Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Switch witch FFS if you don’t want sweets don’t bloody take them

51 replies

Credittocress · 05/11/2026 17:33

I think we can all agree Halloween has exploded in recent years. When I was younger trick or treating wasn’t really a thing, then you’d go to your immediate neighbours, and now people are driving their kid’s around to the “good roads” to get absolute hauls of sweets.

A decade ago you could buy a multipack of twix and that would cover you for the evening, now you need to buy for 40 odd kids if you don’t want to disappoint any. But this is fine…

Apart from this new trend I am seeing on social media of the “switch witch”. Parents who don’t want their kids eating oodles of sweets trading the evenings haul for a toy or a treat. Look I don’t mind giving your kids sweets if they get to enjoy them, but I’ve spent good money on them, and not for them to end up in the bin or being scoffed by mum and dad.

Theres also I guess an environmental impact of taking something you don’t want just to bin it.

I get your kid wants to knock on doors-but how about stick a sign on the bucket saying we’ve collected enough, please just tell us a joke- or something.

It just feels really wrong to take something that you have no intention of actually eating

OP posts:
Thingsthatgo · 06/11/2026 08:44

my DCs would put any sweets that they weren’t going to eat in a bucket outside our house with a pumpkin and a ‘take a treat’ sign for the late Trick or Treaters.

TrepidationOfTheSpheres · 06/11/2026 09:05

When I was a child (in North America), trick or treating was a much bigger deal than here, and one of the things that we did was collect money for Unicef. We were given special collecting boxes at school that we wore on strings around our necks, on top of our costumes, and people would have bowls of pennies or other small coins to put in them. Most places didn't make you choose between coins or sweets, though, and still gave out treats. The supermarkets sold big backs of Hallowe'en sized treats - kind of like they are starting to do here, but on a much bigger scale with loads of different ones that you only get that size or type at hallowe'en - so that even when you collected lots, they weren't enormous. And then you rationed them out to last for ages.

But the collecting idea was nice as everyone knew about it in advance, so would have small coins saved up for it. I realise people don't have loose change lying around quite so much now, but perhaps with publicity, they would - and it was nice when you went into school the next day with super-heavy boxes to turn in with all the coins you collected. If you didn't want to collect sweets, or had too many, you would still have had a good reason for going round the houses.

We also sometimes got asked for a song or joke as our 'trick', before being given coins or sweets or both.

Sdpbody · 06/11/2026 09:25

This was my DD9's first Halloween since being diagnosed as Coeliac.

We bought sweets we knew my DD could have, and after she had been trick or treating, we swapped the ones we had in her bag with the ones she could eat.

She loves Halloween and she would have been so upset to not be able to go and take part with her friends just because we knew she couldn't have the sweets. At the end of the night, she put the sweets she couldn't have in our bowl and they all went.

Credittocress · 06/11/2026 09:26

Sdpbody · 06/11/2026 09:25

This was my DD9's first Halloween since being diagnosed as Coeliac.

We bought sweets we knew my DD could have, and after she had been trick or treating, we swapped the ones we had in her bag with the ones she could eat.

She loves Halloween and she would have been so upset to not be able to go and take part with her friends just because we knew she couldn't have the sweets. At the end of the night, she put the sweets she couldn't have in our bowl and they all went.

But I’m not saying don’t go. I specifically said can’t we normalise something else like asking for a joke, so they can still have the experience.

OP posts:
Boreded · 06/11/2026 09:27

Mosaic80 · 05/11/2026 17:39

I’ve not heard of the switch witch! I can see the purpose but at the same time, it makes you wonder what happens to the sweets. I do wish people would just go to their local houses though, we had well over 100 children by 6.30pm and run out of our approx 150 sweets by 7pm! I don’t know whether to get 200 next year or just not do it at all. Apparently we are known as the village to go and I’m on the main road through.

I’m on a main road, nobody came to our house, haven’t for years. After the 2nd year in a row i stopped buying sweets

Sdpbody · 06/11/2026 09:30

Credittocress · 06/11/2026 09:26

But I’m not saying don’t go. I specifically said can’t we normalise something else like asking for a joke, so they can still have the experience.

As a coeliac, you are already "othered" all of the time! She is probably singled out 3/4 times a day at school, more, if we go out for lunch or dinner etc as we have to be so strict and mention her CD constantly.

At 9, she just wants to be the same as everyone else.

Arbourimage · 06/11/2026 09:38

Credittocress · 06/11/2026 09:26

But I’m not saying don’t go. I specifically said can’t we normalise something else like asking for a joke, so they can still have the experience.

Why though? You have no idea whether anyone eats everything you have them or not to begin with. You’re getting weirdly pent up about it.
Plenty of parents go through child’s sweets if they’re too young and take out lollies or choking hazards.
You willingly give it out, are you going to quiz every child about whether they are going to eat your twix with an acceptable time frame or not?
What about when children swap between themselves? Is that banned too?

Credittocress · 06/11/2026 09:47

Arbourimage · 06/11/2026 09:38

Why though? You have no idea whether anyone eats everything you have them or not to begin with. You’re getting weirdly pent up about it.
Plenty of parents go through child’s sweets if they’re too young and take out lollies or choking hazards.
You willingly give it out, are you going to quiz every child about whether they are going to eat your twix with an acceptable time frame or not?
What about when children swap between themselves? Is that banned too?

Kids who swap between themselves are still going to eat the sweets. My issue is with parents who don’t want their kids eating what they’ve collected so swap it and put it in the bin.

Chocolate and sweets take energy and water to grow, manufacture, package, transport and sell; plus I am spending my money on buying something. It should then be enjoyed not just binned by someone who took something they had no intention of eating

OP posts:
Sandsnake · 06/11/2026 09:53

Agree with most on here that it’s a ridiculous idea, barring medical considerations. I think Halloween (as I’ve experienced it) is great! But if you don’t want your kids to get kids to get sweets then don’t go! They can easily be rationed and in our house there always seems to be a weird evaporative effect on the kids’ Halloween sweets (into my mouth).

DS had his first Halloween as a T1 diabetic this year. I took most of his sweets and replaced with a big bag of biltong!

Arbourimage · 06/11/2026 09:56

Credittocress · 06/11/2026 09:47

Kids who swap between themselves are still going to eat the sweets. My issue is with parents who don’t want their kids eating what they’ve collected so swap it and put it in the bin.

Chocolate and sweets take energy and water to grow, manufacture, package, transport and sell; plus I am spending my money on buying something. It should then be enjoyed not just binned by someone who took something they had no intention of eating

I think it’s very unlikely most people who swap out sweets are simply putting it in the bin though.

Chrimbobo · 06/11/2026 10:06

I've only heard of it relating to allergies. For my dairy allergic child we switch all his chocolate into a toy (like a small lego set). The chocolate is eaten by me, and would never be thrown out Bear

Chrimbobo · 06/11/2026 10:08

Also, people under estimate the importance of being a "normal" kid and taking part, when it comes to kids with e.g. diabetes or allergies.

IMO it's the best of both worlds- they get to have a normal kid experience and aren't endangered by eating the sweets/choc

Sproutling · 06/11/2026 10:10

There's definitely been a development towards parents finding the 'good' streets to visit.

On our local facebook pages someone was asking which streets to take the kids for good Halloween decorations- code for where do the households give out.

We used to fill a bucket with sweets, and loved seeing the little kids all dressed up as monsters and witches, they were in awe of the whole lantern lights and wandering the dark, parents stayed at the end of the drive, watching out.And the kids all said 'thankyou'.

Then the little kids started being crowded out by teenagers, lurching round in plastic masks, and grabbing handfuls , then coming back a few minutes later, and back until the tub was empty. Seldom a thankyou.

We stopped when a group of teenage girls started getting flirty with dp- I could hear from the sitting room so went into the hall and they scattered- that was the end.

We now spend the night at a country pub and avoid. It probably costs us the same lol.

Iwannamarryharry · 06/11/2026 10:18

Sproutling · 06/11/2026 10:10

There's definitely been a development towards parents finding the 'good' streets to visit.

On our local facebook pages someone was asking which streets to take the kids for good Halloween decorations- code for where do the households give out.

We used to fill a bucket with sweets, and loved seeing the little kids all dressed up as monsters and witches, they were in awe of the whole lantern lights and wandering the dark, parents stayed at the end of the drive, watching out.And the kids all said 'thankyou'.

Then the little kids started being crowded out by teenagers, lurching round in plastic masks, and grabbing handfuls , then coming back a few minutes later, and back until the tub was empty. Seldom a thankyou.

We stopped when a group of teenage girls started getting flirty with dp- I could hear from the sitting room so went into the hall and they scattered- that was the end.

We now spend the night at a country pub and avoid. It probably costs us the same lol.

But what’s wrong with asking what streets are doing trick or treating?

There is little point or fun trudging around an area where no houses are taking part.

I don’t see the problem with asking which houses are decorated, you only knock on houses that are decorated/have pumpkins outside.

Ellie1015 · 06/11/2026 10:20

I buy a stupid amount of sweets for the kids chapping our door. My 10 year old collects for too many too. He gets ownership of the sweets for a few days then they become house sweets.

I do it because the kids love collecting, I dont care if the sweets are shared with parents or swapped, not my business.

If i cant be bothered once my kids are too old I will stop.

Credittocress · 06/11/2026 10:36

Ellie1015 · 06/11/2026 10:20

I buy a stupid amount of sweets for the kids chapping our door. My 10 year old collects for too many too. He gets ownership of the sweets for a few days then they become house sweets.

I do it because the kids love collecting, I dont care if the sweets are shared with parents or swapped, not my business.

If i cant be bothered once my kids are too old I will stop.

This isnt swapping with each other though. This is the parents trading the sweets for a toy so the kids don’t get the sweets

OP posts:
FanFckingTastic · 06/11/2026 10:46

There's definitely been a development towards parents finding the 'good' streets to visit.

I would agree with this. We've done Halloween for years. It started off as an evening handing out sweets to local kids, all dressed up in their costumes and enjoying the fun of walking out at night. Now we have targeted 'drive by' drop offs - parents consulting a map of the good spots and sitting in their car whilst their kids are sent to collect as much as they possibly can, as quickly as they can.

It seems to be less about the experience and fun of Halloween now and more about what they can get from it, which is sad in my opinion.

waterrat · 06/11/2026 10:52

I always want to come on these threads to stick up for halloween! firstly it isn't new - my dad is 83 and has actual photos (!) of himself dressed up trick or treating in the 1940s/50s. He remembers it as a really fun time.

Secondly - how lovely is it to see kids giggling and excited out on the streets in their own communities after dark - when I see it it makes me wish we had so many more community events that get children outside in winter.

Kids spend SO much time in front of devices - here is an annual event where they dress up, hang out with neighbours, actually get to know people on their own streets and generally just enjoy being children.

I also see how much older kids yearn to join in.

It's about community - it is absolutely not about sweets.

DontEatTheMushies · 06/11/2026 10:56

What a stupid thing! Just put it all in a box and teach your kid self control rather than bin or barter! Things like that can make kids binge eat. Literally witnessed it in a school friend whos mum would deny sweets - got out of the house and OMG, they would eat everything they were banned from at home and they put on near 10 stone.

Not hard, that's how we did it back in the 90s if we had a MEGA haul...but usually we only had like what is 1 bag of haribos equivalent.

TheRealSmurfette · 06/11/2026 10:59

Buy Halloween sweets or don’t - your choice.
Step away from social media so silly things like this don’t annoy you - your choice.
Get wound up about Halloween or don’t - it’s happening anyway - your choice.
What other people do - not your choice.

Ellie1015 · 06/11/2026 11:13

Credittocress · 06/11/2026 10:36

This isnt swapping with each other though. This is the parents trading the sweets for a toy so the kids don’t get the sweets

So? Kids eat them, parents eat them, parents buy a toy or not. I take part to reciprocate for all the people dishing out sweets to my child. What those families do with them is their business.

ETA i eat some of my own child's as he has too many, and he doesnt even get a toy.

Sdpbody · 06/11/2026 11:45

Chrimbobo · 06/11/2026 10:08

Also, people under estimate the importance of being a "normal" kid and taking part, when it comes to kids with e.g. diabetes or allergies.

IMO it's the best of both worlds- they get to have a normal kid experience and aren't endangered by eating the sweets/choc

Exactly!! Why would my DD want to tell a joke and make herself be the centre of attention when she can just take a sweet, say thank you, and carry on chatting with her friends. I would take away her CD and give it to me if it meant she could just be "normal".

Raindropskeepfallingon · 06/11/2026 11:58

Credittocress · 06/11/2026 09:26

But I’m not saying don’t go. I specifically said can’t we normalise something else like asking for a joke, so they can still have the experience.

I don’t give out Halloween candy because I don’t agree with the whole concept, but if I did the very last thing I’d want is to be put on the spot by a kid who wants me to tell a joke. Take the mini Mars bar and do what you want with it, don’t start asking for alternatives.

You need to accept not everyone will go about this the way you think they should, so either participate gracefully or just don’t. Buy chocolate for the foodbank instead.

Kadiofakit · 06/11/2026 12:12

I also saw on social media parents who won't let the kids eat the sweets they get as it could be dangerous but still sent them out for the 'fun experience'

So stupid! It really winds me up the 'can you let me know the best roads in the area' posts. Totally wrong in my opinion.

LazyCrazyAndStupid · 06/11/2026 22:48

waterrat · 06/11/2026 10:52

I always want to come on these threads to stick up for halloween! firstly it isn't new - my dad is 83 and has actual photos (!) of himself dressed up trick or treating in the 1940s/50s. He remembers it as a really fun time.

Secondly - how lovely is it to see kids giggling and excited out on the streets in their own communities after dark - when I see it it makes me wish we had so many more community events that get children outside in winter.

Kids spend SO much time in front of devices - here is an annual event where they dress up, hang out with neighbours, actually get to know people on their own streets and generally just enjoy being children.

I also see how much older kids yearn to join in.

It's about community - it is absolutely not about sweets.

I didn't grow up with Halloween but I've totally fallen in love with it. Three of my favourite experiences:

  1. Kids have allergies so our lovely neighbours give them home made toys. They put so much of time and effort into it. It's just incredible.
  1. We went to a house where there was a group of kids just leaving. When we got there they didn't have any sweets anymore for ds. The little girl who lived there and who had just returned from her own trick n treat walk asked DS to wait, ran into the house, came back with her own haul of sweets and gave DS some of them.
  1. One guy opened the door wearing some sort of wolf mask which absolutely freaked out DS. When he realised how scared DS was he removed his mask and spoke really nicely to DS to show him he isn't scary.
Swipe left for the next trending thread