Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to think my sister has little reason to be upset that Dad left everything to me?

1000 replies

GentleKhakiFox · 02/11/2026 11:34

My dad passed away at the end of last year, aged 102. He had a wonderful long life, and whilst obviously I miss him, I feel incredibly lucky to have had him for so long.

A bit of background. My mum passed away a few years ago, and I was very involved in looking after her. I have an older sister, who is in her 50s (I'm not 40 until next year), so there's a 15 year age gap between us. We also have different mothers. We're in touch occasionally but have never been particularly close but never any animosity, we did not grow up together and I suppose never had a sisterly bond. No ones fault really, maybe our parents aha but I do not blame her and I don't think she blames me.

When my mother passed away, my husband and I made the decision to move him into our home rather than put him into a care home. His house was rented by a family, so that it wasn't sitting there empty. He had more than enough money to fund private care, but I really didn't want him to spend his final years in a care home if we could manage things ourselves. It wasn't always easy, particularly but we managed. At the time I was working three days a week alongside caring for him. I've since gone back to four days a week, as our youngest is only three and I like having one day a week just for the two of us.
Looking back, I'm actually so glad we made that decision. The children got to spend so much time with their grandad, particularly before his health deteriorated. They won't remember all that much when they're older, which is a shame, but we have lots of photographs and memories to share with them.

My sister, on the other hand, was never particularly involved in Dad's life or his care. She lives alone and never offered to have him stay with her or help with his day to day care. In fact, I have text messages going back to 2018 where I've actively asked her to come and spend time with him, visit him and make an effort and her response was generally that she was too busy.
This is despite Dad having done a great deal for her over the years. He paid school fees for her children, helped her financially when her marriage broke down and even gave her a deposit towards a house after her marriage ended.

Anyway, Dad's will has now been dealt with, and he left everything to me. His house, investments, savings etc. He also made provision for his grandchildren, with money held in trusts for them. To give an idea of the sums involved, Dad had been investing since his 30s and one of his Hargreaves Lansdown investment accounts alone had over £2m in it. Obviously, this is invested money rather than cash sitting in a bank account, but you get the picture. There are other assets as well and everything has now been transferred into my name.
I won't pretend it's not a substantial inheritance. It is, and I'm incredibly grateful. It is also quite overwhelming to suddenly be responsible for managing everything.

However, my sister is now upset that she hasn't inherited anything, and I'm honestly not sure what to say to her. Part of me feels that Dad was perfectly entitled to leave his money to whoever he wanted. He knew both of us, he knew who had been there for him, and he made his decision. I didn't ask him to leave me everything, nor did I expect it.

I also feel that it's slightly unfair for her to be upset about not inheriting when she made so little effort to spend time with him, particularly towards the end, when he could have really done with some company and support.
I appreciate that inheritance isn't necessarily payment for caring for someone, and I didn't look after Dad because I expected to receive anything. I would have done exactly the same regardless.

But AIBU to feel that my sister has little grounds to be upset? Should I just leave her to feel how she feels or is there something I ought to say to her? She wants me to share 'half' I don't want to and its not as though I have grand plans for it, more so for my children albeit they have their own inheritance, you can never have too much. My husband and I aren't big spenders, we share the family car, etc. We paid off our mortgage before I even had the inheritance etc, we just know the value of money and have always made sure to plan ahead for our futures. We miss out on personal treats so that we can take our children abroad on holiday 3-4 times a year because we value that.
I don't want this to turn into a family argument, but equally I don't feel I should have to justify my dad's decisions.

Just a bit more information: Dad sorted out his will etc when he was 86, no new changes, this was done before he moved in with my husband and I. I have always spent time with my parents, even before all of this, I would visit my parents every week, at least once a week sometimes more depending on the occasion, help them with ordering this food shop etc, my sister and I both live within the same county, Surrey, much of a much distance from our parents. My husband and I moved out of London to surrey to be closer to my parents, my older sister has always live here. I am not saying she hasn't seen our father but she never really was interested in helping him out, maybe even taking them out for food etc, her children, in their mid to late 20s, would come to see him on their own accord, without her.

OP posts:
PillsBox · 02/11/2026 12:35

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

Oh switch the caps off for goodness sake.

It makes you look like a child in the playground, jumping up to be heard.

PinkViola · 02/11/2026 12:36

SleepSound · 02/11/2026 12:30

Personally, I can’t imagine leaving one child everything and one nothing. It’s something that horrible parents do to punish imo and they know it will cause division. It’s a cunty move and shows your dad for what he is.

BUT, I also believe that everyone should be able to do whatever they like in their will, no matter how cunty.

She can be upset. You can ignore that and keep the money. You’re not close so just get on with your life. You don’t want to share so that’s the end of it.

Yes, he was probably enjoying thinking of all the drama he'd cause after his death. He won't have been unaware he'd cause upset.

86newnameagain · 02/11/2026 12:36

Were there any doubts that he was your sister’s biological father?

wendywoopywoo222 · 02/11/2026 12:36

Completely unreasonable to not understand. How would you feel if it was the other way round. And she can’t even ask him. Very selfish of your dad.

SuddenDaredJelly · 02/11/2026 12:37

So your dad was 63 and went off andhad a new family? You must see how upsetting this would be for a teenager. Your mother must have been quite a bit younger than him too, surely nearly 20 years younger? This is never pleasant for the existing DC. It doesnt matter if the separation from her mum was mutual, her 60+ year old father left your sister to form a new family with a much younger woman, its awful for your sister from any angle.

Gloriia · 02/11/2026 12:37

'Her response to this terrible financial treatment to ignore his existance, she sounds to be a charmer'

Again, she might have had very good reason to be low contact. Family dynamics can be complicated.

So he pays a few k school fees and that means the other dc gets millions whilst the older sister gets zilch?

NoName47 · 02/11/2026 12:37

I feel sorry for your sister because as maybe there is a reason she resented your Dad and that was was why she didn't want to see him (or maybe she is just a selfish person who only takes) but for him to have left nothing must be a message.
However, from a purely financial perspective if he purchased her a house and paid for her kids all the way through private school he has already given her a lot of money. Not sure if he was doing the same for you but if not maybe this was his way of evening it out.
You sound like a lovely daughter and it is so nice that you enjoyed your Dad living with you. If your sister was living in a rented flat I would say maybe share some of the money but as it stands I think you should follow your fathers wishes and I hope you enjoy the money.

bridgetreilly · 02/11/2026 12:37

GentleKhakiFox · 02/11/2026 12:23

Her mum left my father, I do not think there was any resentment because they were friends till the end, she was in his will. I think you have made an assumption, I didn't even mentioned who wanted a divorce yet you assumed

Where adults may understand and continue a friendship, children can still be left devastated. I don’t think you know or understand your sister well enough to make any of these judgments.

Coddledhaddock · 02/11/2026 12:37

On one hand I think follow the wishes laid out in the Will, but on the other it is strange that you know of no reason why your dad would leave out your sister and leave her nothing.
Your sister must be hurting that her own dad left something to everyone but her. And you’ve said yourself you’ve been left a large amount that you weren’t expecting. I think you should maybe give something to your sister, maybe just to take the sting away a little.
For example £100k will be a large amount of money for her to receive, but it doesn’t seem as though it’s going to be a large dent in your inheritance.

Eddielizzard · 02/11/2026 12:37

Did he give you the same level of help that he gave her? Perhaps he felt he had given her inheritance early, and it also seems that he was deeply hurt by her lack of interest and viewing him as a bank.

It seems harsh yes, but as he clearly didn't want to involve you, you'll never know. I might be inclined to gift her something, depending on how entitled and difficult she's acting.

You clearly loved your dad very much, and sacrificed a lot to keep him at home with you. Sorry for your loss.

moonraker0 · 02/11/2026 12:38

FireEngine25 · 02/11/2026 12:31

I have no doubt this is going to happen to my children. Their father has fucked off with the younger woman (equivalent to your mother) got two new kids (equivalent to you) and puts much more effort in to his new family than he did with my kids. Understandably our first family feels put out. If this carries on, I would not blame my children for getting to the stage of not wanting to spend much time with him. I can imagine this is exactly the same set up as happened to your half sister and her mother. Share it, and don't be selfish. She was hard done by by him - you can rebalance that. Don't be greedy. What an AWFUL man to do this to his first child. And you would be just as awful for keeping it.

Really hard done by, all school fees paid and a house deposit. You don’t have any idea of the dynamics in this family but you are using your own situation to judge everyone else.

bookmarket · 02/11/2026 12:39

Two things spring to mind.

You say your sister didn't visit your parents and lived equidistant to them as you. But you said you don't have the same mother. Your sister's relationship with your father and her sense of where he lived as being 'her' home, would have been very different from yours. You say your mother only passed away a few years ago, so your father lived with his second wife - not your sister's mother - for decades.

Did your sister visit her own mother more? It sounds as though your father was good to her in the sense of his financial responsibilities but that still might not have meant they had a close relationship - because he was divorced from her mother. whereas you had your mother and father together in one home for all of your life.

My second thought. Might your father have left you everything because he'd already paid for your sister's children to be educated and given her money for a house. If he made his will 20 years ago, he might have thought what he was leaving to you was equal to what he had already given to your sister. But now his investments and house prices have risen far more than could have been imagined and you have gained more than he'd originally intended?

But, regardless of his intention and what has happened, do you still want to have a relationship with your sister? Because if you do, there might be no coming back from this.

NoName47 · 02/11/2026 12:39

So he pays a few k school fees and that means the other dc gets millions whilst the older sister gets zilch?
Paying for multiple kids from prep the whole way through secondary is not a few k in school fees. If there was 2 kids it could have easily been £250k+ each. Op also mentioned he basically purchased her sister a house in cash!

newrubylane · 02/11/2026 12:39

Your father sounds like he was very financially savvy, OP, and would have put a lot of thought into this. I think there's quite a few things he may have considered, and perhaps you ought to think about them also - how much help has your sister already had from him Vs how much help you have had, and also what may have come to both of you, via him or otherwise, from your respective mothers. You likely don't know the full extent of his financial relationship with her when he was still alive. It sounds like he felt that she had had her inheritance already.

Gloriia · 02/11/2026 12:39

SuddenDaredJelly · 02/11/2026 12:37

So your dad was 63 and went off andhad a new family? You must see how upsetting this would be for a teenager. Your mother must have been quite a bit younger than him too, surely nearly 20 years younger? This is never pleasant for the existing DC. It doesnt matter if the separation from her mum was mutual, her 60+ year old father left your sister to form a new family with a much younger woman, its awful for your sister from any angle.

Exactly. It's as if some cannot imagine how the older dc has probably felt all her life. She probably kept her distance to protect her own wellbeing.

bridgetreilly · 02/11/2026 12:39

JudgeJ · 02/11/2026 12:33

Yet he loved her enough to pay school fees for her children, help with finances when her marriage broke down, deposit for a house, sounds to be a really bad father. Her response to this terrible financial treatment to ignore his existance, she sounds to be a charmer.

Or… he felt guilty enough for how he hadn’t looked after her and loved her that he made up for it financially.

FireEater · 02/11/2026 12:39

I'm not sure why you have asked on here as there is clearly no doubt in your mind that you deserve all the money, despite there being MORE than enough for you to share with her and barely notice it.

You paint yourself as the perfect daughter and your sister as not being bothered. But can't you see that you had different relationships. Her parents separated and then when she was 15 Dad got a new wife and shiny new child.

I wonder how much effort your Dad went to maintain the relationship with his existing child? I don't mean 20 years later when everyone is adults but then when your sister was still a teenager, struggling with all that entails and a baby sister on the scene with Dad's new family.

You are only looking at their relationship from your perspective. You don't know what went on in the early years. Just because her parents remained friendly doesn't mean he was a good dad to your sister once he had you.

To cut her out of his will when leaving something to everyone else shows him for not being the lovely man you portray him as. It was a cruel and spiteful to have done this (and I say that despite knowing he has helped her financially before.)

Imaginingdragonsagain · 02/11/2026 12:40

I’m sorry for your loss, he sounds like a lovely dad to you but I think you ought to give some thought to your sister. She was 15, her 60 year old father goes off to have another replacement daughter. He’s by this point presumably built his retirement fund and had lots of time to build a different relationship with you. He then has completely cut her out of the will. Sounds very cruel.

Mumofoneandone · 02/11/2026 12:40

Sounds like your father felt he had paid his dues to his older daughter and has left inheritance to you and others to balance things up after his death.
You sister can feel bitter about it but that's not really your issue. It's sad but your dad obviously did what he did for a reason.
I have other friends who have had a similar situation with a will!

Lougle · 02/11/2026 12:40

It was his decision, so up to him. However, I am one of three siblings. I visit daily and help my parents with their affairs. One sibling visits every few months despite living in the same small area. One sibling visits possibly once or twice per year. I am highly influential over my parents and they would do as I advise. I was absolutely crystal clear that if there is any inheritance it should be spilt equally, although I don't really want a penny so would rather they spend any money they have on them. Inheritances cause so much pain. I don't want to be a part of that.

DemonsandMosquitoes · 02/11/2026 12:42

Inheritance isn’t earnt. Your DF behaved rather badly here. Firstly for letting you and your family make so many sacrifices in the prime of your lives so he could live with you indefinitely as he aged, and secondly for not leaving anything at all to his other daughter knowing it could cause trouble.
I hope I don’t do this to my children.

SerafinasGoose · 02/11/2026 12:42

GentleKhakiFox · 02/11/2026 11:55

My father never explained any of this to me. I was shocked, he never wanted to discuss his will with me or anyone only qualified professionals as he put it, so I had no idea till he passed. I knew I was going to be the executer and the trustee of his will but that was all, I didn't really know the ins and outs, I just thought it would be split equally and with his house, we would sell it and split but those were not the written instructions I received when I located the will

He's paid for her house. He's also made equal provisions for all the grandchildren.

That's hardly leaving her nothing.

Skippythemagnificent · 02/11/2026 12:42

@GentleKhakiFox

You really need to shift your perspective a bit. Your dad was, to you, a wonderful dad. However you saw him - that’s true about who he was to you, but only to you.

Other people will have different experiences of him. This act, cutting her out when he had millions to share round, should be a huge red flag to you showing that he was, perhaps, a different person to her. He didn’t let her go without publicly while he was around - paid for school and helped with a house, but this act was deliberate and planned almost two decades ago so that, once he was gone, she’d get nothing. Does that sound like your dad? You’ve said you thought it would be even as that’s how you know him, but for her… clearly he was a different dad.

My children see their dad as a funny cool fun Disney dad, which they love. His new girlfriend thinks he is just great and amazing. I know him as the guy who pushed me down the stairs when I was pregnant because I asked him to pick up his work clothes and put them in the washing basket. He is a different person to me than he is to them, but they’d never believe it if I told them.

Just think about. His actions here speak volumes, and I’d never be able to keep millions knowing what my dad had done to his first child. To be so awful and vindictive. But… the pull of having all that money is quite strong so I’m guessing you’re going to keep it.

Skippythemagnificent · 02/11/2026 12:43

SerafinasGoose · 02/11/2026 12:42

He's paid for her house. He's also made equal provisions for all the grandchildren.

That's hardly leaving her nothing.

OP said for “her children.” She hasn’t answered about her sister’s.

BermudaRhombus · 02/11/2026 12:43

bookmarket · 02/11/2026 12:39

Two things spring to mind.

You say your sister didn't visit your parents and lived equidistant to them as you. But you said you don't have the same mother. Your sister's relationship with your father and her sense of where he lived as being 'her' home, would have been very different from yours. You say your mother only passed away a few years ago, so your father lived with his second wife - not your sister's mother - for decades.

Did your sister visit her own mother more? It sounds as though your father was good to her in the sense of his financial responsibilities but that still might not have meant they had a close relationship - because he was divorced from her mother. whereas you had your mother and father together in one home for all of your life.

My second thought. Might your father have left you everything because he'd already paid for your sister's children to be educated and given her money for a house. If he made his will 20 years ago, he might have thought what he was leaving to you was equal to what he had already given to your sister. But now his investments and house prices have risen far more than could have been imagined and you have gained more than he'd originally intended?

But, regardless of his intention and what has happened, do you still want to have a relationship with your sister? Because if you do, there might be no coming back from this.

I wondered this as it’s something that’s come up many times before. An elderly person thinks the value of their estate will roughly equal a gift given to one child during their lifetime. It turns out in the end that the gift was, say, £50k and the estate is worth millions. Seems a common situation. Seems to me there are two options: OP’s father mistakenly thought what he was doing was fair; or he knew it was wildly unfair, but did it out of spite. I’d share the money either way.

Please create an account

To comment on this thread you need to create a Mumsnet account.

This thread is not accepting new messages.
Swipe left for the next trending thread