Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To not follow SIL’s parenting rules for my kids

1000 replies

InconsidetateSillySIL · 11/11/2026 13:44

I have three children aged 7, 5 and 2. My husband’s sister has one child, aged 2. She’s a single mum by choice.

My SIL has quite strong parenting preferences. She’s very anti-plastic toys and prefers everything to be wooden and pastel-coloured. She’s also very anti-screens and doesn’t allow sweets. That’s absolutely her choice, and I’m not criticising how she chooses to raise her child. My children, however, are fairly typical kids. We have brightly coloured plastic toys, toy swords, all sorts of things, and I don’t have a strict no-screen policy. I’m not saying they’ll be glued to an iPad all Christmas, but equally I’m not going to promise that they won’t have any screen time at all. I certainly won’t stop my children having chocolate or a mince pie on Christmas Day (especially the two eldest).

We’re all spending Christmas Day at my in-laws’ house, and SIL has messaged me saying that she appreciates we all have different parenting styles, but she’d prefer it if we didn’t bring any plastic toys, particularly around her toddler, and asked if we could have no screens for the duration of our stay to avoid a situation where her child might join in and watch something, and no sweet treats within sight of her child. I honestly don’t know how to respond. I have no intention of deliberately putting things in front of her child that she doesn’t want him playing with, I’m happy to respect her rules for the gifts to her child and I’m happy to be sensible and considerate. But I don’t think it’s reasonable to expect me to restrict what my own children can bring or play with or eat because she has decided that certain toys and activities aren’t acceptable for hers.

I feel like everyone in the family tends to bend over backwards to accommodate SIL’s preferences (because she’s had a traumatic few years in terms of love life and decided to have a baby solo), and I’m starting to resent the expectation that the rest of us should just go along with everything to avoid upsetting her. Would it be unreasonable to reply along the lines of “I completely respect that you have different rules for your child, I will of course respect your wishes for Freddie’s gifts (ie not gifting Freddie a brightly coloured plastic toy, an iPad, a chocolate Santa) but I can’t promise to follow those same rules with mine. I’ll obviously be considerate, but I need to parent my own children in the way that works for us.”

Or am I being unnecessarily difficult? It’s Christmas, and I don’t want to create family tension, but I also don’t want to spend the whole day feeling like I’m being told how to parent my children.

OP posts:
Footpainconstant · 12/11/2026 05:04

i would do all usual parenting in the day - but expect your husband to do all the explanations and deal with any fallout when your kids are not allowed chocolate etc.

he won’t stand up to his family - he can deal with the consequences of these decisions.

I’d tell him that in advance and say you will be having no part in it - if he wants to enforce these stupid roles to pacify his ridiculous family - then he needs to explain them and pacify his kids.

I’d just focus on playing with them etc and leave all explanations / fall out to him.

personally I would rather not go to what sounds like such as joyless event. If the mil and sil cry - so be it. They are causing all these problems by being so rigid and they need to own their choices as adults and not put in the tears as if they were 2 .

PollyBell · 12/11/2026 05:08

overnightangel · 12/11/2026 05:03

Just wait til little Freddie starts school, is SIL going to stand at the gates every day and check the other 29 kids’ lunchboxes having already been in the classroom to ensure there’s nothing plastic in the toybox?

I’d be tempted to say “the only thing more unsustainable than the plastic tat I’ve bought my children is your approach to parenting”

I have visions of standing at the school gate checking all the kids bags to make sure her little darling doesn't come into contact with anything normal before the poor child goes off to their therapist, this level of control is not normal and yes i think the mother has some other issues going on

Lacksie · 12/11/2026 05:09

InconsidetateSillySIL · 11/11/2026 23:45

Thanks everyone! I really wasn’t expecting so many replies, and I’m grateful for all the advice and suggestions. Just to answer a few questions:

Christmas is at my PILs’ house, not SIL’s, although they live within walking distance. We’ll be staying overnight at PILs, so technically we could have chocolates or watch a Christmas film when Freddie isn’t around. But there are two issues with that. Firstly, we don’t know when he’ll leave, as he has a bedroom at PILs and could easily end up napping or sleeping overnight there. Secondly, I really don’t want to create a whole thing around perfectly normal Christmas activities or food for my children. Why should they have to hide their toys, or secretly scoff their chocolate before Freddie arrives? Why can’t they simply enjoy their Christmas while he’s there?

Not going isn’t really an option. That would mean tears from MIL, accusations that we’re depriving everyone of Christmas and, ultimately, DH having to deal with the fallout.

I’ve decided not to respond to SIL any further, at least for now, as several of you suggested. I think my position is clear and there’s not much more to say.
I did show the entire exchange to DH and explained that I’m genuinely concerned about how much we’re upsetting SIL by having different approaches to parenting. As his family often remind us, we need to look out for her and make sure she isn’t upset.
But, equally, I’m concerned about my own children. What if they’re upset because they can’t have the presents they’ve been looking forward to, or can’t play with their “forbidden” new toys? What if they want a Christmas treat, or to watch a festive film when they’re tired and can’t?
I said that perhaps the only way to avoid upsetting anyone is for us to simply not go. Although I’m not sure whether that would cause upset too!
I said all of this quite matter of factly, but DH wasn’t impressed. He accused me of being sarcastic, deliberately making things difficult and dramatising the situation. I asked him what exactly I was dramatising. People get upset, don’t they?

I’m honestly struggling to understand why SIL’s feelings seem to require so much consideration, while the impact on our own children is barely being discussed. Maybe I’ll just take a leaf out of SIL’s book and get upset when something doesn’t go my (or my kids’) way but trouble is DH knows me and knows I’m not a psycho.

but trouble is DH knows me and knows I’m not a psycho

Are you calling your SIL a "psycho"?

Your SIL is being completely unreasonable, on the other hand she's clearly struggling emotionally being a single mum with a sperm donor etc.
Obviously those were her choices so a tough love attitude says you made your bed, etc. But a more compassionate perspective might consider the fact that her child is only 2, it's her first baby, she's still in the thick of adjusting to being a new parent and that experience brings up so much psychological mess and trauma for people . On top of that she's obviously struggling with the extra burden of feeling like she's failed already by not providing the traditional blue print family for her child.

I think you could step outside yourself a bit, have a bit of empathy and avoid escalating the situation. Maybe let your DH deal with your SIL if you can't tolerate doing that.
Absolutely don't make changes to how your kids do Christmas, but just ease off the character assassination/ judgement maybe?.

The best thing ultimately would be to help her see that her family of 2 is absolutely enough, and that she can relax on her rules and trying to be the perfect parent, and allow herself to just enjoy being a mum like any other .

I appreciate mumsnet will hate me for this perspective , so go on y'all have at it about how #bekind is the worst 😂.

PollyBell · 12/11/2026 05:14

Lacksie · 12/11/2026 05:09

but trouble is DH knows me and knows I’m not a psycho

Are you calling your SIL a "psycho"?

Your SIL is being completely unreasonable, on the other hand she's clearly struggling emotionally being a single mum with a sperm donor etc.
Obviously those were her choices so a tough love attitude says you made your bed, etc. But a more compassionate perspective might consider the fact that her child is only 2, it's her first baby, she's still in the thick of adjusting to being a new parent and that experience brings up so much psychological mess and trauma for people . On top of that she's obviously struggling with the extra burden of feeling like she's failed already by not providing the traditional blue print family for her child.

I think you could step outside yourself a bit, have a bit of empathy and avoid escalating the situation. Maybe let your DH deal with your SIL if you can't tolerate doing that.
Absolutely don't make changes to how your kids do Christmas, but just ease off the character assassination/ judgement maybe?.

The best thing ultimately would be to help her see that her family of 2 is absolutely enough, and that she can relax on her rules and trying to be the perfect parent, and allow herself to just enjoy being a mum like any other .

I appreciate mumsnet will hate me for this perspective , so go on y'all have at it about how #bekind is the worst 😂.

The SIL can raise her poor child the way she wants ahe has no right to dictate to anyone else what they do

And yes the child will have issues growing up all because of the deliberate choices of the parent, a child is not a social experiment

NapsForTheWin · 12/11/2026 05:23

Lacksie · 12/11/2026 05:09

but trouble is DH knows me and knows I’m not a psycho

Are you calling your SIL a "psycho"?

Your SIL is being completely unreasonable, on the other hand she's clearly struggling emotionally being a single mum with a sperm donor etc.
Obviously those were her choices so a tough love attitude says you made your bed, etc. But a more compassionate perspective might consider the fact that her child is only 2, it's her first baby, she's still in the thick of adjusting to being a new parent and that experience brings up so much psychological mess and trauma for people . On top of that she's obviously struggling with the extra burden of feeling like she's failed already by not providing the traditional blue print family for her child.

I think you could step outside yourself a bit, have a bit of empathy and avoid escalating the situation. Maybe let your DH deal with your SIL if you can't tolerate doing that.
Absolutely don't make changes to how your kids do Christmas, but just ease off the character assassination/ judgement maybe?.

The best thing ultimately would be to help her see that her family of 2 is absolutely enough, and that she can relax on her rules and trying to be the perfect parent, and allow herself to just enjoy being a mum like any other .

I appreciate mumsnet will hate me for this perspective , so go on y'all have at it about how #bekind is the worst 😂.

Even people making different rules for their children know they can't force it on everyone else. I preferred toys made of natural materials when my children were younger but they'd have missed out on a lot if I hadn't allowed any other toys.

SIL can't feel she has failed to provide a nuclear family. She chose to be a single mother.

Parents are free to make whatever choices they want but also understand they can't expect everyone else to follow those rules for their own children. In OP's place I'd just not go citing that it would be a miserable Christmas for my own children.

I can support not having screens (it's time to spend with families) but a few treats at Christmas and toys the children will enjoy that don't fit SIL's requirements are where I'd draw the line.

You can be kind while having your own boundaries. In this case, it's not unkind to say that you support the right of SIL to do things her own way, but you are not going to follow her rules with your own children.

OneoftheWeddingPeople · 12/11/2026 05:26

I think the “be kind” virtuous poster has a point but demanding a wooden toy only sugar free Christmas if other people’s kids is really taking it too far!

She sounds like a time traveller from
tbe Puritan times.

NapsForTheWin · 12/11/2026 05:35

OneoftheWeddingPeople · 12/11/2026 05:26

I think the “be kind” virtuous poster has a point but demanding a wooden toy only sugar free Christmas if other people’s kids is really taking it too far!

She sounds like a time traveller from
tbe Puritan times.

What about being kind to OP's kids? Giving them a very restricted Christmas isn't going to be much fun for them. SIL will have to either release a day isn't going to do any harm or deal with enforcing her rules for her own child, even if he has a wobbly.

PollyBell · 12/11/2026 05:36

OneoftheWeddingPeople · 12/11/2026 05:26

I think the “be kind” virtuous poster has a point but demanding a wooden toy only sugar free Christmas if other people’s kids is really taking it too far!

She sounds like a time traveller from
tbe Puritan times.

Why is "be kind' always only one way?

Lacksie · 12/11/2026 05:47

NapsForTheWin · 12/11/2026 05:35

What about being kind to OP's kids? Giving them a very restricted Christmas isn't going to be much fun for them. SIL will have to either release a day isn't going to do any harm or deal with enforcing her rules for her own child, even if he has a wobbly.

But I don't think OP should change what she does for her kids- she should stick to Christmas as she's planned. I just think she should drop the judgement a bit.
It's obvious SIL is comparing herself , feeling inadequate and trying to overcompensate for that with these rigid rules.
She needs a bit of support and time to get used to her situation I reckon.

110APiccadilly · 12/11/2026 06:02

As a parent who tries to be very low screens (though I can't imagine messaging my SIL to ask her to not let her own kids use them!) it can be tricky if other kids are engrossed in screens. Honestly, I think anyone (adult or child) doing more than checking their phone briefly at a family gathering is being rude in general.

As a compromise on screens, is there another room your kids could use them in? I.e., "Yes, Tim, you can play Minecraft for a bit but could you go in the dining room to do it please." Then if SIL doesn't want her kid around the screen, she can enforce the boundary that he stays in the living room. I'd be more than happy with that myself.

I think the other stuff is mad though - you particularly can't expect no one to be eating sweet things at Christmas!

the7Vabo · 12/11/2026 06:05

PollyBell · 12/11/2026 05:36

Why is "be kind' always only one way?

SIL is emotionally manipulative and self centred. That’s the core of the issue.

And if you have a child via sperm donor you signed up to do it alone. It doesn’t give you a right to guilt trip your SIL about trips you can’t afford and rudely say you are bringing your child up happy & healthy. SIL is only interested in SIL, OP’s kids are dismissed as “older” ie not important.

But DH is the biggest issue as he expects Op to fall in line & indulge SIL.

NapsForTheWin · 12/11/2026 06:06

Lacksie · 12/11/2026 05:47

But I don't think OP should change what she does for her kids- she should stick to Christmas as she's planned. I just think she should drop the judgement a bit.
It's obvious SIL is comparing herself , feeling inadequate and trying to overcompensate for that with these rigid rules.
She needs a bit of support and time to get used to her situation I reckon.

I don't think that's obvious at all. I think it seems more likely SIL has an anxiety disorder that is affecting her parenting.

JJMama · 12/11/2026 06:08

MIL and SIL are gonna boo boo about something anyway. May as well not go and at least your children will have a decent Christmas. DH can manage the emotions from his batshit family.

the7Vabo · 12/11/2026 06:14

Lacksie · 12/11/2026 05:47

But I don't think OP should change what she does for her kids- she should stick to Christmas as she's planned. I just think she should drop the judgement a bit.
It's obvious SIL is comparing herself , feeling inadequate and trying to overcompensate for that with these rigid rules.
She needs a bit of support and time to get used to her situation I reckon.

Why is SIL not expected to be as adult but OP is? My sister goes on far more holidays than I do, should I throw a strop about same at our next family gathering?

Op has her own 3 kids Inc a 2 year old. Why is she expected to be supportive to an adult woman who doesn’t return it.

It’s fairly normal not to give a 2 year old screens and sweets. It’s not normal to make that someone else’s priority at Christmas.

And to top it all off SIL will run crying to mummy who will cry to DH, and OP will be the big bad wolf.

Comeinsideforacupoftea · 12/11/2026 06:18

OP are you really going to survive 3 days of this including Christmas morning (?!) I'd rigidly stick to your guns 'This is my kid's Christmas too. They are not going to spend the leadup to Christmas, Christmas day and boxing day not playing with the Christmas toys they've been given and not eating any sweets' The only one I might compromise on is the screen time as I personally do think it's a bit rude for kids to sit there on a screen when they're meant to be socialising and there's other kids to play with but otherwise be firm with your boundaries.

If SIL doubles down the switch the approach. 'So sorry SIL but I'm concerned that we aren't going to reach a compromise here. It is a priority for my kids to have a lovely, relaxed Christmas and this isn't going to happen if the're expected to only play with things and eat things that your 2YO does. I think it would be best if we just visit for a couple of hours on boxing day and then we can absolutely respect your rules but expecting my kids to follow these rules all Christmas isn't going to work for us' I'd then direct all drama towards DH telling him he can do as he sees fit for himself but being firm that you will not be subjecting the kids to this for prolonged lengths of time.

TeensNoMore · 12/11/2026 06:18

Compromise.
Screens in a chill out room that Freddie doesn't have access to.
Plastic toys for 1 day won't harm Freddie if he sees them.
No toy swords whilst at PIL, they are a safety risk anyway with over excited children and toddlers.
Sweets, SIL has to say no to Freddie, but equally maybe make sure tins etc are out of his reach.

AlertCat · 12/11/2026 06:18

So you go. Every time the children want chocolate, or ask why their toys and gifts are so shit, you shrug and look at their dad, GPs, and Aunty Jane to explain. Or you say “sorry guys, those are the rules here.”

Then after Christmas, if they had a terrible time, you say, ok DH, we’ve done your family’s shit Christmas, but I’m not doing it to the kids again. He wants to enforce those rules again? He can do all the work to persuade them. Lay the blame for this where it belongs. Let the family see the effects of the rules they’ve chosen.

the7Vabo · 12/11/2026 06:21

NapsForTheWin · 12/11/2026 06:06

I don't think that's obvious at all. I think it seems more likely SIL has an anxiety disorder that is affecting her parenting.

Which bit of her anxiety disorder had her ringing her mother to bitch about her brother not attending her child’s 6 month “birthday” at the last minute. Or making people feel bad she can’t afford Disney.

If you decide to have a baby via sperm donor they will be brought up without their father. That isn’t a decision that should be taken lightly. It was up to SIL to decide whether to take that on alone or not and now that she has actually step up without demanding others cancel plans or make her a priority.

PollyBell · 12/11/2026 06:22

TeensNoMore · 12/11/2026 06:18

Compromise.
Screens in a chill out room that Freddie doesn't have access to.
Plastic toys for 1 day won't harm Freddie if he sees them.
No toy swords whilst at PIL, they are a safety risk anyway with over excited children and toddlers.
Sweets, SIL has to say no to Freddie, but equally maybe make sure tins etc are out of his reach.

Why does the op have to compromise and not the sil?

cooldarkroom · 12/11/2026 06:24

These “small adjustments” she wants define all 3 days for your 3 children.
Your children can sit & read a book while waiting for the Turkey dinner…
Even board games (have plastic tokens etc) will cause a problem because a 2 year old cant play.
Whatever you do has to have everyone bowing to her demands if not you are “mean”.
Honestly I’d ask her how your 3 kids will be allowed to occupy themselves while everyone tip toes round her rules ? Or will she permit them to go & play in a bedroom where her kid is excluded ? She wont like that either !!!
& you can tell your H if he wants to adhere to these rules it will be his job, when the kids are bored, to take them out & occupy them all in the garden.😂

TeensNoMore · 12/11/2026 06:26

PollyBell · 12/11/2026 06:22

Why does the op have to compromise and not the sil?

With this they are both compromising:
Screens for OPs children (SIL compromising and has to ensure Freddie stays away, OPs children don't use them in main area but can chill out elsewhere)
Plastic toys allowed (SIL full compromise)
No swords (OP compromise, but as I said a bad mix with excited toddlers for safety anyway)
Sweets allowed but with some adjustments (both compromise)

Zanatdy · 12/11/2026 06:34

My brother & SIL used to have rules around screen time and food and now at 4, niece eats no meals, just snacks (lot of bread, fruit, even some of those pouches) and screams her head off when SIL tried to get her off her tablet or phone. So do see benefit of not introducing screens at all for a 2yr old but expecting people to not buy plastic toys for their own DC as she doesn’t want them for her own child is beyond selfish and not a chance i’d be agreeing. No chocolate either is not on, its Christmas.

If these are the rules, then I would just spend Christmas at home. Hardly your fault you’re not going when you’re being told you can’t buy your child what they want for Christmas as she doesn’t want her own child disappointed when he sees his own less attractive looking gifts. It’s never going to work sharing christmas with her whilst she’s trying to tell you how to parent. Is your DH happy to restrict his own kids gifts so his sister is happy but his own children wondering why they didn’t get what they asked for from santa?

BeCosyOliveScroller · 12/11/2026 06:40

Could you not compromise on:

  1. no screens (to be honest I’m not strict on screens at all - my kids watch some every day - but I doubt they’ll watch any on Christmas as we’re going to my ILs and they’re not keen on screens too much.)

however absolutely ridiculous that they’re not allowed to have the presents they want.

oh and crying all the time is manipulation. Best tactic is to say ‘I’m sorry you’re upset. Let’s talk about this later when you’ve calmed down.’

Whyherewego · 12/11/2026 06:42

Wow I can't believe DH response when you told him.
Frankly then I would bow out of all parenting over the period. Kids want sweets, toys or TV .. tell them to ask Daddy. They cry or get upset. Tell him to deal with it.

JMSA · 12/11/2026 06:44

Please don’t pander to her! That’s how batshit crazy people get away with their unreasonable behaviour.
It goes without saying that YANBU and you sound like a very nice person indeed.

Please create an account

To comment on this thread you need to create a Mumsnet account.

This thread is not accepting new messages.