Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think that every diagnosis of dementia should come with the offer of assisted dying

973 replies

CurdinHenry · 08/11/2026 13:38

Is there really anyone who would hear this news and want to see it out to the bitter end?

It enrages me that I might go out that way and so might everyone I love.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
6
BriarTime · 08/11/2026 18:59

NiaAndFar · 08/11/2026 14:31

And that, dear poster, is the exact reason why they should not offer it!

This is the precise reason why so many disabled people oppose the change in the law. It’s not a question of thinking assisted dying is fundamentally wrong. It’s not. But when we raise the fact that some people would seek to use it to ‘clean up’ society of its burdens (like us), we’re told not to worry our pretty little heads or not to be so selfish. ‘It’ll never happen’, they say. Or worse, that if it does it’s a price worth paying.

Before people get too comfortable with this idea, they should consider that who or what is ‘burdensome’ is subjective and socio-culturally and historically situated. It’s easy to think in black and white about this until you personally find yourself on the wrong side of that ‘line’. ‘Beasts of Burden’ by Sunaura Taylor, while not actually about assisted dying, is a very insightful look at disability and how those without disabilities so often decide that they should be the arbiters of whether or not our lives are worth living.

To address the OP’s point (on the assumption of good faith), making assisted dying available is one thing. ‘Offering’ it is suggestion at best and coercion at worst. And that, I fear, was always the goal for a small but dangerous proportion of those in favour of a change in the law.

XenoBitch · 08/11/2026 19:01

Dixie81 · 08/11/2026 17:41

I’ve always been strongly pro assisted dying but reading this thread has started to make me doubt myself. It didn’t take long at all for the slippery slope to show, suggesting anyone who is a ‘burden’ should be encouraged to take this option, and that old age has no value. In fact, some of the comments from OP are so vile, I’m wondering if they’re trolling or if it’s actually anti-assisted dying propaganda, designed to turn us against it. Which it’s doing very successfully!

Edited

Same.
I am for assisted dying, but my understanding is that it should be something you seek out... not be offered.
I also agree that if dementia is singled out, then it wont be long until it happens with other conditions... down to the point where someone who is declared not fit for work will then be offered it to save the state money (and there are a few people here that would be very welcoming of that). Wasn't there a wheelchair user in Canada that was offered MAiD because he wanted a ramp put in his home.

Thelnebriati · 08/11/2026 19:02

The reason we don't have a choice now is because people who claimed to be in favour of assisted dying sabotaged chances of getting a bill passed by refusing to include proposals for safeguarding.
When you are posting on social media that safeguarding is not needed, or people should feel responsible for being a burden, you are the ones sabotaging assisted dying.
It should be a choice; it should not be possible to coerce anyone into it.

Cardhey · 08/11/2026 19:03

100% would support being given this choice or ability to make that decision.

BriarTime · 08/11/2026 19:04

PencilsInSpace · 08/11/2026 18:58

Reading these threads over the past few years it has been fascinating and horrifying to watch the slow creep of arguments for AD from 'Of course it would only be for terminally ill people with full capacity and of course there would be lots of safeguards to make sure nobody ever felt pressured or coerced', to 'Dementia is so horrible that safeguards should be disregarded and nobody who loves their family should want to be a burden', with a side order of, 'There is a crisis in adult social care so the only solution is to kill people.'

I'm another who has gone from in favour of AD with sufficient safeguards to totally opposed because of attitudes like OP's and a couple of others on this thread.

Someone mentioned a slippery slope 'fallacy'. We already have a slippery slope in the arguments for AD even before legalisation, so where is this fallacy?

There was a case, can't remember if it was in Belgium or NL, where a woman with dementia had signed an advance directive for euthanasia once she reached a certain point in her illness. When that point came she strongly resisted. Her family had to pin her down, kicking and screaming, so the medic could administer the lethal injection. Because she no longer had capacity she was not deemed capable of changing her mind. That is horrific and I will never be in favour of any law that makes that situation a possibility in the UK.

I worked in care homes for the best part of a decade. Dementia is shit, often distressing for the person who has it and even more often for their loved ones. But the idea that everyone with dementia lives a life of unremitting misery and terror is simply not true. Many people with dementia are still able to find joy and contentment in life, right up to the point of actively dying - just like eveyone else. Their lives are worth the same as yours. And no, dementia is not the worst thing that can happen to you. I would prefer dementia to MND, Huntingdons, locked-in syndrome, severe COPD or certain types of cancer.

This is a big site, there will be people reading this thread who themselves have been diagnosed with early stage dementia. You are telling them their lives are not worth living and that it's wrong of them to want to continue living because they will become a 'burden'. How dare you.

Aside from all of that, if we ever did have legal AD, actively offering it should never happen anywhere close to any diagnosis. It's well known that terminal or life altering diagnoses frequently trigger a period of profound depression and despair. But after a while, most people get at least some of their mojo back and want to make the most of the time they have left or their new circumstances.

I think we have ample proof on this thread that it’s no ‘fallacy’ in this case . . .

TheFormerMrsTruelove · 08/11/2026 19:05

It’s a slippery slope. How long will it be until it’s dementia and a number of other conditions?

And if you trust the government to have people’s welfare as the only concern, rather than the money they’d save on treating and caring for people with long term and/or terminal conditions, you’re more trusting than I am.

ownedbymydogs · 08/11/2026 19:06

Fantastic post @PencilsInSpace .

Loveofeclairs · 08/11/2026 19:08

DuckFilledPlatitude · 08/11/2026 18:55

Yes - my thought is that the only way to avoid that dilemma is to be able to give consent in advance, while you still have capacity, for euthanasia to be performed once you have lost capacity, and your quality of life has deteriorated beyond certain thresholds - which you would define when you gave consent.

But what if the person with advanced dementia started saying that they didn’t want to die or they panicked because they didn’t understand what was happening? Should the procedure carry on because the person had consented in the past? Would any medical professional be comfortable administering the injection while the patient was being forcefully held down? I think that would be incredibly distressing for everyone involved and that’s why the patient needs to be capable of consent when the procedure is carried out.

ChampionTheWonderGorse · 08/11/2026 19:10

I watched my mum die of dementia. There is no way I will permit myself to go the same way.

Walkden · 08/11/2026 19:11

"But when we raise the fact that some people would seek to use it to ‘clean up’ society of its burdens (like us), we’re told not to worry our pretty little heads or not to be so selfish"

This. It's a slippery slope. First it's people with dementia being a burden then it's pensioners with cancer, how long before people decide it's long term unemployed who are not " net contributors" or kids with severe sen who will never be be meaningfully employed...

Puzzledandpissedoff · 08/11/2026 19:13

Someone mentioned a slippery slope 'fallacy'. We already have a slippery slope in the arguments for AD even before legalisation, so where is this fallacy?

It never was a "fallacy", @PencilsInSpace, though it suited some to pretend it was

Fortunately, as you said yourself, all such supporters have done is demonstrate exactly why rigorous safeguards would be needed, so for that I suppose we should thank them

DuckFilledPlatitude · 08/11/2026 19:14

Loveofeclairs · 08/11/2026 19:08

But what if the person with advanced dementia started saying that they didn’t want to die or they panicked because they didn’t understand what was happening? Should the procedure carry on because the person had consented in the past? Would any medical professional be comfortable administering the injection while the patient was being forcefully held down? I think that would be incredibly distressing for everyone involved and that’s why the patient needs to be capable of consent when the procedure is carried out.

One option would be, as part of the giving consent process, to be explicit about this scenario.

Actually to say in writing that it has been known for advanced dementia patients who have lost capacity to strongly resist euthanasia, to panic and struggle - if that should happen to you, do you still want to proceed or do you want this to be treated as withdrawal of consent?

If, while they have capacity, the patient says that resistance to the process should be treated as withdrawal of consent, then it should be halted in the event of protest. If they say, no, ignore me and carry on, then that should happen.

lollylo · 08/11/2026 19:18

Ive always assumed it will be incredibly hard to get assisted drying with dementia. By the time some people are diagnosed they will not have capacity and others will hold off and then be at a point they have no capacity. It would mean people in early stages whilst still quite well having to consent to it. And I don’t think many people will.

Cally62 · 08/11/2026 19:24

My DH and I are waiting for a diagnosis of possible early onset dementia. He's 62, stopped working 2 years ago. Originally diagnosed with stress and anxiety but after 6 months of medication and therapy with no improvement and clear signs of cognitive decline our gp suspected dementia.
Referral was made to the MHT 18 months ago. It's been an absolute shit show from the start, MHT are not fit for purpose. No wonder suicide rates are high.
After fighting for dementia testing for 18 months my dh recently had some tests, task and memory based. He was asked just before the tests if he wanted to know if he had dementia, WTAF, why would we be fighting for testing if he didn't want to know. He was then asked what he would do with that information.
He said "I'm going to kill myself" can't begin to describe the look on the psychologists face when he said that.
What the hell was she expecting. In the last 2 years, last year he tried to kill himself 4 times but couldn't go through with it. This year he knows that something isn't right. He had a stroke last November. His cognitive decline is increasing. He is very much aware of this, he fears getting worse or having another stroke leaving him unable to function properly and enjoying life.
We have discussed suicide and what taking himself off somewhere to do it alone would do to me and our family. I don't want to be here at home alone waiting for the knock on the door. This is something we would do as a family, when the time is right we will turn to assisted dying. It's not something we want to do but what is the alternative.

XenoBitch · 08/11/2026 19:24

DuckFilledPlatitude · 08/11/2026 19:14

One option would be, as part of the giving consent process, to be explicit about this scenario.

Actually to say in writing that it has been known for advanced dementia patients who have lost capacity to strongly resist euthanasia, to panic and struggle - if that should happen to you, do you still want to proceed or do you want this to be treated as withdrawal of consent?

If, while they have capacity, the patient says that resistance to the process should be treated as withdrawal of consent, then it should be halted in the event of protest. If they say, no, ignore me and carry on, then that should happen.

What HCP would be happy with forcing a lethal injection into someone who is resisting and saying no, regardless of what papers they may have signed years before.
The very thought of it is chilling.

Loveofeclairs · 08/11/2026 19:25

DuckFilledPlatitude · 08/11/2026 19:14

One option would be, as part of the giving consent process, to be explicit about this scenario.

Actually to say in writing that it has been known for advanced dementia patients who have lost capacity to strongly resist euthanasia, to panic and struggle - if that should happen to you, do you still want to proceed or do you want this to be treated as withdrawal of consent?

If, while they have capacity, the patient says that resistance to the process should be treated as withdrawal of consent, then it should be halted in the event of protest. If they say, no, ignore me and carry on, then that should happen.

What about the mental wellbeing of the medical staff? It would be harrowing to have to euthanise someone in those conditions. The law should absolutely protect them by ensuring that the patient was capable of consent at the time of the procedure.

What about the family? I think it’s very selfish to potentially put your loved ones through this. If you choose assisted dying at least own up to it, don’t make it someone else’s problem.

And I’m saying this as someone who is in favour of assisted dying, but in the right conditions. Not of killing people who are too ill to consent.

MarysSilverBells · 08/11/2026 19:28

ownedbymydogs · 08/11/2026 18:12

With most diagnoses the choice is there already. You just have to get on a plane to Switzerland.

The vast majority of people won’t do this though. And luckily, at the moment, it’s not legal to make that choice for someone else.

It's not a choice if you can't afford it. The vast majority of people can't do this, so your argument is ridiculous.

MaeshoweDragon · 08/11/2026 19:31

DuckFilledPlatitude · 08/11/2026 19:14

One option would be, as part of the giving consent process, to be explicit about this scenario.

Actually to say in writing that it has been known for advanced dementia patients who have lost capacity to strongly resist euthanasia, to panic and struggle - if that should happen to you, do you still want to proceed or do you want this to be treated as withdrawal of consent?

If, while they have capacity, the patient says that resistance to the process should be treated as withdrawal of consent, then it should be halted in the event of protest. If they say, no, ignore me and carry on, then that should happen.

Would the "bringer of death" then be legally bound to kill a kicking and screaming confused little old lady. Would they be prosecuted if they refused?
I find this thread quite disturbing.

BIossomtoes · 08/11/2026 19:31

MarysSilverBells · 08/11/2026 19:28

It's not a choice if you can't afford it. The vast majority of people can't do this, so your argument is ridiculous.

It’s not the cost, it’s that you have to have capacity to do it.

I don’t know why injections are being discussed. Assisted dying in other countries is achieved by drinking barbiturates.

XenoBitch · 08/11/2026 19:35

BIossomtoes · 08/11/2026 19:31

It’s not the cost, it’s that you have to have capacity to do it.

I don’t know why injections are being discussed. Assisted dying in other countries is achieved by drinking barbiturates.

That is true.
Some places have the drugs administered via IV, but the person has to release the clamp themselves.

Newsenmum · 08/11/2026 19:36

CurdinHenry · 08/11/2026 13:44

Taking it is the rational choice in that situation, though. Everyone is free to be irrational but the sane should not be denied an escape from the horror.

It would be pretty awful to get that diagnosis then be offered assisted dying.

Newsenmum · 08/11/2026 19:38

MaeshoweDragon · 08/11/2026 19:31

Would the "bringer of death" then be legally bound to kill a kicking and screaming confused little old lady. Would they be prosecuted if they refused?
I find this thread quite disturbing.

Yeah its fucking disturbing. I understand by the end but with earlier disgnoses and researches in treatment this shouldn’t be immediate.

Newsenmum · 08/11/2026 19:39

Walkden · 08/11/2026 19:11

"But when we raise the fact that some people would seek to use it to ‘clean up’ society of its burdens (like us), we’re told not to worry our pretty little heads or not to be so selfish"

This. It's a slippery slope. First it's people with dementia being a burden then it's pensioners with cancer, how long before people decide it's long term unemployed who are not " net contributors" or kids with severe sen who will never be be meaningfully employed...

And add a little depression and pressure from family and hey presto

kitex · 08/11/2026 19:39

Newsenmum · 08/11/2026 19:36

It would be pretty awful to get that diagnosis then be offered assisted dying.

It wouldn’t be that way for everyone. It’s about having the choice to end your life on your terms.

BIossomtoes · 08/11/2026 19:41

Newsenmum · 08/11/2026 19:36

It would be pretty awful to get that diagnosis then be offered assisted dying.

I think it would be amazing. It’s the only thing that would help me.