Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Milburn review and benefits for 18-24 year olds

1000 replies

ReviewAlternatives · 12/11/2026 07:11

I was just reading about this and have some concerns.

I think a better idea initially would be rather than sinking probably millions into setting a new scheme up the government should be putting that money into CAMHS.

I can see the review mentions support for ‘mild’ ADHD, autism and anxiety but that’s not enough. The whole CAMHS system needs the overhaul and only then with a fit for purpose system should benefit reforms for 18-24 year olds be looked at. To act immediately and include existing claimants is wrong.

AIBU to think this will not work unless they do things the correct way - intensive CAMHS reform initially not during or part of and limited to just ‘mild’ cases of certain issues?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
9
Apotofrealcoffee · 12/11/2026 18:42

Ott3r · 12/11/2026 18:37

Wow so because you don’t know anyone success doesn’t exist. I think those who have had FBT for anorexia, DBT, trauma therapies, OCD treatment …. and the many other much needed treatments available might disagree.

They might but they’re not here are they?

Think about it, when has anyone ever rocked up to say therapy/benefits were life changing and they’ve been a functioning working person needing zero support since experiencing them?

Doesn’t happen. It’s always ‘I’m on benefits, I will need them for life’ ‘I’ve had every kind of therapy going and am untreatable and will always need benefits’ ‘the NHS gave me this and that therapy but I need another one’ etc

PocketSand · 12/11/2026 18:44

@Apotofrealcoffee’the disabled’ are already included in proposed cuts but the savings are a drop in the ocean despite causing hardship to individuals and their families. They already can’t access CAMHs or get a EHCP unless at crisis point so there is little to cut. But I think the net needs to be widened - that’s where the real profits (sorry, savings) are to be found.

@ThingsAreNotWhatTheyWereirony.

Apotofrealcoffee · 12/11/2026 18:46

PocketSand · 12/11/2026 18:44

@Apotofrealcoffee’the disabled’ are already included in proposed cuts but the savings are a drop in the ocean despite causing hardship to individuals and their families. They already can’t access CAMHs or get a EHCP unless at crisis point so there is little to cut. But I think the net needs to be widened - that’s where the real profits (sorry, savings) are to be found.

@ThingsAreNotWhatTheyWereirony.

Personally I’m not a fan of removal of benefits entirely.

What would be better is each household to be capped in terms of total benefits, disability or not, at around £25,000.

There are a small but growing number of houses absolutely raking it in with 3 or 4 lots of disability benefits, child benefit and UC. One poster was on here showing her breakdown of ~£50,000 per year (can link thread if necessary). Sorry but that’s a piss take.

Ott3r · 12/11/2026 18:47

Apotofrealcoffee · 12/11/2026 18:42

They might but they’re not here are they?

Think about it, when has anyone ever rocked up to say therapy/benefits were life changing and they’ve been a functioning working person needing zero support since experiencing them?

Doesn’t happen. It’s always ‘I’m on benefits, I will need them for life’ ‘I’ve had every kind of therapy going and am untreatable and will always need benefits’ ‘the NHS gave me this and that therapy but I need another one’ etc

My dd has had life changing therapy and I know many others. She still needs support because her conditions are life long and will fluctuate throughout life but she will eventually work and pay taxes because of the treatment she has. Without her treatments she would continue to cause the NHS massive bills as she would be significantly worse. You don’t expect people with life long physical disabilities to have just one treatment and never need anything else.

Apotofrealcoffee · 12/11/2026 18:49

Ott3r · 12/11/2026 18:47

My dd has had life changing therapy and I know many others. She still needs support because her conditions are life long and will fluctuate throughout life but she will eventually work and pay taxes because of the treatment she has. Without her treatments she would continue to cause the NHS massive bills as she would be significantly worse. You don’t expect people with life long physical disabilities to have just one treatment and never need anything else.

Gently though she isn’t working and paying taxes now and ‘still needs support’. It’s great she feels therapy has had a positive effect but it wasn’t talking about merely a positive effect.

ThingsAreNotWhatTheyWere · 12/11/2026 18:50

PocketSand · 12/11/2026 18:44

@Apotofrealcoffee’the disabled’ are already included in proposed cuts but the savings are a drop in the ocean despite causing hardship to individuals and their families. They already can’t access CAMHs or get a EHCP unless at crisis point so there is little to cut. But I think the net needs to be widened - that’s where the real profits (sorry, savings) are to be found.

@ThingsAreNotWhatTheyWereirony.

Irony? Not really sure what your point is... And no quotation marks needed around the disabled.

LizzieW1969 · 12/11/2026 18:50

Apotofrealcoffee · 12/11/2026 18:31

Reluctantly I agree. I don’t really know anyone who has managed to break free from bad MH via therapy. It seems little better than having a vent most of the time, they feel better initially then the feelings come back. Then they chalk it up to not enough therapy, or the wrong type.

That’s not true at all. Therapy can really help with poor mental health. It doesn’t cure it, but it helps you to cope with it. I found it really helpful when I had therapy to help me come to terms with my childhood trauma.

FusionChefGeoff · 12/11/2026 18:50

Monty36 · 12/11/2026 08:40

It sounds as if he wants to differentiate between those whose limitations mean employment is unlikely and those who he thinks could work.
Those who he thinks could he wants to just provide the flat rate allowance to. In the hope the costs go down but that the incentive to work, train, be in education increases. I suspect.

He will have spoken to many young people and parents before concluding. I doubt this in isolation of other measures.

Edited

Is this not just the point of the current PIP assessments? They focus on assessing what you can and can’t do so doesn’t that already differentiate between those who are mildly or severely affected by their disabilities?

Ott3r · 12/11/2026 18:53

Apotofrealcoffee · 12/11/2026 18:49

Gently though she isn’t working and paying taxes now and ‘still needs support’. It’s great she feels therapy has had a positive effect but it wasn’t talking about merely a positive effect.

She’s 22, in education thanks to her treatments and with the right support move from education to employment.

creamycustards · 12/11/2026 18:58

But if young people receiving PIP are already in work, why take away their PIP if this is all supposed to be about getting young people into work.

Ott3r · 12/11/2026 19:01

creamycustards · 12/11/2026 18:58

But if young people receiving PIP are already in work, why take away their PIP if this is all supposed to be about getting young people into work.

Or education. It’s madness, particularly when we know the dire state of services. Many are in the state they are because they didn’t get treatment and support when they should have done. Removing a measure that helps them access help to go back to zilch (which will be the reality)is madness. Have they not learnt ignoring need doesn’t make it go away- it gets worse!

LizzieW1969 · 12/11/2026 19:02

creamycustards · 12/11/2026 18:58

But if young people receiving PIP are already in work, why take away their PIP if this is all supposed to be about getting young people into work.

Exactly. The PIP will be being used to support them in getting to work. Like the motability benefit. Some of them won’t be able to get themselves to work as a result. How does that help anyone?

Apotofrealcoffee · 12/11/2026 19:06

Ott3r · 12/11/2026 18:53

She’s 22, in education thanks to her treatments and with the right support move from education to employment.

But it’s more support again. There never seems to be terminus where the work is complete and they are released into the wild, so to speak.

SleeplessInWherever · 12/11/2026 19:06

I knew this before I opened this thread, but there are some bloody awful people on this website.

Practically rubbing their hands together because young vulnerable adults will have less support.

Honestly. Have a word with yourselves.

SleeplessInWherever · 12/11/2026 19:08

Apotofrealcoffee · 12/11/2026 19:06

But it’s more support again. There never seems to be terminus where the work is complete and they are released into the wild, so to speak.

Do you want the girl to work or not?

Because without the support, she’s not going to work, and therefore will definitely and absolutely be a cost to the economy without putting in whatsoever.

If you want people in work, some people will need support to get there. Or, they can not get that support and end up claiming benefits forever, which I’m assuming you’d also dislike.

Ott3r · 12/11/2026 19:09

Apotofrealcoffee · 12/11/2026 19:06

But it’s more support again. There never seems to be terminus where the work is complete and they are released into the wild, so to speak.

Because she has a lifelong disability!!!!

As I said are those with physical disabilities only allowed one round of treatment and support?

Without treatment and support she will end up hospitalised. Can’t click my fingers and get rid of what she was born with. Sorry.

Ott3r · 12/11/2026 19:11

SleeplessInWherever · 12/11/2026 19:08

Do you want the girl to work or not?

Because without the support, she’s not going to work, and therefore will definitely and absolutely be a cost to the economy without putting in whatsoever.

If you want people in work, some people will need support to get there. Or, they can not get that support and end up claiming benefits forever, which I’m assuming you’d also dislike.

This!!!

Without the support she won’t just be out of work but in hospital and trust me as a taxpayer wouldn’t want the bills that comes with.

Apotofrealcoffee · 12/11/2026 19:11

SleeplessInWherever · 12/11/2026 19:06

I knew this before I opened this thread, but there are some bloody awful people on this website.

Practically rubbing their hands together because young vulnerable adults will have less support.

Honestly. Have a word with yourselves.

If I’m being brutally honest I’m more worried about working adults on the edge with families to support whose hard earned savings are dwindling away as the cost of living engulfs them.

We’ve been ordered to care about ‘the vulnerable’ aka NEETs for so long without any concern flowing back to us, that I’m going to start being brazenly self interested in the way everyone else seems to be.

There’s only so much you can take from others before they get sick of it really.

Apotofrealcoffee · 12/11/2026 19:12

Ott3r · 12/11/2026 19:09

Because she has a lifelong disability!!!!

As I said are those with physical disabilities only allowed one round of treatment and support?

Without treatment and support she will end up hospitalised. Can’t click my fingers and get rid of what she was born with. Sorry.

My point was therapy just does not get people to a point of total self sufficiency. Maybe in a tiny number of cases but not the majority. It’s very expensive and makes only a marginal difference.

Ott3r · 12/11/2026 19:12

DoAWheelie · 12/11/2026 07:41

This is a proposed cut to the health element of UC, not a change to PIP.

No the BBC is reporting PIP for under 25s will go completely too.

Ott3r · 12/11/2026 19:15

Apotofrealcoffee · 12/11/2026 19:12

My point was therapy just does not get people to a point of total self sufficiency. Maybe in a tiny number of cases but not the majority. It’s very expensive and makes only a marginal difference.

Complete rubbish. Before therapy my daughter was continuously in and out of hospital, dangerously ill and not in education, waiting to die. Now she is in education and trying to work out a career that she will manage with her disability. I know many like her. Thats not a marginal difference, thats massive.

LizzieW1969 · 12/11/2026 19:16

Apotofrealcoffee · 12/11/2026 19:12

My point was therapy just does not get people to a point of total self sufficiency. Maybe in a tiny number of cases but not the majority. It’s very expensive and makes only a marginal difference.

But if it gets people into work, then they start paying taxes, and contributing to society. Surely that’s what we want? Of would you prefer them to remain on benefits and not make a contribution?

SleeplessInWherever · 12/11/2026 19:16

Apotofrealcoffee · 12/11/2026 19:11

If I’m being brutally honest I’m more worried about working adults on the edge with families to support whose hard earned savings are dwindling away as the cost of living engulfs them.

We’ve been ordered to care about ‘the vulnerable’ aka NEETs for so long without any concern flowing back to us, that I’m going to start being brazenly self interested in the way everyone else seems to be.

There’s only so much you can take from others before they get sick of it really.

Ah. The equity of concern argument.

Life isn’t equal, and it’s not fair either.

Some people are born with life limiting conditions. Some people are born with issues that will make engaging with education and employment harder, if not impossible without support.

This is not an even playing field, and some people (including me) had more of a head start than others.

Unfortunately, maybe. But nobody is as concerned about our ability to feed our kids, because they’re fed, and they’re not concerned about our ability to save, because being able to have savings to fall back on is currently a decent place to be.

I don’t expect the same concern as anyone with any level of disability or condition that impacts their daily life, because rightfully - I don’t need it as much.

Might be because I have a disabled child. Makes you more empathetic and less “selfish” as you put it.

Ott3r · 12/11/2026 19:17

Apotofrealcoffee · 12/11/2026 19:11

If I’m being brutally honest I’m more worried about working adults on the edge with families to support whose hard earned savings are dwindling away as the cost of living engulfs them.

We’ve been ordered to care about ‘the vulnerable’ aka NEETs for so long without any concern flowing back to us, that I’m going to start being brazenly self interested in the way everyone else seems to be.

There’s only so much you can take from others before they get sick of it really.

NEETS have parents who are tax payers. When my child isn’t being supported it impacts my ability to work and pay taxes-
massively!

PocketSand · 12/11/2026 19:18

@ThingsAreNotWhatTheyWerekeep it quiet but I have 2 effected sons for whom I have battled above and beyond parents with shy, introverted and a little anxious DC for two decades now. Think beyond day to day care, issues with school, multiple hospital appointments and assessments, EHCP, tribunal, specialist placement, bespoke educational packages etc etc. I think they are talking shit. But emboldened by political rhetoric.

I am pissed off. I don’t agree with cutting disability benefits in general but especially not to young people trying to recover from cuts to CAMHs and education support who are now in the 18-25 cohort. I am playing devils advocate to question why other groups (the wealthy, those receiving top up benefits and the wealthy retired) are untouchable whilst suggesting if no one is untouchable (if the disabled aren’t) then we ought to consider all NHS users subject to the same standard of care - ie no help unless in crisis.

Please create an account

To comment on this thread you need to create a Mumsnet account.

This thread is not accepting new messages.
Swipe left for the next trending thread