Politicians can’t of course ever say blatantly that they won’t provide resources for the NHS as it would be political suicide.
What they do instead is lie about building fifteen new hospitals and it turns out that seven were already under construction by a previous administration or whatever.
In other words political commitments to fund the NHS are wholly unreliable and the benefit of a closed health insurance scheme is that if everyone is required to pay the minimum, then they know 100 per cent it has to be put in to health care and they come to know the figures necessary to run the service.
Say that the same figure , the equivalent of €170 euros a month has to be paid in to the NHS to fund it, then the corollary is that general tax goes down for everyone by the same amount or near it?
And if you have a separate entity entirely for health out of direct government hands then it become more accountable.
And of course, if the mutual insurance companies running the system are heavily regulated as not-for-profit entities, unlike the USA system, payments are means tested as are other social benefits.
The point is that taxes in the UK are high but costs like public transport to take one example are frankly extortionate compared to many countries in the EU, ditto tertiary education and childcare. Obviously this whole question is like moving deck chairs around on the deck of the Titanic but things in the UK could be organised more efficiently if we could escape political dogma.
You say €170 a month is extortionate and the sterling equivalent would be impossible for some but not for others. Currently millionaires, use our NHS emergency health units and you will find plenty of people in NHS waiting rooms who earn over £250,000 a year; I was talking to one of them in an oncology unit waiting room the other day in fact.
According to the Nationwide Spending Report, on average, a pet owner in the UK spends approximately £126 per month on their animal’s needs such as food, insurance, treats, toys, clothing, bedding, and that cost doesn’t including emergency or vet bills not covered by insurance. I guess it’s a question of priorities?