Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think the reporting of the Russell Brand verdict reveals how deeply ingrained misogyny is in our society?

62 replies

CleverTealGoose · 06/11/2026 06:37

I’ve noticed the frequent references to the jury being made up of eight men and four women. I can’t help but feel that this detail is being emphasised because a guilty verdict delivered by a predominantly male jury is somehow considered more credible, particularly when the defendant is another man accused of sexual violence against women. As though the public, both men and women, should feel more confident in the verdict because men themselves have reached it. Would the jury’s gender composition be highlighted quite so frequently if it consisted of eight women and four men? To me, it speaks volumes about the extent to which men’s judgement continues to be afforded greater authority than women’s, even when it comes to violence against women and girls.

AIBU?

OP posts:
IceColdCampariSpritz · 06/11/2026 07:51

Palmtreesinthegarden · 06/11/2026 07:49

This.

you are literally just looking for a problem. The word misogyny is overused on here

Edited

100% this and twisting yourself into knots thinking otherwise is not healthy or productive.

kirinm · 06/11/2026 07:52

lljkk · 06/11/2026 07:41

Journalists often say the gender distribution of jury members because it humanises the jury process, and because they can see panel genders with their own eyes. They can't report much else about the jury members (nor should they).

That said, OP's mention of jury M&F counts is first I've heard about the jury composition since the story broke last night.

You're sounding paranoid, OP. Can we all just be glad the creep will be locked up and can't hurt more people?

It’s not the first time I’ve heard it. It’s in the guardians article and all over social media.

ThePeppyOpalScroller · 06/11/2026 07:53

CleverTealGoose · 06/11/2026 06:37

I’ve noticed the frequent references to the jury being made up of eight men and four women. I can’t help but feel that this detail is being emphasised because a guilty verdict delivered by a predominantly male jury is somehow considered more credible, particularly when the defendant is another man accused of sexual violence against women. As though the public, both men and women, should feel more confident in the verdict because men themselves have reached it. Would the jury’s gender composition be highlighted quite so frequently if it consisted of eight women and four men? To me, it speaks volumes about the extent to which men’s judgement continues to be afforded greater authority than women’s, even when it comes to violence against women and girls.

AIBU?

So, even when men "do the right thing" you still have a problem with it 🤔🙄

When men say "I can't do anything right" this is what they mean.

Exhausting!

ThePeppyOpalScroller · 06/11/2026 07:55

CleverTealGoose · 06/11/2026 07:25

Yes, that’s much closer to what I’m getting at.
My point is that the emphasis on the jury being predominantly male seems to serve as a form of reassurance that the verdict is credible, precisely because men have convicted another man. It suggests that a conviction reached by a predominantly female jury might be regarded with greater suspicion, as though women’s judgement is somehow less objective or trustworthy, particularly in cases involving sexual violence against women. And that’s where I think the deeply ingrained misogyny comes in. Why should the gender of the people reaching a verdict make it any more or less credible? Your point about the reporting potentially anticipating misogynistic reactions is part of that wider issue.

No. It's perfectly normal to report the make up of the jury.

heresiarch · 06/11/2026 07:57

CleverTealGoose · 06/11/2026 07:25

Yes, that’s much closer to what I’m getting at.
My point is that the emphasis on the jury being predominantly male seems to serve as a form of reassurance that the verdict is credible, precisely because men have convicted another man. It suggests that a conviction reached by a predominantly female jury might be regarded with greater suspicion, as though women’s judgement is somehow less objective or trustworthy, particularly in cases involving sexual violence against women. And that’s where I think the deeply ingrained misogyny comes in. Why should the gender of the people reaching a verdict make it any more or less credible? Your point about the reporting potentially anticipating misogynistic reactions is part of that wider issue.

I saw it more as a rebuttal of the widely held view that men don't understand consent and so are unlikely to convict another man of sexual assault or rape.

Thatcannotberight · 06/11/2026 08:00

As an aside, OH sat on a jury of a rape case, multiple women victims. He was shocked that it was the women on the jury who wanted to give the accused the benefit of the doubt. Fortunately, he was found guilty and subsequently given a long sentence.

MrsBennetsPoorNervesAreBack · 06/11/2026 08:00

I think there should be a balance of sexes on the jury for all sexual violence cases, personally.

I do get your point, OP. Then again, if I were the victim in a rape case, I think I would prefer to have more women on the jury than more men. It's less about credibility as such, and more about recognising that everyone has bias.

Walkden · 06/11/2026 08:10

"because a guilty verdict delivered by a predominantly male jury is somehow considered more credible, particularly when the defendant is another man accused of sexual violence against women"

Come off it OP. There were multiple posters on here claiming he would be found not guilty because the men would take his side.

So on the one hand - if it's mostly women this would be fairer because they are less misogynistic.

On the other if it's mostly men it's still misogyny because there judgement is ( apparently) more trustworthy?

Mochudubh · 06/11/2026 08:10

I was on the jury for a rape trial more than 10 years ago. I won't go into the detail (a rather sordid tale which reflected well on neither party but sex was consensual) but we found the accused not guilty by a majority of 10-5 (Scotland) which I still believe was the right verdict in that case. The 10 were all women and the 5 who went for Not Proven (when that was still an option) were all male.

I think the women could understand how it all happened and that the sex was consensual but the accuser had found herself on a rollercoaster she couldn't get off through the well meaning actions of other people, but the men were trying to be the "good guys". But even at that they voted NP rather than guilty so the accused would still have walked free albeit with the NP verdict hanging round his neck.

So no, I don't think the makeup of the jury is particularly relevant, but the media always seems to report it for some reason.

Passaggressfedup · 06/11/2026 08:12

I love it how feminists can't help themselves but look to find reasons to shout misogyny!

Not guilty: misogyny
Not mentioning how the jury is formed: misogyny
Mentioning it: misogyny

GeneralPeter · 06/11/2026 08:12

I do think there’s a tiny bit of ‘even men found him guilty’ but I can’t see how that reporting reflects misogyny.

It’s a bit like when the head of Digwa’s gurdwara criticised him. It’s newsworthy because it’s someone you might think might want to go easy on him. It’s not because the media think Sikhs are more credible than others in general.

And men do have a slightly lower propensity to vote to convict in rape trials, so it’s not based on some myth.

Papster · 06/11/2026 08:46

CleverTealGoose · 06/11/2026 06:37

I’ve noticed the frequent references to the jury being made up of eight men and four women. I can’t help but feel that this detail is being emphasised because a guilty verdict delivered by a predominantly male jury is somehow considered more credible, particularly when the defendant is another man accused of sexual violence against women. As though the public, both men and women, should feel more confident in the verdict because men themselves have reached it. Would the jury’s gender composition be highlighted quite so frequently if it consisted of eight women and four men? To me, it speaks volumes about the extent to which men’s judgement continues to be afforded greater authority than women’s, even when it comes to violence against women and girls.

AIBU?

In what way is reporting on the jury composition misogynistic?
Its something people might have wondered about for various reasons and it’s a fact

MickyMoonshine · 06/11/2026 09:03

I completely disagree. It’s normal to report on the jury in this way because it’s quite literally the only thing they can report on!

I’ve found the reporting to be very supportive of the women and particularly now we have verdicts so more information can be discussed.
The behaviour of the defence barrister is, rightly, being called out as misogynistic and could result in changes in the justice system. I have a feeling this could be a real watershed moment.
If you want to discuss misogyny in relation to this case the Brand’s barrister is the place to start not the factual reporting on the jury.

montysmaw · 06/11/2026 09:08

It's making the point that men are likely to be less appalled by rape and more likely to find a rapist not guilty.
Therefore when even a predominantly male jury brings in a guilty plea it emphasises how strong the evidence was.

Serenity75 · 06/11/2026 09:10

I think that you might be right, but possibly disagree with the reason for it. My reading was more that the emphasis on there being 8 men on the jury AND they still found him guilty must mean he’s guilty as hell. Almost as though there is an implicit assumption that a jury of men will take more convincing than a jury of women, because men are less likely to believe women. So not that men are likely to be better at being jurors than women because they are men (and therefore superior), but that they are more likely to let other men off. I dislike what that says about society, but do kind of agree.

Mossyfox · 06/11/2026 09:10

They quite often report on the make up of a jury. I've heard not a single reporter speaking favourably about Russell Brand. Yabu.

Irishlinen · 06/11/2026 09:11

I think reporting of any case when there is a conviction changes and that is quite apparent on the news channel. At the time of his fame if you did not like his humour you were seen as prudish - I personally don't like that type of humour and was told that by those who found him funny and went to see him A verdict has been delivered. Some of the comments about the prosecutions where he was found not guilty in my view are hypocritical - in my view you can't claim that justice has been done for the cases where he was found guilty and then that it is all wrong and the justice system is wrong in the other cases.

LemonPuppyPorkChop · 06/11/2026 09:13

Reporting jury composition is entirely standard.

Laulon · 06/11/2026 09:13

BeTidyFinch · 06/11/2026 07:03

Why be so nasty?

Indeed. Most posters disagree with the op, but have managed to do it without insults. I’m so sick of put-downs about how thick someone is instead of engaging.

(And I don’t think op’s interpretation is stupid, even if I don’t agree with it.)

Boomer55 · 06/11/2026 09:15

I thought the reporting was balanced, and the jury, regardless of the make up of it, found him guilty.

Not sure what the issue is here. 🤷‍♀️

honeylulu · 06/11/2026 09:23

I can see where you're going with your point but that's not the way I interpreted the reporting about it being a majority male jury.

I've seen some of the awful comments on social media about the victims ("deciding to cry rape because she didn't get a cuddle after" and "well silly cow went back to his room with him, it was obvious she was consenting" sort of comments). Almost always from men. So I was concerned that if the eight men on the jury thought like those commenters, there would be no chance of conviction on any of the rape charges nor probably any of the assaults without witnesses. I felt glad to be proved wrong as all the jurors presumably followed the guidance on objectively assessing the actual evidence.

I was also glad to hear the male judge telling Brand how serious and appalling his crimes were/are. There have been some shocking comments from judges (usually male) on other cases minimising the severity of rape crimes and the effect on the victims. Maybe I'm sexist but I'd not expect that from a female judge.

Sorry, rambling, but my point is that the reporting seems to be saying the men involved have done the right thing and not closed ranks against "hysterical women".

Weeelokthen · 06/11/2026 09:32

SummerAsh · 06/11/2026 07:14

I don’t see how this is misogyny. If anything it indicates the opposite… That even though the jury was composed of 8 men and 4 women, he was convicted.

I think a lot of women, on here anyway, chuck the misogyny word about too freely withoit a proper understanding of the true meaning of this overused word.
I think people also forget that most men have a female they really love, daughter, sister, mother............ and I was so glad the jury was mostly men.

imisswaitrose · 06/11/2026 10:22

This reply has been withdrawn

Post withdrawn at author's request

BluebellBeth · 06/11/2026 10:52

I disagree. I think it shows men won't stand for other men SA and raping women.

TotaleclipseinFrance · 06/11/2026 10:57

CleverTealGoose · 06/11/2026 07:25

Yes, that’s much closer to what I’m getting at.
My point is that the emphasis on the jury being predominantly male seems to serve as a form of reassurance that the verdict is credible, precisely because men have convicted another man. It suggests that a conviction reached by a predominantly female jury might be regarded with greater suspicion, as though women’s judgement is somehow less objective or trustworthy, particularly in cases involving sexual violence against women. And that’s where I think the deeply ingrained misogyny comes in. Why should the gender of the people reaching a verdict make it any more or less credible? Your point about the reporting potentially anticipating misogynistic reactions is part of that wider issue.

Jeez as if men were the only ones letting Brand get away with stuff.
The facts are women were also complicit in enabling him.
I bet any young woman who 'pulled' Brand had her mates congratulating her.
This is in the instances where he didn't rape or assault of course.

Us women are as much to blame. Flocking around him.

It's also a myth that women are more likely to convict, too.
They don't like the thought of there being men like Brand and downplay it.
If only these girls didn't dress like that etc. It's magical thinking.

Men don't do this.

Swipe left for the next trending thread