Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Milburn review and benefits for 18-24 year olds

1000 replies

ReviewAlternatives · 12/11/2026 07:11

I was just reading about this and have some concerns.

I think a better idea initially would be rather than sinking probably millions into setting a new scheme up the government should be putting that money into CAMHS.

I can see the review mentions support for ‘mild’ ADHD, autism and anxiety but that’s not enough. The whole CAMHS system needs the overhaul and only then with a fit for purpose system should benefit reforms for 18-24 year olds be looked at. To act immediately and include existing claimants is wrong.

AIBU to think this will not work unless they do things the correct way - intensive CAMHS reform initially not during or part of and limited to just ‘mild’ cases of certain issues?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
9
Itchthescratch · 12/11/2026 15:06

BIossomtoes · 12/11/2026 14:59

It’s not unrelated. Both are defrauding the state.

They are unrelated. It will largely be a completely different set of people defrauding the state in a completely different way. The methods used to identify tax evasion will be completely different to identifying and proving PIP fraud. The former is objectively much easier to prove through data matching etc whilst PIP fraud is notoriously difficult without a huge amount of resource and personal intrusion.

Many would argue that morally it's different too. Tax evasion is not paying the tax into the system. Benefit fraud actively removes other taxpayers' money from the system under fake pretences. It also leads to resentment and suspicion of genuine claimants and adds additional burden to an already over burdened systems.

hedgeknight · 12/11/2026 15:06

EasternStandard · 12/11/2026 14:47

It’s also the end of the line on using an uplift in borrowing to resolve the issues and demands. Posts that talk about spending more v cuts or ‘austerity’ are missing that we are not far off the same debt to gdp ratio with £3trn in debt already, and high servicing.

That’s our tax money that could go to other things.

Where would you like to see your tax money being spent on if not helping people at the bottom with living costs and getting into work?

Allseeingallknowing · 12/11/2026 15:07

hedgeknight · 12/11/2026 14:50

Of UC fraud? Doubtful

Unless you believe the stories told on MN about Jane's brother Bill's mate Jack who lives next door to people living the life of Riley on benefits.

Some of us do know families like that!

NippyNips · 12/11/2026 15:07

Itchthescratch · 12/11/2026 15:06

They are unrelated. It will largely be a completely different set of people defrauding the state in a completely different way. The methods used to identify tax evasion will be completely different to identifying and proving PIP fraud. The former is objectively much easier to prove through data matching etc whilst PIP fraud is notoriously difficult without a huge amount of resource and personal intrusion.

Many would argue that morally it's different too. Tax evasion is not paying the tax into the system. Benefit fraud actively removes other taxpayers' money from the system under fake pretences. It also leads to resentment and suspicion of genuine claimants and adds additional burden to an already over burdened systems.

Tax "fraud" is keeping more of your money.

BIossomtoes · 12/11/2026 15:08

NippyNips · 12/11/2026 15:07

Tax "fraud" is keeping more of your money.

No it isn’t, it’s withholding money you owe.

hedgeknight · 12/11/2026 15:09

Allseeingallknowing · 12/11/2026 15:07

Some of us do know families like that!

Some

I am not disputing there are families like that but they are rare. There is no tip of the iceberg.

Itchthescratch · 12/11/2026 15:09

EasternStandard · 12/11/2026 15:02

How would you do it? I agree it’s hard. After receiving it there’d have to be proof the application was fraudulent. Ie look at activity levels etc

That would require an enormous amount of surveillance and intrusion to be workable in most cases. Unless people are stupid enough to post pictures of themselves running marathons on social media then it is virtually impossible. This is why nobody actually has any idea about the level of fraud going on. I imagine a lot of it will be in the grey areas where people aren't entirely lying but also feel like they have to exaggerate a bit and emphasise their bad days and times to be eligible. I suspect many people don't even view this as fraud but simply getting what they are entitled to even though it's quite clear that the complete truth would lead to an unsuccessful claim.

Itchthescratch · 12/11/2026 15:12

BIossomtoes · 12/11/2026 15:08

No it isn’t, it’s withholding money you owe.

Yes, you are not paying what you should but you aren't actively taking other people's money under false pretences. Many view the latter to be more morally reprehensible.

NippyNips · 12/11/2026 15:12

BIossomtoes · 12/11/2026 15:08

No it isn’t, it’s withholding money you owe.

Owe to who? For what? When did I agree to it?

BIossomtoes · 12/11/2026 15:15

Itchthescratch · 12/11/2026 15:12

Yes, you are not paying what you should but you aren't actively taking other people's money under false pretences. Many view the latter to be more morally reprehensible.

And “many” are wrong. Both are as bad as each other.

DoNotComply · 12/11/2026 15:16

Ott3r · 12/11/2026 13:45

Many people are however private is often frankly not as good as NHS, not available for many treatments, can be damaging,doesn’t come with an MDT and is like looking for a needle in a haystack. One of my children receives treatment that has no private alternatives-care from a specialised team. Some therapies like DBT involves group sessions as well as individual and is not available privately, inpatient for things like EDs is a silly amount of money way beyond PIP….

Plus many private practitioners won't take under 18s with serious mental health issues because they don't have the back up of a multi-disciplinary team in a crisis.

Itchthescratch · 12/11/2026 15:18

BIossomtoes · 12/11/2026 15:15

And “many” are wrong. Both are as bad as each other.

No, they aren't wrong. It's subjective and they are neither right or wrong. You also aren't objectively right or wrong either.

I personally see it as the difference between someone not paying to enter an event run by a charity (tax evasion) and someone nicking the collecting tin (benefit fraud). Both wrong but the latter is worse as it is effectively stealing other people's money.

OonaStubbs · 12/11/2026 15:20

Parents would be a lot keener to raise their children to be employable if there wasn't the option of getting them on benefits as soon as they turn 18.

Ohmygiddygirl · 12/11/2026 15:25

BIossomtoes · 12/11/2026 14:52

Benefit fraud is less than unclaimed benefits and is massively overshadowed by tax fraud. Nobody appears to be remotely interested in dealing with that.

Which tax evasion are you talking about? The one where international business people choose to spend on less week in the UK a year and one more in Monaco thus shifting their tax residence because they’re sick of being treated as a cash cow?

Or companies using normal, internationally accepted transfer pricing rules to move their costs to their HQ that is based in a country which doesn’t rinse them dry for taxes?

Or the hairdresser / builders / gardener who takes cash payments?

Because it’s only the latter that is actually evading tax. The top two are tired little tropes wheeled out regularly by those who understand very little about tax. Check out the HMRC website to find out who the real evaders are.

CMMM · 12/11/2026 15:27

Passaggressfedup · 12/11/2026 07:51

My point is if CAMHS was improved these 18-24 year old would likely not need adult services or get to the point of not being able to function
If only it was that simple...

The problem didn't start because cahms suddenly reduced their level of support. As a natter of fact, there was a significant increase in mental health services about 10 years ago.

The problem is parenting and a society that doesn't prepare children for adulthood, and then expect anyone else but themselves to sort out their failure.

I find this really offensive. Autism for example is not down to poor parenting. My son tried to repeatedly kill himself and Camhs did absolutely nothing and provided nothing. We had to privately fund therapy which we could ill afford to save his life. Every day is a struggle but he largely attends school, works hard at his studies with a lot of scaffolding from myself. And we work really hard to grow his social skills and encourage an independent life and focus on working for a living.
I suggest you watch the short film, unauthorised absence and give yourself an education

DeflectionAndWhataboutery · 12/11/2026 15:32

This thread is engagement farming in action people, don't bite.

Badbadbunny · 12/11/2026 15:33

BendyAndTired · 12/11/2026 14:10

@mummymeister without a smartphone, a car and a computer it’s practically impossible to get a job now. Getting a drivers licence and insurance is prohibitively expensive too. Poverty wages means universal credit top ups, which increases the benefits bill, the very thing you’re clamouring to try to reduce.

@Badbadbunny young people do need, and deserve to earn a living wage. Do you know why most 18-25 yr olds are still living at home? Because they can’t afford to move out, and that means parents of adult children are subsidising them one way or another.

Plenty of people of my generation were setting up homes and starting families at 23, 24, but low wages and high cost of living means that’s not possible now.

Yes, once they've been in the workplace for a while, got accustomed to the routine, been trained up, etc., then yes, living wage, but it's unreasonable for employers to have to pay living wage from day one when many of them won't be "productive" in any way, shape nor form until they've been trained to do the work, turn up on time, follow instructions, etc. That's why employers need support, i.e. grants etc to subsidise the worker until they become productive.

frozendaisy · 12/11/2026 15:38

The Briefing Room on radio4 today at 4pm is going to be talking about how can the UK get young people off benefits and into work if anyone wants to/can (although will be available via sounds) have a listen.

theresnolimits · 12/11/2026 15:41

I haven’t RTFT but I think this is the Dutch model that has been much praised. They don’t offer benefits to 18-25 year olds but they do offer tremendous support to get them into work. They build relationships with employers, offer financial incentives and committee support workers. It has been really effective. They say ‘We don’t give up on our young people’.

I don’t see that Dutch society is much different to ours and, although I don’t know officially diagnosed rates of Autism, ADHD etc, I don’t know why they would be much different? The point is that something has to change here to support our young people into fulfilling, productive lives and at least this report is aiming to address that. If it’s done well this probably won’t save money but, in the long term, it could offer enhanced life prospects.

The worry for me is that if we don’t tackle some of these issues head on the whole system (NHS, social care, education) is going to collapse under the weight of the burden and we will be horrified at what we’re left with.

DoNotComply · 12/11/2026 15:44

brownbootsandhats · 12/11/2026 14:28

Was there a golden age of CAMHS or must parents also be picking up some responsibility here ? Have we allowed the outsourcing to professionals of stuff that should be managed by parents ? Is this partly behind the huge growth in demand ?

How exactly do you think parents can manage clinical depression, PTSD or OCD or other serious mental health problems? You can't even get CAMHS to help when your child is suicidal or self-harming, people are not accessing them for minor parenting issues.

Nearly all the money the government has put into mental health in the last couple of decades has gone into the very lowest level of help, usually very time limited CBT. Except in order to even get a referral to CAMHS now you have to be so far past the kind of level where this would help, so you sit on a waiting list for years, then you're offered something completely useless. There's a massive shortage of psychologists and psychiatrists, which is what a lot of these kids need access to.

Rustybike · 12/11/2026 15:45

As encouraging as this appears, I am surprised at the suggestion that the Milburn report will include “People will be given immediate mental health support”.

I do not see the government being able to magic up 1m appointments and then ongoing sessions…

Boomer55 · 12/11/2026 15:48

Well, if this idea gives support to getting younger people into work, and takes them off of benefits, then all good.

We’ll have to wait and see though. 🤷‍♀️

creamycustards · 12/11/2026 15:55

CMMM · 12/11/2026 15:27

I find this really offensive. Autism for example is not down to poor parenting. My son tried to repeatedly kill himself and Camhs did absolutely nothing and provided nothing. We had to privately fund therapy which we could ill afford to save his life. Every day is a struggle but he largely attends school, works hard at his studies with a lot of scaffolding from myself. And we work really hard to grow his social skills and encourage an independent life and focus on working for a living.
I suggest you watch the short film, unauthorised absence and give yourself an education

There will always be cases like your childs, that does not fit into the greater group of people that the statistics represent. It’s not personal.

Those of us that think we have a lot to reflect on as parents, are not talking about every young person. Just most of them. I think most of the NEETs can and should be in work, and have been failed by lazy parenting. This doesn’t mean your son was.

NippyNips · 12/11/2026 15:57

Ohmygiddygirl · 12/11/2026 15:25

Which tax evasion are you talking about? The one where international business people choose to spend on less week in the UK a year and one more in Monaco thus shifting their tax residence because they’re sick of being treated as a cash cow?

Or companies using normal, internationally accepted transfer pricing rules to move their costs to their HQ that is based in a country which doesn’t rinse them dry for taxes?

Or the hairdresser / builders / gardener who takes cash payments?

Because it’s only the latter that is actually evading tax. The top two are tired little tropes wheeled out regularly by those who understand very little about tax. Check out the HMRC website to find out who the real evaders are.

Edited

Exactly. It's SMEs and sole traders

Please create an account

To comment on this thread you need to create a Mumsnet account.

This thread is not accepting new messages.