Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Switch witch FFS if you don’t want sweets don’t bloody take them

51 replies

Credittocress · 05/11/2026 17:33

I think we can all agree Halloween has exploded in recent years. When I was younger trick or treating wasn’t really a thing, then you’d go to your immediate neighbours, and now people are driving their kid’s around to the “good roads” to get absolute hauls of sweets.

A decade ago you could buy a multipack of twix and that would cover you for the evening, now you need to buy for 40 odd kids if you don’t want to disappoint any. But this is fine…

Apart from this new trend I am seeing on social media of the “switch witch”. Parents who don’t want their kids eating oodles of sweets trading the evenings haul for a toy or a treat. Look I don’t mind giving your kids sweets if they get to enjoy them, but I’ve spent good money on them, and not for them to end up in the bin or being scoffed by mum and dad.

Theres also I guess an environmental impact of taking something you don’t want just to bin it.

I get your kid wants to knock on doors-but how about stick a sign on the bucket saying we’ve collected enough, please just tell us a joke- or something.

It just feels really wrong to take something that you have no intention of actually eating

OP posts:
Mosaic80 · 05/11/2026 17:39

I’ve not heard of the switch witch! I can see the purpose but at the same time, it makes you wonder what happens to the sweets. I do wish people would just go to their local houses though, we had well over 100 children by 6.30pm and run out of our approx 150 sweets by 7pm! I don’t know whether to get 200 next year or just not do it at all. Apparently we are known as the village to go and I’m on the main road through.

WaneyEdge · 05/11/2026 17:47

Where I used to live (coastal Kent) there was a lot of older people. The council used to give out pumpkin stickers for doors to identify who was/wasn't taking part. Good idea and it largely kept the nuisance aspect away. I hate it now, as you say, we just used to go to neighbours with our friends older siblings taking us. All pre-arranged with parents.

JamieVardysHavingAParty · 05/11/2026 17:48

I only came across this concept recently. I was appalled, to put it mildly. Why go trick or treating then?

Candleabra · 05/11/2026 17:52

I’ve never heard of this, but agree, so rude. Just tell your kids not to take the sweets if you won’t let them eat them.

Lookingforwardtospringnextyear · 05/11/2026 17:52

Never heard of this.

I think Halloween is a load of nonsense. And one of the annoying things is going out the next morning and there are always quite a lot of discarded packets of sweets, lollipops etc. lying in the street. Obviously just thrown away because the children don't like those particular items.
I dont understand how so many children - and adults- don't put any value on things. Easy come, easy go .

TellMeItsNotTrue · 05/11/2026 22:19

I think it's a good idea for kids who can't have a lot of treats, like kids with diabetes, so they don't have to be excluded from what their friends/siblings are doing

But otherwise I'd say either don't do it, or only do the amount of houses you are comfortable with them having treats from

Two of my kids have allergies, and I swap things for allergy safe treats 1 for 1 and the unsuitable treats we usually give to a local charity that works with families in need as the charity are very glad of it. We also don't go to too many houses to begin with

No gifts, no waste, no character, just an allergy mum making sure her child is included and kept safe

I've seen ridiculous gifts being left, saying that 🤔 the price of allergy safe treats, maybe the switch witch can leave a games console next year 😜 probably cheaper than allergy safe treats for two 🤣

Irritableowlwan · 05/11/2026 22:37

Never heard of this concept and I am in Ireland where Halloween is a huge thing. If mine got too many sweets we just donated to the local charity shop to bag up and sell off.

MeowDoku · 05/11/2026 22:47

We didn't take DS when he was really small he helped man our door instead, he's older now and collected a fair few sweets this year, they sit in a pantry drawer and he has a few occasionally, he had some last Sunday and none since, we are going to the cinema Saturday so I'll say to him to pick a few to take with him. I think if you don't want your DC to have sweets don't take them trick or treating. I think the only exception to that would be a diabetic child with siblings. One of DS' friends has a severe milk allergy so when they go to a house with chocolate she swaps with the other DC for jelly sweets

5foot5 · 05/11/2026 23:06

now people are driving their kid’s around to the “good roads” to get absolute hauls of sweets.

A decade ago you could buy a multipack of twix and that would cover you for the evening, now you need to buy for 40 odd kids if you don’t want to disappoint any.

Interesting. I didn't grow up with the idea of Trick or Treat and only encountered it as an adult. When it became obvious it was a thing I realised I needed to be prepared. But, yes, a decade ago I would buy a bag of fun size Mars or something and that was OK.

But, here's the thing, it seems that in the last few years, post Covid probably, the etiquette has been established so that Trick-or-treaters only go to decorated houses or those with pumpkins outside. Hence we now get nobody, hurrah! But it sounds like for those who do decide to participate there is a danger you will be swamped. I guess more people wanting to benefit than people wanting to participate.

But to your AIBU, you are quite right. If you don't want your kids to have hideous quantities of sweets then let them only do a few doors then call it a night. Anymore is just plain greedy

seahorsessky · 05/11/2026 23:32

Don't parents usually eat the sweets anyway, when they're going with really small kids. Not something I did, but there seem to be more people taking actual babies nowadays.

Credittocress · 06/11/2026 06:10

seahorsessky · 05/11/2026 23:32

Don't parents usually eat the sweets anyway, when they're going with really small kids. Not something I did, but there seem to be more people taking actual babies nowadays.

I think there’s a difference between sharing the sweets with the family but the kids still enjoying them over the next few weeks, versus the parents orchestrating a swap out because the kids aren’t allowed them at all.

OP posts:
mondaytosunday · 06/11/2026 06:47

Goodness do parents really do that? I never found that my kids gobbled them all up at once but I suppose with very young kids having them pick their favourites and portioning them out over time is just about acceptable if their kids can’t control themselves.
But sign on the bucket saying we’ve collected enough??? Don’t be ridiculous- parents should just take their kids home if they’ve got enough.
I had at least 250 kids come this year. Guess we are ‘that neighbourhood’.

BendingSpoons · 06/11/2026 06:54

It's a bit weird. We don't Trick or Treat, but when we get lots of sweets e.g. school fair, we just put some away and bring them out gradually. If people are actually binning them, that is so wasteful.

Credittocress · 06/11/2026 08:13

mondaytosunday · 06/11/2026 06:47

Goodness do parents really do that? I never found that my kids gobbled them all up at once but I suppose with very young kids having them pick their favourites and portioning them out over time is just about acceptable if their kids can’t control themselves.
But sign on the bucket saying we’ve collected enough??? Don’t be ridiculous- parents should just take their kids home if they’ve got enough.
I had at least 250 kids come this year. Guess we are ‘that neighbourhood’.

The only reason why I say a sign on the bucket is I’m seeing people saying I let the kids keep three then swap out the rest, I guess these parents want the experience of trick or treating but don’t really know how to navigate that without the waste.

I hate the idea of spending on sweets that are just going to be binned rather than enjoyed

OP posts:
gooset · 06/11/2026 08:18

This is stupid. I'm surprised the kids are bothered if they know they're not getting the sweets in the end. I'm also surprised parents can be bothered going to dozens of houses.

We go to a few houses on our road and the next one (no more than 10). We know pretty much everyone whose door we knock on, so it's fun seeing all the costumes and stuff. We tell our kids in advance that we're only going to let them have a certain number of sweets so they choose wisely and if they have a few extra they go to their teen brother who is too embarrassed to trick or treat.

HRTtoHeart · 06/11/2026 08:21

But, here's the thing, it seems that in the last few years, post Covid probably, the etiquette has been established so that Trick-or-treaters only go to decorated houses or those with pumpkins outside

It's been the etiquette for over 20 years. My eldest is 28 and it has been that way since he was tiny.

Firstttimemama · 06/11/2026 08:22

Credittocress · 05/11/2026 17:33

I think we can all agree Halloween has exploded in recent years. When I was younger trick or treating wasn’t really a thing, then you’d go to your immediate neighbours, and now people are driving their kid’s around to the “good roads” to get absolute hauls of sweets.

A decade ago you could buy a multipack of twix and that would cover you for the evening, now you need to buy for 40 odd kids if you don’t want to disappoint any. But this is fine…

Apart from this new trend I am seeing on social media of the “switch witch”. Parents who don’t want their kids eating oodles of sweets trading the evenings haul for a toy or a treat. Look I don’t mind giving your kids sweets if they get to enjoy them, but I’ve spent good money on them, and not for them to end up in the bin or being scoffed by mum and dad.

Theres also I guess an environmental impact of taking something you don’t want just to bin it.

I get your kid wants to knock on doors-but how about stick a sign on the bucket saying we’ve collected enough, please just tell us a joke- or something.

It just feels really wrong to take something that you have no intention of actually eating

I don’t agree with this. My son has ARFID and can’t eat sweets or most chocolate. We swap the sweets he can’t eat for some toys. Why should he miss out on the experience?

Iwannamarryharry · 06/11/2026 08:24

I understand for allergies. I’m coeliac so there are sweets I couldn’t eat (smarties come to mind). So a swap for something else in that case would soften the blow if I was still a kid.

But I used to know people who did this. They were so fucking worthy about it, posting on Facebook groups about how they had swapped all the terrible sweets for natural things (twigs and shit from what I could see as they didn’t do plastic), and droning on about the consumerism of Halloween.

Christ almighty, just stay at home then? No one is marching to your door and forcing you to take your children trick or treating.

One of them posted a very smug photos of pouring the sweets into the bin, “where they belong.”

She was one of the ones always harping on about food waste and recycling, all the fucking time, so much so that it made me want to take a blow torch to the polar ice caps myself, such a hypocrite.

Performative shit.

EmeraldShamrock000 · 06/11/2026 08:26

It is always a big thing where I leave. I can’t get over the greed either. I know the local children, they’re usually finished by 7pm.
I took the pumpkin and door bell in after 7.
I was appalled by some of the photos online of huge hauls of sweets I didn’t realise people were going to different areas to load up.
Greedy and mean spirited, manners are not being taught by a few parents.

EmeraldShamrock000 · 06/11/2026 08:28

Firstttimemama · 06/11/2026 08:22

I don’t agree with this. My son has ARFID and can’t eat sweets or most chocolate. We swap the sweets he can’t eat for some toys. Why should he miss out on the experience?

What do you do with the sweets? Are you binning them?

Arbourimage · 06/11/2026 08:31

Most kids getting the sweets won’t be allowed to eat them all anyway. You can’t give out sweets and then control what happens to them.
I don’t do it but I have a t1 child and I can see why people might, same for serious allergies.

Not wanting a young child to get involved in trick or treating because they can’t safely eat the sweets is pretty miserable imo.

FedUpCelery · 06/11/2026 08:32

I've never heard of that but I can't have a strong opinion on it. The sunk cost fallacy makes us do things we don't want, have had enough of, or aren't good for us. I don't think it's a big deal to toss the sweets.
We give the sweets (and I love Halloween more than Christmas. It's quick and over and done in one night.) then it's up to them what they do with them.

fruitbrewhaha · 06/11/2026 08:35

My kids have always eaten their sweets. It might take until February to get through them but they just had the occasional sweet. Then some weird ones would last a bit longer.

sleepylittlebunnies · 06/11/2026 08:38

Halloween, as in parties and adults dressing up wasn’t a thing when I was growing up. But we definitely did trick or treating in the 80’s with a carved out swede. No one decorated their houses back then, so we just knocked on all the doors in our neighbourhood.

Mine are late teens but I always took them trick or treating. It was etiquette by then that you only knock on decorated houses. They would get loads of sweets. They’d swap between themselves to get favourites, plus nut allergy child. They could eat some, otherwise they were put in tubs and have them spread out, or for cinema trips etc

thinkfast · 06/11/2026 08:41

I’ve never heard of this but love the idea that stocking up for Halloween means getting 40 sweets. By my rough calculations we must’ve had around 300 sweets and we were all out by 6:30pm