Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

any teachers here - is the job unsustainable now

243 replies

teachertetherendof · 09/11/2026 15:11

Hello - career teacher- needing somewhere to rant
I am sick of every child (almost to a fault) arguing that they shouldn't do what you have asked - this is from the tiniest thing to the biggest things
Also today I have been physically shoved which will lead to no more than a day of isolation for the 15 year old that did it
What has happened to young people? We are literally at the point where even if you are warning a student about something dangerous to themselves - they don't listen- instead their default is to argue back first

It's exhausting

Also, I am not a strict or savage teacher- our school does not have lots of stupid rules- this is a really strong societal drift into this constant state. And no, it hasn't always happened- there has been a massive change in the last 8 years

OP posts:
VaccineSticker · 11/11/2026 21:05

TheHateIsNotGood · 09/11/2026 21:15

@VaccineSticker Actually I don't work in a school (quelle suprise). Do you have to in order to have an opinion? If so, how narrow minded of the so-called educational professionals. But I have been a Guvner and me dear departed DM was SLT and later earned her crust after retirement in an LA SEN unit and very unsuited to that role indeed she was. At least she didn't know "what to say" after her autistic grandson became the Leper of Devon.

But hey ho, finger on the pulse of society, teachers are not. The kids are near to rioting and the teachers are blaming the parents, huddling towards their working T&Cs, crying to their unions, blaming anything but the stark reality of life in the UK today.

Excelsior!

Parents have got no time to parent because our dear government wants everyone to work themselves to the ground. No one has down time for anything anymore, by the time families get home, families have zero bandwidth for their children because it is all work work work, pay your taxes, get fleeced then get nothing back to show for it.
Teachers are then having to be a parent, social worker, nurse, educator, cleaner etc a place of emotional support that they can’t access from their parents.
Why do you assume I am blaming the parents here? It is quite presumptuous.
I’m sorry but being a governor does not count as worked experience in a school. Until you get your hands dirty in the every day running of a class with very recent experience, you can keep your opinion to yourself. My colleague who has been in education for 20 years (not a snowflake but any shape or form) echoes what most teachers have said on here and on social media. She is on the brink of quitting as she’s being worked to the ground with behaviour, workload and SEND as main concerns.
Next story will be I am a secretary, ask me anything about how to do a brain surgery. Being a governor qualifies in nothing my dear.

AlphabetMole · 12/11/2026 14:29

TheBlueKoala · 11/11/2026 18:32

As you said; those with ressources get more while those without get less. My DS2 is in private secondary and I compare with DS1s state secondary and it's night and day. DS1 was in a SEN hub with inclusion in state with 1:1 support, not academic at all so he thought the disruptions were funny and told us every day about them. That's why we decided that DS2 who is very calm and academic had to go private. And even though they are about 30 in his class it's calm and study oriented, excellent pastoral care and no bullying at all. Really. Not only my son says it but all students I have talked to. They have a strong social cohesion and won't let anyone get away with bullying.

But I think about those calm, academic students in our state who just have to deal with getting pushed in corridors and lessons being interrupted non-stop and I find it really unfair.

Yes, it's just not fair.

It's not fair that children from calm, orderly homes with access to significant resources also get a positive, nurturing school environment where they're treated as human beings, while children from chaotic backgrounds are retraumatized and written off in schools where they're shouted at, controlled and treated as less than human.

I really worry about the effect it has on teenage girls especially. Imagine you come from a deprived home, parents absent or working constantly, already feeling marginalised. And you go to a zero tolerance ultra-strict school where you're expected to conform absolutely and punished harshly for the slightest mistake or things beyond your control. What does that say to you about your worth as a human being and the way it is acceptable for people, including future relationship partners, to treat you?

If we're expecting teenage girls to spend their formative years in ultra strict, coercive environments where they are shouted at, treated as sub-human, have little autonomy and are expected to comply unquestioningly, how can that not have an effect in terms of making them vulnerable to abusive relationships later on in life?

Children from non-disadvantaged families understand societal rules and so can be better relied upon to cooperate. They also have parents who support the school in their policies.

I don't see securing order and compliance as a justification for essentially subjecting children from disadvantaged backgrounds to what often seems to amount to a form of psychological abuse and extreme control. They need more help, support and warmth, not less. I don't know what the answer is, but taking a less punitive and more therapeutic approach towards children who struggle with school might be a good start. And also being more realistic about which aspects of the curriculum children who are struggling with school are going to be able to access, at least at first. Get them into school, make sure they're safe, warm and fed and give them something, anything to do, even if lego or doodling, and then when they feel less threatened, try to increase the academic demands.

jumpingjohnny · 12/11/2026 17:58

AlphabetMole · 12/11/2026 14:29

Yes, it's just not fair.

It's not fair that children from calm, orderly homes with access to significant resources also get a positive, nurturing school environment where they're treated as human beings, while children from chaotic backgrounds are retraumatized and written off in schools where they're shouted at, controlled and treated as less than human.

I really worry about the effect it has on teenage girls especially. Imagine you come from a deprived home, parents absent or working constantly, already feeling marginalised. And you go to a zero tolerance ultra-strict school where you're expected to conform absolutely and punished harshly for the slightest mistake or things beyond your control. What does that say to you about your worth as a human being and the way it is acceptable for people, including future relationship partners, to treat you?

If we're expecting teenage girls to spend their formative years in ultra strict, coercive environments where they are shouted at, treated as sub-human, have little autonomy and are expected to comply unquestioningly, how can that not have an effect in terms of making them vulnerable to abusive relationships later on in life?

Children from non-disadvantaged families understand societal rules and so can be better relied upon to cooperate. They also have parents who support the school in their policies.

I don't see securing order and compliance as a justification for essentially subjecting children from disadvantaged backgrounds to what often seems to amount to a form of psychological abuse and extreme control. They need more help, support and warmth, not less. I don't know what the answer is, but taking a less punitive and more therapeutic approach towards children who struggle with school might be a good start. And also being more realistic about which aspects of the curriculum children who are struggling with school are going to be able to access, at least at first. Get them into school, make sure they're safe, warm and fed and give them something, anything to do, even if lego or doodling, and then when they feel less threatened, try to increase the academic demands.

And you do that with a ratio of 1 adult to 30-35 children how exactly?

Allrightonthenight1 · 12/11/2026 18:57

@AlphabetMole If you offer help, support and warmth, you're viewed as weak. Compliance doesn't just 'happen', it has to be instilled. The discipline is in response to the chaos; children need boundaries.

ThrallsWife · 13/11/2026 05:55

AlphabetMole · 12/11/2026 14:29

Yes, it's just not fair.

It's not fair that children from calm, orderly homes with access to significant resources also get a positive, nurturing school environment where they're treated as human beings, while children from chaotic backgrounds are retraumatized and written off in schools where they're shouted at, controlled and treated as less than human.

I really worry about the effect it has on teenage girls especially. Imagine you come from a deprived home, parents absent or working constantly, already feeling marginalised. And you go to a zero tolerance ultra-strict school where you're expected to conform absolutely and punished harshly for the slightest mistake or things beyond your control. What does that say to you about your worth as a human being and the way it is acceptable for people, including future relationship partners, to treat you?

If we're expecting teenage girls to spend their formative years in ultra strict, coercive environments where they are shouted at, treated as sub-human, have little autonomy and are expected to comply unquestioningly, how can that not have an effect in terms of making them vulnerable to abusive relationships later on in life?

Children from non-disadvantaged families understand societal rules and so can be better relied upon to cooperate. They also have parents who support the school in their policies.

I don't see securing order and compliance as a justification for essentially subjecting children from disadvantaged backgrounds to what often seems to amount to a form of psychological abuse and extreme control. They need more help, support and warmth, not less. I don't know what the answer is, but taking a less punitive and more therapeutic approach towards children who struggle with school might be a good start. And also being more realistic about which aspects of the curriculum children who are struggling with school are going to be able to access, at least at first. Get them into school, make sure they're safe, warm and fed and give them something, anything to do, even if lego or doodling, and then when they feel less threatened, try to increase the academic demands.

They need more help, support and warmth, not less. I don't know what the answer is, but taking a less punitive and more therapeutic approach towards children who struggle with school might be a good start. And also being more realistic about which aspects of the curriculum children who are struggling with school are going to be able to access, at least at first.

School league tables and Ofsted don't allow for the latter. Schools are under enormous pressure to get all students to achieve their target grade, determined at the age of 10/11 when they sit their SATS. There is no regard for home life considerations, not even a regard for students who have just arrived to the country and don't speak any English.

And I agree with the PP who said you cannot show any warmth when it comes to rules. Teenagers - like toddlers - push boundaries at every step; it's an inherent part of growing up. Take the often-debated toilet rule. Let one student go and half the class suddenly "needs" to go, too. Seating plans. Allow one student to move and you have 10 other requests to do the same. Allow one student to keep to sleep in class and you will have debates on why others should have to do work. Ignore one student talking and you will have a whole class talking over you. Without stringent rules, things soon descend into chaos.

And while some rules may seem unreasonable (e.g. tucking shirts in), it has background (students need to learn to dress appropriately) and gives them something smaller to rebel about, rather than the larger, more invisible rules.

The PP got it right when they said students from deprived backgrounds often don't understand unspoken societal rules.

Oaktree1952 · 13/11/2026 06:14

I have been teaching for 20 years and felt a huge shift. I think this is for several reasons.
Gentle parenting - parents feel like they are wrong to discipline their children and that everything needs to be explained and reasoned with children.
Parent guilt/Mummy guilt - both parents are having to work more and more and they want nice times with their children so they over compensate.
The happy complex - the belief that children should be happy all the time. Life being hard has been lost. Every child now seems to think they have the right to be happy. Being content and ok is not explored and all other feelings are put down as bad feelings.
Respect - we are loosing respect as a society. We no longer respect someone because of their position. Everyone has got to earn respect. So when a teacher does something a child doesn’t like it’s ok not to respect them anymore regardless of what that is.

Sleighmyname86 · 13/11/2026 06:22

Secondary teacher of 17 years.
Lots of experience in middle management within the school.
Since having my own family I’m just a classroom teacher and I DREAD going to work.
Behaviour unmanageable, workload unmanageable, SLT blame everything on staff and nothing on the students, just like parents!
Im sick of having to justify a detention in back and forth emails to parents who don’t believe me.
I hate it now but feel stuck as I’ve been a teacher my entire career and am qualified for nothing else.
The only reason I stay is the holidays with my own kids.
It’s not you, the job is a horror.

BeCosyOliveScroller · 13/11/2026 06:37

SevenYellowHammers · 11/11/2026 18:17

A calm orderly environment, definitely, but not being able to speak in the corridors is over the top. Why is it only children from deprived backgrounds that are subject to these ultra strict schools? There’s a school nearby that’s modelling its self on Michaela and there are lots of mental health issues amongst staff and students alike. There has to be a healthy balance. I also can’t support a school that has banned prayer. Surely that’s a human right.

A lot of people mentioning Michaela. I think you need to be careful. It is in a tough area and gets amazing results but the make up of the student body isn’t discussed enough. Largely children of 1st/2nd generation immigrant families from countries where respect for elders is more ingrained, and where education is valued and seen as the ticket to future success, especially as an immigrant.
compare that to a rural, white working class dominated catchment and honestly you’re comparing apples and oranges. I do believe in strict sanctions as a teacher but study after study shows that it’s rural white working class pupils (mainly boys but also girls) who are being left behind and everyone pointing at a multicultural school in the middle of London completely misses the point.

friedaklein · 13/11/2026 07:12

BeCosyOliveScroller · 13/11/2026 06:37

A lot of people mentioning Michaela. I think you need to be careful. It is in a tough area and gets amazing results but the make up of the student body isn’t discussed enough. Largely children of 1st/2nd generation immigrant families from countries where respect for elders is more ingrained, and where education is valued and seen as the ticket to future success, especially as an immigrant.
compare that to a rural, white working class dominated catchment and honestly you’re comparing apples and oranges. I do believe in strict sanctions as a teacher but study after study shows that it’s rural white working class pupils (mainly boys but also girls) who are being left behind and everyone pointing at a multicultural school in the middle of London completely misses the point.

I did mention Michaela as something to possibly emulate.

I am a second gen immigrant. You are right, my parents valued education and so do I. They respected teachers, elders and the law. So do I. I made sure to tell my kids to respect their teachers and put education first.

We need schools where kids who value education can go. The ones who don't can go elsewhere, whatever their ethnicity.

I have no problem with strict rules like no praying, uniforms and so on. Not talking in the corridor and some other things seem OTT but in the larger scheme of things, I do not care.

MyLimeGuide · 13/11/2026 07:53

TFI Friday fellow teachers!! 😂🍾

Gofaster2023 · 13/11/2026 07:59

Im a teacher and I absolutely dont think it will be a life long career anymore. I am struggling (been punched and hit this week). Unfortunately I haven't been successful in my job applications so I guess I have to suck it up and keep working on my cv, which obviously isnt good enough yet.

Yellowbelliedsapsuckeristaken · 13/11/2026 09:56

Allrightonthenight1 · 11/11/2026 18:43

If pupils aren't used to boundaries, the boundary has to be rigorously enforced or it doesn't work. Pupils don't understand 'quiet' because they haven't experienced it, so it has to be 'silence'. If you allow any talking, everyone does it, therefore it's not a calm and orderly environment.

It's very wearing for staff. Amongst pupils, many of the issues would go away if they, er, followed the rules. The healthy balance comes once pupils learn to follow the rules.

Children from non-disadvantaged families understand societal rules and so can be better relied upon to cooperate. They also have parents who support the school in their policies.

HAHAHAAHAH.
Seriously. I taught inan independent schools and most kids came from wealthy, non-disadvantaged backgrounds and they were WILD.Maybe they understood societal rules, but thought they didn't apply to them, as did their parents. To be honest while it was an ever so slightly nicer experience than being called a c*nt by a racist dad in my first school, I also didn't enjoy it.

Kids absolutely do not to have stay silent all the time to know what silence is. Also not everything has to be militaristic style orderly. Schools are full of mini Hitlers who seem to think that though and pride themselves of corridors where 'silence is loud' or some other PR BS.

Total silence is not a sign of respect either.
The stupid rules tens to only be implemented schools with prevalent working/ higher level of PP/EAL/FSM students, and behind the scenes the main purpose is to show the kids their place- be quiet, shup up, obey. Nothing positive about it- saying this as a teacher. There absolutely is a mid way between total silence and kids shouting on top of their lungs. And there exist school leaders and policies supporting the mid way, but it's often easier to just get everyone quiet. It doesn't mean that white middle class children are somehow amazingly behaved and follow rules.

Yellowbelliedsapsuckeristaken · 13/11/2026 10:10

TheHateIsNotGood · 09/11/2026 19:04

@CousinBette . Yes teachers are leaving, many in their first 5 years and I'd hazard a guess that many of those have left after becoming parents themselves and found that the parenting whilst working is a bit harder than they assumed, even with the 'preferential' school holidays off that they have.

When teachers stop blaming parents first and use the critical thinking skills they were supposed to have learned at uni, then they will see that it's actually the society we have created, whilst we were all asleep at the wheel, that is the root cause of our current educational problems.

Every single comment from you is just so silly and ignorant.
Not sure if you managed to acquire any thinking or critical skills at any point in life, or is reading comprehension not your strongest suit.

It's not that teachers 'blame' parents. The fact is, supported by a lot of research, that parents do have the biggest influence on their kids. If parents don't support schools, then there is little we can actually achieve.

I don't know a single teacher who think we are the only difficult profession out there or who claims we are worse done by than other jobs- but we do speak up about it. The amount of people I met over the years who suffer hardship but go "well it is what it is"- if they don't want to stand up and fight for themselves, it's one thing. Doesn't mean everyone else should aspire to suffer in silence and suck it up. Believe it or not, teachers 'moaning' don't do it just for themselves- our working conditions directly influence students' learning conditions and outcomes.
You mention the pay rise- I'm sure you know the pay was frozen for many years and the pay rise has not matched the cost of living and inflation, or maybe linking the two would be too hard for you?
No one stops you from being an ignorant armchair expert, but have a go and working in a school (maybe as a TA?) for a while, and Id love to hear about your wisdom being put in practice!

AlphabetMole · 13/11/2026 10:40

Yellowbelliedsapsuckeristaken · 13/11/2026 09:56

HAHAHAAHAH.
Seriously. I taught inan independent schools and most kids came from wealthy, non-disadvantaged backgrounds and they were WILD.Maybe they understood societal rules, but thought they didn't apply to them, as did their parents. To be honest while it was an ever so slightly nicer experience than being called a c*nt by a racist dad in my first school, I also didn't enjoy it.

Kids absolutely do not to have stay silent all the time to know what silence is. Also not everything has to be militaristic style orderly. Schools are full of mini Hitlers who seem to think that though and pride themselves of corridors where 'silence is loud' or some other PR BS.

Total silence is not a sign of respect either.
The stupid rules tens to only be implemented schools with prevalent working/ higher level of PP/EAL/FSM students, and behind the scenes the main purpose is to show the kids their place- be quiet, shup up, obey. Nothing positive about it- saying this as a teacher. There absolutely is a mid way between total silence and kids shouting on top of their lungs. And there exist school leaders and policies supporting the mid way, but it's often easier to just get everyone quiet. It doesn't mean that white middle class children are somehow amazingly behaved and follow rules.

Yeah, the difference is that parents in independent schools have sufficient power that they won't tolerate their kids being taught in coercive and emotionally abusive environments.

I think the behaviour is better, because there are expectations on the kids and the teachers from the parents that the children will succeed, and so ultimately anything that gets in the way of that, including excessively bad behaviour, will be clamped down upon. So children who are openly disruptive, as opposed to quietly cheeky and entitled, won't be tolerated.

I don't know any private school parent who would tolerate their child being put in detention for being a minute late or wearing the wrong socks or anything stupid like that. It just wouldn't happen.

The main problem I have with these 'zero tolerance' type schools is that they're conditioning children to accept coercive and abusive behaviour as standard, and normalising being in a permanent state of fear of infringing the rules. They're conditioning their students to accept victimization in future relationships or workplaces.

friedaklein · 13/11/2026 11:01

AlphabetMole · 13/11/2026 10:40

Yeah, the difference is that parents in independent schools have sufficient power that they won't tolerate their kids being taught in coercive and emotionally abusive environments.

I think the behaviour is better, because there are expectations on the kids and the teachers from the parents that the children will succeed, and so ultimately anything that gets in the way of that, including excessively bad behaviour, will be clamped down upon. So children who are openly disruptive, as opposed to quietly cheeky and entitled, won't be tolerated.

I don't know any private school parent who would tolerate their child being put in detention for being a minute late or wearing the wrong socks or anything stupid like that. It just wouldn't happen.

The main problem I have with these 'zero tolerance' type schools is that they're conditioning children to accept coercive and abusive behaviour as standard, and normalising being in a permanent state of fear of infringing the rules. They're conditioning their students to accept victimization in future relationships or workplaces.

Edited

I suppose we have a different view of abusive and coercive. Students hitting teachers sounds far more abusive to me than following rules. I like rules and I don't think they are emotionally abusive.

LadyMacbethGotABadPress · 13/11/2026 11:10

One of my oldest friends teaches modern languages in a secondary school. It’s a “good” school in an ok area. She has been shoved and pushed and is verbally abused by students and parents frequently. She is 55 and just wants to retire.

My daughter was an EYT last year (year 4 in a fairly challenging primary school). She was only in post for half a term before she unexpectedly died. But she loved it and was full of enthusiasm. She also felt well supported by the superb head. I am aware that this might have been the difference between primary and secondary, or the particular head/school. Or that indeed the charm of it would have worn off for my beloved daughter had she lived longer.

You have my sympathy OP. It’s an important job being made increasingly difficult.

desperatemum1234 · 13/11/2026 11:12

I’ve worked in a school for the past 5 years, not as a teacher but I see what teachers are subjected to - the SLT, the kids, the parents 😩, the curriculum, the marking, the exams etc. Nothing could convince me to be a teacher nowadays. The kids are out of control, raised on “gentle parenting” (and general shit parenting - unlimited screens, unlimited video games etc) and having had “children’s rights” drilled into them throughout school. The schools either don’t or can’t impose sanctions, so simply bribe kids who misbehave - which basically means rewarding bad behaviour. I keep saying to my husband that the school set-up that we experienced has been reversed - teachers are now subservient to students and parents, the kids now rule the roost. And they know it.

AlphabetMole · 13/11/2026 11:26

friedaklein · 13/11/2026 11:01

I suppose we have a different view of abusive and coercive. Students hitting teachers sounds far more abusive to me than following rules. I like rules and I don't think they are emotionally abusive.

It's not having rules in itself which is abusive, it is the arbitrary and controlling nature of many of the rules (so for instance, requiring students always to visually track the teacher) and the harsh and disproportionate penalties imposed when rules are infringed, even inadvertently. Isolation being used for prolonged periods as a punishment for children with complex needs who can't comply, for example... how can that be appropriate?

thebrowncatisback · 13/11/2026 11:32

I think millennials have gotten parenting quite wrong !!!

thebrowncatisback · 13/11/2026 11:33

That and many years of austerity which has contributed to lack of resources for kids with SEN

thebrowncatisback · 13/11/2026 11:35

@LadyMacbethGotABadPress

so sorry ❤️ your daughter sounds like a wonderful teacher. How cruel life is xx

friedaklein · 13/11/2026 11:53

AlphabetMole · 13/11/2026 11:26

It's not having rules in itself which is abusive, it is the arbitrary and controlling nature of many of the rules (so for instance, requiring students always to visually track the teacher) and the harsh and disproportionate penalties imposed when rules are infringed, even inadvertently. Isolation being used for prolonged periods as a punishment for children with complex needs who can't comply, for example... how can that be appropriate?

I am not talking about kids with complex needs, but it also can't be that every damn kids has complex needs to the point that teachers are being attacked, like pp upthread said.
My sympathy is mostly with teachers. And I am not a teacher.

friedaklein · 13/11/2026 11:59

Also those who don't want to go to Michaela type schools needn't. If I had my kids again, I would happily send them.

AlphabetMole · 13/11/2026 12:09

friedaklein · 13/11/2026 11:53

I am not talking about kids with complex needs, but it also can't be that every damn kids has complex needs to the point that teachers are being attacked, like pp upthread said.
My sympathy is mostly with teachers. And I am not a teacher.

Teachers are adults. They can walk out of abusive environments.

Children cannot. There is no excuse for abusing or not safeguarding children, including in the name of 'discipline' or 'compliance'.

friedaklein · 13/11/2026 12:12

AlphabetMole · 13/11/2026 12:09

Teachers are adults. They can walk out of abusive environments.

Children cannot. There is no excuse for abusing or not safeguarding children, including in the name of 'discipline' or 'compliance'.

Then we won't have any teachers left. We already don't.
You and I have different definitions of abusive.
But as I said, you don't need to send your kids to Michaela..I can assure you immigrant parents like me don't find that environment abusive or coercive