I have an interesting perspective because I am a teacher in one (specialist) setting, and support staff in a mainstream secondary school. I started my teaching career nearly 20 years ago in a fairly challenging school, and I’ve done supply as well.
My theory has a few strands.
first, I think smart phones (and I got my first one about 12 years ago, I wasn’t an early adopter) have done terrible things to us. We are nearly all slightly addicted, and not only does this manifest as a loss or failure to develop concentration and perseverance, but I also think it’s creating a problem in very early childhood where parents are unpredictably responsive, as they might be in other addictions. You see, if a parent is on their phone a lot, the child or baby gets much less interaction, and those are crucial for attachment and brain development. Like in the Still Face experiment. So that strand has a couple of problematic elements.
Then there is the increasing sense of individualisation that started under the Thatcher government. She famously outlined why she felt society doesn’t really exist and why none of us have a responsibility to one another, and that’s so ingrained now. In education we see it in the drive over 20 years or so towards individualised learning plans, which creates a lot of additional work for teachers and also the ground for parents and students to argue that they need more special treatment. While the aim of these is laudable, in practice it makes the job really difficult to do well, partly because of workload and partly because of parents who see one person getting a special thing and demanding it for their kid (even though their kid doesn’t need it). In the specialist unit I work at, we see the same thing, even though all our learners have EHCPs and unique learning plans with inputs tailored to their specific needs. Parent A sees that Child B has SALT, and demands to know why their child doesn’t see the SaL therapist. The answer is almost always that their child doesn’t need that input, but they see something someone else has and they want it too. Same attitude that leads people to resent those who receive PIP or other disability benefits.
Then there is the problem that a pp alluded to. Those of us who grew up in the 80s were essentially left to get on with everything- pastoral care and safeguarding barely existed. For example, in around 1992 a PE teacher saw the self harm marks on my arm and told the deputy head. She asks if there was anything I wanted to talk to her about. I said no. That was it. No-one rang my parents, i was never followed up with. We were determined to do better by our children, and we may, as a generation, have overcorrected. Our kids are rarely left to be bored. Either we play with them, we pay for structured activities, or we let them use smart phones and tablets. But boredom is imperative for creativity and resilience.
In education, we see this in the demand for every lesson to be engaging and entertaining. It isn’t always possible to do this, of course, and sometimes we just have to practise or recite or read. But the expectation is that we don’t allow children to learn like this; I’d never plan an observation lesson with that sort of activity. I’m not arguing for lazy teaching, but the pressure to devise clever, well structured, multi part lessons with student led learning as well as teacher led for every single class is horrendous, and it’s a very draining way of working and very time-intensive at the planning and resource-creation stage. Remember you also have to account for each child’s specific needs in your planning and it’s no longer enough to talk about just three levels or categories of learners as it was when I did my PGCE.
I also feel like we should have ‘education credits’ for those who are so disaffected at 14 that they want to leave. They should be allowed to leave and get a job (if they can) but have the option to return to education if/when they decide they want to, so there’d be colleges for older learners, free at point of use, with classes around working patterns. (Much as there used to be back in the 70s and 80s 🤔) This would mean people could improve themselves for free when they’d grown up a bit, as they hadn’t taken the provision at 14-16.