Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

any teachers here - is the job unsustainable now

243 replies

teachertetherendof · 09/11/2026 15:11

Hello - career teacher- needing somewhere to rant
I am sick of every child (almost to a fault) arguing that they shouldn't do what you have asked - this is from the tiniest thing to the biggest things
Also today I have been physically shoved which will lead to no more than a day of isolation for the 15 year old that did it
What has happened to young people? We are literally at the point where even if you are warning a student about something dangerous to themselves - they don't listen- instead their default is to argue back first

It's exhausting

Also, I am not a strict or savage teacher- our school does not have lots of stupid rules- this is a really strong societal drift into this constant state. And no, it hasn't always happened- there has been a massive change in the last 8 years

OP posts:
Corrrrrblimey · 11/11/2026 07:18

Yup! I was sworn at on Monday because a boy (around 16) had his phone out in class (not allowed) and his pal grabbed it off him. I was in the process of helping another pupil with their work so called over to them “X, give the phone back and Y, get it back in your bag!” Owner of the phone then shouts backing, swearing at me for not getting his phone back immediately, then argues about being sent out of class for this. I just persist with the line “I don’t come to my place of work to be verbally abused” which is my usual go-to when this happens.
I didn’t even bother reporting to anyone because it’s so common place.

Corrrrrblimey · 11/11/2026 07:28

Sartre · 09/11/2026 16:21

Why would anyone choose to teach secondary age children? You can select primary when doing the PGCE, or even further education but go with teenagers of all young people?! I’m not sure what you expect.

Threads like this make me think other peoples schools must have been great in the 90/00s. Mine was like Lord of the Flies.

10 years ago, it wasn’t anywhere near as bad as it is now. I thoroughly enjoyed (and sometimes still do) teaching secondary age kids - lots of chat and banter, seeing them blossom into the wonderful young people they’re capable of becoming, igniting a spark in them when they see success. But teachers have had to become more than just teachers - GPs in our area pass any neurodevelopmental referrals our way; social work tell us to do home visits to kids in the first instance; parents call in saying they need more support when they can’t get their kid out of bed for school in the morning; there are very few services available to support those who genuinely need it (mental health/anxiety etc) and the paperwork required for all these supports and interventions piles up and up, alongside our ACTUAL work, never mind lesson planning etc.

But teachers only work 9-3, don’t you know! 🙄

Sartre · 11/11/2026 07:37

Corrrrrblimey · 11/11/2026 07:28

10 years ago, it wasn’t anywhere near as bad as it is now. I thoroughly enjoyed (and sometimes still do) teaching secondary age kids - lots of chat and banter, seeing them blossom into the wonderful young people they’re capable of becoming, igniting a spark in them when they see success. But teachers have had to become more than just teachers - GPs in our area pass any neurodevelopmental referrals our way; social work tell us to do home visits to kids in the first instance; parents call in saying they need more support when they can’t get their kid out of bed for school in the morning; there are very few services available to support those who genuinely need it (mental health/anxiety etc) and the paperwork required for all these supports and interventions piles up and up, alongside our ACTUAL work, never mind lesson planning etc.

But teachers only work 9-3, don’t you know! 🙄

Interesting. I just know my secondary school in the 00s was sheer chaos. Constant fighting, teen pregnancies, endless truancy, kids being sent out / put in exclusion / actually excluded non stop and the teachers basically had zero control. I can’t imagine it getting much worse nowadays, maybe just because the fighting can now be recorded and distributed I suppose.

As I say, no clue why people would select secondary. I avoided kids all together and went into HE. It has its pitfalls but I don’t generally have to deal with absolute jerks.

edwinbear · 11/11/2026 07:43

@AlphabetMole my DC are at private school and I agree with you completely. No child at their school would swear or physically assault a teacher, mainly because it’s just unacceptable behaviour but also, you’d be expelled by the end of the day. In the main, pupils want to learn and do well and are engaged in their work, they have ample, specialist teachers, plenty of sport and extra curricular. Parents are respectful of teachers, although I think can be quite demanding in terms of replying to e mails etc. I think teachers work very long hours though with after school and Saturday sports fixtures, parents wanting to speak/e mail in the evenings etc and the work staff have put into my son’s UCAS application is incredible.

Dicedpumpkin · 11/11/2026 08:06

Sartre · 11/11/2026 07:37

Interesting. I just know my secondary school in the 00s was sheer chaos. Constant fighting, teen pregnancies, endless truancy, kids being sent out / put in exclusion / actually excluded non stop and the teachers basically had zero control. I can’t imagine it getting much worse nowadays, maybe just because the fighting can now be recorded and distributed I suppose.

As I say, no clue why people would select secondary. I avoided kids all together and went into HE. It has its pitfalls but I don’t generally have to deal with absolute jerks.

I think teachers now are held more accountable for progrrss, attainment and so on. I was at a nicer sounding school than yours and a few years earlier but there was no suggestion that a pregnant teen was the fault of the school or tutors had let her down. The pressure on attendance was way less. My mum signed me off sick lots and noone cared. No pressure on a tutor to improve my attendance stats. If pupils did badly it was on them. Im sure there was some pressure on teachers to get exams passed but not the way there is now. The amount of data captured grows and grows.

AlphabetMole · 11/11/2026 08:18

edwinbear · 11/11/2026 07:43

@AlphabetMole my DC are at private school and I agree with you completely. No child at their school would swear or physically assault a teacher, mainly because it’s just unacceptable behaviour but also, you’d be expelled by the end of the day. In the main, pupils want to learn and do well and are engaged in their work, they have ample, specialist teachers, plenty of sport and extra curricular. Parents are respectful of teachers, although I think can be quite demanding in terms of replying to e mails etc. I think teachers work very long hours though with after school and Saturday sports fixtures, parents wanting to speak/e mail in the evenings etc and the work staff have put into my son’s UCAS application is incredible.

I think this is an important point to stress.

There are some children in the UK who are learning in calm, well-resourced schools with teachers who can afford to be kind, patient and humorous with them without fearing a full-on riot or losing control. If kids in these schools misbehave or have a meltdown, they are not usually put in isolation, excluded or punished harshly. There may be some minor sanctions applied, but usually someone will talk to them and try to get to the bottom of the behaviour and why they are unhappy. And all adults (teachers and parents) will genuinely try to address the root of the problem and there will be money to throw at the issue if extra tuition/counselling is necessary.

The problem is that these schools are either private schools (or, in some cases, good state schools in affluent areas). Their demographic is well-off, engaged, socially included. There is an expectation that children will be supported, and will succeed and be happy and healthy. Anything that works against this (including schools and teachers being too harsh) is disapproved of and parents won't tolerate it. And yes, this brings some problems in terms of pressure/competitiveness/entitlement, but these are relatively minor in terms of the problems other schools face.

To those that have little, little will be given. So children without access to money, resources, supportive parents etc can often expect to learn in schools which treat them with punitive disdain and put them in isolation for forgetting a pencil. And how are these children supposed to trust and respect adults when often the world has been a scary place for them so far? Too many families are struggling, and as a result many children are growing up not feeling safe and protected. How are they meant to trust in authority and the system when this is their experience?

AutumnAllTheWay · 11/11/2026 08:21

TheHateIsNotGood · 09/11/2026 17:06

Well then, just leave. Leave in droves, leave the UK's dc without any teachers. Why not? Because you are not brave enough, that's why. Teachers aren't the only people with bills to pay, dc to take care of and Aged Ps to worry about.

Rather than come up with reasons to blame anything and everything look at the society we all have to get by in right now. It's crap for most of us.

So, do something about it rather than moan; you actually do have a bit more power than you think. Stop being a bunch of moany scaredy cats claiming you are so wonderful and actually DO something about it. Or leave.

Sorry, but your posts are unbelievably ignorant. Clearly, youve never taught. Dont know why you're on this thread.

Genevieva · 11/11/2026 08:39

Strictly1 · 11/11/2026 05:57

Do you really think SLT alone that turn this ship? What does that look like? What are the sanctions we are giving that are having an impact with the most challenging? I’m genuinely interested because as a Head, as a group, it is one of the hottest topics.

Visit the Michaela school. She manages it in a very challenging area. You might not like everything she does, but there’s a lot anyone can learn from.

In my experience you need to make discipline consistent and easy. Years ago, I worked in a school where the new head introduced staffed detention timetables, with SLT on rota for the longer detentions. Small offences lost a child their morning break. Large or repeat offences after school etc. It took the burden off teachers and improved behaviour, tardiness, etc within half a term. SEN are never excusable reasons for abusive or disruptive behaviour. You have to protect and empower your workforce and the kids who want to learn from the disrupters.

There are a lot of softer things too - ways of nurturing community belonging and pride in their school etc. It’s hard in modern massive schools with no hall big enough to accommodate everyone, but it’s possible. Faith schools often find thus easier. However, our sixth form college manages it through high expectations, good results and the knowledge that it is a desirable college to go to.

dizzydizzydizzy · 11/11/2026 08:40

Dollymylove · 09/11/2026 16:02

Respect for the law, respect for social norms, seem to be a thing of the past.
Single parenthood, multiple children with different fathers, mothers unable to control children. Actual discipline is frowned upon. Teachers can barely even raise their voices now. Schools cant cope with the extraordinary explosion of ADHD. Where did that come from? It was virtually unknown 20 years ago. Then suddenly theres benefits to be claimed and lo and behold everyones got it. Police now more like social workers than law enforcers. The justice system has been on its arse for years, except if you post an opinion on SM that attracts the attention of the establishment. Then the polis are round quicker than shit off a shovel. Drugs are rife, walk through any town centre and you will walk straight into the stench of weed. The former "Great" Britain has descended into a shit hole and Im glad im in my 60s not my 20s.
Ill get my coat

I’ve had ADHD my whole life. I’m in my 50s and it was diagnosed last year. We should be pleased more children are now being diagnosed because it
will give them a better chance of doing well
at school and behaving better. Also less chance of ending up in prison and more chance of having a healthier life. The world has changed and I think it is potentially harder to live now with ADHD than it was in my youth.

More generally to answer OP’s question, I think one factor is a wider societal change. Less caring and more individualistic. There is limited help of any kind for people having any sorts of struggles - need a council house? In a mental health crisis? Drug addiction problems? In severe pain? Not enough income to pay the bills and feed the kids?

Most of my teacher friends say that behaviour has dramatically worsened since the pandemic. Terrible behaviour has always existed. DM worked in a school in a very deprived area in the 1980s. A 15yo punched her in the face. Her car tyres were also slashed during the school day on tbe school grounds.

Sassylovesbooks · 11/11/2026 08:43

I'm support staff at a First school (Foundation - Year 4) and have previously worked in an Infant school (Reception - Year 2) and Junior school (Year 3 - Year 6). I have noticed as the years have gone by, the downward spiral of children's behaviour. Children aren't given boundaries and consequences to poor behaviour at home. Children are indulged and pandered too, resulting in them wanting their own way in absolutely everything. They come to school and expect staff to treat them like prince and princesses, because that's how they're treated at home.

It makes life so hard for the poor child. They invariably end up struggling socially....no one wants to play with a child who will only play the game they want, who won't compromise and then shouts/screams because other children won't obey them. They also end up in trouble with staff because they refuse to do as they're being asked or argue about it. Parents then get uppity with staff, because their precious child can't possibly be anything than an angel!!! It's always someone else's fault, apart from their own, because they're the ones who are bringing their child up!!

I wouldn't be a teacher in a million years. They need the patience of a saint.

BedZeppelin · 11/11/2026 14:40

Teacher here. Also a parent.
This is 100% unreasonable. We get a directed time calendar and it is usually finalised for the next school year before the summer holidays.
The school must have known about this and if they didn't they should not be subjecting teachers/staff (many of whom are also parents) or parents to something seemingly so important at such short notice.

IMO it also sends a poor message to year 11 students. We spend a lot of time telling them to plan ahead and that the school arranges everything around their year group. So to insist they attend too for the evening like they do not have any prior arrangements or plans is really unfair.

Allrightonthenight1 · 11/11/2026 16:22

AlphabetMole · 11/11/2026 08:18

I think this is an important point to stress.

There are some children in the UK who are learning in calm, well-resourced schools with teachers who can afford to be kind, patient and humorous with them without fearing a full-on riot or losing control. If kids in these schools misbehave or have a meltdown, they are not usually put in isolation, excluded or punished harshly. There may be some minor sanctions applied, but usually someone will talk to them and try to get to the bottom of the behaviour and why they are unhappy. And all adults (teachers and parents) will genuinely try to address the root of the problem and there will be money to throw at the issue if extra tuition/counselling is necessary.

The problem is that these schools are either private schools (or, in some cases, good state schools in affluent areas). Their demographic is well-off, engaged, socially included. There is an expectation that children will be supported, and will succeed and be happy and healthy. Anything that works against this (including schools and teachers being too harsh) is disapproved of and parents won't tolerate it. And yes, this brings some problems in terms of pressure/competitiveness/entitlement, but these are relatively minor in terms of the problems other schools face.

To those that have little, little will be given. So children without access to money, resources, supportive parents etc can often expect to learn in schools which treat them with punitive disdain and put them in isolation for forgetting a pencil. And how are these children supposed to trust and respect adults when often the world has been a scary place for them so far? Too many families are struggling, and as a result many children are growing up not feeling safe and protected. How are they meant to trust in authority and the system when this is their experience?

Treating adults who want to help them with respect rather than disdain, belligerence and rudeness would be a good place to start. Which other profession would tolerate the same level of abuse from 'stakeholders'?

Yellowbelliedsapsuckeristaken · 11/11/2026 17:04

AlphabetMole · 11/11/2026 06:54

The behaviour of kids is so bad but also I think ability wise there has been a big shift downwards, with fewer kids being motivated and curious about things? The ones that are are not enough to counterbalance the constant moaning and laziness.

I think this is a good point, but I also think schools should adapt to respond to it. The curriculum is far too crowded. Both at primary and secondary level, there should be more space for independent, creative, supervised 'play' (which obviously would look different for teenagers than reception kids) so kids can find out what inspires them, rather than constant pressure to learn.

I kind of think that constantly chasing after "what are kids interested in" is partially why that downward shift happened though. Students think if it is not 'interesting' they don't have to do it.
We do need more vocational subjects, doesn't necessarily mean whatever we have is bad for students who are more academic- there should be something aspirational about teaching and learning, sometimes things that are not 100% relevant to their experience, but giving them general knowledge so they can make an informed choice of what they'd like to do after GCSEs.
I do think having less focus on exam and doing subjects because they are interesting useful has a benefit- a lot more children could do a foreign language or Art/Drama/Music for general development, without a pressure of doing a GCSE. In many countries around the world students don't necessarily do exam at this stage and drop subjects before A Levels without having to do examinations in them.

The lack of ability is a different thing altogether. My old school used to do a big competitive test in y8 which would determine two top sets (which also include gifted and talented programme in my subject ) and the rest would be mixed ability. When I started to get in you would need let's say low 80%-high 70% and high percentage of students scored close to 100%. Last year when they did it relatively few kids scored in the region of 90% and the lowest score admitted was 50 something %.

Yellowbelliedsapsuckeristaken · 11/11/2026 17:10

AlphabetMole · 11/11/2026 08:18

I think this is an important point to stress.

There are some children in the UK who are learning in calm, well-resourced schools with teachers who can afford to be kind, patient and humorous with them without fearing a full-on riot or losing control. If kids in these schools misbehave or have a meltdown, they are not usually put in isolation, excluded or punished harshly. There may be some minor sanctions applied, but usually someone will talk to them and try to get to the bottom of the behaviour and why they are unhappy. And all adults (teachers and parents) will genuinely try to address the root of the problem and there will be money to throw at the issue if extra tuition/counselling is necessary.

The problem is that these schools are either private schools (or, in some cases, good state schools in affluent areas). Their demographic is well-off, engaged, socially included. There is an expectation that children will be supported, and will succeed and be happy and healthy. Anything that works against this (including schools and teachers being too harsh) is disapproved of and parents won't tolerate it. And yes, this brings some problems in terms of pressure/competitiveness/entitlement, but these are relatively minor in terms of the problems other schools face.

To those that have little, little will be given. So children without access to money, resources, supportive parents etc can often expect to learn in schools which treat them with punitive disdain and put them in isolation for forgetting a pencil. And how are these children supposed to trust and respect adults when often the world has been a scary place for them so far? Too many families are struggling, and as a result many children are growing up not feeling safe and protected. How are they meant to trust in authority and the system when this is their experience?

I worked in some 'difficult' schools in deprived areas. I can tell you that there are many, many staff who get jobs in those schools in the best possible faith, only to be ground down by disrespect and horrific behaviour from both parents and their children. The draconian rules (I disagree with by the way) are sometimes sadly the only way anyone can survive teaching.
I was verbally abused by parents and children, and it really opened my eyes to the fact that no matter how nice my resources are and how enthusiastic I am, I don't wanna work with children who call me a c and parents who tell me to f off when I ring them to discuss anything. Many people I know now prioritise their own safety over working in some areas- if the respect for school and learning is not there to begin with, then it will not happen, and nothing will ever change it.

Shinyandnew1 · 11/11/2026 17:37

BedZeppelin · 11/11/2026 14:40

Teacher here. Also a parent.
This is 100% unreasonable. We get a directed time calendar and it is usually finalised for the next school year before the summer holidays.
The school must have known about this and if they didn't they should not be subjecting teachers/staff (many of whom are also parents) or parents to something seemingly so important at such short notice.

IMO it also sends a poor message to year 11 students. We spend a lot of time telling them to plan ahead and that the school arranges everything around their year group. So to insist they attend too for the evening like they do not have any prior arrangements or plans is really unfair.

Was this meant for the thread about parents evenings?

skylarkrise · 11/11/2026 17:47

AlertCat · 10/11/2026 08:00

I have an interesting perspective because I am a teacher in one (specialist) setting, and support staff in a mainstream secondary school. I started my teaching career nearly 20 years ago in a fairly challenging school, and I’ve done supply as well.

My theory has a few strands.
first, I think smart phones (and I got my first one about 12 years ago, I wasn’t an early adopter) have done terrible things to us. We are nearly all slightly addicted, and not only does this manifest as a loss or failure to develop concentration and perseverance, but I also think it’s creating a problem in very early childhood where parents are unpredictably responsive, as they might be in other addictions. You see, if a parent is on their phone a lot, the child or baby gets much less interaction, and those are crucial for attachment and brain development. Like in the Still Face experiment. So that strand has a couple of problematic elements.

Then there is the increasing sense of individualisation that started under the Thatcher government. She famously outlined why she felt society doesn’t really exist and why none of us have a responsibility to one another, and that’s so ingrained now. In education we see it in the drive over 20 years or so towards individualised learning plans, which creates a lot of additional work for teachers and also the ground for parents and students to argue that they need more special treatment. While the aim of these is laudable, in practice it makes the job really difficult to do well, partly because of workload and partly because of parents who see one person getting a special thing and demanding it for their kid (even though their kid doesn’t need it). In the specialist unit I work at, we see the same thing, even though all our learners have EHCPs and unique learning plans with inputs tailored to their specific needs. Parent A sees that Child B has SALT, and demands to know why their child doesn’t see the SaL therapist. The answer is almost always that their child doesn’t need that input, but they see something someone else has and they want it too. Same attitude that leads people to resent those who receive PIP or other disability benefits.

Then there is the problem that a pp alluded to. Those of us who grew up in the 80s were essentially left to get on with everything- pastoral care and safeguarding barely existed. For example, in around 1992 a PE teacher saw the self harm marks on my arm and told the deputy head. She asks if there was anything I wanted to talk to her about. I said no. That was it. No-one rang my parents, i was never followed up with. We were determined to do better by our children, and we may, as a generation, have overcorrected. Our kids are rarely left to be bored. Either we play with them, we pay for structured activities, or we let them use smart phones and tablets. But boredom is imperative for creativity and resilience.

In education, we see this in the demand for every lesson to be engaging and entertaining. It isn’t always possible to do this, of course, and sometimes we just have to practise or recite or read. But the expectation is that we don’t allow children to learn like this; I’d never plan an observation lesson with that sort of activity. I’m not arguing for lazy teaching, but the pressure to devise clever, well structured, multi part lessons with student led learning as well as teacher led for every single class is horrendous, and it’s a very draining way of working and very time-intensive at the planning and resource-creation stage. Remember you also have to account for each child’s specific needs in your planning and it’s no longer enough to talk about just three levels or categories of learners as it was when I did my PGCE.

I also feel like we should have ‘education credits’ for those who are so disaffected at 14 that they want to leave. They should be allowed to leave and get a job (if they can) but have the option to return to education if/when they decide they want to, so there’d be colleges for older learners, free at point of use, with classes around working patterns. (Much as there used to be back in the 70s and 80s 🤔) This would mean people could improve themselves for free when they’d grown up a bit, as they hadn’t taken the provision at 14-16.

Really interesting post

i was in a busy city today and it it is horrifying the way many people walk around looking at their phone screens all the time

skylarkrise · 11/11/2026 17:53

Dollymylove · 09/11/2026 16:02

Respect for the law, respect for social norms, seem to be a thing of the past.
Single parenthood, multiple children with different fathers, mothers unable to control children. Actual discipline is frowned upon. Teachers can barely even raise their voices now. Schools cant cope with the extraordinary explosion of ADHD. Where did that come from? It was virtually unknown 20 years ago. Then suddenly theres benefits to be claimed and lo and behold everyones got it. Police now more like social workers than law enforcers. The justice system has been on its arse for years, except if you post an opinion on SM that attracts the attention of the establishment. Then the polis are round quicker than shit off a shovel. Drugs are rife, walk through any town centre and you will walk straight into the stench of weed. The former "Great" Britain has descended into a shit hole and Im glad im in my 60s not my 20s.
Ill get my coat

Yes I think there is a correlation

skylarkrise · 11/11/2026 18:03

BreatheAndFocus · 09/11/2026 16:40

Many children have no respect for adults now. The number of young children, say 6yrs, just pushing adults in school out of the way, or repeatedly poking them on the arm to get attention is shocking. I wouldn’t have dared touch my teacher when I was in school.

This is because society has sent the wrong message to them. Yes, children have rights. Yes, they are full human beings, equal in worth to adults. However, they are junior members of the human beings team and need to follow the ‘management’, ie adults, and show respect. The same goes for rules. They don’t respect rules so they don’t want to follow them. They think they, as 10 year olds or whatever, are entitled to argue and criticise rules like their input is equal to adults. The cockiness can be shocking.

This isn’t helped by poor parenting. Not poor parenting from those who aren’t good parents, but a generally reduced level of good parenting from people who you’d class as potentially good parents. They treat everything as a negotiation, when you shouldn’t be negotiating with a young child. You’re the adult, they should do as you say. You’re their parent, not their best mate, and sometimes being a parent means being a bit strict.

Yes I feel this with my Dgc and there is always underlying tension but I try not to say anything

skylarkrise · 11/11/2026 18:12

TheHateIsNotGood · 09/11/2026 17:06

Well then, just leave. Leave in droves, leave the UK's dc without any teachers. Why not? Because you are not brave enough, that's why. Teachers aren't the only people with bills to pay, dc to take care of and Aged Ps to worry about.

Rather than come up with reasons to blame anything and everything look at the society we all have to get by in right now. It's crap for most of us.

So, do something about it rather than moan; you actually do have a bit more power than you think. Stop being a bunch of moany scaredy cats claiming you are so wonderful and actually DO something about it. Or leave.

What would you do differently then?

SevenYellowHammers · 11/11/2026 18:17

friedaklein · 09/11/2026 22:27

Why? My kids are adults now so I am out of date, but it all seems hellish now. Some parents would prefer that. Some kids too. And many teachers.

Edited

A calm orderly environment, definitely, but not being able to speak in the corridors is over the top. Why is it only children from deprived backgrounds that are subject to these ultra strict schools? There’s a school nearby that’s modelling its self on Michaela and there are lots of mental health issues amongst staff and students alike. There has to be a healthy balance. I also can’t support a school that has banned prayer. Surely that’s a human right.

TheBlueKoala · 11/11/2026 18:32

AlphabetMole · 11/11/2026 08:18

I think this is an important point to stress.

There are some children in the UK who are learning in calm, well-resourced schools with teachers who can afford to be kind, patient and humorous with them without fearing a full-on riot or losing control. If kids in these schools misbehave or have a meltdown, they are not usually put in isolation, excluded or punished harshly. There may be some minor sanctions applied, but usually someone will talk to them and try to get to the bottom of the behaviour and why they are unhappy. And all adults (teachers and parents) will genuinely try to address the root of the problem and there will be money to throw at the issue if extra tuition/counselling is necessary.

The problem is that these schools are either private schools (or, in some cases, good state schools in affluent areas). Their demographic is well-off, engaged, socially included. There is an expectation that children will be supported, and will succeed and be happy and healthy. Anything that works against this (including schools and teachers being too harsh) is disapproved of and parents won't tolerate it. And yes, this brings some problems in terms of pressure/competitiveness/entitlement, but these are relatively minor in terms of the problems other schools face.

To those that have little, little will be given. So children without access to money, resources, supportive parents etc can often expect to learn in schools which treat them with punitive disdain and put them in isolation for forgetting a pencil. And how are these children supposed to trust and respect adults when often the world has been a scary place for them so far? Too many families are struggling, and as a result many children are growing up not feeling safe and protected. How are they meant to trust in authority and the system when this is their experience?

As you said; those with ressources get more while those without get less. My DS2 is in private secondary and I compare with DS1s state secondary and it's night and day. DS1 was in a SEN hub with inclusion in state with 1:1 support, not academic at all so he thought the disruptions were funny and told us every day about them. That's why we decided that DS2 who is very calm and academic had to go private. And even though they are about 30 in his class it's calm and study oriented, excellent pastoral care and no bullying at all. Really. Not only my son says it but all students I have talked to. They have a strong social cohesion and won't let anyone get away with bullying.

But I think about those calm, academic students in our state who just have to deal with getting pushed in corridors and lessons being interrupted non-stop and I find it really unfair.

Granville82 · 11/11/2026 18:40

LaughingArmadillo · 09/11/2026 15:18

Not a teacher but you have my utmost sympathy if Mumsnet parents are typical

This

Allrightonthenight1 · 11/11/2026 18:43

SevenYellowHammers · 11/11/2026 18:17

A calm orderly environment, definitely, but not being able to speak in the corridors is over the top. Why is it only children from deprived backgrounds that are subject to these ultra strict schools? There’s a school nearby that’s modelling its self on Michaela and there are lots of mental health issues amongst staff and students alike. There has to be a healthy balance. I also can’t support a school that has banned prayer. Surely that’s a human right.

If pupils aren't used to boundaries, the boundary has to be rigorously enforced or it doesn't work. Pupils don't understand 'quiet' because they haven't experienced it, so it has to be 'silence'. If you allow any talking, everyone does it, therefore it's not a calm and orderly environment.

It's very wearing for staff. Amongst pupils, many of the issues would go away if they, er, followed the rules. The healthy balance comes once pupils learn to follow the rules.

Children from non-disadvantaged families understand societal rules and so can be better relied upon to cooperate. They also have parents who support the school in their policies.

CousinBette · 11/11/2026 20:09

SomeoneIsWrongOnTheInternet · 10/11/2026 22:23

I always blame Blair and his New Labour government. It was in his times that the economy changed to the rentier buy-to-let economy, giving a complete free hand to both national and globalised wealth with a few handouts to the poorest to win their support, continuing right to buy among other handouts. He began the two tier society and the change away from rewarding those who worked and followed rules and law. At first when it mostly affected working class people trying to work up no one in wider society cared much, proclaiming ‘we’re all middle class now’ and other such inane nonsense. Now the middle class are affected and no work pays for anyone any more, meritocracy is dead and there is little point to education or working hard.

I’m not necessarily disagreeing with your points about the overall effect of globalisation, but New Labour poured money into schools. I saw it disappear as soon as Cameron got in in 2010 and austerity started.

takemebackto1990 · 11/11/2026 20:28

TheHateIsNotGood · 09/11/2026 16:42

So many workplaces are just toxic now. The problem is that teachers complained so much about their perceived hardships before that now no one cares. You got a pay rise, have long holidays despite how you couch it and things are still bad. As they are so for many others.

It's a situation of suck it up buttercup or leave; just like it is for millions of other workers in the UK.

I don't like it but that's how it is.

@TheHateIsNotGood but that’s the problem - it’s a societal issue & people in all jobs are getting abused or spoken to rudely just for doing their job. People in customer service roles, front line NHS, hospitality. The list goes on. I guess teachers see it first & it might be a few years before the ones who are badly behaved pre-teens are launched into the world.

There are quite a few students who will struggle to hold down a job. NEET figures are sky high. It’s a worry for all of society - not just teachers.

Swipe left for the next trending thread