Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To not follow SIL’s parenting rules for my kids

1000 replies

InconsidetateSillySIL · 11/11/2026 13:44

I have three children aged 7, 5 and 2. My husband’s sister has one child, aged 2. She’s a single mum by choice.

My SIL has quite strong parenting preferences. She’s very anti-plastic toys and prefers everything to be wooden and pastel-coloured. She’s also very anti-screens and doesn’t allow sweets. That’s absolutely her choice, and I’m not criticising how she chooses to raise her child. My children, however, are fairly typical kids. We have brightly coloured plastic toys, toy swords, all sorts of things, and I don’t have a strict no-screen policy. I’m not saying they’ll be glued to an iPad all Christmas, but equally I’m not going to promise that they won’t have any screen time at all. I certainly won’t stop my children having chocolate or a mince pie on Christmas Day (especially the two eldest).

We’re all spending Christmas Day at my in-laws’ house, and SIL has messaged me saying that she appreciates we all have different parenting styles, but she’d prefer it if we didn’t bring any plastic toys, particularly around her toddler, and asked if we could have no screens for the duration of our stay to avoid a situation where her child might join in and watch something, and no sweet treats within sight of her child. I honestly don’t know how to respond. I have no intention of deliberately putting things in front of her child that she doesn’t want him playing with, I’m happy to respect her rules for the gifts to her child and I’m happy to be sensible and considerate. But I don’t think it’s reasonable to expect me to restrict what my own children can bring or play with or eat because she has decided that certain toys and activities aren’t acceptable for hers.

I feel like everyone in the family tends to bend over backwards to accommodate SIL’s preferences (because she’s had a traumatic few years in terms of love life and decided to have a baby solo), and I’m starting to resent the expectation that the rest of us should just go along with everything to avoid upsetting her. Would it be unreasonable to reply along the lines of “I completely respect that you have different rules for your child, I will of course respect your wishes for Freddie’s gifts (ie not gifting Freddie a brightly coloured plastic toy, an iPad, a chocolate Santa) but I can’t promise to follow those same rules with mine. I’ll obviously be considerate, but I need to parent my own children in the way that works for us.”

Or am I being unnecessarily difficult? It’s Christmas, and I don’t want to create family tension, but I also don’t want to spend the whole day feeling like I’m being told how to parent my children.

OP posts:
Blindinglybaffled · 12/11/2026 07:32

Gosh - your dh is a total chocolate tea pot isn’t he?! If he’s not capable of sticking up for his own kids & you then that’s pathetic. I‘m in the just don’t go camp - sounds like it has the potential to be drama filled anyway so if SIL can’t be sensible at this point I’d not bother. SIL & MIL need to grow the feck up.

Scottishskifun · 12/11/2026 07:34

Given her response I wouldn't engage any further and a simple they are children it's Christmas will suffice if she really pushes it.

If MIL wades in then the same a simple it's Christmas I'm not going to tell them to not play with their toys or have a treat if they wish.

Out of interest does SIL and nephew had dessert at Xmas? As surely that's full of sugar.
I'm also guessing nephew must attend a montessori nursery as most other settings include plastic toys.

I did used to ask for wooden toys for DS1 and DS2 when they were little but more to reduce the volume of plastic tat in the house.

I do suggest leaving plastic swords at home though.

Notquitethetruth · 12/11/2026 07:35

Your husband is putting the demands of his sister before his wife and children. That is a serious statement from him. I would calmly tell him you have considered what he said very carefully and would tell him that he should do likewise.
The implications of his words are far reaching leading to some serious questions. Who are the most important people in his life and who he is prioritising? It seems his sister and her demands for her nephew are No. 1. If this is not dealt with and some clear boundaries established, it will continue to dominate all your family dynamics going forward. You deserve better, your children deserve better. Your children should not have to have their happiness dictated to by their aunt. They should grow up without fond memories of Christmas. Not remembering a miserable time where they couldn't play with whatever toy they wanted to, couldn't eat chocolate, couldn't watch a film or cartoon because Daddy agreed with his sister. Meanwhile Mum was sitting there clearly unhappy as they were.
Withdraw from Christmas at your PIL. Let your husband attend if he wants to. Enjoy a happy Christmas with your children doing what they want. Red line time!

Billy47 · 12/11/2026 07:36

Your husband is as manipulative as his mum and his sister. He made the issue your tone instead of his sisters batshit demands. He cares more about not upsetting his mum and his sister than he does about upsetting you and his kids. That would give me the ick. Honestly, I couldn't live with coming second to them and their nonsense at the kids' expense. That's something to think about in the new year. Anyway, my suggestion is that you skip it all together and stay home. It will kick off but its going to kick off anyway or book a hotel and limit your time with his family so your kids dont miss out. You could get a little mini tree. Do presents their. Go to in-laws after midday once you've opened all your presents, watched some Christmas TV and done what you want. Leave the in-laws at the earliest possible time and go back to the hotel watch Christmas films and gorge on chocolate.

Your husband is yhe biggest problem here. You need to stop being the path of least resistance. Either fight for what you want or divorce the spineless idiot.

Chenecinquantecinq · 12/11/2026 07:37

She sounds an absolute nightmare and you sound like a saint

Yodeldodeldo · 12/11/2026 07:39

For the sake of peace I would grin and bear it for one year. By next year her child will probably be in nursery and then primary school and she'll probably have caved on her principles.

Tinyterrier · 12/11/2026 07:40

Also, her 2 yr old’s needs are not the same as a 5 & 7 yr old’s. It’s totally unfair of her to compare them. At 2, I wouldn’t have let my kids have chocolate or sweets either, or a tablet. I didn’t mind tv, but they didn’t have the understanding or attention span to watch tv at that age anyway and weren’t interested. However now they’re 5 and 6 they get plenty of sweets, chocolate and Christmas films at Christmas cos that’s what it’s all about at the end of the day. It’s like saying “I’m gluten intolerant so I can’t have a Yorkshire pudding with my Christmas dinner, so can everyone else please not have one either?” !!

DrinkFeckArseBrick · 12/11/2026 07:41

Very unimpressed with the husbands response on this. "He accused me of being sarcastic, deliberately making things difficult and dramatising the situation". The OP had a batshit request from the SIL, sent a perfectly reasonable response back saying that she won't be restricting her children's enjoyment of Christmas day, and the SIL has piled on the emotional manipulation. The OP has given her husband various options and pointed out potential consequences. But it seems the husbands preference would be to pander to the batshittery to the detriment of his own kids. Yes it's only a bit of chocolate this time but if this pattern is allowed to continue there is no way that it won't escalate. It's really unhealthy that everyone in thr husbands family is so scared of upsetting SIL that they'd rather blame other people for not going through with her unreasonable demands. I'd be raging at him for turning my reasonable response to her mental message into something that was somehow my fault.

Planningatripsoon · 12/11/2026 07:42

I think no screens is fine. They can watch Christmas movies on the TV - more sociable. But the rest of it, no way. Is your husband normally so weird about his family?

Passingthroughagain · 12/11/2026 07:43

Your DH is the problem. He should be telling his parents and sister in no uncertain terms that his children will be allowed screen time and chocolate and to play with their new toys and it's for SIL to manage Freddie's expectations according to her wishes.

Failing that, I'd be staying at home with the kids and having the most chocolatey, plasticky Xmas imaginable. Sod the fallout - why should your DC suffer because their dad is a conflict-avoidant coward?

HAPPILYMARRIEDSINCE2012 · 12/11/2026 07:44

EstoyRobandoSuCasa · 11/11/2026 23:52

Don’t forget to remind MIL that your children will hardly be able to have any of the presents they’ve asked for, “they’re going to be so upset” and also how hurt you are that SIL thinks your children aren’t happy and healthy. Show that you’re even more upset than SIL by sobbing for longer and more loudly than her.

I’m only half joking.

This and this

WhereAreTheTrueGreens · 12/11/2026 07:45

MJagain · 11/11/2026 13:53

I think you shut this down more firmly. I’d say something like you respect her choices for her 2yo but your family dynamics are entirely different. No sane person treats a 7yo eldest of 3 siblings the same as a solo 2yo. He’s hardly going to play with wooden blocks all Xmas?!
Just say the different children have different boundaries and needs, approropriate to their age & maturity. You will respect hers but she also needs to respect yours.

This is just right

NapsForTheWin · 12/11/2026 07:45

Yodeldodeldo · 12/11/2026 07:39

For the sake of peace I would grin and bear it for one year. By next year her child will probably be in nursery and then primary school and she'll probably have caved on her principles.

Peace for who? OP won't have any peace if she restricts her kids' normal fun at Christmas. They'll be upset.

fashionqueen0123 · 12/11/2026 07:45

InconsidetateSillySIL · 11/11/2026 23:45

Thanks everyone! I really wasn’t expecting so many replies, and I’m grateful for all the advice and suggestions. Just to answer a few questions:

Christmas is at my PILs’ house, not SIL’s, although they live within walking distance. We’ll be staying overnight at PILs, so technically we could have chocolates or watch a Christmas film when Freddie isn’t around. But there are two issues with that. Firstly, we don’t know when he’ll leave, as he has a bedroom at PILs and could easily end up napping or sleeping overnight there. Secondly, I really don’t want to create a whole thing around perfectly normal Christmas activities or food for my children. Why should they have to hide their toys, or secretly scoff their chocolate before Freddie arrives? Why can’t they simply enjoy their Christmas while he’s there?

Not going isn’t really an option. That would mean tears from MIL, accusations that we’re depriving everyone of Christmas and, ultimately, DH having to deal with the fallout.

I’ve decided not to respond to SIL any further, at least for now, as several of you suggested. I think my position is clear and there’s not much more to say.
I did show the entire exchange to DH and explained that I’m genuinely concerned about how much we’re upsetting SIL by having different approaches to parenting. As his family often remind us, we need to look out for her and make sure she isn’t upset.
But, equally, I’m concerned about my own children. What if they’re upset because they can’t have the presents they’ve been looking forward to, or can’t play with their “forbidden” new toys? What if they want a Christmas treat, or to watch a festive film when they’re tired and can’t?
I said that perhaps the only way to avoid upsetting anyone is for us to simply not go. Although I’m not sure whether that would cause upset too!
I said all of this quite matter of factly, but DH wasn’t impressed. He accused me of being sarcastic, deliberately making things difficult and dramatising the situation. I asked him what exactly I was dramatising. People get upset, don’t they?

I’m honestly struggling to understand why SIL’s feelings seem to require so much consideration, while the impact on our own children is barely being discussed. Maybe I’ll just take a leaf out of SIL’s book and get upset when something doesn’t go my (or my kids’) way but trouble is DH knows me and knows I’m not a psycho.

Well yes why should a grown woman come before your little kids. I’d not reply to anymore daft messages and carry on as normal. And I’d make sure my kids were opening massive selection boxes

the7Vabo · 12/11/2026 07:49

Yodeldodeldo · 12/11/2026 07:39

For the sake of peace I would grin and bear it for one year. By next year her child will probably be in nursery and then primary school and she'll probably have caved on her principles.

I woundnt. The woman has no boundaries. She rang mummy upset that her brother wouldn’t cancel his plans to go to her 6 month old’s last minute “birthday”. And instead of telling her to get a grip mummy indulged her because poor poor SIL. And she feels entitled to bring up that they can afford Disney - what about poor her.

I think Op panders to her too much already.

SIL wants “Freddie’s only family” as her support system but she wants to also make demands of them - cancel plans, feel guilty about being able to afford Disney, adjust Christmas. It’s all about her.

the7Vabo · 12/11/2026 07:50

Planningatripsoon · 12/11/2026 07:42

I think no screens is fine. They can watch Christmas movies on the TV - more sociable. But the rest of it, no way. Is your husband normally so weird about his family?

A TV is a screen! I doubt SIL would be cool with that!

KindlySurfiingPlatypus · 12/11/2026 07:51

Absolutely yanbu.

In her own home she can have her own rules, and you can respect those rules but choose to not spend much time there.

Outside her home she is not in charge.

"Dear SiL. We absolutely respect your parenting decisions for your own child, and wouldn't criticise or try to change your mind. However it is not reasonable for you to ask our family to live by your rules for the duration of our stay with PiL. That isn't being respectful of different styles. We certainly will be allowing our children to enjoy favourite toys and modest amounts of screen time within reason. We would not stay for an extended period anywhere where these things weren't allowed at all - the kids are perfectly happy to be in situations where these rules apply for a few hours but any more than that would be perceived as a punishment and we will not do that to them at Christmas. We are happy to try to limit how much (herkidsname) is exposed to things you aren't happy with, within reason, but our children aren't going to spend Christmas without things that they enjoy."

MangoSalsa6 · 12/11/2026 07:53

"I'm sorry you feel that way, but you and your child are not intrinsically more important than my children. I appreciate you are parenting solo but that doesn't give you carte blanche to dictate every situation. It's Christmas and my children will be extremely upset if they're forced to not have any of the toys or food they like for reasons that won't make sense to them. I'm not sure why you think your rules should override their feelings? Why is it acceptable for my children to be upset but not yours?"

Then tell DH to stop being a massive wet flannel and advocate for his kids. And also burst into tears every time SIL and MIL so much as look at you and say you can't stop thinking about how Christmas for your children has already been ruined. They all sound batshit.

Tinyterrier · 12/11/2026 07:54

InconsidetateSillySIL · 11/11/2026 15:01

She’s replied…

I just don’t understand why his cousins can’t make a few small adjustments for Freddie, especially when they’re older and should understand. He’s my only child and you guys plus our parents are the only family he has. I just want him to feel included and not like he has to be around things that I’m trying so hard to avoid for him. I don’t think it’s unreasonable to expect a bit of support from family, especially when I’m doing this on my own. I want him to grow up healthy and happy. It honestly makes me quite sad x

The “it honestly makes me quite sad” is SO manipulative! I can’t bear people like this. They guilt-trip to get their own way then throw a tantrum if that doesn’t work - this has clearly worked for her her whole life, unfortunately I think it’s going to have to be you that breaks the cycle, cos not likely any of his people pleasing family are going to. Personally I’d tell her I find her message quite manipulative and don’t appreciate it. I’d send one more message, saying something along the lines of I’m going to give my kids the Christmas I want to give them and that it’s her responsibility to give her child the Christmas she wants to give him and to keep him away from anything she doesn’t want him involved in. Also, point out that a 2, 5, and 7 yr old are not going to “understand” why they “shouldn’t” bring their toys/watch tv etc

MadinMarch · 12/11/2026 07:54

Holeymoley28 · 11/11/2026 16:29

Good angle.

Sister in law are you saying that my children are not happy and healthy? Are you saying I don’t want the best for my children? I feel rather insulted at your suggestion and as such will not be continuing this conversation any further for you to just insult my children and my parenting. You deal with your child and I will deal with mine but do not come to me again with such insults on myself and children and expect me to pander to your ways.

Edited

I'd sorely tempted to reply with this. Her message gives OP the opportunity to set out her stance and establish it for the future, as the situation is only going to get worse I suspect. It might help sil actually start to question her rigid parenting style and whether it's workable around other families.
I can't help but feel very sorry for Freddie, who is likely going to be isolated throughout his childhood because of his mother's endeavours.

Sortingmyself · 12/11/2026 07:55

InconsidetateSillySIL · 11/11/2026 23:45

Thanks everyone! I really wasn’t expecting so many replies, and I’m grateful for all the advice and suggestions. Just to answer a few questions:

Christmas is at my PILs’ house, not SIL’s, although they live within walking distance. We’ll be staying overnight at PILs, so technically we could have chocolates or watch a Christmas film when Freddie isn’t around. But there are two issues with that. Firstly, we don’t know when he’ll leave, as he has a bedroom at PILs and could easily end up napping or sleeping overnight there. Secondly, I really don’t want to create a whole thing around perfectly normal Christmas activities or food for my children. Why should they have to hide their toys, or secretly scoff their chocolate before Freddie arrives? Why can’t they simply enjoy their Christmas while he’s there?

Not going isn’t really an option. That would mean tears from MIL, accusations that we’re depriving everyone of Christmas and, ultimately, DH having to deal with the fallout.

I’ve decided not to respond to SIL any further, at least for now, as several of you suggested. I think my position is clear and there’s not much more to say.
I did show the entire exchange to DH and explained that I’m genuinely concerned about how much we’re upsetting SIL by having different approaches to parenting. As his family often remind us, we need to look out for her and make sure she isn’t upset.
But, equally, I’m concerned about my own children. What if they’re upset because they can’t have the presents they’ve been looking forward to, or can’t play with their “forbidden” new toys? What if they want a Christmas treat, or to watch a festive film when they’re tired and can’t?
I said that perhaps the only way to avoid upsetting anyone is for us to simply not go. Although I’m not sure whether that would cause upset too!
I said all of this quite matter of factly, but DH wasn’t impressed. He accused me of being sarcastic, deliberately making things difficult and dramatising the situation. I asked him what exactly I was dramatising. People get upset, don’t they?

I’m honestly struggling to understand why SIL’s feelings seem to require so much consideration, while the impact on our own children is barely being discussed. Maybe I’ll just take a leaf out of SIL’s book and get upset when something doesn’t go my (or my kids’) way but trouble is DH knows me and knows I’m not a psycho.

So his sister and his nephew are more important than you, his wife, and his own children? Wow. That would have me digging my heels in, all the more. I would ask him why his SIL needs trump mine and his own kids?

I'd show him this thread OP, you've been far from sarcastic and a drama llama...

but personally I'd try not to go at all, but if you do are you able to just limit it to a couple of hours rather than a 2 night stop over? (Sorry if youve already explained why this isn't an option)

JoshLymanSwagger · 12/11/2026 07:56

@InconsidetateSillySIL Please please please buy Freddie the biggest, brightest and loudest piece of plastic you can find.

A drum kit? Little Tykes car? Play kitchen? with bonus points for extra plastic food?

And don't forget the industrial sized bucket of Haribo. 😁

Because you're so thoughtful, don't forget to have "FREDDIE" in bloody enormous bright letters written on each one...just to make sure his age-appropriate gifts don't get mixed up with your youngests gifts.

I'm sure the hive-minds of MN are happy to help with gift suggestions that SIL will treasure for all eternity. 🤣

ParisBalloons · 12/11/2026 07:56

Planningatripsoon · 12/11/2026 07:42

I think no screens is fine. They can watch Christmas movies on the TV - more sociable. But the rest of it, no way. Is your husband normally so weird about his family?

The tv is a screen and OP has said it's banned too under SIL's rules - no Christmas cartoons or movies allowed.

I really want to know what this means for adult Christmas too - no Strictly special, no Christmas pudding? Is Father Christmas allowed a mince pie left out by the stockings? Or does everyone have to follow toddler rules?

ChangeMyHair · 12/11/2026 07:59

I can see where she's coming from. She doesn't want that stuff introduced to her kid. Once they've had it, its harder to take away. Its like the kids that only eat chicken nuggets, if they've never had them, they'll never know what they are.

JoshLymanSwagger · 12/11/2026 07:59

ParisBalloons · 12/11/2026 07:56

The tv is a screen and OP has said it's banned too under SIL's rules - no Christmas cartoons or movies allowed.

I really want to know what this means for adult Christmas too - no Strictly special, no Christmas pudding? Is Father Christmas allowed a mince pie left out by the stockings? Or does everyone have to follow toddler rules?

No Carols from Kings on Christmas Eve...no Kings Speech...

NO DIE HARD??!!!?!? 🤬

Please create an account

To comment on this thread you need to create a Mumsnet account.

This thread is not accepting new messages.
Swipe left for the next trending thread