Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think the internet has not been good for humanity

47 replies

Newbutoldfather · 05/11/2026 08:18

I have been thinking about the internet a lot. I wonder how many ‘digital natives’ even think about what life was like before the internet. And yet, it was all so recent really. Smart phones only really started about 20 years ago and I remember using e mail for the first time at work in about 1990, and the internet was only really usable about the same time.

The advantages of the internet are huge, but so are the drawbacks.

A few of the advantages I can think of are:

-infinite variety of shopping delivered next day
-encyclopaedia in your pocket
-huge network of contacts that you can instantly message.
-massive boost to economy (at least in theory)
-infinite virtual photo album at zero cost
-sex and ‘romance’ at the click of a few buttons

However, the disadvantages are:

-dating and sex are way too easy. They become like a smorgasbord to browse and a tick box exercise, rather than an effort at real communication and an acceptance of imperfections.
-online porn has ruined sex. People used to just be please to have someone to date, not a checklist of sexual preferences. And the addiction and ED that can follow.
-endless distractions (especially smart phones) and no down time. For many, it has destroyed the pleasures of reading a book or dedicated studying.
-death of local businesses
-increased loneliness as people choose to stay home online rather than actually going out.
-online abuse of all kinds
-political manipulation

That is a short summary of what I can think of. I deliberately did not use AI! People are welcome to add anything.

I just don’t think humans can evolve fast enough to keep up with the technology and we were generally happier pre internet.

Curious as to other views, though, especially from digital natives.

OP posts:
Sartre · 05/11/2026 10:07

I don’t think the internet is bad but smart phones definitely are. It’s the fact we’re connected to others at all times, we can’t escape notifications. When it was based on the PC at home you could log off.

Newbutoldfather · 05/11/2026 10:13

@Letsgonowthen ,

‘I think the Internet has pros, but wish it was restricted to computers rather than on phones.’

That is an interesting perspective. However the distinction between computers and phones has blurred. It is smartphones which have caused the most problems though.

@MrsBennetsPoorNervesAreBack ,

‘I would not go back, personally. But I would support better regulation and better education to help people self regulate more effectively.’

In theory, if we could keep the good that the internet does and throw out the bad, it would be amazing! However, there is no evidence that is possible. A huge issue is that technological evolution is infinitely faster than human evolution (look at AI). In previous industrial revolutions, there was time to adjust.

@TheAmberKoala ,

‘I am not sure that there is this I think the opposite - I think WFH has increased equality.’

Again, is there evidence for this? There are few minimum wage jobs that can be done from home. And, in any event, the concentration of wealth in the ‘tech bros’ has hugely outweighed this effect, if it exists at all.

OP posts:
InOverMyHead84 · 05/11/2026 10:19

Everything needs to be 'Smart.'

But, it's making us stupid. We have all the knowledge in history at our fingertips but it just leaves people taking things for granted and not discriminating critically over what it actually means.

MrsBennetsPoorNervesAreBack · 05/11/2026 10:21

Newbutoldfather · 05/11/2026 10:13

@Letsgonowthen ,

‘I think the Internet has pros, but wish it was restricted to computers rather than on phones.’

That is an interesting perspective. However the distinction between computers and phones has blurred. It is smartphones which have caused the most problems though.

@MrsBennetsPoorNervesAreBack ,

‘I would not go back, personally. But I would support better regulation and better education to help people self regulate more effectively.’

In theory, if we could keep the good that the internet does and throw out the bad, it would be amazing! However, there is no evidence that is possible. A huge issue is that technological evolution is infinitely faster than human evolution (look at AI). In previous industrial revolutions, there was time to adjust.

@TheAmberKoala ,

‘I am not sure that there is this I think the opposite - I think WFH has increased equality.’

Again, is there evidence for this? There are few minimum wage jobs that can be done from home. And, in any event, the concentration of wealth in the ‘tech bros’ has hugely outweighed this effect, if it exists at all.

It may not be possible to limit all of the disadvantages. But we can do a lot to protect ourselves from the disadvantages individually, and people should be encouraged to do this. Obviously, you can't eliminate every negative.

But I would still keep it on balance.

MerryAquaKoala · 05/11/2026 10:22

YANBU. Worst thing to have happened.

notanothernamesurely · 05/11/2026 10:23

I’d be over the moon if there was just a big internet switch and they turned it off for 50 years 😂

NoisyMonster678 · 05/11/2026 10:28

The internet will only be as good as the people using it, hence the polarity between the good and the bad.

So I supose the internet is what we make of it.

GiveMeOodlesofPoodles · 05/11/2026 10:32

TheAmberKoala · 05/11/2026 09:56

I think the opposite - I think WFH has increased equality.

WFH (obvs enabled by the internet) did also go a way to equalising the North/South divide for a while. The candidate pool was huge, and you had to be good to stand out!

Until CEOs demanded bums on specific seats in a specific building again.

Trouble is they want their cake and eat it ; they also want those bums on seats to be responsive outside of hours as well (enebaled by the internet again)

LiterallyUnderArmourDaily · 05/11/2026 11:16

@Newbutoldfather There's evidence that overuse, misuse, abuse of certain aspects of the internet (e.g. social media) is unhealthy and increases risk of harm. https://share.google/kSOhBPSTxl2PZPGsi and https://bmjgroup.com/social-media-use-linked-to-risky-health-behaviours-in-young-people/ and https://share.google/ZTwrkwN038W13uDfI It's not just social media. Around the world, there are tons of authority figures exploiting the internet to spread misinformation, disinformation and malinformation. I believe founders of the internet and social media networks created what they did with good intentions but there wasn't enough thought about how it could be misused and abused. It is addictive. The amount of time parents spend on the internet when they could be having conversations with their children or playing games (exc. online games). The internet offers so much to hold our attention but we don't have to always be on it. We have a choice as to whether we want to step away from it, put down our phones, laptop etc... like finding willpower to quit smoking, for example - it's hard when temptation is always there but it is possible. Some use it to avoid having to talk to others. Have I done this? Yes. Sometimes, I try to initiate conversation or talk to my child or watch them for safety but it's so tempting to take a peek at my phone. We need to find a balance in terms of how much time we spend on it and how much time we spend doing things that don't involve it. I feel sad that future generations may not be able to enjoy the 'non-internet' activities we had as children.

Social media use linked to risky health behaviours in young people - BMJ Group

Exposure to content such as alcohol advertising had strongest evidence of harm Social media use is associated with risky health behaviours in young people including increased alcohol, drug and tobacco use, anti-social behaviour, risky sexual behaviours...

https://bmjgroup.com/social-media-use-linked-to-risky-health-behaviours-in-young-people

QwestSprout · 05/11/2026 11:19

Dreadingtheday · 05/11/2026 10:04

How has that benefited the average Joe on the street?

Medicines, new treatments, new vaccines. Treatments are faster to create because scientists can collaborate in real time regardless of where they are geographically.
Diagnostics are smarter, we have advanced machine learning models that pick up on issues years before they would have otherwise been.

Your smartphone only exists because of worldwide collaboration between academics and scientists, every piece of technology in it.

Storms and extreme weather can now be predicted accurately down to the minute of when they will hit. Yes you may still have damage but now we have proper warnings in place (I live somewhere where we have red storm warnings more than the rest of the UK and while we might not be able to stop the roof tiles flying off, we can at least know that the winds will die down at x time).

A lot of it is the underlying infrastructure and systems that you don't think about but affect every aspect of your life, whether that's how food is transported or how farmers make use of new technologies to better know the nitrogen capabilities of their soil (see the latest series of Clarkson's Farm for some real world examples).

Newbutoldfather · 05/11/2026 11:33

@LiterallyUnderArmourDaily ,

I think your post very eloquently sums up what I think.

Of course, theoretically, it is amazing and should be a huge boon.

Having an encyclopaedia at your finger tips-what’s not to like? And yet, how many understand referencing sources properly? Add to that that people can make serious money by reinforcing harmful incorrect beliefs, and you have the internet of today.

Having an infinite dating pool instead of work and friends of friends. What’s not to like?! Except infinite choice isn’t psychologically positive for human beings and leads to the kind of behaviour that is often complained about on here (and which is pretty disgraceful).

I could go on.

I think a lot of the pro internet arguments come down to if human beings acted in a way that we don’t, and if there were no bad actors, the internet would be great. But is that realistic?

OP posts:
Newbutoldfather · 05/11/2026 11:38

@QwestSprout ,

I do read a lot of your post as a defence of science and computing power rather than the internet per se.

The medical progress in terms of extending life expectancy peaked a long time before the internet. Antisepsis, antibiotics and steroids did most of the heavy lifting. We are now dealing with rare diseases.

However, I do think my point was more about the global democratised internet and not professional fast connections (which have existed since the 1970s). I also think that maybe most of the damage is done by portable devices, rather than having the internet as a tool.

OP posts:
MerryAquaKoala · 05/11/2026 12:46

None of the other stuff matters - the internet enables child sex abuse and women sex abuse. Prolific paedophilia and trafficking of women and girls enabled worldwide. Male groups set up to abuse wives who have been drugged. International networks exchanging babies, children and women being sexually abused videos and photos, enabling it in real life. The internet is a bad thing. Like guns in America. Easy porn access for all. Leading to boys and men expecting the same irl. It won't stop because - men.

GoodGirlFaith · 05/11/2026 12:53

We cannot and should not go back. It's a wonderful invention however, I have said for many years that our brains are not wired for so much news and information.

I actually saw a reel last week that portrayed this really well. Pre-internet, we all had the radio on before work. So, we would have some idea of the latest news but this was interspersed with some great music and comedy. Now, if I look at my phone before work, I am bombarded with today's reason for Armageddon, the latest drama in the village, various friends night out and birthday, 'grandmother showed me this' and... well... it's too much. And we wonder why so many feel tense, afraid and anxious.

My 22 year old son tells me of a renaissance in his peer group. He and his friends have all downloaded some app that stops them scrolling and are reading books, playing guitar and engaging with each other.

TheAmberKoala · 05/11/2026 12:59

Dreadingtheday · 05/11/2026 10:04

How has that benefited the average Joe on the street?

Medical research benefits most people for a start.

Happylife32 · 05/11/2026 13:03

I agree that it's not necessary a good thing, but the world can't do without it now. Think of online banking for a start. Many local branches have closed, so where would that leave us?

There's health as well. Lots of appointments are missed when a letter is delivered too late. Texts to remind people of their appointments are indispensable now.

I'm sure there are many more examples. All in all, the Internet is here to stay.

scalt · 05/11/2026 15:23

I remember reading this in a book "Curious and Interesting Numbers", which was written in about 1990, so long before widespread internet use, which said a lot of the same things about numbers, at the times of the Romans and Ancient Greeks: Numbers were simpler, and smaller. It was seldom necessary to count beyond a few thousand, which would have been the size of the entire Greek army. Now, a few thousand is a poor attendance at a football match.

Andrew Lloyd Webber once said in an interview that if you had a show which weren't sure would work, you would put it on in a small local theatre, instead of in London, so that fewer people would see it. That's no longer possible, with the internet, and online reviews.

Anarchy99 · 05/11/2026 15:28

I was born way before the internet but I think it’s great. COVID proved that people could run their entire lives online - shopping, chatting to people, working, studying.

I am ND and it has been a real boon for me. I can conduct a social life without leaving the house and have more control over social situations.

Newbutoldfather · 05/11/2026 15:32

@Happylife32 ,

‘I agree that it's not necessary a good thing, but the world can't do without it now. Think of online banking for a start. Many local branches have closed, so where would that leave us?’

I agree that we can’t put the genie back in the bottle. I was just wondering how people felt about our Brave New World. Want some Soma? Internet porn or endless YouTube shorts about the cutest cats (as per your taste). Or find someone online to hook up with. Anything but engage in serious slow thought.

In the last few years we now have low level AI on phones even. Suddenly, when your child solves a mathematical problem brilliantly or writes a great essay, the first thing you ask yourself is whether they used AI.

Even the evidence of our own eyes is no longer much of a proof of anything.

It is amazing how prophetic some of the dystopian novels have turned out.

OP posts:
CostcoFanofThree · 05/11/2026 19:19

i know this is limited to my family but with adult children all living far from my home it allows me to stay in touch and has done so for decades now.
last year my son was diagnosed with primary progressive ms, thanks to the internet and ai, cell and gene therapy mainly car t types are making huge progress and it looks possible that a long term treatment that halts disease progression (in a brutal disease) will be available soon (within a few years time) as countries are able to collaborate together.
recently my dh developed diabetes (non obese runs in his family) and thanks to cgi monitoring he is able learn how to manage is blood sugars within a matter of days.
there are some horrible aspects but i think if there was a will there would be a way to stop (pornography).

Netcurtainnelly · 05/11/2026 19:21

It's social media that's the worst.
Unsocial media.

New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Swipe left for the next trending thread