I was trying to reply to a post that described a assisted dying as a 'clean and easy death' but cant find it again, think the post might have been withdrawn.
There is no ' clean and easy' in any of this, in dementia, death or decisions around death. Many people think so in their current (hopefully) healthy and compos mentis state, where as an adult they are quite rightly accustomed to rational decision making and control over your actions and choices you think - well, I know what I would choose. 'The healthy young animal’s distaste for age and debility', is very well known
But the choice you think you would make in you life phase now may not be the same choice you would make 30-40-50 years down the line as you are faced with the reality of an serious illness, or an awareness that you are losing physical or mental capacities.
The reality is that illness, debility and dependency sneak up on you, most losses and changes are gradual and people adjust to them - healthy, young and in your prime, self focused and perhaps not used to being in a caring role, the idea of incontinence is humiliating, embarrassing and horrible, the idea of dependency and vulnerability gives a visceral response of disgust, and the idea of pain gives fear. The most extreme form of this is the 'maximum longevity lifehackers' like Bryan Johnson and the ' dont die' movement- where people pour huge amounts of energy, time and resources into trying to optimise and control every factor in the hope of avoiding aging and control things that in many ways are uncontrollable - you can be as healthy and optimal as you like, but still get run over by a bus tomorrow (while you are out jogging) or have a rogue cancer cell, or an unsuspected genetic issue as a timebomb.
Many people want to end things when it gets 'bad enough' for them: but what 'bad enough' means changes as people live their life. Maybe they are struggling with the process of gradual losses of their function due to illness but have also a mass of positive factors where they will try and struggle on because there is enjoyment and positivity in their lives, or they still feel they have to be there for others eg a partner, a caring role, family, friends, hobbies, children or grandchildren. Maybe they don't particularly relish incontinence and needing assistance to change themselves but that is only one small thing in the whole of their day and the rest of their day hugely outweighs those episodes - and after a lifetime that includes child rearing and possibly care for other family members they realise that shit is just shit, and one can live through embarrassment.
Maybe they do have pain, but with medication they can function, maybe they have lived with increasing pain and inconvenience over the years and its become their normal: its not screaming agony but background static, their usual state. And they could tolerate it yesterday, so what is so different about today that means they should end it right now?
And of course, the bind of dementia is that the gradual loss of mental capacity and higher functions means that taking decisions or actions becomes more and more difficult, while emotional lability and expression of distress are more common, and the issues that they have lived with and controlled become apparent to family members.
There's an attitude that we should live like rational computers and at the first sign of a problem should weigh up all the pros and cons, and take a cold clearheaded decision to reboot ourselves for the good of the world and the economy: but that is just not how humans, their decision making or the process of aging and illness work. For anyone suggesting that this is how we should live - fine, make your 'rational' decisions. Why not do right it now so you never risk any lack of control in your life, and avoid the rush?
I fundamentally think we need to be discussing and talking about these things, and looking at the process of aging and debility, and how our society deals with it but there are no easy answers. For many generations we didn't have a model for 'extreme old age' and dementia as people died younger, of things that are now survivable. For many years we didn't have a concept of ' a good life' for those with disabilities for the very same reason - yet it is hard to argue against the lives of those disabled people who are lucky enough to live in this time and are able to access resources that allow them to live as fully as possible.
We should be discussing these issues - 'heroics treatments' versus symptom palliation, advanced directives and do not resuscitate orders, an acceptance that death will come for us all, and that families need to have discussions and make plans for this, and that yes, no matter how well you plan its still going to be emotionally grueling and some bits of it will be out of your control. Perhaps assisted dying should be part of this - but the messy reality needs to be looked at head on before simplistic solutions are implemented. Its interesting how much the Overton window has shifted since the Liverpool care pathway scandal in the 90s/2000s - then a pathway to palliation and limitation of life supporting treatment for frail/chronically unwell/dementia patients was brought in. As it was poorly considered/communicated and implemented it became anathema to the public: but now we have had bills proposing assisted dying in clear cut terminal cases, and yet a huge number of the public who misunderstand the critera the bill is proposed to apply to and think it should be broader.
Edited for spelling