in disability associated with mental health and neurodiversity. The state pension age will only rise further. The majority of the workforce in some age groups will be disabled or chronically ill. Human survival has always been a struggle. The idea that you can opt out completely when others with the same condition and symptoms are fighting hard to work should be challenged robustly. We simply can't afford to support everyone in the way they would like.

WhitegreeNcandle · 14/11/2026 06:59

I thought the thread was about mild conditions and earlier CAMHS interventions. It’s not a case of jealousy. Quite often I think certain people might need targeted support for certain elements. But a lifetime passport of access to free money? I’ll be shouted down on here for this but it’s what many of us are seeing in our workplaces.

I’m also not berating or am jealous of anyone. I’m worried where our society is headed because we can’t afford to have to social division this is causing. Let alone afford so many people to not work or work part time. We’ve moved away from a perspective of work is healthy and good for us to something that triggers people and is to be avoided at all costs.

ArtieChoke · 14/11/2026 07:08

I have a family member with autism, he has a mental age of 5/6 years old. He attends day clubs has 24/7 hour carers and is 32 years old.

there is absolutely no way he is going to be able to work

Itchthescratch · 14/11/2026 07:12

ArtieChoke · 14/11/2026 07:08

I have a family member with autism, he has a mental age of 5/6 years old. He attends day clubs has 24/7 hour carers and is 32 years old.

there is absolutely no way he is going to be able to work

These discussions obviously aren't about those with such severe disabilities. The majority of people claiming PIP will not be as impacted by their disability as your relative. None of my relatives are as impacted for example and several claim PIP.

Arguably reducing the number of people eligible to claim and not work would be of benefit to your relative as it would make the system much more sustainable and leave more money in the pot for those with higher needs.

Ott3r · 14/11/2026 07:22

Itchthescratch · 14/11/2026 07:12

These discussions obviously aren't about those with such severe disabilities. The majority of people claiming PIP will not be as impacted by their disability as your relative. None of my relatives are as impacted for example and several claim PIP.

Arguably reducing the number of people eligible to claim and not work would be of benefit to your relative as it would make the system much more sustainable and leave more money in the pot for those with higher needs.

Define severe. It’s not either or. Many are in between at various levels as regards support needs and ability to work. The bar is high to get PIP mobility. My daughter does not have a learning disability but her autism and other conditions involve a high need of services that fluctuates and she needs a huge amount of support and careful handing. She wants to work and is in education but is on a long journey and absolutely can’t do any old work somebody with zero expertise as regards her conditions pluck out of a job centre computer list. She needs her PIP to get further along that journey to the right job and withdrawing her support or forcing her into situations that will be catastrophic will simply invoke hospitalisation, even more complexity and massive bills to the NHS.

Ott3r · 14/11/2026 07:25

WhitegreeNcandle · 14/11/2026 06:59

I thought the thread was about mild conditions and earlier CAMHS interventions. It’s not a case of jealousy. Quite often I think certain people might need targeted support for certain elements. But a lifetime passport of access to free money? I’ll be shouted down on here for this but it’s what many of us are seeing in our workplaces.

I’m also not berating or am jealous of anyone. I’m worried where our society is headed because we can’t afford to have to social division this is causing. Let alone afford so many people to not work or work part time. We’ve moved away from a perspective of work is healthy and good for us to something that triggers people and is to be avoided at all costs.

It’s not a lifetime of free money. PIP is regularly reviewed and it’s a tough process. NEETS aren’t in work so not sure how they’re in your place of work. I’d love to know how you know the intimate financial details of the hoards of young people on PIP lounging about your workplace on minimal contracts that we all know are ludicrously hard to get.

ArtieChoke · 14/11/2026 07:30

Itchthescratch · 14/11/2026 07:12

These discussions obviously aren't about those with such severe disabilities. The majority of people claiming PIP will not be as impacted by their disability as your relative. None of my relatives are as impacted for example and several claim PIP.

Arguably reducing the number of people eligible to claim and not work would be of benefit to your relative as it would make the system much more sustainable and leave more money in the pot for those with higher needs.

He is autistic and that is what this is about, there aren’t grades of autism. He receives pip & UC

he is 32 so clearly not in the age group, now, to be affected

i

Itchthescratch · 14/11/2026 07:36

Ott3r · 14/11/2026 07:22

Define severe. It’s not either or. Many are in between at various levels as regards support needs and ability to work. The bar is high to get PIP mobility. My daughter does not have a learning disability but her autism and other conditions involve a high need of services that fluctuates and she needs a huge amount of support and careful handing. She wants to work and is in education but is on a long journey and absolutely can’t do any old work somebody with zero expertise as regards her conditions pluck out of a job centre computer list. She needs her PIP to get further along that journey to the right job and withdrawing her support or forcing her into situations that will be catastrophic will simply invoke hospitalisation, even more complexity and massive bills to the NHS.

Of course it's not either or. That's been my whole point in previous posts. Disability in general isn't binary. You don't miraculously lose that last bit of sight or have that one extra ASD trait that adversely impacts your life and suddenly you go from a completely non-impaired individual to someone who is disabled. Life is way more complex than that. As you suggest, there isn't an objective, definitive tipping point where a disability becomes severe either.

What we can generally acknowledge though is that there are huge amounts of young people that report having significant struggles. 53% of generation Z identify as being Neurodivergent. No, they aren't all diagnosed but the point is that they feel that they are disabled by their ND traits enough to believe that they are ND. 18% of those between 16-24 report having a disability which has more than doubled in the past decade. We know from previous generations that the prevelance of disability increases as people age so what does this mean for the future?

I can't comment specifically about your daughter but these statistics should alarm everyone. There are ways of offering support that aren't about withdrawing the requirement to work or offering PIP. I think this is a great idea. We can't be blackmailed by threats of hospitalisation and suicide as a society in debates like this. This is how the trans movement and more recently people like David Walliams have attempted to force society to step away from challenging and reforming areas.

Itchthescratch · 14/11/2026 07:39

ArtieChoke · 14/11/2026 07:30

He is autistic and that is what this is about, there aren’t grades of autism. He receives pip & UC

he is 32 so clearly not in the age group, now, to be affected

i

Edited

It is ludicrous and shameful that pressure groups have worked to remove the idea that those that are clearly more severely impaired by their autism have the same level of condition as Elon Musk. Again, an example where the most capable advocates have worked to fight for their own rights at the expense of those that can't do the same. This is a huge bone of contention amongst the Autism community and I totally understand why.

Apotofrealcoffee · 14/11/2026 07:41

Itchthescratch · 14/11/2026 07:39

It is ludicrous and shameful that pressure groups have worked to remove the idea that those that are clearly more severely impaired by their autism have the same level of condition as Elon Musk. Again, an example where the most capable advocates have worked to fight for their own rights at the expense of those that can't do the same. This is a huge bone of contention amongst the Autism community and I totally understand why.

Me too. Well, they’ve got what they wanted, which is everyone being treated the same and therefore open to the same level of scrutiny 🤷‍♀️

Ott3r · 14/11/2026 07:55

Itchthescratch · 14/11/2026 07:36

Of course it's not either or. That's been my whole point in previous posts. Disability in general isn't binary. You don't miraculously lose that last bit of sight or have that one extra ASD trait that adversely impacts your life and suddenly you go from a completely non-impaired individual to someone who is disabled. Life is way more complex than that. As you suggest, there isn't an objective, definitive tipping point where a disability becomes severe either.

What we can generally acknowledge though is that there are huge amounts of young people that report having significant struggles. 53% of generation Z identify as being Neurodivergent. No, they aren't all diagnosed but the point is that they feel that they are disabled by their ND traits enough to believe that they are ND. 18% of those between 16-24 report having a disability which has more than doubled in the past decade. We know from previous generations that the prevelance of disability increases as people age so what does this mean for the future?

I can't comment specifically about your daughter but these statistics should alarm everyone. There are ways of offering support that aren't about withdrawing the requirement to work or offering PIP. I think this is a great idea. We can't be blackmailed by threats of hospitalisation and suicide as a society in debates like this. This is how the trans movement and more recently people like David Walliams have attempted to force society to step away from challenging and reforming areas.

Autism diagnosis rates are 1-2.3% . Fogarty has pointed out that we have been a diagnosis lead society ie you can’t get help without diagnosis. So young people can think what they like but unfortunately but without diagnoses it’s hard to get anything.

It also isn’t blackmailing to highlight the impact of withdrawing of support needs that is a reality that many families are living with and you will see on paed wards,A&E, crisis up and down the country. The impact of unsupported need has been highlighted by the government’s own reports.

The Fonagy review highlighted that unsupported need cause manageable difficulties to escalate into severe crises and the impact of leaving needs unsupported spans individual wellbeing, public services, and the wider economy. When early, accessible help is unavailable, everyday struggles and mild distress escalate into severe, complex mental health conditions. Because people are left to cope alone on multi-year waiting lists, services often only intervene when an individual reaches a breaking point or emergency. Leaving neurodevelopmental or mental health needs unaddressed undermines a person's relationships, education, and ability to sustain secure employment. The review notes that the consequences of rising, unsupported mental distress ripple outward into families, schools, workplaces, and the wider economy.

The NHS ADHD task force highlighted how undiagnosed and unsupported ADHD alone costs the country £17 billion a year!

Just ripping away PIP as a knee jerk collective policy is hugely dangerous. Nobody is being looked at individually and there is literally nothing in place to replace it or likely to be for a very long time.

Ott3r · 14/11/2026 07:58

Itchthescratch · 14/11/2026 07:39

It is ludicrous and shameful that pressure groups have worked to remove the idea that those that are clearly more severely impaired by their autism have the same level of condition as Elon Musk. Again, an example where the most capable advocates have worked to fight for their own rights at the expense of those that can't do the same. This is a huge bone of contention amongst the Autism community and I totally understand why.

There you go again. Writing off everybody with autism without a learning disability comorbidity as having “mild autism” and the same as Musk.

itsgettingweird · 14/11/2026 08:10

I think it’s wrong.

I also think if you’re going to go ahead to have to look into dla too.

A child doesn’t suddenly become less disabled on their 16th birthday.

Also you need to consider that taking away health element from 18-25 isn’t going to suddenly change the health of lots of claimants. My ds neurological genetic condition won’t disappear because they aren’t paying a health element (he’s not getting to now but is awaiting a capacity to work assessment).

He went through education with an EHCP. The same sort of support into work would be great. However - if they are removing the health element they need to be paying employers who will take on a young person who’s whole body can go into spasm spontaneously rendering them bed bound.

Because that won’t change whatever “support” is out there.

Plus what about those with severe learning disabilities.

Itchthescratch · 14/11/2026 08:37

Ott3r · 14/11/2026 07:58

There you go again. Writing off everybody with autism without a learning disability comorbidity as having “mild autism” and the same as Musk.

Except I haven't done anything of the sort. I find it interesting that you think that suggesting that not everybody is impaired to the same extent by their Autism is tantamount writing them off. Many respected experts and groups in the field believe the exact opposite and that severity tiers are important for all kinds of reasons including resource allocation which is what we are discussing here. Levels of Autism are used in many Countries and it seen as essential to protecting and distinguishing those with high support needs.

I used Elon Musk as an example of someone with ASD who under the UK model has the same level of Autism as a person that will never be able to live independently, work or even be left alone without 24/7 supervision.

CatkinToadflax · 14/11/2026 08:46

If the plan is to just take PIP and LCWRA off every single 16-24 year old without assessing their needs individually, I think that’s a colossal worry. Obviously DWP will then need to provide assessments to work out who to give the new version of support to and at what level. Given that currently many people’s PIP renewal assessments are being postponed by up to a year due to not enough staff to carry out the reviews, how exactly will this vast new process be undertaken?

I haven’t read the whole thread due to its length, so apologies if this has been discussed already.

I do absolutely think those who can work but currently aren’t, should be helped into work - but vastly more jobs for young people are needed. Others can’t work, or can only manage a maximum of a couple of hours a day in highly supported work (such as my son). Where are the jobs that these young people are supposed to be accessing?

Ott3r · 14/11/2026 08:53

Itchthescratch · 14/11/2026 08:37

Except I haven't done anything of the sort. I find it interesting that you think that suggesting that not everybody is impaired to the same extent by their Autism is tantamount writing them off. Many respected experts and groups in the field believe the exact opposite and that severity tiers are important for all kinds of reasons including resource allocation which is what we are discussing here. Levels of Autism are used in many Countries and it seen as essential to protecting and distinguishing those with high support needs.

I used Elon Musk as an example of someone with ASD who under the UK model has the same level of Autism as a person that will never be able to live independently, work or even be left alone without 24/7 supervision.

If you’re referring to DSM 5 countries that rely on this such as the USA explicitly use support levels (Level 1: requiring support, Level 2: requiring substantial support, and Level 3: requiring very substantial support) to denote how much assistance an autistic individual needs. That is not levelling autism. Also the same manual has a caveat that support needs can fluctuate ie nobody with autism can be tucked neatly into a box. If you tried to do that based on support needs you will need to commit to regular reviews and as we can barely give autistic people any diagnosis with waiting lists running into years I’d love to know how you can regularly monitor support needs on top- you can’t . The bar is high as regards getting a diagnosis anyway ie it has to significantly impact life. Any support given is entirely as regards individual need. You can have very differing high support needs needing very different care. What my dd gets would be of no use to others and VV. Fonagy recommends a needs lead plus diagnosis model thus making a straight jacket and unworkable autism level system pointless anyway.

You appear on every thread pushing this and derailing.

BeLemonMoose · 14/11/2026 09:06

Lots of countries give people a percentage of his disabled they are assessed as being.

Please create an account

To comment on this thread you need to create a Mumsnet account.

This thread is not accepting new messages.