Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think we underestimate the homelessness crisis because of our stereotypical image of what homelessness looks like?

53 replies

BeTidyFinch · 06/11/2026 08:24

I think one of the reasons we don’t fully appreciate the scale of the homelessness crisis in this country is because so many of us have a very narrow perception of what a homeless person looks like. We tend to picture someone sleeping rough on the streets when the reality is that homelessness takes many different forms. You could be working alongside someone who is homeless. You could be next to them at the gym, sitting beside them on the train or driving alongside them on the motorway.

They might be employed, well-dressed, educated and outwardly appear to have their life together. Yet they have nowhere permanent or secure to call home.

I think this misconception means that a huge part of the homelessness crisis remains invisible to the wider public. I also think that until we challenge our assumptions about what homelessness looks like, we’ll continue to underestimate just how widespread the problem really is.

AIBU?

OP posts:
Bacha1910 · 06/11/2026 08:32

I think you’re talking about a wider housing crisis, which is much broader. Not to diminish the impact of it, it’s also very serious, but the causes and fixes are not the same. Acute homelessness, street homelessness, is what most people mean when they talk about homelessness and we shouldn’t muddy that. It is a real crisis and needs to be addressed.

BeTidyFinch · 06/11/2026 08:37

Bacha1910 · 06/11/2026 08:32

I think you’re talking about a wider housing crisis, which is much broader. Not to diminish the impact of it, it’s also very serious, but the causes and fixes are not the same. Acute homelessness, street homelessness, is what most people mean when they talk about homelessness and we shouldn’t muddy that. It is a real crisis and needs to be addressed.

But that’s precisely the misconception I’m highlighting in my OP. Homelessness and rough sleeping are not synonymous. Rough sleeping is one form of homelessness but it isn’t the only one.

Someone living in temporary accommodation or sofa-surfing because they have nowhere else to go can also be homeless. They don’t suddenly become part of a separate crisis simply because they’re not sleeping on the pavement.

I agree that different forms of homelessness can have different causes and require different solutions, but recognising the wider reality of homelessness doesn’t diminish the seriousness of rough sleeping. In fact, your comment rather illustrates my point about how narrowly homelessness is understood.

OP posts:
tomorrowfollowstoday · 06/11/2026 08:41

Bacha1910 · 06/11/2026 08:32

I think you’re talking about a wider housing crisis, which is much broader. Not to diminish the impact of it, it’s also very serious, but the causes and fixes are not the same. Acute homelessness, street homelessness, is what most people mean when they talk about homelessness and we shouldn’t muddy that. It is a real crisis and needs to be addressed.

This post helpfully illustrates the point the OP is making!

OP - I agree with you - many people (sometimes deliberately, sometimes not) minimise wider homelessness by focusing on street homelessness.

Catza · 06/11/2026 08:58

I see the point you are making but I don't understand what you think will change if we recognise other types of homelessness. I was homeless for 9 months last year in exactly the way you are describing - holding on to a professional job but having to sofa surf and live in holiday lodges for extended periods of time. I was miles better off than a rough sleeper and I think the resources should go to those who need a lot more support than me at that point. So what would change if we acknowledge the scale of the problem by recognising other types of homelessens? Being part of a statistic is frankly useless to me. I just needed a little time to find a permanent solution and had resources to do so. I don't need public recognition. I need a guy sleeping rough on my high street to be prioritised.

LemonPuppyPorkChop · 06/11/2026 09:00

I think the kinds of non-street homelessness you are talking about are pretty well-known about.

KimWexlersPonyTail · 06/11/2026 09:03

I do think however that having to sofa surf can so easily turn into street homelessness. I also believe that the blended family situations that seem so common now are fuelling the sofa surfing problem.

AnneLovesGilbert · 06/11/2026 09:05

What would you want people to do about it though?

tomorrowfollowstoday · 06/11/2026 09:09

Catza · 06/11/2026 08:58

I see the point you are making but I don't understand what you think will change if we recognise other types of homelessness. I was homeless for 9 months last year in exactly the way you are describing - holding on to a professional job but having to sofa surf and live in holiday lodges for extended periods of time. I was miles better off than a rough sleeper and I think the resources should go to those who need a lot more support than me at that point. So what would change if we acknowledge the scale of the problem by recognising other types of homelessens? Being part of a statistic is frankly useless to me. I just needed a little time to find a permanent solution and had resources to do so. I don't need public recognition. I need a guy sleeping rough on my high street to be prioritised.

The way politics works is if an issue is understood, the public tend to care. If the public start to care, politicians start to care.

Plenty of the people sofa surfing today will be street homeless in future. Just as with health issues, we need to prevent street homelessness as well as reverse it after it happens.

user1471538275 · 06/11/2026 09:09

I think expanding the concept of homelessness to include what I would call insecure or temporary housing /shelter makes people switch off.

It seems to be used to inflate the homelessness statistics.

You could say anyone in private rental has insecure housing - because they do, but they are not homeless.

If I'm giving a charity money, I want precision in what they are trying to achieve - who exactly are they prioritising.

Otherwise there is too much generic 'helping change the narrative' work which to me looks like wasting money.

BeTidyFinch · 06/11/2026 09:11

Catza · 06/11/2026 08:58

I see the point you are making but I don't understand what you think will change if we recognise other types of homelessness. I was homeless for 9 months last year in exactly the way you are describing - holding on to a professional job but having to sofa surf and live in holiday lodges for extended periods of time. I was miles better off than a rough sleeper and I think the resources should go to those who need a lot more support than me at that point. So what would change if we acknowledge the scale of the problem by recognising other types of homelessens? Being part of a statistic is frankly useless to me. I just needed a little time to find a permanent solution and had resources to do so. I don't need public recognition. I need a guy sleeping rough on my high street to be prioritised.

Your experience is the sort of situation I’m referring to in my OP. You were homeless for nine months while maintaining a professional job and I imagine many of the people you encountered during that period had absolutely no idea about your living circumstances. I’m not suggesting that your situation was equivalent to that of someone sleeping rough nor am I arguing that everyone experiencing homelessness requires the same level of intervention or support.

But I disagree that recognising the scale of homelessness is pointless. How can we properly understand, measure or address a problem if we’re only acknowledging its most visible manifestation?

Recognising hidden homelessness isn’t about seeking public sympathy or diverting resources away from rough sleepers. It’s about understanding the full extent of housing insecurity and ensuring that people’s circumstances aren’t overlooked simply because they don’t fit the stereotypical image of homelessness.

We can prioritise those with the most acute needs while still recognising that homelessness extends far beyond the streets. The two aren’t mutually exclusive.

OP posts:
tomorrowfollowstoday · 06/11/2026 09:11

AnneLovesGilbert · 06/11/2026 09:05

What would you want people to do about it though?

Society could invest in social housing rather than paying billions of taxpayer's money to private landlords.

Homelessness is a political issue.

augustuss · 06/11/2026 09:12

I think it’s unfair to say people are underestimating or not understanding the different forms of homelessness. It is widespread, as you say, so many people will know someone, or have experienced what you are describing.

I completely agree with the first response that the causes and fixes are not the same. And I think, actually putting them all in the same bracket will diminish the seriousness of rough-sleeping, and thin out available resources.

tomorrowfollowstoday · 06/11/2026 09:14

user1471538275 · 06/11/2026 09:09

I think expanding the concept of homelessness to include what I would call insecure or temporary housing /shelter makes people switch off.

It seems to be used to inflate the homelessness statistics.

You could say anyone in private rental has insecure housing - because they do, but they are not homeless.

If I'm giving a charity money, I want precision in what they are trying to achieve - who exactly are they prioritising.

Otherwise there is too much generic 'helping change the narrative' work which to me looks like wasting money.

Homelessness figures are not inflated.

Politicians deliberately minimise the figures.

BeTidyFinch · 06/11/2026 09:14

AnneLovesGilbert · 06/11/2026 09:05

What would you want people to do about it though?

For a start, recognise that homelessness isn’t limited to people sleeping rough. Greater public awareness can influence how we discuss homelessness, how seriously we take its scale and the pressure placed on policymakers to address it.

It also matters for prevention. If we only recognise homelessness once someone is sleeping on the streets, we’re overlooking people who may need support long before they reach that point.

I’m not suggesting that individuals can solve the homelessness crisis. I’m suggesting that we can’t properly address a problem if we don’t understand the full extent of it.

OP posts:
Rainingasusual · 06/11/2026 09:15

I see what you're saying OP. Homelessness is an enormous issue and equating it to purely sleeping rough allows us as a society to both diminish the scale of the problem and other those sleeping rough. Really bolsters "it could never be me" mindset, when in reality most of us are closer to being homeless than we'd like to think.
This is also inextricable in many respects from the housing crisis, although granted often those sleeping rough have different or additional support requirements.

Catza · 06/11/2026 09:20

BeTidyFinch · 06/11/2026 09:11

Your experience is the sort of situation I’m referring to in my OP. You were homeless for nine months while maintaining a professional job and I imagine many of the people you encountered during that period had absolutely no idea about your living circumstances. I’m not suggesting that your situation was equivalent to that of someone sleeping rough nor am I arguing that everyone experiencing homelessness requires the same level of intervention or support.

But I disagree that recognising the scale of homelessness is pointless. How can we properly understand, measure or address a problem if we’re only acknowledging its most visible manifestation?

Recognising hidden homelessness isn’t about seeking public sympathy or diverting resources away from rough sleepers. It’s about understanding the full extent of housing insecurity and ensuring that people’s circumstances aren’t overlooked simply because they don’t fit the stereotypical image of homelessness.

We can prioritise those with the most acute needs while still recognising that homelessness extends far beyond the streets. The two aren’t mutually exclusive.

But again, I will ask you what this recognition looks like in practice? This is management speak "recognising", "raising awareness", "shining light on...". What would fundamentally change as a result of that? What is the solution to this problem beyond "raising awareness"?

BeTidyFinch · 06/11/2026 09:26

Catza · 06/11/2026 09:20

But again, I will ask you what this recognition looks like in practice? This is management speak "recognising", "raising awareness", "shining light on...". What would fundamentally change as a result of that? What is the solution to this problem beyond "raising awareness"?

In practice, it means ensuring that homelessness policy, prevention services and public understanding reflect the full range of circumstances in which people experience homelessness. For example, earlier intervention for people who are sofa-surfing or moving between temporary arrangements, better access to housing advice before their circumstances deteriorate and ensuring that homelessness data captures those who aren’t visibly sleeping rough. It also means recognising that someone can be employed and outwardly financially stable while still experiencing homelessness rather than assuming that having a job somehow excludes them from needing housing support. These things matter because the way we define and understand a problem influences how we measure it, where we direct resources and what interventions we prioritise.

None of that means taking resources away from rough sleepers or suggesting that everyone requires identical support. And fundamentally, my OP was about challenging a widespread misconception, not presenting a comprehensive housing policy. I don’t think someone needs to have solved a national crisis before they’re entitled to question how it’s understood.

OP posts:
fuckeditupbadly · 06/11/2026 09:35

But you rather patronisingly assume that a sofa surfer needs 'advice' or intervention. It may well be that their situation is a temporary one after a relationship breakdown or gap between rentals. The state cannot be a giant safety net for absolutely everyone in slightly less than ideal.circumstances.
I dont disagree with the nerd for more social.housing but I also have no problem with private landlords provided they are operating lawfully..that is an area perhaps to be looked at. There's nothing immoral about being a landlord.

I would like to see changes in lending criteria so people who can prove they hsve paid x rent on time for x period could be allowed a 100% mortgage. I know several people who have rented for decades and occasionally been uprooted as the owner has sold up or whatever. Their rent is more than my mortgage so it would make far more sense for them to become owners..though not everyone wants that. There's a freedom in not being responsible for the building.

5128gap · 06/11/2026 09:35

AnneLovesGilbert · 06/11/2026 09:05

What would you want people to do about it though?

I suppose its to recognise that the problem isn't 'solved' at the point we no longer see people in doorways because they've been tidied away for the night.
As well as the problem of the hidden homeless OP describes, there's the issue that often getting people in from the streets can be easier than keeping them in. So there's a whole lot of other work to be done around support with MH, addiction, life skills etc, above and beyond providing more beds.
Also preventative work that stops the vulnerably housed escalating to homelessness. Renters rights for example.
Its a massive task that involves joined up work across several departments, CJS, NHS, welfare and housing.
I suppose OP wants to raise awareness.

BeTidyFinch · 06/11/2026 09:41

fuckeditupbadly · 06/11/2026 09:35

But you rather patronisingly assume that a sofa surfer needs 'advice' or intervention. It may well be that their situation is a temporary one after a relationship breakdown or gap between rentals. The state cannot be a giant safety net for absolutely everyone in slightly less than ideal.circumstances.
I dont disagree with the nerd for more social.housing but I also have no problem with private landlords provided they are operating lawfully..that is an area perhaps to be looked at. There's nothing immoral about being a landlord.

I would like to see changes in lending criteria so people who can prove they hsve paid x rent on time for x period could be allowed a 100% mortgage. I know several people who have rented for decades and occasionally been uprooted as the owner has sold up or whatever. Their rent is more than my mortgage so it would make far more sense for them to become owners..though not everyone wants that. There's a freedom in not being responsible for the building.

Where have I suggested that everyone sofa-surfing automatically needs intervention or that the state should provide a safety net for every less-than-ideal housing situation? Recognising that someone may be experiencing homelessness is not the same as assuming they’re incapable of managing their circumstances or require state assistance.

Of course, some people are between tenancies or staying with friends temporarily through choice. Others are sofa-surfing because they have nowhere secure to live, with little financial stability or any realistic prospect of finding permanent accommodation. Those are very different situations.

My point is that homelessness exists across a much broader spectrum than the stereotypical image of someone sleeping on the street. Recognising that distinction isn’t patronising, it’s acknowledging reality.

I’m also not sure where the morality of private landlords comes into my OP, as I’ve made no argument about landlords being inherently immoral. You raise some interesting points about mortgage lending and housing security, but they’re rather separate from the observation I was making.

OP posts:
Dearg · 06/11/2026 09:48

Rainingasusual · 06/11/2026 09:15

I see what you're saying OP. Homelessness is an enormous issue and equating it to purely sleeping rough allows us as a society to both diminish the scale of the problem and other those sleeping rough. Really bolsters "it could never be me" mindset, when in reality most of us are closer to being homeless than we'd like to think.
This is also inextricable in many respects from the housing crisis, although granted often those sleeping rough have different or additional support requirements.

Exactly this. Having a secure ‘home’ is one of life’s basic needs.

What that security looks like will vary among us, but the sheer desperation that comes from not having a secure place to lay our heads, without worry, cannot be understated.

Social housing used to be a safety net, but right to buy, and non-reinvestment of those proceeds eroded that, and paved the way for rental insecurity etc. ( I am not anti-landlord btw).

Even the most right wing of us would surely understand the economics of this.

Secure housing allows people to be productive members of society , and ultimately helps GDP, particularly for those ‘homeless’ who are not sleeping rough.

Catza · 06/11/2026 09:56

BeTidyFinch · 06/11/2026 09:26

In practice, it means ensuring that homelessness policy, prevention services and public understanding reflect the full range of circumstances in which people experience homelessness. For example, earlier intervention for people who are sofa-surfing or moving between temporary arrangements, better access to housing advice before their circumstances deteriorate and ensuring that homelessness data captures those who aren’t visibly sleeping rough. It also means recognising that someone can be employed and outwardly financially stable while still experiencing homelessness rather than assuming that having a job somehow excludes them from needing housing support. These things matter because the way we define and understand a problem influences how we measure it, where we direct resources and what interventions we prioritise.

None of that means taking resources away from rough sleepers or suggesting that everyone requires identical support. And fundamentally, my OP was about challenging a widespread misconception, not presenting a comprehensive housing policy. I don’t think someone needs to have solved a national crisis before they’re entitled to question how it’s understood.

Homelessness policy and prevention services already reflect that.
Homelessness Prevention Act 2017
Domestic violence act 2021
Homelessness Act 2002
Renter's Rights Act 2025
Children's Wellbeing and Schools Act 2026

All reflect the full range of circumstances and outline statutory responsibility to prevent homelessness.

throughthe · 06/11/2026 09:59

I agree there are "homeless" people then there are "street homeless" people but i'm pretty sure we all understand the difference between them and the wider problems we have.

tomorrowfollowstoday · 06/11/2026 10:05

Catza · 06/11/2026 09:56

Homelessness policy and prevention services already reflect that.
Homelessness Prevention Act 2017
Domestic violence act 2021
Homelessness Act 2002
Renter's Rights Act 2025
Children's Wellbeing and Schools Act 2026

All reflect the full range of circumstances and outline statutory responsibility to prevent homelessness.

In the real world there are insufficient efforts/resources allocated.

fuckeditupbadly · 06/11/2026 10:07

OP you mentioned tax payers money going to private landlords. To me that implies some issue with the idea that people are making money (ie earning their living) in this way. Apologies if I misread that. The alternative is to ban private letting which you can only do if you provide an alternative which no government in a modern economy can possibly do.

So far, noone on this thread has said they were unaware of different 'levels' of homelessness. For those in less dire straits, there are CABs and council offices and websites for help and advice. I do think sometimes we need to put more emphasis on people pro-actively looking for help, not just waiting for it to magically appear. I'm approaching pension age. I know I need to educate myself about where I stand, what the different options are and what will serve me best. Its not someone else's job to flag it up to.me.