Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think that every diagnosis of dementia should come with the offer of assisted dying

973 replies

CurdinHenry · 08/11/2026 13:38

Is there really anyone who would hear this news and want to see it out to the bitter end?

It enrages me that I might go out that way and so might everyone I love.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
6
Ileithyia · 10/11/2026 08:59

Yes. It’s a terrible and distressing end of life, but, unless you’ve seen how it affects patients and their families most don’t really understand the real impact it has. I’ve watched two family members disappear into a confused and distressed state, one becoming aggressive and needing to be virtually sedated. We absolutely should have the option to end things voluntarily.

MaeshoweDragon · 10/11/2026 09:18

Assisted Dying is not being put forward for people dying of dementia or with cognitive issues anyhow so it is a moot point.

CloudBuster66 · 10/11/2026 09:22

I see lots of people with dementia in my line of work and often feel if I was diagnosed i would want to end my life before I deteriorate. I don't want my family and friends' last memories of me to be like that. I would certainly want to draw up an Advance Care plan so that I would not receive any life prolonging treatments, (not even oral antibiotics for example)

BIossomtoes · 10/11/2026 09:29

MaeshoweDragon · 10/11/2026 09:18

Assisted Dying is not being put forward for people dying of dementia or with cognitive issues anyhow so it is a moot point.

This thread is making the argument that it should be.

EstoyRobandoSuCasa · 10/11/2026 09:47

DuckFilledPlatitude · 10/11/2026 08:37

No two patients are alike, and the same patient can change drastically as they go through different stages of the disease.

At one stage, my mum could enjoy things like tribute acts, which they have in her care home, but she is beyond that now.

Some patients sadly never pass through a stage where they can enjoy things like that - each case is different; there are different types of dementia and a patient can have more than one (my mum has two) so different combinations - it all adds up to a complex picture.

But I do agree that the happy old lady in a care home trope is annoying. I actually switch off TV programmes that go down that route - it's a surprisingly common cliche. In real life is it never everyone singing happily along to the band, you have half of the people not responding at all, and at least one person upset about something and shouting.

This is a minor niggle, but I never said everyone was singing along to the band. I said “clapping”.

DuckFilledPlatitude · 10/11/2026 09:55

@EstoyRobandoSuCasa I was thinking, in that post, of the general kind of 'cosy care home' scenes you see on TV rather than your specific scenario - singing, bingo, 'cute' nonsensical conversations, all that kind of rose-tinted imagery.

Gloriia · 10/11/2026 10:01

Ileithyia · 10/11/2026 08:59

Yes. It’s a terrible and distressing end of life, but, unless you’ve seen how it affects patients and their families most don’t really understand the real impact it has. I’ve watched two family members disappear into a confused and distressed state, one becoming aggressive and needing to be virtually sedated. We absolutely should have the option to end things voluntarily.

It is such a common condition I fail to see how anyone won't have experience either directly with their own family or indirectly via friend's family members.

Dementia is of course horrible but so many illnesses are. Suicide should not be encouraged for awful conditions. Life is hard, illnesses are hard. The amount of people who say 'they couldn't remember us', yes that is terrible but accept it and do what you can to make the whole thing bearable.

What next, someone's had a stroke can't speak or walk so they 'aren't the person they were' and no doubt 'can't make their legendary roast' either would some encourage them to off themselves too?

QiBengong · 10/11/2026 10:09

I was trying to reply to a post that described a assisted dying as a 'clean and easy death' but cant find it again, think the post might have been withdrawn.

There is no ' clean and easy' in any of this, in dementia, death or decisions around death. Many people think so in their current (hopefully) healthy and compos mentis state, where as an adult they are quite rightly accustomed to rational decision making and control over your actions and choices you think - well, I know what I would choose. 'The healthy young animal’s distaste for age and debility', is very well known

But the choice you think you would make in you life phase now may not be the same choice you would make 30-40-50 years down the line as you are faced with the reality of an serious illness, or an awareness that you are losing physical or mental capacities.
The reality is that illness, debility and dependency sneak up on you, most losses and changes are gradual and people adjust to them - healthy, young and in your prime, self focused and perhaps not used to being in a caring role, the idea of incontinence is humiliating, embarrassing and horrible, the idea of dependency and vulnerability gives a visceral response of disgust, and the idea of pain gives fear. The most extreme form of this is the 'maximum longevity lifehackers' like Bryan Johnson and the ' dont die' movement- where people pour huge amounts of energy, time and resources into trying to optimise and control every factor in the hope of avoiding aging and control things that in many ways are uncontrollable - you can be as healthy and optimal as you like, but still get run over by a bus tomorrow (while you are out jogging) or have a rogue cancer cell, or an unsuspected genetic issue as a timebomb.

Many people want to end things when it gets 'bad enough' for them: but what 'bad enough' means changes as people live their life. Maybe they are struggling with the process of gradual losses of their function due to illness but have also a mass of positive factors where they will try and struggle on because there is enjoyment and positivity in their lives, or they still feel they have to be there for others eg a partner, a caring role, family, friends, hobbies, children or grandchildren. Maybe they don't particularly relish incontinence and needing assistance to change themselves but that is only one small thing in the whole of their day and the rest of their day hugely outweighs those episodes - and after a lifetime that includes child rearing and possibly care for other family members they realise that shit is just shit, and one can live through embarrassment.
Maybe they do have pain, but with medication they can function, maybe they have lived with increasing pain and inconvenience over the years and its become their normal: its not screaming agony but background static, their usual state. And they could tolerate it yesterday, so what is so different about today that means they should end it right now?
And of course, the bind of dementia is that the gradual loss of mental capacity and higher functions means that taking decisions or actions becomes more and more difficult, while emotional lability and expression of distress are more common, and the issues that they have lived with and controlled become apparent to family members.

There's an attitude that we should live like rational computers and at the first sign of a problem should weigh up all the pros and cons, and take a cold clearheaded decision to reboot ourselves for the good of the world and the economy: but that is just not how humans, their decision making or the process of aging and illness work. For anyone suggesting that this is how we should live - fine, make your 'rational' decisions. Why not do right it now so you never risk any lack of control in your life, and avoid the rush?

I fundamentally think we need to be discussing and talking about these things, and looking at the process of aging and debility, and how our society deals with it but there are no easy answers. For many generations we didn't have a model for 'extreme old age' and dementia as people died younger, of things that are now survivable. For many years we didn't have a concept of ' a good life' for those with disabilities for the very same reason - yet it is hard to argue against the lives of those disabled people who are lucky enough to live in this time and are able to access resources that allow them to live as fully as possible.

We should be discussing these issues - 'heroics treatments' versus symptom palliation, advanced directives and do not resuscitate orders, an acceptance that death will come for us all, and that families need to have discussions and make plans for this, and that yes, no matter how well you plan its still going to be emotionally grueling and some bits of it will be out of your control. Perhaps assisted dying should be part of this - but the messy reality needs to be looked at head on before simplistic solutions are implemented. Its interesting how much the Overton window has shifted since the Liverpool care pathway scandal in the 90s/2000s - then a pathway to palliation and limitation of life supporting treatment for frail/chronically unwell/dementia patients was brought in. As it was poorly considered/communicated and implemented it became anathema to the public: but now we have had bills proposing assisted dying in clear cut terminal cases, and yet a huge number of the public who misunderstand the critera the bill is proposed to apply to and think it should be broader.

Edited for spelling

DuckFilledPlatitude · 10/11/2026 10:29

Gloriia · 10/11/2026 10:01

It is such a common condition I fail to see how anyone won't have experience either directly with their own family or indirectly via friend's family members.

Dementia is of course horrible but so many illnesses are. Suicide should not be encouraged for awful conditions. Life is hard, illnesses are hard. The amount of people who say 'they couldn't remember us', yes that is terrible but accept it and do what you can to make the whole thing bearable.

What next, someone's had a stroke can't speak or walk so they 'aren't the person they were' and no doubt 'can't make their legendary roast' either would some encourage them to off themselves too?

It has to be about quality of life for the person who is ill, rather than the experience of their loved ones.

I also believe a distinction should be drawn between terminal, degenerative conditions that occur towards the end of a person's natural expected lifespan; and illnesses that may occur in old age but are not degenerative; lifelong conditions; and terminal degenerative conditions that manifest when someone is far younger than their natural expected lifespan.

To translate this into personal terms, if I've had the 80 or so years on this planet that's usual and I succumb to dementia, I do not want or need any more life once my quality of life has deteriorated beyond a certain level. It would be different if I developed a terminal illness tomorrow, when I am only in my 50s, and haven't lived a full life yet.

dreamiesformolly · 10/11/2026 10:36

Gloriia · 10/11/2026 08:43

Exactly. Everyone is different.

What hcps need to do is educate and support relatives to manage expectations. No, don't keep repeating 'I'm your son John I've just told you!' or 'I've told you Dad is dead'. Just live day to day and accept their altered state.

I hate those alzheimer 'awareness' ads 'mam died 3 times, the first time when she couldn't cook her legendary roast'. No, she didnt die she had declining cognitive ability so just go with it and forget the roast fgs.

Exactly. Everyone is different.

I think that's partly the problem with this thread. Some on here (I don't mean you) are trying to insist on a 'one size fits all' solution, and that's never going to be possible where this issue is concerned.

RaggedRocks · 10/11/2026 11:51

Where does it end? Wheelchair bound after being hit by a car whilst out walking. Being told you will never walk again coming with an offer of assisted dying. Life imprisonment coming with an offer of assisted dying. There are too many situations where assisted dying would save the state a fortune and that's why I oppose it.

Puzzledandpissedoff · 10/11/2026 12:06

I completely agree that stringent safeguards must be in place (which were not in adequate in the recently defeated bill) if AD is legalised. But I don't think that's a good reason not to try to find a way to make it possible in certain circumstances and I actually think that dementia is a situation where it is most appropriate

I wouldn't argue with that at all, @biggreenbows
Of couse, some would have voted against in all circumstances, but plenty of others said it was because of the arrogant lack of answers and watered-down safeguards, so there seems no reason why it shouldn't be tried again if its proponents can do better

Unfortunately it appears some don't want to do that, and like Leadbeater would rather rail against the questioners, so if they carry on this way I have to wonder if the measure will ever get through

HelpMyBlackLabradorVotesReform · 10/11/2026 12:11

Puzzledandpissedoff · 10/11/2026 12:06

I completely agree that stringent safeguards must be in place (which were not in adequate in the recently defeated bill) if AD is legalised. But I don't think that's a good reason not to try to find a way to make it possible in certain circumstances and I actually think that dementia is a situation where it is most appropriate

I wouldn't argue with that at all, @biggreenbows
Of couse, some would have voted against in all circumstances, but plenty of others said it was because of the arrogant lack of answers and watered-down safeguards, so there seems no reason why it shouldn't be tried again if its proponents can do better

Unfortunately it appears some don't want to do that, and like Leadbeater would rather rail against the questioners, so if they carry on this way I have to wonder if the measure will ever get through

The arrogance comes from those who say I don't deserve to have the right to decide what happens to my body because they know better.

HelpMyBlackLabradorVotesReform · 10/11/2026 12:12

RaggedRocks · 10/11/2026 11:51

Where does it end? Wheelchair bound after being hit by a car whilst out walking. Being told you will never walk again coming with an offer of assisted dying. Life imprisonment coming with an offer of assisted dying. There are too many situations where assisted dying would save the state a fortune and that's why I oppose it.

So you're more interested in maximising the states spend that giving people human dignity? There's no sense in that.

dreamiesformolly · 10/11/2026 13:18

HelpMyBlackLabradorVotesReform · 10/11/2026 12:11

The arrogance comes from those who say I don't deserve to have the right to decide what happens to my body because they know better.

That's a childish and inaccurate statement. Most opposition relates to the issue of vulnerable people being coerced into being killed for the wrong reasons.

dreamiesformolly · 10/11/2026 13:22

HelpMyBlackLabradorVotesReform · 10/11/2026 12:12

So you're more interested in maximising the states spend that giving people human dignity? There's no sense in that.

What do you mean by that? What would be your suggested course of action be for people in the situations the pp described? Because presumably you're not suggesting we just off them for 'human dignity' whether they want it or not and in order to save the state money? 🤔

QiBengong · 10/11/2026 13:28

HelpMyBlackLabradorVotesReform · 10/11/2026 12:11

The arrogance comes from those who say I don't deserve to have the right to decide what happens to my body because they know better.

You do have the right to decide what happens to your body, suicide is not a crime and while no one should be encouraging it, as a society we are much more compassionate and understanding of the situation than we used to be, and the social stigma for relatives and family members is gone.

What you don't have is a right to involve the state in sanctioning your death, or in providing a mechanism by which your life can be ended by other individuals. (much in the same way you equally cannot demand all possible medical treatment in all circumstances using an advanced directive)
Dignitas and other providers of assistance in dying requires that you are conscious, and in a state of mind to make decisions, and can administer/ingest the medicine yourself.

HelpMyBlackLabradorVotesReform · 10/11/2026 14:14

QiBengong · 10/11/2026 13:28

You do have the right to decide what happens to your body, suicide is not a crime and while no one should be encouraging it, as a society we are much more compassionate and understanding of the situation than we used to be, and the social stigma for relatives and family members is gone.

What you don't have is a right to involve the state in sanctioning your death, or in providing a mechanism by which your life can be ended by other individuals. (much in the same way you equally cannot demand all possible medical treatment in all circumstances using an advanced directive)
Dignitas and other providers of assistance in dying requires that you are conscious, and in a state of mind to make decisions, and can administer/ingest the medicine yourself.

It is sad to live in a world where we give more dignity to our pets than we do our elderly in the final stages of life.

sum12luv · 10/11/2026 14:23

No! If I was diagnosed with dementia, I would not like to be offered the option of 'assisted dying' when the time comes. I would think it cruel to be given a diagnosis that most people fear, and then the option of ending it all when things got too bad. Rather, I would like to know how I could be supported to live my life to the fullest, how my loved ones could be supported to recognise when I needed extra help, and what my options were if/when I could no longer look after myself. I would rather have compassionate end of life or palliative care when the time comes.

I can also fully understand why people may feel they need to end their lives before they become a 'burden' to others, but I think if society and policy condones and supports those sentiments, we could be on the slippery slope back to the misguided eugenics of the early 20th century.

Gloriia · 10/11/2026 15:07

HelpMyBlackLabradorVotesReform · 10/11/2026 14:14

It is sad to live in a world where we give more dignity to our pets than we do our elderly in the final stages of life.

Some people eat animals that have been slaughtered horrifically but we don't eat people <obviously> . It's an absolutely invalid comparison. People are not animals. It should not need saying yet here we are.

Animals are pts because they are of course more replaceable than people. Sad though it is when one dog dies we can all get another, not so with parents.

Dogs quality of life is much more measurable than human beings. Once they can't run about and have a sniff that's pretty much it. People obviously have far more ability to enjoy some quality of life even if less than before and of course interaction is still possible even if immobile or with various deficits.

QiBengong · 10/11/2026 15:13

HelpMyBlackLabradorVotesReform · 10/11/2026 14:14

It is sad to live in a world where we give more dignity to our pets than we do our elderly in the final stages of life.

We rationalise euthanasia for animals precisely because they are not human, we act for them, own them, control the times they breed and the times they die, thats seen as responsible and compassionate ownership. But there is a world of difference between a pet and another human being, no matter their capacity
We do need to be more realistic, more compassionate towards our elderly in their final stages of life, but not by treating them like we treat animals.

There are a lot of ways the social and care system could support elderly people and their families better, and a lot of ways the medical system could be more realistic in dealing with acute illnesses in this population, allowing palliation of symptoms without providing huge interventions. This also would require people and society in general to become more acclimatized to dealing with the elderly and dying, and individuals less averse to discussing and planning for their own care and deaths, and more realistic about declines in their health and capabilities.

Puzzledandpissedoff · 10/11/2026 16:30

HelpMyBlackLabradorVotesReform · 10/11/2026 12:11

The arrogance comes from those who say I don't deserve to have the right to decide what happens to my body because they know better.

We're all entitled to our own opinions of course, but it's worth remembering this wasn't the one of the judges, so since the professionals are the ones who've scrutinised this thoroughly I think I'll take their word for it

Bitsostuff · 10/11/2026 16:40

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

QiBengong · 10/11/2026 16:55

Sorry bit of stuff, I can see that was a reply to my last post but it seems to have been deleted before I managed to read it.
Still interested in what you want to say, will keep checking the thread

Dancingsquirrels · 11/11/2026 13:45

RaggedRocks · 10/11/2026 11:51

Where does it end? Wheelchair bound after being hit by a car whilst out walking. Being told you will never walk again coming with an offer of assisted dying. Life imprisonment coming with an offer of assisted dying. There are too many situations where assisted dying would save the state a fortune and that's why I oppose it.

Absolutely. If / when this is introduced, a few decades later i have no doubt that if you make one comment that you're fed up of life, off you'd go

It terrifies me