Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think aggression toward local authorities is getting out of hand?

725 replies

Apotofrealcoffee · 08/11/2026 10:51

And this is one of the nicer ones. I feel like with the NHS people appreciate that the problems with the service aren’t the fault of the ground level staff, but with local authorities it seems absolutely fine to be highly abusive. People seem to be egging each other on. I think it’s disgraceful. I’m seeing it more and more.

To think aggression toward local authorities is getting out of hand?
OP posts:
Thread gallery
7
Stressedandgrey · 08/11/2026 19:37

BluebellBeth · 08/11/2026 19:33

You can deny it all you want, thousand of families live it every day. And it wasn't me who intially said they deliberately stall to save costs either. It was the OP who acknowledged they do so!

Edited

But that is utter bullshit. It honestly is.

I'm going to leave you to your conspiracy theories now. I have to prepare for a work week of thinking up malicious ways to harm children with SEND, schemes to delay the support going in place, and general planned wickedness to children (like my own) who are having a shit time in a broken system 🙄

OneandFiveOnly · 08/11/2026 19:38

Stressedandgrey · 08/11/2026 19:34

So if they have made a decision you disagree with you have the right of appeal. The fact that they are denying it is a viewpoint, one which can pursue.

The LAs are applying the law to what they see in front of them.

I have worked a across several LAs, sat in panels, funding decisions etc and I can assure of this.

And I can assure you I have a letter in front of me applying the wrong legal test to justify denying carrying out a EHCnA. This local authority knows full well what the legal test is - they’ve been taken to tribunal and ombudsman enough times about it.

They lie. They gaslight, They stall. They are chancers knowing that by doing this some families will go away.

PeasOff · 08/11/2026 19:38

Apotofrealcoffee · 08/11/2026 19:33

That’s not a human rights concern.

There is usually an offer of an education, which satisfies the right to an education. It’s just it isn’t taken up, or something else is requested. It isn’t a human right to a certain type of education.

Why do you think an offer isn't taken up or something else is requested? Often because what's being offered isn't suitable or doesn't meet the child's needs.

There's a big difference between being offered a place on paper and being able to access education that meets a child's needs. Children shouldn't have to accept unsuitable provision just so a LA can say it's made an offer. The right to education is about meaningful access, not just ticking a box.

BluebellBeth · 08/11/2026 19:38

OneandFiveOnly · 08/11/2026 19:34

It’s really not.

LAs regularly insist that the legal test for an EHCNA is reams and teams of evidence of struggles with school.

That is not the legal test. It never has been. LAs regularly lost on this basis - they ALL KNIW IT US NOT THE LEGAL TEST and yet they continue to tell families it is.

This. Anyone that believes LAs are making decisions based on the law re SEND are the only ones veering into fantasy land. Again, if they're making lawful decisions, how are they losing 99% of appeals?

OneandFiveOnly · 08/11/2026 19:38

Stressedandgrey · 08/11/2026 19:37

But that is utter bullshit. It honestly is.

I'm going to leave you to your conspiracy theories now. I have to prepare for a work week of thinking up malicious ways to harm children with SEND, schemes to delay the support going in place, and general planned wickedness to children (like my own) who are having a shit time in a broken system 🙄

No, it isn’t.

hibernatinghedgehog · 08/11/2026 19:39

Stressedandgrey · 08/11/2026 19:26

I asked you what could be done within the LAs remit, one case with 100k costs might pay for 1 year at an independent SEND school for one child. That's not solving the crisis is it? It's just pulling the narrative back you you.

And FWIW I knew you'd have EOTISC as soon as you stated those sorts of costs.

Honestly, I work supporting looked after children with SEND who just want a school place and a some support whilst the LA are forced by tribunal to spend stretched high needs funding on ponies, holidays, david lloyd memberships and soho farmhouse membership (all real examples I have actually seen a tribunal order an LA to pay for).

You have 3 children, non of whom could possibly be appropriately educated at any school anywhere, is that right?

Out of curiosity, would you be happy to share what each of your children does through their EOTISC packages?

It is within the LA’s remit to not spend large sums of money defending indefensible cases against unrepresented parents when they know they will lose. I just gave my experience as an example, but I am by no means the only one. LAs spend large sums of money on representation.

I would love my two with EOTAS/EOTIS/C to have a school place. Sadly, it is inappropriate for provision to be made in a school for them. EOTAS isn’t the easy option some like to think it is.

SENDIST doesn’t Order provision that isn’t reasonably required, in the legal sense. If LAs thought they had, they would be quick to challenge the decision.

You have 3 children, non of whom could possibly be appropriately educated at any school anywhere, is that right?

No, it’s not right. Try actually reading the post. Two have EOTAS/EOTIS/C. One is in MS.

I will answer your question about the content of the packages in another post.

OneandFiveOnly · 08/11/2026 19:40

Apotofrealcoffee · 08/11/2026 19:33

That’s not a human rights concern.

There is usually an offer of an education, which satisfies the right to an education. It’s just it isn’t taken up, or something else is requested. It isn’t a human right to a certain type of education.

It usnt?

The right to an education is not in the Human Rights Act?

What about Freedom from Discrimination? Is that not in the HRA either?

hibernatinghedgehog · 08/11/2026 19:41

The LAs are applying the law to what they see in front of them.

LAs regularly act unlawfully.

OonaStubbs · 08/11/2026 19:42

All children have the right to an education. They do not have the right to an education that is specifically tailored to their specific needs. Because the cost of doing that for every child would be astronomical and unaffordable.

Stressedandgrey · 08/11/2026 19:43

NanofTwo · 08/11/2026 19:34

Tell me you haven't had the utter misery of needing an Ehcplan and going through the tribunal process, without telling me!

The LA stall at every given opportunity, play games and ultimately act unlawfully all to safe money

I have three children with EHCPS. I have had placement breakdowns, periods out of school when there was no special school place, mental health difficulties as a result. I had to change jobs to accomodate this.

But I have the benefit of working for a (different... No favours) LA and can see the real cause of the difficulty not the conspiracy theories.

Tell me you've never managed a caseload of 300 kids, with no special school places available and 100 arsey parents sending AI generated complaints they don't even understand each week eh?

BluebellBeth · 08/11/2026 19:43

Stressedandgrey · 08/11/2026 19:37

But that is utter bullshit. It honestly is.

I'm going to leave you to your conspiracy theories now. I have to prepare for a work week of thinking up malicious ways to harm children with SEND, schemes to delay the support going in place, and general planned wickedness to children (like my own) who are having a shit time in a broken system 🙄

👍🏻

hibernatinghedgehog · 08/11/2026 19:43

@Stressedandgrey DS1 has:
8 hours of 1:1 home tuition maths
13hrs SEN tutor covering literacy/general learning/enrichment/mentoring/accessing the community/PfA/life skills/just ‘being’ at home

13 hours of other provision consisting of:
1 hour each of SALT, SIOT, CP, Lego therapy, rebound therapy, and swimming.
2hrs of ‘normal’ OT
1hr of exercise of our choosing
4 x 1hr physio (2 sessions with a physio, 2 sessions specialist personal trainer)

Full time HLTA hours (the role is actually split into more than 1 role).
TA time to cover lunchtime.

Then other provision such as professional time (e.g. for planning, report writing, termly MDTs, updated advice and information, ARs, summary communication post sessions, time for professionals to access advice from each other, training, QTVI, QHS, ToD and EP input/training/provision, EOTIS co-ordinator hours), equipment, membership/subscriptions, budget for resources, sundries, etc, budget for PfA/life skills, accessing the community/trips/enrichment, etc, travel costs/time, insurances, payroll company.

DS3 has:
2 days at an outward bounds AP
15 hours of 1:1 face to face tuition
1hr study skills support
1hr each of SALT, OT/SIOT and 1:1 music lesson
1.5hr cooking lesson
physio - 5 x 1hr active sports sessions for 39 weeks/7 x 1hr active sports sessions for the 13 weeks outside of the AP’s term time provision.
LSA time to cover all the provision except the AP (the role is split into more than one position).
2hrs per week mentoring/PfA/accessing the community/enrichment/supported work experience term time 39 weeks per year. 5hrs per week outside of term time for 13 weeks per year.

Then other provision such as 12 CP sessions over the years, science lab practicals, professional time (e.g. for planning, report writing, termly MDTs, updated advice and information, ARs, summary communication post sessions, time for professionals to access advice from each other, training, ToD, physio and EP input/training/provision, EOTIS co-ordinator hours), equipment, membership/subscriptions, budget for resources, sundries, etc, budget for PfA/life skills, accessing the community/trips/enrichment, etc, travel costs/time, insurances, payroll company.

Unexpectedlysinglemum · 08/11/2026 19:43

There is such a mix of LA workers and teams it’s such a lottery, some are incredibly dedicated and some are awful at their jobs and dive deserve to be involved with vulnerable children.
Lots of parents are awful and abusive too thoigh including lots with their own mental health and social skills struggles

BluebellBeth · 08/11/2026 19:44

OonaStubbs · 08/11/2026 19:42

All children have the right to an education. They do not have the right to an education that is specifically tailored to their specific needs. Because the cost of doing that for every child would be astronomical and unaffordable.

Err, yeah they do.

hibernatinghedgehog · 08/11/2026 19:44

OonaStubbs · 08/11/2026 19:42

All children have the right to an education. They do not have the right to an education that is specifically tailored to their specific needs. Because the cost of doing that for every child would be astronomical and unaffordable.

DC with SEN are entitled to SEP they reasonably require to meet the SEN. That is set out in law.

Stressedandgrey · 08/11/2026 19:44

hibernatinghedgehog · 08/11/2026 19:43

@Stressedandgrey DS1 has:
8 hours of 1:1 home tuition maths
13hrs SEN tutor covering literacy/general learning/enrichment/mentoring/accessing the community/PfA/life skills/just ‘being’ at home

13 hours of other provision consisting of:
1 hour each of SALT, SIOT, CP, Lego therapy, rebound therapy, and swimming.
2hrs of ‘normal’ OT
1hr of exercise of our choosing
4 x 1hr physio (2 sessions with a physio, 2 sessions specialist personal trainer)

Full time HLTA hours (the role is actually split into more than 1 role).
TA time to cover lunchtime.

Then other provision such as professional time (e.g. for planning, report writing, termly MDTs, updated advice and information, ARs, summary communication post sessions, time for professionals to access advice from each other, training, QTVI, QHS, ToD and EP input/training/provision, EOTIS co-ordinator hours), equipment, membership/subscriptions, budget for resources, sundries, etc, budget for PfA/life skills, accessing the community/trips/enrichment, etc, travel costs/time, insurances, payroll company.

DS3 has:
2 days at an outward bounds AP
15 hours of 1:1 face to face tuition
1hr study skills support
1hr each of SALT, OT/SIOT and 1:1 music lesson
1.5hr cooking lesson
physio - 5 x 1hr active sports sessions for 39 weeks/7 x 1hr active sports sessions for the 13 weeks outside of the AP’s term time provision.
LSA time to cover all the provision except the AP (the role is split into more than one position).
2hrs per week mentoring/PfA/accessing the community/enrichment/supported work experience term time 39 weeks per year. 5hrs per week outside of term time for 13 weeks per year.

Then other provision such as 12 CP sessions over the years, science lab practicals, professional time (e.g. for planning, report writing, termly MDTs, updated advice and information, ARs, summary communication post sessions, time for professionals to access advice from each other, training, ToD, physio and EP input/training/provision, EOTIS co-ordinator hours), equipment, membership/subscriptions, budget for resources, sundries, etc, budget for PfA/life skills, accessing the community/trips/enrichment, etc, travel costs/time, insurances, payroll company.

That's quite a full on week for someone who can't manage any school at all...

OneandFiveOnly · 08/11/2026 19:44

OonaStubbs · 08/11/2026 19:42

All children have the right to an education. They do not have the right to an education that is specifically tailored to their specific needs. Because the cost of doing that for every child would be astronomical and unaffordable.

They have a right to an education that they CAN ACCESS - article 14 Freedom from Discrimination - will also come into play here.

Christmasiscoming26 · 08/11/2026 19:44

I’ll use school transportation as an example. Central govt sets rules re who is entitled to free transport. It costs an authority millions to meet this. This comes out of local council highways budget in my LA. Yet most local voters would want highways budget spent on fixing potholes - that was high up in election manifesto of reform cllrs they voted for. The cllrs who have promised to fix the potholes to get elected would rather say let’s not provide school transport but are told legally they can’t so instead do things like mini buses. Tinkering for political purposes and to try and save a bit.
Then they can’t recruit the aides to sit on the buses as who wants to work a couple of hours a day and be in charge of a bus full of medically vulnerable or potentially violent children all for min wage.
Some LA’s have written to central government to demand local authorities be permitted to set their own rules re school transport.
What they can’t do is say local people have voted to use the money for potholes and think parents should take their own children to school so we aren’t complying with the law. If they do then they will be challenged legally as the council cannot ignore the law.

PeasOff · 08/11/2026 19:45

Stressedandgrey · 08/11/2026 19:34

So if they have made a decision you disagree with you have the right of appeal. The fact that they are denying it is a viewpoint, one which can pursue.

The LAs are applying the law to what they see in front of them.

I have worked a across several LAs, sat in panels, funding decisions etc and I can assure of this.

Right of appeal doesn't negate the problem though and as you're no doubt aware, appeals take time, and in the meantime children are often left without the support or provision they need and are therefore not accesing education.

You working across several LAs doesn't mean the system is consistently getting decisions right or that families experiences can be dismissed either.

Applying the law means properly considering each child's individual needs and securing the provision they're legally entitled to. Having an appeal process doesn't make the failures any less real or the impact on children any less significant!

OneandFiveOnly · 08/11/2026 19:45

Stressedandgrey · 08/11/2026 19:44

That's quite a full on week for someone who can't manage any school at all...

Here we go….

ScholesPanda · 08/11/2026 19:45

This is why I'd never do a job like this if I could help it.

People go into these jobs- housing officers, SEND, helping the vulnerable etc. thinking they are going to make a real positive difference and help people. Then they realise they have limited resources, and will always have limited resources (we'll never be able to afford 100% of the support that every SEND child needs for e.g.); that demand is constant and rising; that they'll never get thanked for getting it right; and that they face a choice of repeatedly helping those who know how to navigate the system and shout loudest, or trying to help everyone and spreading yourself very thin.

Frankly, you will also come across people who are plain entitled, who burden every public service going without ever giving anything back, who do nothing to help themselves, and in some cases are just deeply unpleasant.

You have to develop a thick skin to cope with all this and still be able to function, and that is a vicious circle as it probably does mean that success in these careers can go to those with the thickest skins, and least empathy.

Robotmonkeybutler · 08/11/2026 19:47

You can't get blood from a stone - there is simply not enough money to support the ever increasing number of children with SEND needs. Everyone and their dog seems to have a "need" not a "want" these days. This means the genuine ones aren't getting the support they should be getting.
SEND schools should also not have been allowed to get into the hands of private business owners. Making money off the most venerable in society is abhorrent (same with care homes and children's homes)!!!

hibernatinghedgehog · 08/11/2026 19:48

Stressedandgrey · 08/11/2026 19:44

That's quite a full on week for someone who can't manage any school at all...

They have ‘waking day’ provision. (Waking day is in ‘ ‘ because I know it isn’t a term SENDIST like these days.) We have wording that enables us to use the hours flexibly and responsively across the year.

But, yes, just because it is inappropriate for provision to be made in a school doesn’t mean they can’t manage provision. If you think you can magically make it not inappropriate, you are deluded.

BluebellBeth · 08/11/2026 19:48

Stressedandgrey · 08/11/2026 19:34

So if they have made a decision you disagree with you have the right of appeal. The fact that they are denying it is a viewpoint, one which can pursue.

The LAs are applying the law to what they see in front of them.

I have worked a across several LAs, sat in panels, funding decisions etc and I can assure of this.

You seem keen to ignore the fact LAs lose 99% of appeals. Making unlawful decisions in 99% of cases isn't a case of 'well they're trying their best' is it. It can't even be fobbed off as incompetence at that level frankly.

User5667887765544331 · 08/11/2026 19:48

Stressedandgrey · 08/11/2026 19:26

I asked you what could be done within the LAs remit, one case with 100k costs might pay for 1 year at an independent SEND school for one child. That's not solving the crisis is it? It's just pulling the narrative back you you.

And FWIW I knew you'd have EOTISC as soon as you stated those sorts of costs.

Honestly, I work supporting looked after children with SEND who just want a school place and a some support whilst the LA are forced by tribunal to spend stretched high needs funding on ponies, holidays, david lloyd memberships and soho farmhouse membership (all real examples I have actually seen a tribunal order an LA to pay for).

You have 3 children, non of whom could possibly be appropriately educated at any school anywhere, is that right?

Out of curiosity, would you be happy to share what each of your children does through their EOTISC packages?

Sorry I just don’t believe that parents demand ponies, David Lloyd and Soho House memberships. I am sure that parents who have to give up work to support a child without a suitable school placement say hey lets go for a fancy gym membership when all they want is their child educated.

Swipe left for the next trending thread