Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To have just put my three year and four month old back in nappies after eight months

123 replies

wouldyouactuallydothat · 08/11/2026 13:02

I just cannot take the shit any more.

I know I’m going to get the usual bingo responses here about ERIC (useless) constipation, GPs and all the rest of it and that’s not what I’m about. I’ve been trying to solve this issue for months now and just - cannot.

I am done with it. I just kicked the potty outside with a sense of satisfaction (yes, I know MN hate potties but ERIC recommend them for children with toileting problems for poo,)

I just cannot take another pair of shit filled pants.

OP posts:
Decisionfatiguemum · 08/11/2026 14:25

wouldyouactuallydothat · 08/11/2026 13:52

The GP does not agree @Kingdomofsleep . I think she’s withholding but that isn’t the same as constipation.

@SoThatsTheWayItIs she is fine with wee is the thing and I am worried about undoing that, but I’ll just have to cross that bridge when I come to it. I do feel like a massive failure though.

I feel your pain op. I have a very capable and clever three year old who hit every milestone early or on time, but potty training was a pain in the bim. Thankfully he got the wees quite quickly but will he poo in a potty or a toilet?? No. Even at nursery he won't. We tried everything. Our issue is he labours over his poos for ages and they're huge, despite upping his fibre etc and water as much as we can, but he is on all fours to poo as it seems to be the position he finds easies, so sitting on the potty for him just doesn't work atm.

Thankfully, he tells us he needs a poo, we put a nappy on, and he poos in it. No poo accidents but with his skills and language, and comprehension, he really should be pooping on the loo but as I say, he just cannot connect it in his head and has a huge fuss if expected to. So I see how it happens and how frustrating it is when you've tried everything and nothing is working. His friend was similar but one day he just clicked and took himself to the loo for a poo but mine isn't there yet, wish he was!

Neverendingstory111 · 08/11/2026 14:25

wouldyouactuallydothat · 08/11/2026 14:17

@Neverendingstory111 i have tried to talk to her about it but don’t really get anywhere to be honest, I’ve asked her if she’s scared to go and she says no, but I think she probably is because she will often poo in her nappy just before she goes to bed (she isn’t consistently dry overnight.)

Bless her and you, I really do understand and in this situation constantly trying and trying is not going to help.
I would work with her to help her with her anxiety of going for a poo maybe social storys before trying again when your not so stressed.

Itsthewoluff · 08/11/2026 14:26

Mine was scared of pooing so we went back into pull ups despite being ok with wee’s. Luckily I managed to catch one in a potty one day on holiday when he didn’t have trousers on, and he realised that nothing bad would happen and then he was immediately 100% clean. Don’t traumatise her for longer. She won’t be in them forever.

Toddlergrumps · 08/11/2026 14:30

Kingdomofsleep · 08/11/2026 14:01

It's ok,I get it, you think i am being unhelpful, but i am just passing on the wisdom i got from MN myself. It was a magic bullet for my son, but you have to get the dosage right - the first gp I spoke to (an inexperienced one) suggested half a sachet a day which did nothing. The second gp said up to 8 initially then taper down. It worked in weeks. Perhas the pp also needs to increase the dose, i don't know.

Laxido is not a laxative - this convinces me you haven't read Eric in spite of dismissing it. It's a stool softener.

I must have been more desperate than you are, because I didn't dismiss any advice I was given. My ds is about to turn 3 now and is pooing one solid poo in the potty everyday, and I'm so grateful for the many mn movicol threads I read. I'm just paying that forward now. It's ok if this advice doesn't appeal to you, it'll work for others reading

We’ve seen 3 possibly 4 different GPs and an out of hours GP after he’d gone 8 days without pooing. We started on lactulose, upped that, switched to laxido, started at one sachet and increased to 10 a day.

In terms of advice, I have been extremely desperate and followed a lot, perhaps we are more desperate than you, and tried too many things.
We’ve got 6 potty books, we’ve tried the poo poo, wee wee song, we’ve tried different potty’s (got 5) toilet seats (3 free to a good home), him picking pants (must have 50+ pairs), stickers, chocolate buttons (currently using an advent calendar to open a window and get a chocolate which is more successful), larger rewards like a farm animal reward for his farm. We’ve tried rewarding for sitting on the potty, wees and poos, we’ve also tried rewarding dry pants after an hour. We’ve tried timing toilet visits, we’ve tried waiting for signals, we’ve tried waiting for him to tell us. We’ve tried bare bum, I honestly don’t think there is anything we haven’t tried. Even nursery have run out of ideas, and just say carry on he will get there eventually.

lanthanum · 08/11/2026 14:31

The suggestion of "do it in a nappy, but you need to be in the bathroom first" makes a lot of sense if she's withholding (and might confirm that that's the issue).
Mine managed to keep all poo for after bedtime so she could do it in her nappy - fortunately successfully, so we could just wait until she was ready to get rid of the night-time nappy.

Tereseta · 08/11/2026 14:31

My dd took ages to come out of nappies, she was constipated and on movicol and we had lots of pooey pants. It is an awful stage but.you will come through. I used to get so stressed over it but she is now a regular as clockwork poo girl (though she doesn't flush which is another story!)
We used pull ups at that age and when it was knickers I used to buy really cheap ones from primark so they could be binned when needed.
Sending a bit of solidarity and support... she has a long 10 months before school. We managed to get our dd there before school, hopefully your dd does....but if not it will happen when it happens. Our Gp just gave movicol sachets and not an awful lot else, they didn't seem concerned which I figured meant I should be stressing about it. It's hard because chatting about these things with other parents inevitably leads to comparisons and feeling inadequate...keep going and do what's right for you and your family 💐

Soontoomuch · 08/11/2026 14:35

Get some "old fashioned" nappies, terry toweling ones, nappy pins etc. They are really horrible to wear. Wet and bulky between their legs and they rub (not too much). I would be surprised if she wore them for over a week!

I was with a group of oldies where we were all discussing how children are not that keen to give up using nappies. Once ours were into pants, or nothing, most of them didn't like having a nappy on. There wasn't much of an issue then.

maggisimpson · 08/11/2026 14:35

One of mine was a difficult to train for poos, bribery was the thing that worked in the end.

Went to Poundland and the Works and bought 10 of the cheapest, biggest toys, and wrapped them in shiny paper with bows on.
I put them in a basket in the bathroom and said every time you poo on the toilet, you can choose a present.

That was the thing that eventually got them pooing. We'd go and try as a routine twice a day, after breakfast and after dinner, and they'd sit there and stare at the presents.

SassyTee · 08/11/2026 14:37

I have twins. One of them potty trained at 2 years old, only took a week and never had an accident since. The other twin was much more difficult, wasn't remotely ready until over a year later, then we had a year of regular accidents as well.
I guess what I'm trying to get at is that no child is the same, what works for one may not work for another, and it isn't anything you're doing wrong.
Nothing wrong with giving both you and her a break for a month then revisit potty training again.

wouldyouactuallydothat · 08/11/2026 14:38

Toddlergrumps · 08/11/2026 14:30

We’ve seen 3 possibly 4 different GPs and an out of hours GP after he’d gone 8 days without pooing. We started on lactulose, upped that, switched to laxido, started at one sachet and increased to 10 a day.

In terms of advice, I have been extremely desperate and followed a lot, perhaps we are more desperate than you, and tried too many things.
We’ve got 6 potty books, we’ve tried the poo poo, wee wee song, we’ve tried different potty’s (got 5) toilet seats (3 free to a good home), him picking pants (must have 50+ pairs), stickers, chocolate buttons (currently using an advent calendar to open a window and get a chocolate which is more successful), larger rewards like a farm animal reward for his farm. We’ve tried rewarding for sitting on the potty, wees and poos, we’ve also tried rewarding dry pants after an hour. We’ve tried timing toilet visits, we’ve tried waiting for signals, we’ve tried waiting for him to tell us. We’ve tried bare bum, I honestly don’t think there is anything we haven’t tried. Even nursery have run out of ideas, and just say carry on he will get there eventually.

Ten a day? That sounds crazy to me but I am obviously not an expert. But my concern is that treating a child for constipation who is not constipated is going to result in the body becoming reliant on them.

@lanthanum it would make sense if she’d do it!

OP posts:
sittingonabeach · 08/11/2026 14:46

We had DC who withheld. Can’t remember what we were given for them (long time ago) but it was a stool softener. Potty training had worked well but then had a bout of constipation and that’s when the withholding started

WhereverYouGoThereYouAre · 08/11/2026 14:46

You’re not alone OP. This is very similar to my son who wasn’t toilet trained for poo until he was 4. He was dry for wee much earlier so was out of pull ups. I also had a younger child in nappies so I get what you mean to be fed up literally dealing with shit, as he would soil his pants multiple times a day.

My son also held onto his poo and let bits out at a time. The GP recommended two laxatives at the same time (Movicol and Parachoc, I’m in Aus and one is a sachet and one paraffin oil based) so he couldn’t hold on anymore as he did get impacted bowels and poo overflow. I ended up binning pants rather than cleaning them as I couldn’t deal with more shit especially the ones mixed with the oil.

I hear you OP. My son got there eventually right before he started 4 year old kindy and that was one of his motivations to be clean. These stubborn, independent thinking children just need steered in the right direction. You’re not doing anything wrong. My son is 14 now and his late toilet training has not affected him at all.

Withholding poos is actually quite common. She will get there eventually OP.

Itsthewoluff · 08/11/2026 14:55

I’m presuming you do realise that you can just rip pull ups off at the side and you don’t do as my dad did and try to pull them down like normal pants and thus getting poo all the way down his legs 🤣

wouldyouactuallydothat · 08/11/2026 14:56

That’s a huge problem when she does soil in pants actually. The mess it makes is horrendous.

OP posts:
Ved · 08/11/2026 14:57

Who's ERIC? 😬

wouldyouactuallydothat · 08/11/2026 15:01

Does it matter?

OP posts:
ThisNiftyMember · 08/11/2026 15:11

TeddyBeans · 08/11/2026 13:26

I put my 3 year 8 month old back in nappies after a year of potty training when she was relentlessly wetting herself at nursery. She hated it and very quickly stopped wetting herself to get back into pants. She is on a strict 1 chance only routine at the moment. If she wets one pair of pants, she goes straight in a nappy 🤷‍♀️ it can work if the expectation is still that she keeps clean but saves our sanity a little bit if they don't

That sounds so harsh they way you have worded it. It must be stressful for your child that even if she has gone weeks with no accident, one minor slip and she is back in a nappy? How long before she allowed pants again?

TeddyBeans · 08/11/2026 15:44

She gets one chance at dry pants a day and if she manages it, she gets a sticker for her sticker book. If not, she's in nappies for the rest of the day (usually it stays dry) and then she starts over the next day. She's a very content little girl in every other aspect of life 🤷‍♀️

Boomer55 · 08/11/2026 15:45

wouldyouactuallydothat · 08/11/2026 13:02

I just cannot take the shit any more.

I know I’m going to get the usual bingo responses here about ERIC (useless) constipation, GPs and all the rest of it and that’s not what I’m about. I’ve been trying to solve this issue for months now and just - cannot.

I am done with it. I just kicked the potty outside with a sense of satisfaction (yes, I know MN hate potties but ERIC recommend them for children with toileting problems for poo,)

I just cannot take another pair of shit filled pants.

Persevere. You don’t want to be one of ‘those’ parents.

wouldyouactuallydothat · 08/11/2026 15:51

‘Those’ being a parent of a child with continence difficulties? No one would choose it!

OP posts:
ThisNiftyMember · 08/11/2026 16:06

TeddyBeans · 08/11/2026 15:44

She gets one chance at dry pants a day and if she manages it, she gets a sticker for her sticker book. If not, she's in nappies for the rest of the day (usually it stays dry) and then she starts over the next day. She's a very content little girl in every other aspect of life 🤷‍♀️

Ah that sounds reasonable and if most days the nappy stays dry then it sounds as though it won't be long before she has cracked it!

Rainallnight · 08/11/2026 18:40

Kingdomofsleep · 08/11/2026 14:01

It's ok,I get it, you think i am being unhelpful, but i am just passing on the wisdom i got from MN myself. It was a magic bullet for my son, but you have to get the dosage right - the first gp I spoke to (an inexperienced one) suggested half a sachet a day which did nothing. The second gp said up to 8 initially then taper down. It worked in weeks. Perhas the pp also needs to increase the dose, i don't know.

Laxido is not a laxative - this convinces me you haven't read Eric in spite of dismissing it. It's a stool softener.

I must have been more desperate than you are, because I didn't dismiss any advice I was given. My ds is about to turn 3 now and is pooing one solid poo in the potty everyday, and I'm so grateful for the many mn movicol threads I read. I'm just paying that forward now. It's ok if this advice doesn't appeal to you, it'll work for others reading

I’m with @Kingdomofsleep GPs are notoriously bad at treating childhood constipation. I went all round the houses before getting a referral to a gastroenterologist and embarking on the mother of all disimpactions. By that stage, DD had an enlarged rectum and is dealing with the fallout years later.

Allthevarious · 08/11/2026 19:30

What about using Father Christmas as a bit of leverage? Ie

“I wonder if FC will think that you only want really very babyish toys because you’re still doing poos in a nappy?”

wouldyouactuallydothat · 08/11/2026 19:51

@Allthevarious i don’t want to shame her. Apart from the fact it’s not a parenting method I feel comfortable with it’s also not a choice on her part (imo) it’s rooted in something else. I can go back to the GP but what I don’t want is her being prescribed laxatives and her body becoming reliant on them. I have seen that pattern in other children to be honest and it makes me very cautious. I do think she is withholding poo. But that isn’t the same as constipation.

OP posts:
Kingdomofsleep · 08/11/2026 19:55

Op just please look up the difference between a stool softener and a laxative. Your dd deserves that level of engagement in the issue, she is suffering, and it will take you 5 minutes.