Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think the reporting of the Russell Brand verdict reveals how deeply ingrained misogyny is in our society?

62 replies

CleverTealGoose · 06/11/2026 06:37

I’ve noticed the frequent references to the jury being made up of eight men and four women. I can’t help but feel that this detail is being emphasised because a guilty verdict delivered by a predominantly male jury is somehow considered more credible, particularly when the defendant is another man accused of sexual violence against women. As though the public, both men and women, should feel more confident in the verdict because men themselves have reached it. Would the jury’s gender composition be highlighted quite so frequently if it consisted of eight women and four men? To me, it speaks volumes about the extent to which men’s judgement continues to be afforded greater authority than women’s, even when it comes to violence against women and girls.

AIBU?

OP posts:
TotaleclipseinFrance · 06/11/2026 11:20

Weeelokthen · 06/11/2026 09:32

I think a lot of women, on here anyway, chuck the misogyny word about too freely withoit a proper understanding of the true meaning of this overused word.
I think people also forget that most men have a female they really love, daughter, sister, mother............ and I was so glad the jury was mostly men.

Yep.
No wonder a lot of decent guys are saying 'fuck it' I'm not bothering with women any more.
They must be looking at the women now saying how disgusting Brand was at the height of his fame (emphasis on was - obviously we didn't know he was a rapist at the time) and thinking that they weren't disgusted by him at all at the time.

They're told being decent and kind are what women want in a man yet look what a sizeable amount of them were actually attracted to.
Back in the day, I bet a lot of decent ordinary men got chucked because their girlfriends secured a date with Brand.

Motnight · 06/11/2026 11:46

TotaleclipseinFrance · 06/11/2026 11:20

Yep.
No wonder a lot of decent guys are saying 'fuck it' I'm not bothering with women any more.
They must be looking at the women now saying how disgusting Brand was at the height of his fame (emphasis on was - obviously we didn't know he was a rapist at the time) and thinking that they weren't disgusted by him at all at the time.

They're told being decent and kind are what women want in a man yet look what a sizeable amount of them were actually attracted to.
Back in the day, I bet a lot of decent ordinary men got chucked because their girlfriends secured a date with Brand.

Are a lot of decent guys saying that? What's their alternative then if they want a relationship and fatherhood?

TiredShadows · 06/11/2026 12:17

The reporting I've seen I don't think shows that - as many have said, it's fairly normal and really there is very little that can be reported about jurors so it does humanise them a bit more.

How some people talk about that fact can be, and I can imagine some of the reporting may lean into that more, I've only seen a couple articles so may have missed what you've seen.

I do think there is some cultural ideas around how sex influences how jurors work, but as others have mentioned, it's not that clear cut, people are more complicated than that.

Why could it not have been 50/50?

It could have been, but it wasn't. The random selection of people to do jury service from a particular area, the random selection from jurors at that court for the jury panel for that case, and the random selection from the panel to serve on that jury makes it statistically unlikely for it to be 50/50 - it can happen, but more often than not there is some imbalance.

ByDreamyMember · 06/11/2026 13:29

You're right insofar that women get blamed either way. If women are a minority on the jury then it's 'he must be guilty because even men said so', and if they're a majority on the jury it's 'he must really be not guilty and the women are stitching him up'.

BooHissScarySeason · 06/11/2026 13:38

It’s all in what you hear on that jury stat - I hear that most ordinary people are starting to accept credible witness testimony and the MET police are rightly proud. We’re always hearing about men’s rights activists but no cut through here from RB’s US haven to Uk juries.

also, glad to see the MET speaking out about borderline victim blaming arguments used by the defence.

5128gap · 06/11/2026 13:39

TotaleclipseinFrance · 06/11/2026 11:20

Yep.
No wonder a lot of decent guys are saying 'fuck it' I'm not bothering with women any more.
They must be looking at the women now saying how disgusting Brand was at the height of his fame (emphasis on was - obviously we didn't know he was a rapist at the time) and thinking that they weren't disgusted by him at all at the time.

They're told being decent and kind are what women want in a man yet look what a sizeable amount of them were actually attracted to.
Back in the day, I bet a lot of decent ordinary men got chucked because their girlfriends secured a date with Brand.

I don't know a single decent guy who's saying he's no longer bothering with women. All the decent guys I know have excellent relationships with women. The only times I hear the sort of things you're describing, its coming from sad incel types who claim to 'not to be bothering' to save face, because no woman wants them.

Screamingabdabz · 06/11/2026 13:46

thingstheydonttellyouu · 06/11/2026 07:47

I was on jury service for a case involving rape and other sexual assaults. Let me tell you it was the men who were open minded and supportive towards the women, it was some of the other women who absolutely vile about the victims. I too had assumed having men on the jury would be a bad thing but it was the opposite!

I agree. That’s how deeply ingrained internal
misogyny is. Depressing.

icecreamscreams · 06/11/2026 13:53

I expected the jury to be quite varied on my SA case as I live in a multicultural area
11 men, 1 woman, all white

Isittimeformynapyet · 06/11/2026 17:17

Passaggressfedup · 06/11/2026 08:12

I love it how feminists can't help themselves but look to find reasons to shout misogyny!

Not guilty: misogyny
Not mentioning how the jury is formed: misogyny
Mentioning it: misogyny

Totally agree, but wish you'd put "feminists" in quotes to distinguish these women from actual feminists who live it rather than continuously shout about it.

CatesandAle · 06/11/2026 17:47

TotaleclipseinFrance · 06/11/2026 11:20

Yep.
No wonder a lot of decent guys are saying 'fuck it' I'm not bothering with women any more.
They must be looking at the women now saying how disgusting Brand was at the height of his fame (emphasis on was - obviously we didn't know he was a rapist at the time) and thinking that they weren't disgusted by him at all at the time.

They're told being decent and kind are what women want in a man yet look what a sizeable amount of them were actually attracted to.
Back in the day, I bet a lot of decent ordinary men got chucked because their girlfriends secured a date with Brand.

I don’t really understand this post. Are you saying women should have been disgusted by Brand before they knew he was a rapist? Why? Because he talked a lot about sex or was explicit in his comedy? I expect some women liked that, some didn’t, some barely paid attention to him and didn’t know who he was. Much like men.

Lhori · 06/11/2026 19:10

TotaleclipseinFrance · 06/11/2026 11:20

Yep.
No wonder a lot of decent guys are saying 'fuck it' I'm not bothering with women any more.
They must be looking at the women now saying how disgusting Brand was at the height of his fame (emphasis on was - obviously we didn't know he was a rapist at the time) and thinking that they weren't disgusted by him at all at the time.

They're told being decent and kind are what women want in a man yet look what a sizeable amount of them were actually attracted to.
Back in the day, I bet a lot of decent ordinary men got chucked because their girlfriends secured a date with Brand.

Are decent guys not bothering with women anymore? What are they doing instead?

I think most men can grasp the idea that women aren't all the same and don't all find the same men attractive. I reckon there were always many, many more women that found Russell Brand unattractive than ones who found him attractive. Personally, I always found him revolting and I am sure I am not the only one.

SeanHolden · 07/11/2026 15:26

The whole point about juries is that they are randomely selected to maintain the independence of the judicial system. If you start to compose a jury to give a theoretically more acceptable verdict the impartial basis of the system vanishes instantly. Is that what you want? How about the government starts requiring selection to be based on how jurors voted in the last election?

New posts on this thread. Refresh page