Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to wonder why we accept the state of the NHS?

337 replies

Pinkgorilla101 · 03/11/2026 08:56

Having spent time living abroad and having top quality almost free healthcare (state, not private) I genuinely cannot believe that there hasn’t been a revolt or more done about the state of the NHS. Just this week I have heard of an 80 year old man with heart failure sitting in A&E for 17 hours then being told to go home as they had no beds and they would make him a routine appointment with a cardiologist. Seeing a GP is almost impossible. There are 2 at my NHS practice but both also run private clinics elsewhere. Why do we accept this or am I unreasonably unrealistic in my expectations?

OP posts:
rwalker · 03/11/2026 18:20

Blankscreen · 03/11/2026 09:02

I don't know amy other industry where you can moonlight to the detriment of your main job and get away with it yet somehow doctors are allowed to run their own practice on the side. Outrageous.

My friends wife is a rota coordinator for doctors and consultants
they literally hold the trust to ransom just please themselves because they know they can

mybiggreenfrog · 03/11/2026 18:27

NewGoldFox · 03/11/2026 09:51

Because people won’t / can’t afford more tax.

But we are paying more tax, every year, due to the tax threshold freeze.

Mortgagedecisions · 03/11/2026 18:32

I have 30 years service in the NHS. Some reflections from me (long and garbled but cathartic!):

Basic care was better 30 years ago in many ways. Particularly if you were a patient on a ward ran by a ‘dragon’. The junior staff were usually scared of the dragon but all the patients were clean and had pain relief. Staff regularly worked 1-3 unpaid additional hours per day and you often didn’t get a break. Maybe the basic care was better because the staff were working in a way that isn’t acceptable today. Or maybe we need more staff plus the dragons back and the staff to have respect for them.

Most patients treated staff with respect and were in hospital because they needed to be. If as a nurse you suspected someone was under the influence of a substance they were treated kindly but firmly. You did not worry they would assault you, film you or complain about you.

People with mental health conditions were not on the acute wards generally. Today we seem to have people in acute hospitals who need a different type of care. It’s impossible to meet their care needs (mental health and substance misuse are just examples) on an acute ward or in an A&E department. We don’t want to go back to institutionalising people but it’s clear the current care in the community isn’t working for everyone. Acute NHS staff are spending ineffective hours trying to contain someone when what they need is specialist help.

Old, outdated practices which we do not want to go back to were used 30 years ago. People were lifted and handled, this meant sometimes patients were injured as were staff; but needs were met more quickly. People for example those with dementia who were distressed or wandering were sedated. This is illegal now, rightly, but safe, effective alternative treatments do not seem to be used in ward settings. Families were more involved in care 30 years ago particularly in the community. This doesn’t seem as possible now (probably as there isn’t a woman at home to do the unpaid caring work).

30 years ago staff ran hospitals to protect the system. Visiting was restricted to maintain privacy and dignity. If people attended A&E and were deemed not to need it they were firmly told this and directed elsewhere. Of course this meant sometimes people were sent away that shouldn’t have been.

People demanded less. People generally didn’t attend A&E or the GPs unless there was something very wrong with them. Sometimes this was the right decision. Sometimes people attended too late.

In 2026 the dragons have all been investigated for bullying. There aren’t enough managers to supervise the staff. Staff work the hours they are paid for. Staff will only follow policy and procedure because they have been trained to do this. Patients complain quite rightly if staff get something wrong so all decisions are made defensively.
There can’t be a policy or procedure for every scenario in the NHS so this means quite often patients bounce around between departments or professionals.

Patients are more demanding, sometimes rightly, you should have pain relief when you need it for example but also patients are asking staff who are very busy to do things like open the door for their deliveroo deliveries multiple times per shift. Staff do not feel able to refuse this or question how ill they are if they’re able to order and eat a takeaway from their bed on the acute ward.

Staff do not dare ask people who are under the influence of drink or drugs to behave appropriately or go elsewhere because what if they have an underlying medical condition and this is missed?

Health care advances are amazing and many more people survive illnesses and injuries than they did 30 years ago. However us humans seem to have started to take good health for granted rather than take responsibility for looking after ourselves.

I’ve worked with other health systems and our NHS is something we should be very proud of and something we should fight for.

poetryandwine · 03/11/2026 18:51

LetsDillyDally · 03/11/2026 16:59

I would argue that with all the issues I’ve seen with an ageing population and the difficulties accessing social care - IVF is important if we want enough people in the population to sustain our society, especially if they introduce huge limits to immigration

This is a fair point for a national conversation.

poetryandwine · 03/11/2026 18:53

Mortgagedecisions · 03/11/2026 18:32

I have 30 years service in the NHS. Some reflections from me (long and garbled but cathartic!):

Basic care was better 30 years ago in many ways. Particularly if you were a patient on a ward ran by a ‘dragon’. The junior staff were usually scared of the dragon but all the patients were clean and had pain relief. Staff regularly worked 1-3 unpaid additional hours per day and you often didn’t get a break. Maybe the basic care was better because the staff were working in a way that isn’t acceptable today. Or maybe we need more staff plus the dragons back and the staff to have respect for them.

Most patients treated staff with respect and were in hospital because they needed to be. If as a nurse you suspected someone was under the influence of a substance they were treated kindly but firmly. You did not worry they would assault you, film you or complain about you.

People with mental health conditions were not on the acute wards generally. Today we seem to have people in acute hospitals who need a different type of care. It’s impossible to meet their care needs (mental health and substance misuse are just examples) on an acute ward or in an A&E department. We don’t want to go back to institutionalising people but it’s clear the current care in the community isn’t working for everyone. Acute NHS staff are spending ineffective hours trying to contain someone when what they need is specialist help.

Old, outdated practices which we do not want to go back to were used 30 years ago. People were lifted and handled, this meant sometimes patients were injured as were staff; but needs were met more quickly. People for example those with dementia who were distressed or wandering were sedated. This is illegal now, rightly, but safe, effective alternative treatments do not seem to be used in ward settings. Families were more involved in care 30 years ago particularly in the community. This doesn’t seem as possible now (probably as there isn’t a woman at home to do the unpaid caring work).

30 years ago staff ran hospitals to protect the system. Visiting was restricted to maintain privacy and dignity. If people attended A&E and were deemed not to need it they were firmly told this and directed elsewhere. Of course this meant sometimes people were sent away that shouldn’t have been.

People demanded less. People generally didn’t attend A&E or the GPs unless there was something very wrong with them. Sometimes this was the right decision. Sometimes people attended too late.

In 2026 the dragons have all been investigated for bullying. There aren’t enough managers to supervise the staff. Staff work the hours they are paid for. Staff will only follow policy and procedure because they have been trained to do this. Patients complain quite rightly if staff get something wrong so all decisions are made defensively.
There can’t be a policy or procedure for every scenario in the NHS so this means quite often patients bounce around between departments or professionals.

Patients are more demanding, sometimes rightly, you should have pain relief when you need it for example but also patients are asking staff who are very busy to do things like open the door for their deliveroo deliveries multiple times per shift. Staff do not feel able to refuse this or question how ill they are if they’re able to order and eat a takeaway from their bed on the acute ward.

Staff do not dare ask people who are under the influence of drink or drugs to behave appropriately or go elsewhere because what if they have an underlying medical condition and this is missed?

Health care advances are amazing and many more people survive illnesses and injuries than they did 30 years ago. However us humans seem to have started to take good health for granted rather than take responsibility for looking after ourselves.

I’ve worked with other health systems and our NHS is something we should be very proud of and something we should fight for.

A very interesting and, I think, balanced post.

IntentionallyAsymmetrical · 03/11/2026 19:07

Why do we accept this or am I unreasonably unrealistic in my expectations?

How can we not accept it - we have no choice, other than paying for private medical care/health insurance, which many who can afford it are now doing anyway.

You pose the question as though there were some route of appeal, or an alternative free healthcare choice - but there isn't.

I don't think you have thought your question through, OP.

WarmHiker · 03/11/2026 19:14

You did not get free healthcare abroad. Someone paid for it.

Badbadbunny · 03/11/2026 19:15

WarmHiker · 03/11/2026 19:14

You did not get free healthcare abroad. Someone paid for it.

Just like the NHS in the UK then.

THisbackwithavengeance · 03/11/2026 19:51

My experience of the NHS has generally been good but given that we’ve become a nation of fat, mentally unwell, druggies and depressives. No wonder it’s fucked.

Pinkgorilla101 · 03/11/2026 20:27

5128gap · 03/11/2026 16:40

What do you suggest? I've already voted for the government I believe most committed to improve it. I don't complain about the tax I pay and wouldn't complain about paying more. I give my constructive feedback on patient surveys and I donate to fund raisers to purchase equipment etc.
I'm not going to start throwing chairs about and shouting at staff who have no power to do anything about it, and it's not like we can boycott it, or storm the hospital walls and stage a coup, helping ourselves to the tests, treatments and surgeries we need. So what form of revolt to you have in mind?

I have absolutely no idea which is why I asked the question

OP posts:
WarmHiker · 03/11/2026 20:32

Badbadbunny · 03/11/2026 19:15

Just like the NHS in the UK then.

And?

Barney16 · 03/11/2026 20:40

I find the NHS bizarre. I have had some really good experiences and some frankly awful brushes with it. It's so inconsistent. My elderly dad ended up in a and e for about ten hours because he was sent there by his GP who said oh all referrals through A and E now. That just doesn't make any sense. He didn't need emergency treatment he needed to be moved on to a specific department. I have sat in a and e with poorly people but been surrounded by very very sick people,generally very old people, who wait and wait. It's awful. It needs a massive overhaul and at the same time a huge remodeling of adult social care.

5128gap · 03/11/2026 20:45

Pinkgorilla101 · 03/11/2026 20:27

I have absolutely no idea which is why I asked the question

You asked why do we accept it and why don't we revolt. I'm answering you by saying I accept it, while doing what little I can about it, because I don't see what else I can do. Presumably other people who accept it feel the same way.

Jopo12 · 03/11/2026 21:31

I agree it's shit. I have nothing nice to say about it.

It's not underfunded at all. We have worse health outcomes than western countries that spend similar or less than we do per capita.

But there is realistically nothing the public can do about it

Bushmillsbabe · 03/11/2026 23:12

Jopo12 · 03/11/2026 21:31

I agree it's shit. I have nothing nice to say about it.

It's not underfunded at all. We have worse health outcomes than western countries that spend similar or less than we do per capita.

But there is realistically nothing the public can do about it

Agree. Funding is higher than ever, but it's not valued. Patients view it as 'free' so think it's OK to miss appointments, abuse staff and demand things they could buy themselves much cheaper - such as prescriptions for paracetamol when it costs 20p! Corporate nhs undertake millions of pounds of 'transformation' projects which don't actually acheive anything meaningful. There are so many barriers to effective care which take up so much staff time trying to get around, and make the patients journey longer, and end up costing more.

It's so big, and complicated. It's like a load of jigsaw pieces from different jigsaws which we keep trying to get to fit together, when what we need to do is start again somehow, with a system fit for purpose. But all any government does is tinker round the edges.

CharSiu · 04/11/2026 01:11

Medicine and treatments have got so much better but the unintended consequence of this is those surviving may need ongoing care including expensive drugs. It’s not a debate about who we should treat it’s just really the outcome of modern medicine. We have become too successful at living. When the NHS was founded it was a whole different lot of expectations.

ginkhao · 04/11/2026 03:45

MyKindHiker · 03/11/2026 09:45

There are not that many places with true state funded healthcare. I've lived in Denmark and yes, they have a much better system, nicer hospitals etc. The difference is they have consistently pumped money into this system for 50 years plus, with consistently high taxation of the population. Fundamentally it's a much more socialist system than we in the UK have had much appetite for.

The challenge is where for generations we've had governments who have been trying to make the NHS more efficient and finding ways to cut spending, it's all fallen to pieces.

It's a bit like a house. Imagine you have a house where every year you spend quite a bit of cash keeping it up to date. You repair the roof proactively so if there's a storm it keeps the rain out. You re-decorate every few years, you make sure the boiler is current. Sure it costs you £10k a year+ to do the stuff which maybe feels a bit unnecessary, but that's how it goes.

Then imagine you don't do any of this. You wait for things to break before fixing them. Or you leave them broken and patch them up for a short term and figure the next owner of the house will sort it. There's a storm and suddenly the whole house is flooded. It costs hundreds of thousands to repair the house. Or the whole house needs knocking down and starting again.

This is exactly where we are in the NHS... the amount that would need to be pumped in to fix it is not going to be possible for any government for a long time.

Denmark is a great example because their health system is very similar to NHS. Where they are very good though is with joined up care using the ID card system. They will know everything about you through your ID number. You also can't just rock up to the A & E (unless truly absolute emergency) or urgent care without an appointment through their 111 number or you will be last to be seen and wait hours.

But it does work well and is so much better than the UK - I think because it is better funded but also more efficeint. It shows that you don't need to change the system, you just need to fund it properly and make it work.

ginkhao · 04/11/2026 03:47

CharSiu · 04/11/2026 01:11

Medicine and treatments have got so much better but the unintended consequence of this is those surviving may need ongoing care including expensive drugs. It’s not a debate about who we should treat it’s just really the outcome of modern medicine. We have become too successful at living. When the NHS was founded it was a whole different lot of expectations.

BUt every country is facing these challenges and most are doing a better job. The UK doesn't even have a high elderly poulation compared to other countries as fertility hasn't gone as low and there is immigration. It should be doing better.

FascinatingCapybara · 04/11/2026 04:26

Nostalgia and fear of change.

Makeyourownmister · 04/11/2026 05:23

JulietteRoche · 03/11/2026 17:38

We want our taxes being well spent, not on funding people having endless kids and propping up too many poorly paid immigrants.

I think you’ll find that many of the poorly paid immigrants you refer to are the ones propping up the NHS and thank heavens for them, we should all be very grateful for their work as surgeons, nurses, cleaners and support staff.

Makeyourownmister · 04/11/2026 05:31

Newname26 · 03/11/2026 15:44

People often mention going to a European insurance based model.

Other than putting more money in, how does that actually make it better?

In my head that just adds another layer of administration, insurance companies will want their profits.

Does the NHS not have some of the lowest administration costs of all western health care systems?

I think you have missed the very important point that many of the successful health care systems in the EU are run through obligatory insurance schemes that are highly government regulated and are non-profit and bear no relation to the USA model.

The systems are based on Christian mutual funds which operate as a non-profit, member-owned health insurance funds.

They are driven by principles of social solidarity, they manage state reimbursements and offer supplementary health benefits rather than seeking corporate profit.

ginkhao · 04/11/2026 05:35

Makeyourownmister · 04/11/2026 05:23

I think you’ll find that many of the poorly paid immigrants you refer to are the ones propping up the NHS and thank heavens for them, we should all be very grateful for their work as surgeons, nurses, cleaners and support staff.

Migrants also tend to be of working age. It's the elderly who use the most health services (yes, migrants eventually age too but as long as the flow remains the same, keeps the pop structure younger).

BeethovenNinth · 04/11/2026 05:39

I agree.

our healthcare system isn’t even third world at times - it’s non existent. I worry about anyone I love developing a sudden serious illness and being left to die

it’s not safe to give birth in the UK any more. I got through alive by the skin of my teeth and because I was conscious and able to fight.

it failed my MIL who died of cancer that was treatable but not detected.

we have millions of young people affected by severe mental health problem who are basically untreated because there is no one to help them.

I could go on but I won’t. All this means longer ill health and a bigger impact on the state

it’s not my job to fix it. I work and pay my taxes and expect a health system that works.

from the outside I observe gross inefficiencies around appointments, an external care system that is broken meaning people bed block, not enough staff, a majority of amazing staff that are broken and also a minority of staff who don’t give a shit and need managed

i also a corrupt food system that means our population is chronically sick .

ginkhao · 04/11/2026 05:43

Makeyourownmister · 04/11/2026 05:31

I think you have missed the very important point that many of the successful health care systems in the EU are run through obligatory insurance schemes that are highly government regulated and are non-profit and bear no relation to the USA model.

The systems are based on Christian mutual funds which operate as a non-profit, member-owned health insurance funds.

They are driven by principles of social solidarity, they manage state reimbursements and offer supplementary health benefits rather than seeking corporate profit.

Edited

There are many differnt types of health care system models with the only the US (and Switzerland but with stronger legislation) having almost fully privately run. The US model would be the worst one to follow and no one in their right could suggest it preforms well on almost any dimension used to evaluate systems. The NHS model isn't a bad one at all, it's not perfect but the model can perform well and it is surprisingly efficient since being free at the point of care with universal coverage does reduce a lot of bureaucracy and administration.

That said, something is clearly going wrong. I had thought it was just funding but actually UK is spending more than comparable countries with similar or older populations and seemingly better erforming health systems.
www.oecd.org/content/dam/oecd/en/publications/reports/2025/11/health-at-a-glance-2025_a894f72e/8f9e3f98-en.pdf

Newname26 · 04/11/2026 07:58

Makeyourownmister · 04/11/2026 05:31

I think you have missed the very important point that many of the successful health care systems in the EU are run through obligatory insurance schemes that are highly government regulated and are non-profit and bear no relation to the USA model.

The systems are based on Christian mutual funds which operate as a non-profit, member-owned health insurance funds.

They are driven by principles of social solidarity, they manage state reimbursements and offer supplementary health benefits rather than seeking corporate profit.

Edited

Thanks i didn't know they were non-profit.

I'm not convinced they'd be non-profit in the uk.

Swipe left for the next trending thread