Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think the internet has not been good for humanity

47 replies

Newbutoldfather · 05/11/2026 08:18

I have been thinking about the internet a lot. I wonder how many ‘digital natives’ even think about what life was like before the internet. And yet, it was all so recent really. Smart phones only really started about 20 years ago and I remember using e mail for the first time at work in about 1990, and the internet was only really usable about the same time.

The advantages of the internet are huge, but so are the drawbacks.

A few of the advantages I can think of are:

-infinite variety of shopping delivered next day
-encyclopaedia in your pocket
-huge network of contacts that you can instantly message.
-massive boost to economy (at least in theory)
-infinite virtual photo album at zero cost
-sex and ‘romance’ at the click of a few buttons

However, the disadvantages are:

-dating and sex are way too easy. They become like a smorgasbord to browse and a tick box exercise, rather than an effort at real communication and an acceptance of imperfections.
-online porn has ruined sex. People used to just be please to have someone to date, not a checklist of sexual preferences. And the addiction and ED that can follow.
-endless distractions (especially smart phones) and no down time. For many, it has destroyed the pleasures of reading a book or dedicated studying.
-death of local businesses
-increased loneliness as people choose to stay home online rather than actually going out.
-online abuse of all kinds
-political manipulation

That is a short summary of what I can think of. I deliberately did not use AI! People are welcome to add anything.

I just don’t think humans can evolve fast enough to keep up with the technology and we were generally happier pre internet.

Curious as to other views, though, especially from digital natives.

OP posts:
Newbutoldfather · 05/11/2026 08:36

Just one bump, just in case. I think this is fascinating, but I am clearly in a minority!

OP posts:
Nuttyrubble · 05/11/2026 08:42

I agree, it is so very useful but it's all consuming. Fridges are being hacked ffs...a fridge it's insane. If anything did happen to our I internet connection as a nation we would be fairly fucked! We rely on it too much and it makes us vulnerable.

MargoLivebetter · 05/11/2026 08:45

I think it is worth a debate too @Newbutoldfather . Like most things in life, I tend to think how it is used determines how good or bad it is going to be.

I think that it has helped to open up the world and give people access to places and communities that they otherwise wouldn't know about or ever visit.

I think it has helped small businesses.

It almost goes without saying that the access to so much information is AMAZING.

That in turn has helped people become more knowledgeable - should they want to be so.

I'm less convinced about the benefits of it connecting people, as I think it has probably led to wider and more superficial connections, but possibly not enhanced deeper relationships.

As it is a system designed and used by humans, it is deeply flawed and imperfect, but I definitely wouldn't want to be without it now.

scalt · 05/11/2026 08:46

The same was said about other inventions of mass communication, in their time: television, radio, and the church fiercely objected to the invention of printing.

Newbutoldfather · 05/11/2026 08:47

@Nuttyrubble ,

That is another drawback (also of globalisation). Efficiency is massively increased, but at the expense of resilience.

I don’t think many businesses, or utilities, could manage if the internet went down, which is possible, even with a huge sun storm.

OP posts:
scalt · 05/11/2026 08:47

And the internet enabled months and months of lockdown. Even ten years previously, it would have been difficult to keep it for as long as they did.

throughthe · 05/11/2026 08:47

I dont think its done men any favours. They just seem to use it wanking themselves senseless to internet porn.

Ratherhaveacupofteaandabiscuit · 05/11/2026 08:50

I would happily give up the internet if the world could go back but the genie can’t be returned to the bottle.

RowsOfFlowers · 05/11/2026 08:52

Don’t forget cyber crime and sexual abuse that takes place over the web

Newbutoldfather · 05/11/2026 08:53

@scalt ,

‘And the internet enabled months and months of lockdown. Even ten years previously, it would have been difficult to keep it for as long as they did.’

That was something I thought about a lot during lockdown; what would have happened pre internet.

Against serious disease, there did used to be lockdowns, but mostly by town or area. And the economy did virtually stop.

I suspect, with Covid, though, we would have let it burn and accepted a higher mortality rate and some very difficult periods. There would have been a lot more triaging and allowing some older and sicker people to die at home rather than admitting them to hospital.

The internet did save lives, but it also prolonged the epidemic.

OP posts:
QwestSprout · 05/11/2026 08:58

The Internet has been incredibly good for humanity. Academia before online journals was incredibly slow and laborious. Now we have access to pretty much every paper there is, instantaneously, and we can make far better scientific connections and advancements because we aren't waiting months for the latest paper copies!

FrostyMorn · 05/11/2026 08:58

The two additional big problems for me are the environmental impact (quite wide ranging if you include direct electricity use and emissions but also the mining of critical minerals for chips, water use, habitat destruction for data sites... the list goes on) - and how it is used to spread disinformation on so many issues. AI is only making the latter exponentially worse.

I'm not a luddite, accept the great things it can do (especially for physically isolated or less able bodied people for whom it opens up opportunities) and my job would be extremely difficult without the Internet but on balance I think the world would be better off without it. But that ship has well and truly sailed.

Newbutoldfather · 05/11/2026 09:14

@QwestSprout ,

‘The Internet has been incredibly good for humanity. Academia before online journals was incredibly slow and laborious. Now we have access to pretty much every paper there is, instantaneously, and we can make far better scientific connections and advancements because we aren't waiting months for the latest paper copies!’

I think that your linkage of faster academic progress to it being good is debatable. Academic progress is not an aim in itself , unless it leads to greater health and happiness. Recently, in the developed world, health, happiness, longevity (and even IQ) have been on a downward trajectory.

Technology and, IMO, especially the connectivity of the internet, has hugely increased wealth inequality.

It has been a massive plus for medicine, though, as is AI, but the more we cure, the more preventable disease seems to increase and those cures are available to relatively few people.

I am being a bit Luddite here, I admit, but previous progress has always been linked to increased health and happiness. It’s not really happening recently, though.

OP posts:
MargoLivebetter · 05/11/2026 09:16

Has previous progress always been linked to increased health and happiness? I'm not sure miners, Victorian mill workers or any current sweat shop workers in Asia would agree with you there!

Newbutoldfather · 05/11/2026 09:19

@MargoLivebetter ,

But look at global health, wealth, infant mortality and longevity measures over the last 200 years, say.

I think that progress has brought benefits to the vast majority.

OP posts:
MargoLivebetter · 05/11/2026 09:23

Agree that the overall trend has been upward @Newbutoldfather but there have been some big dips in the last 200 years too. Just off the top of my head, I'm going to use 1930s as an example where global health, wealth, mortality etc took a massive hit.

I'm not sure the problems we are currently encountering economically are to do with the internet.

Letsgonowthen · 05/11/2026 09:30

I think the Internet has pros, but wish it was restricted to computers rather than on phones.

I did look at changing back to a dumb phone once, but life is pretty hard these days without.

JacknDiane · 05/11/2026 09:46

I agree @Newbutoldfather

randomchap · 05/11/2026 09:50

One of the issues is no matter how wrong your belief or theory, you're bound to find a community who agree with you. And you are then surrounded by people who reinforce your beliefs.

Algorithms also feed into this, showing content for engagement, for the advertising clicks, rather than to educate, infrom and correct.

Flat earthers, antivaxxers, etc.

MrsBennetsPoorNervesAreBack · 05/11/2026 09:54

On balance, I think I disagree.

Yes, there are many disadvantages. Better regulation and international cooperation could tackle some of them.

But the Internet has made the world so much smaller. It is so much easier for people to communicate and collaborate across great distances. It has given so many people who might otherwise be isolated a chance to connect and build community. It has democratised access to information and knowledge. It has enabled people to organise and campaign on particular issues.

I would not go back, personally. But I would support better regulation and better education to help people self regulate more effectively.

TheAmberKoala · 05/11/2026 09:55

Good question OP. Its such a complex topic. The internet can be a huge help to people who are isolated due to illness/disability/distance and its a social leveler in many ways, eg things like musicians being able to share their music with the world and not being reliant on getting picked up by a record label.
Doctors and medical specialists are able to treat people who are on the other side of the country.
We can cut down on pollution by reducing travel with WFH and spend more time with our families. But then AI uses resources.
I think its pros and cons either way.

QwestSprout · 05/11/2026 09:55

Newbutoldfather · 05/11/2026 09:14

@QwestSprout ,

‘The Internet has been incredibly good for humanity. Academia before online journals was incredibly slow and laborious. Now we have access to pretty much every paper there is, instantaneously, and we can make far better scientific connections and advancements because we aren't waiting months for the latest paper copies!’

I think that your linkage of faster academic progress to it being good is debatable. Academic progress is not an aim in itself , unless it leads to greater health and happiness. Recently, in the developed world, health, happiness, longevity (and even IQ) have been on a downward trajectory.

Technology and, IMO, especially the connectivity of the internet, has hugely increased wealth inequality.

It has been a massive plus for medicine, though, as is AI, but the more we cure, the more preventable disease seems to increase and those cures are available to relatively few people.

I am being a bit Luddite here, I admit, but previous progress has always been linked to increased health and happiness. It’s not really happening recently, though.

I wholeheartedly disagree that 'academic progress is not an aim in itself'. I'm a linguist who writes papers, I work in academia. Of course advancement is the aim, furthering the sum of human knowledge does not have to be linked to health or happiness. By that rationale you could argue there is no point to several academic disciplines! (Including but not limited to astronomy, my own linguistics, and so on).

TheAmberKoala · 05/11/2026 09:56

Newbutoldfather · 05/11/2026 09:14

@QwestSprout ,

‘The Internet has been incredibly good for humanity. Academia before online journals was incredibly slow and laborious. Now we have access to pretty much every paper there is, instantaneously, and we can make far better scientific connections and advancements because we aren't waiting months for the latest paper copies!’

I think that your linkage of faster academic progress to it being good is debatable. Academic progress is not an aim in itself , unless it leads to greater health and happiness. Recently, in the developed world, health, happiness, longevity (and even IQ) have been on a downward trajectory.

Technology and, IMO, especially the connectivity of the internet, has hugely increased wealth inequality.

It has been a massive plus for medicine, though, as is AI, but the more we cure, the more preventable disease seems to increase and those cures are available to relatively few people.

I am being a bit Luddite here, I admit, but previous progress has always been linked to increased health and happiness. It’s not really happening recently, though.

I think the opposite - I think WFH has increased equality.

InterestedDad37 · 05/11/2026 10:03

It's been as important a change for humanity as the industrial revolution, electricity, the internal combustion engine, and the first homínid to use a stick to get food out of a hole in a tree.
And just like all of those, as well as huge advantages, it's brought many drawbacks and things which are ultimately harmful to individuals, humanity and our planet. But it isn't going away. Humanity needs to learn how to use it properly, and mitigate the damage it also does.

Dreadingtheday · 05/11/2026 10:04

QwestSprout · 05/11/2026 08:58

The Internet has been incredibly good for humanity. Academia before online journals was incredibly slow and laborious. Now we have access to pretty much every paper there is, instantaneously, and we can make far better scientific connections and advancements because we aren't waiting months for the latest paper copies!

How has that benefited the average Joe on the street?

Swipe left for the next trending thread