Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Milburn review and benefits for 18-24 year olds

1000 replies

ReviewAlternatives · 12/11/2026 07:11

I was just reading about this and have some concerns.

I think a better idea initially would be rather than sinking probably millions into setting a new scheme up the government should be putting that money into CAMHS.

I can see the review mentions support for ‘mild’ ADHD, autism and anxiety but that’s not enough. The whole CAMHS system needs the overhaul and only then with a fit for purpose system should benefit reforms for 18-24 year olds be looked at. To act immediately and include existing claimants is wrong.

AIBU to think this will not work unless they do things the correct way - intensive CAMHS reform initially not during or part of and limited to just ‘mild’ cases of certain issues?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
9
Dicedpumpkin · 13/11/2026 16:29

Rustybike · 13/11/2026 15:47

I answered all questions honestly - why would I therefore not be made an award, if I proceed with an application?

Edit.

Edited

I didnt say you wouldnt be successful but that an online checker isnt the same as recieving an award. They review your form and your evidence and interview you. You can only confidently say youd get an award if you can 'pass' those parts not just be honest on a checker.

PocketSand · 13/11/2026 16:31

@Rustybikei thought tax payers were resilient but now they are struggling? Well how about ignoring their claims and telling them to tough it out, or take in ironing, ignoring suicidal ideation and calling their bluff. Some may die but I’m not their mother and their grip on life was not all that.

The last voted down benefit reforms were shown by Citizen’s Advice to result in a loss of income of over 10k a year if a claimant lost daily living component of PIP due to not scoring 4 points in a single area and so lost CA and disability element of UC. This could be a loss of nearly 70% of total income. Not because disability or functional impairment was reduced but by moving the goalposts.

What other group is facing similar loss - don’t forget the same increase in cost of living applies.

No doubt CA and disability charities will highlight the cost to the 420,000 existing recipients of UC care element and PIP and the cost to those no longer eligible to claim such benefits to pay for reforms that are unlikely to benefit them directly as they suffer the greatest barriers to work.

Rustybike · 13/11/2026 16:36

Dicedpumpkin · 13/11/2026 16:29

I didnt say you wouldnt be successful but that an online checker isnt the same as recieving an award. They review your form and your evidence and interview you. You can only confidently say youd get an award if you can 'pass' those parts not just be honest on a checker.

Evidently prospective claimaints are using online checkers, and via ‘walk through’ consultants, judging by the number advertising their services online.

YouTube has some with over 300k views.

Rustybike · 13/11/2026 16:40

PocketSand · 13/11/2026 16:31

@Rustybikei thought tax payers were resilient but now they are struggling? Well how about ignoring their claims and telling them to tough it out, or take in ironing, ignoring suicidal ideation and calling their bluff. Some may die but I’m not their mother and their grip on life was not all that.

The last voted down benefit reforms were shown by Citizen’s Advice to result in a loss of income of over 10k a year if a claimant lost daily living component of PIP due to not scoring 4 points in a single area and so lost CA and disability element of UC. This could be a loss of nearly 70% of total income. Not because disability or functional impairment was reduced but by moving the goalposts.

What other group is facing similar loss - don’t forget the same increase in cost of living applies.

No doubt CA and disability charities will highlight the cost to the 420,000 existing recipients of UC care element and PIP and the cost to those no longer eligible to claim such benefits to pay for reforms that are unlikely to benefit them directly as they suffer the greatest barriers to work.

I think a significant number of people are probably struggling, yes - this government acknowledges that, hence the energy and cost of living ‘support’ announced in the recent budget.

The funding has to come from somewhere and I do think people are entitled to ask questions to ensure that their tax revenue is allocated legitimately.

That’s just fair.

Ott3r · 13/11/2026 16:42

Rustybike · 13/11/2026 16:36

Evidently prospective claimaints are using online checkers, and via ‘walk through’ consultants, judging by the number advertising their services online.

YouTube has some with over 300k views.

An application is only as good as its supporting evidence hence the very low fraud rate.No supporting evidence no PIP,so people advertising services are ripping people off.

Ott3r · 13/11/2026 16:43

Rustybike · 13/11/2026 16:40

I think a significant number of people are probably struggling, yes - this government acknowledges that, hence the energy and cost of living ‘support’ announced in the recent budget.

The funding has to come from somewhere and I do think people are entitled to ask questions to ensure that their tax revenue is allocated legitimately.

That’s just fair.

So we can examine CB, people using the NHS….

PocketSand · 13/11/2026 16:44

@Rustybikei put my completed PIP review for DS through AI and it was confident it would score over 20 points on daily living. I already knew it had scored 12. You won’t score enough for standard.

ThingsAreNotWhatTheyWere · 13/11/2026 16:49

PocketSand · 13/11/2026 16:44

@Rustybikei put my completed PIP review for DS through AI and it was confident it would score over 20 points on daily living. I already knew it had scored 12. You won’t score enough for standard.

Yeah, that checker will not take into account all attempts to downplay and ignore evidence...

It really isn't as easy as people like to think!

Rustybike · 13/11/2026 16:51

Ott3r · 13/11/2026 16:42

An application is only as good as its supporting evidence hence the very low fraud rate.No supporting evidence no PIP,so people advertising services are ripping people off.

Some of the testimonials say differently.

As of the summer, there were 4,090,120 claimants (up 7% or about 262,000 from the previous year).

Let’s be conservative, and take 76/week x 52 x 262,000

Thats a 1bn increase in one year, alone.

Itchthescratch · 13/11/2026 16:54

Ott3r · 13/11/2026 16:43

So we can examine CB, people using the NHS….

Whataboutery at its finest. Why can't we just discuss disability benefits on a thread about disability benefits? Anyone would think the current process doesn't stand up to much scrutiny

Ott3r · 13/11/2026 16:57

Itchthescratch · 13/11/2026 16:54

Whataboutery at its finest. Why can't we just discuss disability benefits on a thread about disability benefits? Anyone would think the current process doesn't stand up to much scrutiny

It wasn’t me who said tax payers should be able to scrutinise what their taxes are spent on. Ok with that in mind, I’m a tax payers so why are we paying out CB to people who don’t need it and all sorts of things on the NHS to no people
who cause the need! Weight loss jabs anyone!

PocketSand · 13/11/2026 17:00

@Rustybikeare those initial claimants (whether or not awarded) or those awarded on initial claim, or mandatory review or tribunal? How have you accounted for increase in normal retirement age?

Itchthescratch · 13/11/2026 17:04

Ott3r · 13/11/2026 16:57

It wasn’t me who said tax payers should be able to scrutinise what their taxes are spent on. Ok with that in mind, I’m a tax payers so why are we paying out CB to people who don’t need it and all sorts of things on the NHS to no people
who cause the need! Weight loss jabs anyone!

But again, this is just whataboutery. The tax payer has a right to scrutinise where their money is going in all kinds of areas. The thread is about disability benefits so will rightly focus on this. There are plenty of other threads to discuss weight loss jabs on the NHS etc so feel free to debate that there.

The desperate use of red herrings and distraction techniques makes me think you have very little faith in the system. If you did, you wouldn't be so desperate to draw attention elsewhere.

It's also true that disabled people receive a lot of support from the NHS, are more likely to need weight loss jabs and many claim CB. So many people discuss these issues like there are discreet groups taking advantage of different benefits and support wine often it's disproportionately the same people that rely on lots of aspects of state assistance.

Ott3r · 13/11/2026 17:13

Rustybike · 13/11/2026 16:51

Some of the testimonials say differently.

As of the summer, there were 4,090,120 claimants (up 7% or about 262,000 from the previous year).

Let’s be conservative, and take 76/week x 52 x 262,000

Thats a 1bn increase in one year, alone.

The government’s own department says different

According to the Department for Work and Pensions Fraud and Error Statistics,the estimated claimant fraud rate for Personal Independence Payment (PIP) is low, remaining under 1.5% (with specific official estimates and campaign groups citing rates around 0.4% to roughly 1.4% depending on the specific measurement period and inclusion of organised crime vs. individual error).
Key PIP Fraud and Error Breakdown

  • Claimant Fraud Rate: Estimated at approximately 0.4% to 1.4% of total PIP expenditure, meaning the vast majority (over 98.6%) of claims are not fraudulent.
  • Official and Administrative Errors: The DWP itself incurs overpayment rates through official processing errors (such as assessment or award allocation mistakes), which often match or exceed individual fraud levels.
  • Comparison with Other Benefits: PIP consistently registers one of the lowest fraud and error rates in the UK welfare system, significantly lower than benefits like Universal Credit, which experience much higher overpayment and fraud rates.
Passaggressfedup · 13/11/2026 17:13

That isn't what the review says. It's just what you think
How convenient an argument! You're the one who said that the report was stating there wasn't an overdiagnosis issue. That's incorrect though. It says it can't show that there is an overdiagnosis, that's very different! It then goes on to say that there is a serious concern over independent providers who are in it for the money and there is a complete lack of governance.

The whole pip hasn't increased because of the transition from DLA to pip. Surely that would be an that DLA applications have decreased....except they haven't, they have more than double.

As for the whole 'you can't get pip for mild conditions, the process is rigourous, if you get the points it means you are definitely very affected....' just doesn't wash any longer. Society has moved on from these rebukes. Average Joe nowadays knows that with the will and the right support and determination, getting pip is not the hard feast people like you still try to get people to believe.

10 years ago, if you dared criticising disability benefits, you were banned from posting. Nowadays, people are willing to ask questions and want answers. It won't be long until people will see the abuse the system has created and the serious impact it is having on our society and especially our now young people. It can't go on and more and more sees it clearly.

Passaggressfedup · 13/11/2026 17:20

According to the Department for Work and Pensions Fraud and Error Statistics,the estimated claimant fraud rate for Personal Independence Payment (PIP) is low, remaining under 1.5% (with specific official estimates and campaign groups citing rates around 0.4% to roughly 1.4% depending on the specific measurement period and inclusion of organised crime vs. individual error)
And that's another one people are getting tired of being thrown down their throats. The only reason why the figure is so low is because people are not being investigated and they're not investigated because it cost way too much to do so, that would provide enough evidence to take the person to court, and then somehow recouping the money.

This does not in anyway mean that people are not claiming fraudulently, especially people who do get better but don't report improvements. I'd like to know the percentage of people who report an improvement before their next assessment or at all. I bet that's very low too!

Kirbert2 · 13/11/2026 17:24

hibernatinghedgehog · 13/11/2026 16:28

Those who say no-one thinks those with significant disabilities should have support removed/reduced are wrong.

DS1 has complex needs. A complex mix of physical, psychological, developmental and medical needs. He needs 24/7 care, needs support with all ADLs, will never live independently, has an LLI, has needs complex enough that it is inappropriate for provision to be made in a school or college and instead has an EOTIS package with 2:1 support, receives continuing care funding, has an ongoing PIP award… Yet I have been told on MN previously that his support should be removed and support should be reduced.

Yep.

My son also has complex needs, though he is able to manage with 2:1 support in mainstream. I've been told on here that he shouldn't be in mainstream but I've also been told that money shouldn't be spent for specialist provision so not exactly sure what some people think the solution is if it isn't mainstream with support or specialist provision that is somehow cheaper.

I've also been criticised for not working to care for him and it suggested that I get a job to pay for a carer to look after him as well as the very helpful suggestion of moving to a cheaper place so I wouldn't need UC or social housing.

Rustybike · 13/11/2026 17:25

Passaggressfedup · 13/11/2026 17:20

According to the Department for Work and Pensions Fraud and Error Statistics,the estimated claimant fraud rate for Personal Independence Payment (PIP) is low, remaining under 1.5% (with specific official estimates and campaign groups citing rates around 0.4% to roughly 1.4% depending on the specific measurement period and inclusion of organised crime vs. individual error)
And that's another one people are getting tired of being thrown down their throats. The only reason why the figure is so low is because people are not being investigated and they're not investigated because it cost way too much to do so, that would provide enough evidence to take the person to court, and then somehow recouping the money.

This does not in anyway mean that people are not claiming fraudulently, especially people who do get better but don't report improvements. I'd like to know the percentage of people who report an improvement before their next assessment or at all. I bet that's very low too!

Reassessment Rate: Around 1.7% of the total caseload is reassessed each month.…

Roughly 7,600 to 8,000 claimants per month lose their PIP award through formal reassessments (out of over 4 million claimants).

Ott3r · 13/11/2026 17:25

Itchthescratch · 13/11/2026 17:04

But again, this is just whataboutery. The tax payer has a right to scrutinise where their money is going in all kinds of areas. The thread is about disability benefits so will rightly focus on this. There are plenty of other threads to discuss weight loss jabs on the NHS etc so feel free to debate that there.

The desperate use of red herrings and distraction techniques makes me think you have very little faith in the system. If you did, you wouldn't be so desperate to draw attention elsewhere.

It's also true that disabled people receive a lot of support from the NHS, are more likely to need weight loss jabs and many claim CB. So many people discuss these issues like there are discreet groups taking advantage of different benefits and support wine often it's disproportionately the same people that rely on lots of aspects of state assistance.

No it should be open season, not one rule for one section of society( the most vulnerable) and another for everything else. If people want to promote tax payers having aright to scrutinise then let’s have it for everything.

And as for saying disabled people are more likely to need weight loss jobs- disability comes in all shapes and sizes.🙄

EasternStandard · 13/11/2026 17:28

Rustybike · 13/11/2026 15:47

I answered all questions honestly - why would I therefore not be made an award, if I proceed with an application?

Edit.

Edited

I had a look at what you were referring to and it covers many areas. On the topic of proof if you can’t cook a meal for example you might ask someone to write a statement to that effect, would they take your word for it if you didn’t have that?

Passaggressfedup · 13/11/2026 17:30

So if pip can't be awarded without strong documented evidence, why do we regularly see people taken to court, where they inevitably all end up pleading guilty to fraud, where it comes to light that they got awarded high mobility rate when they are perfectly able to walk, run, do martial arts.... Surely that should be absolutely impossible.

These people taken to court are the idiots who posts pictures and films online, talk to people they trust but ultimately get fed up and report them.

How many are doing just the same but covering their tracks and don't ever get investigated?

SleeplessInWherever · 13/11/2026 17:30

In fairness, the “not the most disabled” argument does fall flat very quickly.

My personal favourites about my son are:

  • put him in a home
  • he should be institutionalised
  • just give him basic education in the form of a holding pen because he won’t be a productive member of society anyway
  • why are we wasting money on “lost causes”

and the wonderful, genuinely said more than once…

  • people with that level of need should really be euthanised at birth
PocketSand · 13/11/2026 17:35

@Itchthescratchcan you please provide links to credible research to support your claim that disabled people are more likely to qualify for weight jabs on the NHS and ‘many’ claim CB. Thanks.

We all know there is a cost of living crisis. But really this is an inequality crisis. It’s just that the middle are being pulled down and are blaming those below them. The sick and disabled and especially young adults whose parents are trying to support them are easy pickings.

I must also say that parents of SEND DC on the whole are Uber parents. The average parent of a child that is shy or introverted and a little anxious is the difference between couch to 5K and a person who has run multiple marathons back to back. Nursery, school, assessments, hospital, LA, EHCP, tribunal, special school on top of your usual stuff. Benefits are way on the back burner. It is often only considered when professionals recommend applying.

Passaggressfedup · 13/11/2026 17:35

Reassessment Rate: Around 1.7% of the total caseload is reassessed each month.…Roughly 7,600 to 8,000 claimants per month lose their PIP award through formal reassessments (out of over 4 million claimants)
So very few reassessments. And how many claimants contact pip before their reassessment to ask for an early one because they believe they might not meet the criteria any longer?

Ott3r · 13/11/2026 17:40

Passaggressfedup · 13/11/2026 17:13

That isn't what the review says. It's just what you think
How convenient an argument! You're the one who said that the report was stating there wasn't an overdiagnosis issue. That's incorrect though. It says it can't show that there is an overdiagnosis, that's very different! It then goes on to say that there is a serious concern over independent providers who are in it for the money and there is a complete lack of governance.

The whole pip hasn't increased because of the transition from DLA to pip. Surely that would be an that DLA applications have decreased....except they haven't, they have more than double.

As for the whole 'you can't get pip for mild conditions, the process is rigourous, if you get the points it means you are definitely very affected....' just doesn't wash any longer. Society has moved on from these rebukes. Average Joe nowadays knows that with the will and the right support and determination, getting pip is not the hard feast people like you still try to get people to believe.

10 years ago, if you dared criticising disability benefits, you were banned from posting. Nowadays, people are willing to ask questions and want answers. It won't be long until people will see the abuse the system has created and the serious impact it is having on our society and especially our now young people. It can't go on and more and more sees it clearly.

Sorry but a lot of your post is not true. We have 3 degrees between us and masses of strong evidence for our daughter- the 14 page form is hugely difficult to fill out and provide qualifying evidence for.

Re Fogarty you’re twisting his words. ADHD and autism have long been under diagnosed in this country as pointed out in the nhs adhd taskforce published not long before Fogarty. The review states that based on current evidence, experts cannot conclude that overdiagnosis is occurring. Fonagy claims rising referrals reflect genuine distress, greater openness, and improved awareness. Misdiagnosis , and overdiagnosis can all coexist at the same time. The report also points out that women, girls, people in care, and certain ethnic minority groups—such as South Asian children—continue to be historically under-recognised and underdiagnosed.

It highlights as did the taskforce review how dire wait lists are causing people who can afford it( and many can’t) to go private however we need better consistency between NHS and private which has been highlighted by pretty much everybody for a very long time. The nhs task force highlighted how better access to nhs diagnosis is key as it would lessen the need for private.

Please create an account

To comment on this thread you need to create a Mumsnet account.

This thread is not accepting new messages.
Swipe left for the next trending thread