Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think we underestimate the homelessness crisis because of our stereotypical image of what homelessness looks like?

53 replies

BeTidyFinch · 06/11/2026 08:24

I think one of the reasons we don’t fully appreciate the scale of the homelessness crisis in this country is because so many of us have a very narrow perception of what a homeless person looks like. We tend to picture someone sleeping rough on the streets when the reality is that homelessness takes many different forms. You could be working alongside someone who is homeless. You could be next to them at the gym, sitting beside them on the train or driving alongside them on the motorway.

They might be employed, well-dressed, educated and outwardly appear to have their life together. Yet they have nowhere permanent or secure to call home.

I think this misconception means that a huge part of the homelessness crisis remains invisible to the wider public. I also think that until we challenge our assumptions about what homelessness looks like, we’ll continue to underestimate just how widespread the problem really is.

AIBU?

OP posts:
tomorrowfollowstoday · 06/11/2026 10:08

fuckeditupbadly · 06/11/2026 09:35

But you rather patronisingly assume that a sofa surfer needs 'advice' or intervention. It may well be that their situation is a temporary one after a relationship breakdown or gap between rentals. The state cannot be a giant safety net for absolutely everyone in slightly less than ideal.circumstances.
I dont disagree with the nerd for more social.housing but I also have no problem with private landlords provided they are operating lawfully..that is an area perhaps to be looked at. There's nothing immoral about being a landlord.

I would like to see changes in lending criteria so people who can prove they hsve paid x rent on time for x period could be allowed a 100% mortgage. I know several people who have rented for decades and occasionally been uprooted as the owner has sold up or whatever. Their rent is more than my mortgage so it would make far more sense for them to become owners..though not everyone wants that. There's a freedom in not being responsible for the building.

There is something immoral about taxpayer's money paying for the private assets of landlords.

The amount the taxpayer spends on housing benefit which goes to private landlords is a major issue.

tomorrowfollowstoday · 06/11/2026 10:13

fuckeditupbadly · 06/11/2026 10:07

OP you mentioned tax payers money going to private landlords. To me that implies some issue with the idea that people are making money (ie earning their living) in this way. Apologies if I misread that. The alternative is to ban private letting which you can only do if you provide an alternative which no government in a modern economy can possibly do.

So far, noone on this thread has said they were unaware of different 'levels' of homelessness. For those in less dire straits, there are CABs and council offices and websites for help and advice. I do think sometimes we need to put more emphasis on people pro-actively looking for help, not just waiting for it to magically appear. I'm approaching pension age. I know I need to educate myself about where I stand, what the different options are and what will serve me best. Its not someone else's job to flag it up to.me.

No one is talking about banning private letting. Private letting has never been banned.

The fact is that private landlords take billions per year from the taxpayer. The taxpayer is buying assets for them.

fuckeditupbadly · 06/11/2026 10:15

Anytime the government buys anything from a private company they are doing that. Any government contract for literally anything is using tax payers money to increase profits for a business. How is this different?

Snorlaxo · 06/11/2026 10:24

I’m not sure what the point of your post is.

I think most people are aware of temporary housing being a “thing” but wouldn’t know how many people are in that category vs rough sleeping.

In a resource limited place like the UK, only the people in the extreme category like rough sleepers get help from public institutions. The NHS, police, social services… all operate like that. For example SS often don’t act until the situation is critical rather than intervene in the early stages because they are swamped with cases and have no resources.

tomorrowfollowstoday · 06/11/2026 10:28

fuckeditupbadly · 06/11/2026 10:15

Anytime the government buys anything from a private company they are doing that. Any government contract for literally anything is using tax payers money to increase profits for a business. How is this different?

As you understand, some taxpayers are unhappy about the level of transfer of money to private landlords, which is over £10billion per year. High private rents contribute significantly to a high welfare bill.

It's just politics, different people hold different policy opinions.

It's your political right to be in favour of a high welfare bill and the purchases of landlords' assets by the taxpayer.

Isitvintage · 06/11/2026 10:29

Catza · 06/11/2026 08:58

I see the point you are making but I don't understand what you think will change if we recognise other types of homelessness. I was homeless for 9 months last year in exactly the way you are describing - holding on to a professional job but having to sofa surf and live in holiday lodges for extended periods of time. I was miles better off than a rough sleeper and I think the resources should go to those who need a lot more support than me at that point. So what would change if we acknowledge the scale of the problem by recognising other types of homelessens? Being part of a statistic is frankly useless to me. I just needed a little time to find a permanent solution and had resources to do so. I don't need public recognition. I need a guy sleeping rough on my high street to be prioritised.

I was in the exact situation as you @Catza the only difference is that I had children when this happened and an awful secret in my relationship left me “homeless”. But I hopped between living with parents or my lying and emotionally abusive now ex. I was lucky I had friends I could “have holidays with” during term time.

I felt lucky to have a roof over my head, even if it was having to be with someone who was making me feel sick to the point I developed an eating problem, or being squished in my childhood home with my kids. Obviously the moving around wasn’t great for the kids. But the truth is many women stay in bad situations to have a roof over their heads.

I found a charity that actually help people that are vulnerable to other forms of homelessness - mainly women who end up being in vulnerable positions due to having to sofa surf or stay in a bad relationship etc.

For me this happened for 2 years. But I made it work. In my case recognition is important. Although I appreciate that I needed help with different issues such as domestic abuse and childcare.

Looking back, and now that I am in a permanent place (well as permanent as renting can be), it really disorientated my life.

I think street homelessness is also an issue but it comes with its own problems too. I used to help a friend that had a charity that helped rough sleepers and one of the shocking things I found is the ecosystem that many rough sleepers build, many of them end up with bad coping mechanism such as alcohol and drugs that they need extra support to function in society again. We really need to also work on helping those that are sofa surfing aswell before they run out of sofas and end up on the streets.

Last note I guess councils do have a system for people with children. But I feel for single people that may not have the friends or connections that end up being homeless.

Catza · 06/11/2026 11:31

tomorrowfollowstoday · 06/11/2026 10:05

In the real world there are insufficient efforts/resources allocated.

How would "raising awareness" fix this?

tomorrowfollowstoday · 06/11/2026 11:33

Catza · 06/11/2026 11:31

How would "raising awareness" fix this?

Same way as with any issue - if there's awareness, it moves up the political agenda.

However currently the list of political concerns is crowded, that's a feature of consistent underfunding since 2010.

Supersimkin7 · 06/11/2026 11:43

True street homeless in London are majority foreign nationals eg Romanians and people refused LTR,

Very good charity systems operate so they never have to sleep in the cold and they get fed very well year round. Good medical care, benefits advice, etc. are delivered.

fuckeditupbadly · 06/11/2026 12:17

tomorrowfollowstoday · 06/11/2026 10:28

As you understand, some taxpayers are unhappy about the level of transfer of money to private landlords, which is over £10billion per year. High private rents contribute significantly to a high welfare bill.

It's just politics, different people hold different policy opinions.

It's your political right to be in favour of a high welfare bill and the purchases of landlords' assets by the taxpayer.

Edited

Im in favour of entrepreneurial effort and the right for people to make a living. Provided they are operating legally, I have no.issue with this. The fa t that it impacts on tje welfare bill is due to the drop of availability of social housing which is the fault of successive governments. There's a guy on fb who makes excellent posts about his private landlord business abd how he purchases disused retail and brownfield sites, coverts them and leases them. He is trying to show how councils ought to be operating to provide more affordable housing instead of always focusing on new builds.

EmmaOvary · 06/11/2026 12:23

Supersimkin7 · 06/11/2026 11:43

True street homeless in London are majority foreign nationals eg Romanians and people refused LTR,

Very good charity systems operate so they never have to sleep in the cold and they get fed very well year round. Good medical care, benefits advice, etc. are delivered.

This is total BS on all counts. Have you seen the statistics for how many people die on the streets in the winter months? Shame on you.

Passaggressfedup · 06/11/2026 12:35

You are arguing over the semantics of a word.

Yes, homelessness is more widely defined than living in the street. Then what?

People living on a street is still a more urgent issue to take than someone working who is renting and has been given notice.

JJMama · 06/11/2026 18:19

I think most people do know and understand the depth of homelessness in this country. We don’t all walk around in a bubble, and some of us have experienced it ourselves.

Elleherd · 06/11/2026 18:36

Supersimkin7 · 06/11/2026 11:43

True street homeless in London are majority foreign nationals eg Romanians and people refused LTR,

Very good charity systems operate so they never have to sleep in the cold and they get fed very well year round. Good medical care, benefits advice, etc. are delivered.

Absolute Bollocks!
Yours sincerely,
A London street kitchen operative.

Oxaloacetate · 06/11/2026 23:57

Well yes there’s a difference between homeless and street homeless.

Oxaloacetate · 06/11/2026 23:58

Supersimkin7 · 06/11/2026 11:43

True street homeless in London are majority foreign nationals eg Romanians and people refused LTR,

Very good charity systems operate so they never have to sleep in the cold and they get fed very well year round. Good medical care, benefits advice, etc. are delivered.

Majority of the street homeless I see are white men with English accents and generally appearing to have substance abuse and/or mental health conditions. That’s my experience volunteering for a food bank.

EmeraldRoulette · 07/11/2026 00:09

@BeTidyFinch “They don’t suddenly become part of a separate crisis simply because they’re not sleeping on the pavement.”

but they do. They are two separate crises. And actually the means of addressing both of them are quite separate. There is an immediate urgency of the crisis where somebody is actually sleeping outside of shelter.

I’m not disputing that both of them are a huge problem, but putting them under the same category of homeless actually wouldn’t help either group.

pineapplecrushed · 07/11/2026 00:23

Do you have experience of working in the sector? You've made confident statements here about your understanding of who is homeless.

Fridgemanageress · 07/11/2026 00:28

The film “Cathy Come Home” was filmed in 1966, it was a truly shocking and harrowing film which helped change laws about homelessness, and councils could later rent properties to unmarried mothers too.

Sixty years on, we are still discussing homelessness. I work with young men and woman who live in the car park in converted vans, live on houseboats or travel miles from cheaper to buy areas. A very dear friend has moved 200miles because she can afford (after lots of overtime and living in a converted ambulance) a small house outright.

i don’t know the answers, I don’t pretend to know the answers, but listening to a lot of the younger people at work, they don’t want to rent, they want to buy, and like many before them, they know they have to move out and start again, which not everyone wants to do.

Housing does needs to be looked at, stamp duty needs to come down massively, and many other factors need looking into too

CherryKerry · 07/11/2026 00:29

I used to work in Local Authority Homesslessness Services and would say the majority of people don't understand the actual definition of a homeless person and confuse the term with rough sleeper.

Not sure about other UK countries but in Scotland every rough sleeper is entitled to temporary accommodation provided by or arranged by the local authority so the people you see sitting in the streets in Edinburgh etc are either choosing not to ask for help or actively refuse help, sadly many don't want to engage when we try, or they aren't homeless but actually part of begging gangs and being exploited.

Elleherd · 07/11/2026 06:33

CherryKerry · 07/11/2026 00:29

I used to work in Local Authority Homesslessness Services and would say the majority of people don't understand the actual definition of a homeless person and confuse the term with rough sleeper.

Not sure about other UK countries but in Scotland every rough sleeper is entitled to temporary accommodation provided by or arranged by the local authority so the people you see sitting in the streets in Edinburgh etc are either choosing not to ask for help or actively refuse help, sadly many don't want to engage when we try, or they aren't homeless but actually part of begging gangs and being exploited.

Edited

Very much not the case in London. Here street sleepers are everyone from people with serious substance abuse, mental health issues, people with ASD, tourettes etc affecting abilities and others perceptions of them, a small number without recourse to public funds, a tiny number without LTR, through to a large glut of very ordinary home bred people who have just run out of options, (especially men and older silent Black women) including more recently, a concerning rise in working homeless struggling not to lose their work.
(The well known groups of Romanians don't use our kitchens or other services)

Some are out begging as a way of life, some beg when they need something extra, a lot don't beg and are totally invisible to the general public.
We're not yet at a point where the wider public recognize the street homeless around them.

The difference between street homelessness and other forms of homelessness is how many resources you can call on to stay alive and functioning.

Once people slide through into no roof at all they become resource heavy, so yes it would be economically sensible to focus on preventing it, but there's a danger where it becomes so much easier and rewarding to focus on nicer 'at risk' individuals, than those multiply damaged by the realities of street survival.

Cornishclio · 07/11/2026 07:22

There is street homelessness and then there is displacement. People sofa surfing, in hostels or temporary accommodation. It is a big problem and successive governments cannot seem to sort it. There is also people in unsuitable accommodation. There are lots of reasons and not all financial. Domestic abuse, drug and alcohol dependency and mental health issues can all make someone homeless. Marriage break ups are another reason. There is no one cause and no one solution. I think we should not have sold off council houses at discounts. The lack of affordable private rentals is a massive problem and job instability make mortgages tricky to manage. We need more hostels to get people off the street.

Cornishclio · 07/11/2026 07:28

Supersimkin7 · 06/11/2026 11:43

True street homeless in London are majority foreign nationals eg Romanians and people refused LTR,

Very good charity systems operate so they never have to sleep in the cold and they get fed very well year round. Good medical care, benefits advice, etc. are delivered.

I do not believe that. Given how hard it is to access any social care services these days I doubt a homeless person with mental health issues or a dependency knows how to access help or has the wherewithal. I also am sceptical LAs are fulfilling their obligation to house those who don’t have permanent accommodation

WantALieDown · 07/11/2026 07:36

I think people well understand the housing crisis after all these years. Fighting over definitions isn’t that helpful. It’s just that politicians won’t sort it out!

ExtraOnions · 07/11/2026 08:07

…yet almost every time a scheme is proposed to build Social and Affordable Housing, it’s met with opposition. Nobody wants building near them… leading to sometimes years of costly court cases and appeals.

“Solving the crisis” inevitably means building more home, increasing supply, reducing the cost (and maybe the value of homes that people already own)

We also need to stop large multi-nationals buying up swathes of property. In certain areas I also think there should be much stronger restrictions on who can buy

HMOs are now also targeted, despite them providing homes for those who can’t afford a place on their own. One near here got refused, despite it being tied to the hospital, and specifically for Student Doctors.

Street Homelessness is an altogether more complicated issue.