Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think some women deliberately derail threads just to abuse other posters?

84 replies

WryJadeWren · 04/11/2026 16:33

I think quite a lot of women post on here with the intention of derailing threads so they can have a go at other posters and let off some steam. I’ve noticed that some posters seem completely uninterested in engaging with the actual subject being discussed. Instead, they’ll deliberately misinterpret what’s been said, make personal remarks, become unnecessarily hostile or try to provoke an argument. I sometimes wonder whether certain posters are simply looking for an outlet for whatever frustrations they have in their own lives and an anonymous forum provides a convenient place to take those frustrations out on strangers.

AIBU to think this is quite common on here?

OP posts:
DyslexicPoster · 05/11/2026 08:13

I find that people will latch onto a micro part of your thread like your spelling or grammar and go down the "how can you xyz when you cant spell?" Which is a depressing reflection of how society really think of our SEN children. Im declaring im dyslexic then attacked for being thick.

Also with a child's age, like having a teen and doing something domestic for them. So if im talking about one of my teens friendships and a problem they are having you get people picking apart the bit where you drove the teen somewhere or made a meal for them or you wash their clothes etc ( posters who hate woman who cook, or wash etc for other males in their house). Or you dont state the gender or age of the child or friend and that becomes the focus point. Even when posting about cancer or death people pick you apart.The micro precise details on everyone age and gender going back and reading past posts.

Im not convinced its all male trolls. The only safe topic is if your partner is caught having an affair but even the OP is told they was selfish, controlling or needs to try again sometimes. Or they aren't dumping him fast enough, making themselves and kids homeless fast enough.

FairyInTheMossGarden · 05/11/2026 08:18

"I sometimes wonder whether certain posters are simply looking for an outlet for whatever frustrations they have in their own lives and an anonymous forum provides a convenient place to take those frustrations out on strangers.
AIBU to think this is quite common on here?"

Seems like @WryJadeWren came on to do exactly that and after a couple of half hearted posts he buggered off.

Wildfairy · 05/11/2026 08:24

TheRealSmurfette · 05/11/2026 08:12

How do you know they are women?

Posting history, of course no one knows for sure, but there are tells,

DelphineFox · 05/11/2026 08:26

INeedAnotherName · 04/11/2026 16:59

Some women yes, but I bet an awful lot of them are men. There seems to have been a surge in male posters over the last few years.

Agreed. It's naive to assume people posting are women. Some are men coming on to wind people up.

Goatsarebest · 05/11/2026 09:01

WhatNoRaisins · 05/11/2026 07:28

With the posters that only want validation it's often the nicer and more thoughtful replies that they blow up over. Validation seeking would maybe bother me less if it was made clear that's what they want, I've often thought that there should be a tell me I'm right subforum as an AIBU alternative.

'Tell me I'm right' subforum is the solution. Are MN listening😂
You could be the first thread and I'd tell you that you are right. Then another 50 people could say you're right. Then we could say those saying you are right, are right. Everyone would be happy, I think. Or maybe not. Someone is going to say you are not right, I just know it😂

Goatsarebest · 05/11/2026 09:10

The one that gets me is the pile on that as a 'grown adult' you dare ask for a lift from your partner to get back from the pub or the train station or ask a partner to drop a friend off 2 miles out of your way. Living in rural Ireland this attitude is genuinely bizarre.

Ereshkigalangcleg · 05/11/2026 09:20

XDownwiththissortofthingX · 05/11/2026 01:31

And yes, you do get banned for having perfectly legal and rational opinions in completely unrelated subreddits sometimes

Ok, I'm happy to take your word for that, but it's not something I've ever encountered myself. The only time I'm been censured by Reddit was when I made an obviously tongue-in-cheek remark and copped an automatic but temporary suspension for "inciting or promoting violence" 😆

Reddit subs are moderated by out of touch, tinpot dictators in their own little realm quite frequently. As I say, I don’t need any lessons on it. MN is considerably better for freedom of speech

Well this is just the thing. The vast majority of Subs I'm on have their clear and unambiguous rules spelled out, and there is never any pretence of "freedom of speech" to begin with, so I don't think there is any merit in complaining about a lack of freedom of speech when the platform doesn't promise that in the first place, and it's not under any obligation to either.

For the most part it's relatively simple and straightforward stuff. If I'm on the Sub for fans of the colour Green, I immediately start arguing Red is superior and antagonising Green fans, I'm absolutely expecting to be moderated off the place sooner or later. That's the entire purpose of the Subs being niche in the first place and why they are actively and effectively moderated.

I’m not talking about posting on trans Reddit or anywhere I’m going directly against the ethos. I’m talking about being in more general forums, being a bit snippy and getting disciplined because my opinions are wrongthink, however carefully I word them, while other posters get to be significantly more insulting and spout unfounded nonsense which I then can’t challenge.

You might not be aware of this phenomenon as it sounds like you post in some fairly niche subreddits, but in the wider world it’s well known what a self-reinforcing, often fairly extremist and out of touch echo chamber Reddit is and how authoritarian it can be with dissenting views. I prefer Mumsnet because although people call certain boards an echo chamber, they aren’t, it’s just a whingey knee jerk reaction people have when no one agrees with them, which yes can be uncomfortable. Unlike most Reddit subs, you won’t get banned for expressing a perfectly reasonable and legal opinion. I would be fine with no one agreeing with me on Reddit if I could just be allowed to challenge misinformation in my own words. But on certain topics I am not.

MostlyHoldingItTogether · 05/11/2026 09:24

Goatsarebest · 05/11/2026 09:10

The one that gets me is the pile on that as a 'grown adult' you dare ask for a lift from your partner to get back from the pub or the train station or ask a partner to drop a friend off 2 miles out of your way. Living in rural Ireland this attitude is genuinely bizarre.

i’m so confused by this comment. Did you comment on the right thread?

thecloakofrelativeanonymity · 05/11/2026 09:28

I wish MN would be a bit more on the posts that are just needlessly aggressive.

I was reading a thread the other day about siblings not getting on. One poster decided that favouritism was the problem and was laying into the (perfectly polite) OP. I did report; nothing happened. OP didn’t come back.

Then the other day I said something like ‘don’t be an arsehole’ (might have been dickhead tbf, can’t remember.) Voila, deleted. I don’t care especially but it is a bit exasperating that one is permitted and one is not.

New posts on this thread. Refresh page