Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To have just put my three year and four month old back in nappies after eight months

123 replies

wouldyouactuallydothat · 08/11/2026 13:02

I just cannot take the shit any more.

I know I’m going to get the usual bingo responses here about ERIC (useless) constipation, GPs and all the rest of it and that’s not what I’m about. I’ve been trying to solve this issue for months now and just - cannot.

I am done with it. I just kicked the potty outside with a sense of satisfaction (yes, I know MN hate potties but ERIC recommend them for children with toileting problems for poo,)

I just cannot take another pair of shit filled pants.

OP posts:
wouldyouactuallydothat · 08/11/2026 20:02

I quite resent the implication there @Kingdomofsleep

OP posts:
Kingdomofsleep · 08/11/2026 20:05

wouldyouactuallydothat · 08/11/2026 20:02

I quite resent the implication there @Kingdomofsleep

It's not about your ego or mine or who is winning the argument or one up man ship etc. Your poor dd. For some reason someone at Eric has offended you and you've dismissed an entire treatment path that will probably work, without knowing the first thing about it! Laxido is not a laxative, and it is impossible to become reliant on stool softeners. See screenshot

To have just put my three year and four month old back in nappies after eight months
wouldyouactuallydothat · 08/11/2026 20:05

Agreed but you are turning this into a criticism and I don’t appreciate it, so let’s move on.

OP posts:
Kingdomofsleep · 08/11/2026 20:06

I am literally just trying to help you, no doubt just like the Eric rep was, but because I'm not doing it particularly tactfully, you are dismissing it out of pique. But your dd should matter more than what nobodies like me on the Internet think

wouldyouactuallydothat · 08/11/2026 20:10

And I just need to be clear here (and I have already stated this) Eric does not offend me in the slightest. But if I’d posted and people assumed it was for advice, I’d then get criticism for ignoring helpful advice.

I have been to the GP. Her stools are soft; she isn’t passing hard pebbles. I have contacted Eric and the HV. I have tried the usual tricks of blowing bubbles etc on the potty. It’s rooted in anxiety I think but very difficult to deal with when she won’t talk about it.

I have no desire to argue but I won’t just meekly accept bitchy remarks about my lack of care for my daughter; it is unfair and upsetting to read when it is patently not true.

OP posts:
Stelladid · 08/11/2026 20:10

Are you one of the parents who will send their child into school in nappies, so the teachers can do the job? My kids are all grown-up now, but won’t yours start Reception class in a matter of months?

wouldyouactuallydothat · 08/11/2026 20:11

Of course Eric were trying to help; that’s literally their job. The fact there was nothing of any real use to us was not their fault and I am not suggesting it was. I would actually prefer to wrap it up there.

OP posts:
SuddenDaredJelly · 08/11/2026 20:12

wouldyouactuallydothat · 08/11/2026 14:17

@Neverendingstory111 i have tried to talk to her about it but don’t really get anywhere to be honest, I’ve asked her if she’s scared to go and she says no, but I think she probably is because she will often poo in her nappy just before she goes to bed (she isn’t consistently dry overnight.)

I know she tries to hold them in and so then of course eventually out they come but because she’s holding them in it’s in lots of little messy oozes throughout the day - ugh

This and waiting for a nappy is two things:

  1. constipation (probably due to withholding) to some degree.
  2. liking/being habituated to going in an nappy. Its weird, these days people's first thought is that children "arent ready" but theres a school of thought that withholding is because we leave it much too late nowadays. Bowel control develops earlier than bladder, its strongly linked to digestion (most people go after meals). In the past when people didnt have the washing facilities we have now babies were stool trained alongside weaning from 1 or so, being sat on a pot after meals.

A lot of kids are now conditioned to pooing in nappies too long and find it too hard to poo without one. There are good guides on very slowly training this out, eg starting by sitting to poo in a nappy, then moving to undo one side, then the other, then cutting the nappy smaller until you swap it out for tissue etc. But you do it over weeks/months.

wouldyouactuallydothat · 08/11/2026 20:12

Stelladid · 08/11/2026 20:10

Are you one of the parents who will send their child into school in nappies, so the teachers can do the job? My kids are all grown-up now, but won’t yours start Reception class in a matter of months?

Clearly that gate at that farm is open Hmm

The teachers can’t do anything that I’m not already. I’m not expecting anyone to go my job as is obvious, given she’s been out of nappies for eight months.

If (and it is a huge if) she is still soiling by next September I will have to look at deferring her place as i agree she cannot go to school doing this for her own dignity as much as anything else.

OP posts:
Stelladid · 08/11/2026 20:15

wouldyouactuallydothat · 08/11/2026 20:12

Clearly that gate at that farm is open Hmm

The teachers can’t do anything that I’m not already. I’m not expecting anyone to go my job as is obvious, given she’s been out of nappies for eight months.

If (and it is a huge if) she is still soiling by next September I will have to look at deferring her place as i agree she cannot go to school doing this for her own dignity as much as anything else.

Fair enough. I hope the situation gets easier for you.

wouldyouactuallydothat · 08/11/2026 20:16

I don’t accept for one moment that two and a half (which is when we started to potty train her) is ‘too late’, sorry. For most children, a few months either side of three is pretty standard

OP posts:
wouldyouactuallydothat · 08/11/2026 20:18

Stelladid · 08/11/2026 20:15

Fair enough. I hope the situation gets easier for you.

Well, it is rare someone is that reasonable so thank you for that! I do think it’s worth remembering that while lazy parenting can be a thing if can also be rooted in other problems and not every parent of a child struggling with toileting just can’t be arsed Smile

OP posts:
Kingdomofsleep · 08/11/2026 20:19

If she's "oozing" several times a day, that's not soft stools, that's impaction overflow. You know this.

Your decision making is based on a combination of incorrect misconceptions (eg about children you "know" becoming physically reliant on stool softener) and pique, ie you don't like the tone of the advice so you won't take it. I wasn't criticising you before but I am now, because your poor dd is going to school soon and this will be so damaging to her confidence and friendships and learning.

Londersand · 08/11/2026 20:20

She’s either got constipation problems or special needs. Probably helpful to work out which one eh

Velumental · 08/11/2026 20:26

wouldyouactuallydothat · 08/11/2026 13:46

@Kingdomofsleep I’m not saying that to be rude. It is just that after eight months of difficulties I’ve explored extensively all of the obvious (and not so obvious!) solutions and just keep hitting a brick wall. I was just trying to avoid lots of ‘have you contacted ERIC op’ sort of replies.

I may change my mind tomorrow but she is in a pull up now. I just cannot take any more of it for now. Shit fatigue is real.

I know she tries to hold them in and so then of course eventually out they come but because she’s holding them in it’s in lots of little messy oozes throughout the day - ugh.

Everyone else I know just potty trained so easily and seamlessly and it’s hard not to think about why meeee!

It's hard when they with old because it's not physical it's psychological. Having a break may be the right answer. I'd keep the potty out, take her to the toilet when you go, offer before and after bath and on waking g etc so she's still using the potty/ toilet. It doesn't have to be all or nothing

wouldyouactuallydothat · 08/11/2026 20:27

@Kingdomofsleep look, we aren’t going to agree on this. She’s seen a GP and I’m really sorry but I am not taking her to multiple GPs until they give me the answer someone on MN wants. I can see myself what’s happening: she needs a poo, she won’t allow it out but of course eventually it has to come out, doesn’t it? Now honestly, let’s move on. I didn’t post for advice and I hate the way anyone with a child with problems using the toilet for bowel movements can’t post about it under the sheer weight of insistence the child is constipated, even if a medical professional (who has actually SEEN the child!) has said otherwise. I do trust our GP: she’s a mother herself and she knows our children and family.

OP posts:
wouldyouactuallydothat · 08/11/2026 20:29

And what I don’t like is bitchy comments about my ‘poor’ DD. You know what you’re doing and I really don’t want to engage any further.

OP posts:
Sleepster · 08/11/2026 20:29

wouldyouactuallydothat · 08/11/2026 14:21

Eric are not tremdendously helpful to be honest @ScaryM0nster . I spoke to them when ds was struggling and I found them very judgemental.

Did your son also struggle with potty training? If so, what worked in the end for him?

Velumental · 08/11/2026 20:30

wouldyouactuallydothat · 08/11/2026 20:16

I don’t accept for one moment that two and a half (which is when we started to potty train her) is ‘too late’, sorry. For most children, a few months either side of three is pretty standard

It's too late to.i troduce the concept for the first time. I trained mine around 2/2.5 but it started with going to he loo with me since babyhood, knowing therefore what the toilet was for, I got a wee mini toilet they would sit on from 1(/12 while at the loo with me and they'd pretend to wipe. Both of them around 2 took their nappy off, had a wee, we kept that up u tilt hey could also hold a wee rather than dribble all day then spent a week naked at home with eldest before he was reliable before putting pants on and youngest it took 24 hours and she was asking for pants and literally day 2 we went to softplay and she used the toilet there and she was trained.

If your child so impacted you need to get lactulose or movical into her to clear her out fully, and then it's getting more water and fruit into her to help her be more regular. We've had a couple fo episodes with my youngest as she's so fussy and a poor drinker. She's 5 now though and knows she needs to drink more and will say to me her poo feels a bit spiky and she wants poo medicine so they sort of grow into an aware ness of their body. Meantime though you need to be the adult here.

Sleepster · 08/11/2026 20:31

Really surprised her nursery hasn’t been much more keen to meet with you and discuss a plan and how to address

wouldyouactuallydothat · 08/11/2026 20:33

Sleepster · 08/11/2026 20:29

Did your son also struggle with potty training? If so, what worked in the end for him?

Edited

With Ds, I tried to get him on the toilet too quickly. His feet weren’t on the floor and so he struggled to poo. I reintroduced the potty and it was that simple. I didn’t make that mistake with DD though!

It is interesting as I remember posters insisting ds was constipated as well and I didn’t see how he could be as with DD; really good diet, lots of water (and only water.) Maybe it’s something simple like that with her.

I feel better about it now (and the potty is back in from the garden!) It is rooted in anxiety but I just wish she’d talk to me about it. I don’t mind a bit if she wanted to use a nappy and ask to use one but cleaning up a mess is so dispiriting especially as it just always seems to happen at the worst possible times! She did one on a boat tour last week and it did rather impede on the autumnal serenity of the riverbanks!

OP posts:
wouldyouactuallydothat · 08/11/2026 20:34

Sleepster · 08/11/2026 20:31

Really surprised her nursery hasn’t been much more keen to meet with you and discuss a plan and how to address

I think they can see I’m doing everything I can to try to help her, so what plan could realistically be put in place? It isn’t that she isn’t trained at all after all.

OP posts:
SuddenDaredJelly · 08/11/2026 20:35

wouldyouactuallydothat · 08/11/2026 20:27

@Kingdomofsleep look, we aren’t going to agree on this. She’s seen a GP and I’m really sorry but I am not taking her to multiple GPs until they give me the answer someone on MN wants. I can see myself what’s happening: she needs a poo, she won’t allow it out but of course eventually it has to come out, doesn’t it? Now honestly, let’s move on. I didn’t post for advice and I hate the way anyone with a child with problems using the toilet for bowel movements can’t post about it under the sheer weight of insistence the child is constipated, even if a medical professional (who has actually SEEN the child!) has said otherwise. I do trust our GP: she’s a mother herself and she knows our children and family.

So take a step back.

How does putting her back in a nappy help? If it's that psychologically, she associates wearing the nappy with relaxing her bowels to poo, then thats probably at the heart of solving it (both the withholding when not in a nappy, resulting impaction & leakage soiling) She wont magically outgrow that association of needing a nappy to poo. It will take work on your part to train it out.

wouldyouactuallydothat · 08/11/2026 20:37

It helps with the clean up process; that’s it really. I’m losing a lot of pairs of pants!

OP posts:
Sleepster · 08/11/2026 20:38

wouldyouactuallydothat · 08/11/2026 20:34

I think they can see I’m doing everything I can to try to help her, so what plan could realistically be put in place? It isn’t that she isn’t trained at all after all.

This won’t be new to them. They will have extensive experience of this and may be able to offer you advice that is much more suited to your daughter than Eric - who don’t know her

Swipe left for the next trending thread