Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think aggression toward local authorities is getting out of hand?

725 replies

Apotofrealcoffee · 08/11/2026 10:51

And this is one of the nicer ones. I feel like with the NHS people appreciate that the problems with the service aren’t the fault of the ground level staff, but with local authorities it seems absolutely fine to be highly abusive. People seem to be egging each other on. I think it’s disgraceful. I’m seeing it more and more.

To think aggression toward local authorities is getting out of hand?
OP posts:
Thread gallery
7
OneandFiveOnly · 09/11/2026 18:48

LottaQ · 09/11/2026 18:27

Thanks for highlighting this, OP. I actually came across the posts you're referring to on FB and was genuinely shocked by them. The level of aggression and personal abuse was completely unacceptable. Whatever people's experiences of local authorities, there is no justification for directing that sort of abuse at individuals.
I think there's a much bigger issue here that we need to acknowledge. We are in a crisis across health, education and social care and it's been bubbling away for years. A combination of austerity and the gradual stripping away of early intervention like sure start hubs and support services, the impact of Covid on children's mental health and the huge increase in awareness and diagnosis of neurodivergence has brought us to where we are now.
The number of EHCPs has increased enormously and I think we need to be honest about how much the scope of the system has expanded. EHCPs were originally intended for children and young people with significant and complex needs, but increasingly they're being used to compensate for the lack of other services. Mental health, trauma and wider social care needs are often being channelled through an educational plan because the support that should exist elsewhere simply isn't available.
I also think there's been a real shift towards parental advocacy, much of it fuelled by social media. Obviously parents should advocate for their children and there are absolutely cases where they have to fight to get what their child needs. But equally, a lot of the adversarial behaviour and challenging that we see is unnecessary. There's almost an expectation that the relationship with the LA has to be combative, that every interaction needs to be challenged and that officers are somehow the enemy. Social media can perpetuate this and create expectations that simply aren't realistic.
The reality is that SEND officers are massively overworked, carrying huge and increasingly complex caseloads, trying to meet statutory deadlines, chasing other professionals for advice and provision, dealing with complaints and managing expectations, often with very little actual decision-making power themselves.
And I think it's worth remembering that the vast majority of people who choose to work in SEND do so because they genuinely care about children and young people and want to make a difference. Nobody goes into this work expecting an easy ride and im certainly not suggesting local authorities always get things right. They don't, and there are genuine failings that need to be challenged. But there's a huge difference between holding an organisation accountable and personally attacking the individuals working within an already struggling system.
Ultimately, we're expecting EHCPs and local authority SEND teams to somehow compensate for the failings of health, education and social care as a whole. It's completely unsustainable and it's unfair on children, families AND the staff trying to navigate it.
The system is broken, but that’s no excuse for being vulgar and hostile to the staff trying to keep it going.

I’m curious - how do you think one treats mental health needs that are caused by being forced day in day out into an environment that completely overloads and overwhelms one’s nervous system? What exactly do you expect mental health services to do when it is the school that is causing the anxiety, the panic attacks, the low self esteem, the fight or flight response?

NightHeron · 09/11/2026 18:48

Budgiedrama · 09/11/2026 14:55

The tribunals thing is a bit of an interesting point, as there are lots of things which I bet you could ‘win’ at tribunal such as Pip appeals, the allocation of funding for care, the outcome of care act assessments. Essentially all of these are, to a certain extent, based on opinion and interpretation of the law. There are no concrete standards. I could assess someone’s care needs or eligibility for PIP and a different professional could come to a completely different conclusion. There are no absolutes. I have no doubt a clever lawyer could argue for nearly every child to have an EHCP and/or a certain provision. Because terms such as ‘life changing’ ‘long term impact’ ‘inappropriate’ ‘distressing’ ‘small setting’ ‘sensory profile’ are not quantifiable. The same as I might assess someone’s anxiety as being significant enough to require a package of care for food shopping, another social worker might feel that they need to crack on with it, be referred for CBT or learn to use a computer to do it online, and not feel that a care package is necessary. There’s no right and wrong, there’s no black and white. It could all argued from both perspectives.

Er no - having appealed to the tribunal four times, and participated in a claim for disability discrimination, ime a “clever” lawyer cannot argue anything, unless they have professional evidence to support what they are arguing for! It’s not a lawyer, who decides a child needs specialist dyslexia teaching, speech therapy or whatever; a qualified professional (like an educational psychologist or speech therapist respectively) must have produced a report saying that, and preferably be a witness at the tribunal hearing to elaborate on that, and counter the LA’s arguments.

I know nothing about EOTAS, having no experience of it; but I have sought specified provisions and specialist placement for DD1 over a period of 14 years, and sought judicial review three times before or after a tribunal, to get the LA to comply with their statutory duties in respect of her SEN education.

For those who think Social Services do their best, and don’t lie, cheat or bully parents over social care, I sought judicial review twice over their failures to do their statutory duties in respect of her social care.

LottaQ · 09/11/2026 18:56

OneandFiveOnly · 09/11/2026 18:48

I’m curious - how do you think one treats mental health needs that are caused by being forced day in day out into an environment that completely overloads and overwhelms one’s nervous system? What exactly do you expect mental health services to do when it is the school that is causing the anxiety, the panic attacks, the low self esteem, the fight or flight response?

I don't disagree with you, and I think that's actually part of the problem. If a child's school environment is contributing to their anxiety and distress because their needs aren't being understood or accommodated, then simply referring them to mental health services isn't going to fix that. You can't treat a child so that they're better able to tolerate an environment that is fundamentally unsuitable for them.
But I think we're in danger of conflating a number of different issues here. There's the educational provision and adjustments needed to meet a child's needs, there's the mental health support they might need as a result of their experiences, and there's the wider failure of early intervention and support services.
All of those things need addressing, but an EHCP isn't a substitute for all the other services that should be available to children and families.
My point is that we've gradually reached a position where the SEND system is expected to pick up the pieces for failures across multiple services, and local authority teams are then held responsible for outcomes they often have very little control over.
Children absolutely deserve an education where they feel safe, understood and able to access learning. But we need a properly joined-up system to achieve that, not simply an ever-expanding reliance on EHCPs.

OneandFiveOnly · 09/11/2026 19:00

LottaQ · 09/11/2026 18:56

I don't disagree with you, and I think that's actually part of the problem. If a child's school environment is contributing to their anxiety and distress because their needs aren't being understood or accommodated, then simply referring them to mental health services isn't going to fix that. You can't treat a child so that they're better able to tolerate an environment that is fundamentally unsuitable for them.
But I think we're in danger of conflating a number of different issues here. There's the educational provision and adjustments needed to meet a child's needs, there's the mental health support they might need as a result of their experiences, and there's the wider failure of early intervention and support services.
All of those things need addressing, but an EHCP isn't a substitute for all the other services that should be available to children and families.
My point is that we've gradually reached a position where the SEND system is expected to pick up the pieces for failures across multiple services, and local authority teams are then held responsible for outcomes they often have very little control over.
Children absolutely deserve an education where they feel safe, understood and able to access learning. But we need a properly joined-up system to achieve that, not simply an ever-expanding reliance on EHCPs.

So you’ve got a child unable to access school because it’s the environment….whats the route to them accessing an education? An EHCP - that’s the only route (that I know of) if school cannot meet needs so child can access.

LottaQ · 09/11/2026 19:08

OneandFiveOnly · 09/11/2026 19:00

So you’ve got a child unable to access school because it’s the environment….whats the route to them accessing an education? An EHCP - that’s the only route (that I know of) if school cannot meet needs so child can access.

I think you're deliberately missing the point here. I'm not disputing that children need access to education or that EHCPs are sometimes necessary to secure that. I'm making a much wider point about the systemic failures that have brought us to this position and the unrealistic expectations being placed on SEND teams. Repeatedly reducing that argument to whether a child needs an EHCP doesn't actually address anything I've said.

hibernatinghedgehog · 09/11/2026 19:10

Much mental health support, including therapies, is actually deemed to be special educational provision. Similarly, some social care provision is actually deemed to be special educational provision.

Although, yes, early intervention is always preferable and would save money. Sadly, too many only look at the short-term costs and fail to realise the longer term costs of failing to meet needs in the short term.

@OneandFiveOnly there is section 19 provision which doesn’t require an EHCP but for those who need an EHCP it shouldn’t be instead of an EHCP.

OneandFiveOnly · 09/11/2026 19:30

LottaQ · 09/11/2026 19:08

I think you're deliberately missing the point here. I'm not disputing that children need access to education or that EHCPs are sometimes necessary to secure that. I'm making a much wider point about the systemic failures that have brought us to this position and the unrealistic expectations being placed on SEND teams. Repeatedly reducing that argument to whether a child needs an EHCP doesn't actually address anything I've said.

Apologies

but I can assure you I’m not deliberately missing the point. I may be missing the point you’re trying to make, and I may work for an LA myself, but I can assure you I never deliberately miss a point or play games just to try to ‘win’ - I have standards.

I was trying to point out that in many cases the only route is EHCP, purely because it’s the incompatibility of the school environment and set up with a child’s needs. Not because of failures from social care or NHS. Also health and social care needs that need to be met within our current schooling system also fall within EHCP - that’s why it’s called and EHCP, that’s not due to health or social care failures, it’s just the child’s situation. You can give the best care in the world to let’s say a child with cerebral palsy but they will still have health needs that require education to make provision so it can be accessed.

OneandFiveOnly · 09/11/2026 19:32

hibernatinghedgehog · 09/11/2026 19:10

Much mental health support, including therapies, is actually deemed to be special educational provision. Similarly, some social care provision is actually deemed to be special educational provision.

Although, yes, early intervention is always preferable and would save money. Sadly, too many only look at the short-term costs and fail to realise the longer term costs of failing to meet needs in the short term.

@OneandFiveOnly there is section 19 provision which doesn’t require an EHCP but for those who need an EHCP it shouldn’t be instead of an EHCP.

You’re right there is s19, but that is only supposed to be temporary and the vast majority of that provision for ‘full time’ education is 5-10 hours a week if you’re lucky.

hibernatinghedgehog · 09/11/2026 19:39

@OneandFiveOnly there’s nothing actually stopping s19 provision from being longer term, and 5-10hrs a week does not fulfil the LA’s duty. It does not comply with the law, it is LA’s acting unlawfully, again.

However, where an EHCP is needed, that should still be pursued, it shouldn’t be instead of an EHCP. Not least because the scope that can be provided via an EHCP is wider and it isn’t limited to CSA pupils.

OneandFiveOnly · 09/11/2026 19:46

hibernatinghedgehog · 09/11/2026 19:39

@OneandFiveOnly there’s nothing actually stopping s19 provision from being longer term, and 5-10hrs a week does not fulfil the LA’s duty. It does not comply with the law, it is LA’s acting unlawfully, again.

However, where an EHCP is needed, that should still be pursued, it shouldn’t be instead of an EHCP. Not least because the scope that can be provided via an EHCP is wider and it isn’t limited to CSA pupils.

Oh I know they’re acting unlawfully. I personally have never heard of anyone ever securing full time education on s19.

Thing is, if a parent neglected a child’s education like this what would happen? Oh no, wait - I know!!!!

Fines, more fines, court action, possibly even public law proceedings, imprisonment…..

hibernatinghedgehog · 09/11/2026 20:18

@OneandFiveOnly I secured full-time s19 provision. It was a while ago now and the political climate was different, but I have supported others to do the same including more recently. Although LAs usually only do it when forced.

OneandFiveOnly · 09/11/2026 20:24

hibernatinghedgehog · 09/11/2026 20:18

@OneandFiveOnly I secured full-time s19 provision. It was a while ago now and the political climate was different, but I have supported others to do the same including more recently. Although LAs usually only do it when forced.

Well done! Wish me luck

LottaQ · 09/11/2026 21:12

OneandFiveOnly · 09/11/2026 19:30

Apologies

but I can assure you I’m not deliberately missing the point. I may be missing the point you’re trying to make, and I may work for an LA myself, but I can assure you I never deliberately miss a point or play games just to try to ‘win’ - I have standards.

I was trying to point out that in many cases the only route is EHCP, purely because it’s the incompatibility of the school environment and set up with a child’s needs. Not because of failures from social care or NHS. Also health and social care needs that need to be met within our current schooling system also fall within EHCP - that’s why it’s called and EHCP, that’s not due to health or social care failures, it’s just the child’s situation. You can give the best care in the world to let’s say a child with cerebral palsy but they will still have health needs that require education to make provision so it can be accessed.

Edited

I think we're talking at cross purposes here. You're focusing on one particular aspect of SEND, which I completely understand may be particularly relevant to your own experience, but I'm talking about the much wider pressures on the SEND system and how we've arrived at this point.
My original post was about the cumulative impact of years of austerity, the loss of early intervention and wider support services, the impact of Covid, increased identification of neurodivergence and the resulting demand on an already overstretched system.
I'm not disputing that children can have perfectly legitimate reasons for needing an EHCP because their school environment cannot meet their needs. That's not the point I'm making.
I'm talking about the bigger picture and the pressures this creates for everyone involved – children, families, schools and the people working in SEND. I feel that point is getting somewhat lost in a debate about one particular route to accessing education.
I do wish you well in your endeavours to secure the provision you feel is necessary.

OneandFiveOnly · 09/11/2026 21:31

LottaQ · 09/11/2026 21:12

I think we're talking at cross purposes here. You're focusing on one particular aspect of SEND, which I completely understand may be particularly relevant to your own experience, but I'm talking about the much wider pressures on the SEND system and how we've arrived at this point.
My original post was about the cumulative impact of years of austerity, the loss of early intervention and wider support services, the impact of Covid, increased identification of neurodivergence and the resulting demand on an already overstretched system.
I'm not disputing that children can have perfectly legitimate reasons for needing an EHCP because their school environment cannot meet their needs. That's not the point I'm making.
I'm talking about the bigger picture and the pressures this creates for everyone involved – children, families, schools and the people working in SEND. I feel that point is getting somewhat lost in a debate about one particular route to accessing education.
I do wish you well in your endeavours to secure the provision you feel is necessary.

You can also include the fact that our school system is now far more rigid, the curriculum far narrower in many ways and this also creates more issues for accessibility. Children would have previously coped now cannot due to arbitrary rigid school ‘rules’ and higher pressure, more focus on the three R’s less break times, less opportunity to decompress etc etc etc.

Apotofrealcoffee · 09/11/2026 21:36

OneandFiveOnly · 09/11/2026 21:31

You can also include the fact that our school system is now far more rigid, the curriculum far narrower in many ways and this also creates more issues for accessibility. Children would have previously coped now cannot due to arbitrary rigid school ‘rules’ and higher pressure, more focus on the three R’s less break times, less opportunity to decompress etc etc etc.

I don’t recognise this at all.

In the early 2000s we had uniform inspection, dull rigid lessons where you just faced the front in rows, lots of homework, Saturday detention, no screens or adjustments.

OP posts:
OonaStubbs · 09/11/2026 21:42

Schools were far stricter in the past than they are today. Too many kids are allowed to rule the roost at home so that when it comes to school they can't cope with not having their own way all the time. How their parents expect them to cope with work and adult life is beyond me.

User5667887765544331 · 09/11/2026 22:45

OonaStubbs · 09/11/2026 21:42

Schools were far stricter in the past than they are today. Too many kids are allowed to rule the roost at home so that when it comes to school they can't cope with not having their own way all the time. How their parents expect them to cope with work and adult life is beyond me.

So what are you saying is that SEN is just a product of poor parenting 🙄

runnersfeet · 09/11/2026 22:51

INeverReallyLovedYouAnyway · 08/11/2026 11:46

What I will say is, if you stop sending pages and pages of AI-generated shite complaints and FOI requests etc that we then have to try to respond to, we will have some breathing space and resources to actually do our jobs…

This is a huge problem. This along with a multi strand complaints process means we barely have time to do our actual jobs - which hey presto means more AI and round and round we go. 😩

NightHeron · 09/11/2026 23:23

runnersfeet · 09/11/2026 22:51

This is a huge problem. This along with a multi strand complaints process means we barely have time to do our actual jobs - which hey presto means more AI and round and round we go. 😩

No, SEN officers weren’t doing their jobs properly 30 years ago, when people were lucky to have a home PC with dial up, and barely knew how to do an email. AI only existed in science fiction!

BluebellBeth · 09/11/2026 23:24

runnersfeet · 09/11/2026 22:51

This is a huge problem. This along with a multi strand complaints process means we barely have time to do our actual jobs - which hey presto means more AI and round and round we go. 😩

I don't use AI, but if LAs responded to stage one complaints properly, we wouldn't have to 'waste' anyone's time with stage two (or potentially stage three and and independent review) and then the ombudsman thereafter. Do you think we go through for this for shits and giggles?

INeverReallyLovedYouAnyway · 10/11/2026 00:09

BluebellBeth · 09/11/2026 23:24

I don't use AI, but if LAs responded to stage one complaints properly, we wouldn't have to 'waste' anyone's time with stage two (or potentially stage three and and independent review) and then the ombudsman thereafter. Do you think we go through for this for shits and giggles?

Lodging a six page AI-generated complaint because your DSAR was a day late (because it’s the 15th AI-generated DSAR we have received since last Monday) is not a productive use of anyone’s time.

HelpMyBlackLabradorVotesReform · 10/11/2026 06:38

OonaStubbs · 09/11/2026 21:42

Schools were far stricter in the past than they are today. Too many kids are allowed to rule the roost at home so that when it comes to school they can't cope with not having their own way all the time. How their parents expect them to cope with work and adult life is beyond me.

Many of them don't cope with work hence the NEET crisis,

runnersfeet · 10/11/2026 06:51

BluebellBeth · 09/11/2026 23:24

I don't use AI, but if LAs responded to stage one complaints properly, we wouldn't have to 'waste' anyone's time with stage two (or potentially stage three and and independent review) and then the ombudsman thereafter. Do you think we go through for this for shits and giggles?

I don't work in the sector mostly referred to in this thread but I can say with absolute certainty that some of my customers are doing exactly that. They escalate even when their complaint isn't upheld because they can or they're after financial redress. Then we spend hours and hours more preparing the file for the ombudsman. Hey presto not upheld. And those individuals will submit multiple cases. AI is bringing half the (depleted) workforce to a stop.

HelpMyBlackLabradorVotesReform · 10/11/2026 07:05

runnersfeet · 10/11/2026 06:51

I don't work in the sector mostly referred to in this thread but I can say with absolute certainty that some of my customers are doing exactly that. They escalate even when their complaint isn't upheld because they can or they're after financial redress. Then we spend hours and hours more preparing the file for the ombudsman. Hey presto not upheld. And those individuals will submit multiple cases. AI is bringing half the (depleted) workforce to a stop.

Maybe the difference is in Education 98% of cases are lost by LAs at Tribunal. So the hey presto bit doesn't really apply.

OneandFiveOnly · 10/11/2026 07:13

runnersfeet · 10/11/2026 06:51

I don't work in the sector mostly referred to in this thread but I can say with absolute certainty that some of my customers are doing exactly that. They escalate even when their complaint isn't upheld because they can or they're after financial redress. Then we spend hours and hours more preparing the file for the ombudsman. Hey presto not upheld. And those individuals will submit multiple cases. AI is bringing half the (depleted) workforce to a stop.

So if a person is unhappy with a LAs response to a complaint people shouldn’t fully utilise the complaints process, the ombudsman or JR?

Because in my time I’ve seen some very sloppy complaints processes and outcomes that absoloutly should have been escalated to the next stage. I’ve seen complaints that were turned away at stage one with ‘we did absoloutly everything right and you’re just moaning’ this response and then at stage three the iro has been a very different outcome, and that outcome has helped to repair the horrific damage done to a service user.

But they were just money grabbing, yes?

But I guess we should all just be happy with whatever we get out of stage 1 of an LA’s complaints process? I mean, they’ve done all that work of impartially investigating themselves….